Transcription automatique : elle peut contenir des erreurs, vérifiez l'enregistrement pour la formulation exacte.
0:00 We will see. I'll try to make this the last session on Unit 1 so that we could have the exam on Unit 1 in two weeks. I will send a PDF copy of the updated Unit 1 to Abu Sumayya and he will forward it to all of you. 0:30 And we will give two weeks for revision of Unit 1. And then next time we will start Unit 2. However, we will do the exam for Unit 1, inshallah, the following week. And when we're talking about units, we're talking about the 12 units into which this book was divided. 1:07 This is the book of the late scholar Omar Suleiman al-Ashqar, rahimahullah, on Tariq al-Tashri' al-Islami, history of Islamic legislation. And inshallah we will go over the entire book. It's made up of 12 units because we said that this is going to be a little bit different from our online teaching. We will take our time so that we could... 1:40 basically go over together go over the details of the subject customarily each unit would be finished in one week we took a few weeks and we're still in unit one and this will be the last day because as we said we will not be bound by the timeline for the online studies we have already covered 2:11 The definition of fiqh in language and terminology. We've covered the fiqh including the definitive rulings and the speculative rulings. We covered the difference between fiqh and sharia in detail. And we talked about the aqsam al-fiqh, which are the different chapters. 2:42 topics of fiqh, and we talked about the difference between ahkam al-ibadat, ahkam al-mu'amalat, the rulings that pertain to ibadat, acts of worship, and those that pertain to mu'amalat, or transactions. And today, inshallah, we will go over the last part of Unit 1, which will be about the inclusion of secondary man-made laws under the subject of Islamic fiqh. 3:10 So Sheikh Rahimahullah said the divisions of man-made laws. He said before explaining that Islamic law includes all the divisions of man-made laws, I would like to make mention of the divisions of man-made law. So he said that man-made law is divided into two sections. We have the public law and we have the private law. 3:37 The division is based on whether or not the state is party in the legal relations governed by these legislations. If the state, not in its capacity as a corporation or as an individual, because the state can sometimes be involved with another corporation on a venture, not in the capacity of it as the state, the sovereign state, but as an entity. The state goes into a venture. 4:07 a joint venture with a company. Here the state is not treated as the sovereign state. It's treated as an individual, an entity only. So the state sometimes acts in the capacity of the sovereign state, the authority holder. And whenever the state acts in the capacity of sovereignty and holding authority, then the state is treated differently here. And these laws are called 4:37 public laws. These laws are called public laws. So if the state in its capacity as the holder of authority and sovereignty is involved in the legislation of a particular law, then the law is considered a public law. However, if the state is not a party in its capacity as the holder of authority and sovereignty and instead aims 5:08 and achieving a private interest, then the law is considered a private law. So private laws will be any laws regulating the relationships between people, whether these are interpersonal relationships, family laws, or various transactions between people. The public laws will be defined here. So Al-Qanun Al-A'am, the public law. 5:36 That, in turn, is divided into two categories. There is the external, which is foreign, and the internal, which is domestic. Foreign public law, which is called international law, and the internal, which is the domestic law, which has four subdivisions. The international law is a set of rules. That is the international law. 6:07 is a set of rules that regulate the interrelations between countries and define their rights and obligations towards one another, whether at peace or at war. So that is which law, international law, and the international law is the foreign public law. So because there are states involved here in the capacity of states, sovereign states. Domestic public law, 6:39 which is the other division of the public law, the mystic public law, has a set of rules that determine the entity of the state and regulate its relations with individuals in its capacity as the holder of authority and sovereignty. It has four subdivisions. We have the four subdivisions, constitutional law, that's called the qanun al-disturi, 7:09 constitutional law administrative law from administration financial law and then criminal law which is constitutional law would be a group of rules that designate the government system in the state the general authorities within it 7:40 the jurisdiction of each authority, the interactions between these authorities, and the relationship to the individuals governed therein. It further classifies or clarifies the political rights of individuals and the principles that guarantee their freedom. So that's the constitutional law. Why is he doing this? Because he will later come back and say, where is that included in FIPP? Where is that included in FIPP? 8:09 But these are the laws under the so-called قانون الدستوري or constitutional law. Now we have the administrative law, القانون الإداري, which is different from قانون الدستوري. It's a different layer of public laws. We're all talking about public laws now. We will talk at the end about private laws, but all of this talk is about public laws. 8:36 and we said public laws are divided into two categories foreign domestic foreign is the international law that's a different story that we said regulates the relationship between states with each other and then the domestic public law is what we're talking about now which is divided into constitutional administrative 9:07 financial, and criminal . So the administrative law, a group of rules that represent how the executive authority carries out its duties. This includes the types of services that the executive authority offers and the facilities that are employed to provide such services. It further demonstrates the relationship of the central authority to the provincial 9:36 administrations and the municipal local and rural councils this relationship could either be centralized or decentralized administrative law demonstrates the administrative works and the required conditions of their validity along with the methods of monitoring them basically you have a government you have different state governments and different you know town 10:05 and you have also different branches of the government. You have the judiciary and you have the executive and so on. So all of this needs some regulation. Particularly the administrative law deals with the executive branch. The constitutional law will determine the relationship between the judiciary and the executive and so on. 10:32 But within the executive branch, the administrative hierarchy of the state now, and how the different elements and different entities within the administrative branch or the administrative hierarchy of the state will deal with each other, all of this is called administrative law or qanun idari. And then the financial law, which is al-qanun al-mali, the rules that govern the state's finances. 11:02 It is therefore, it's still the state's finances because we're still talking about the public law, not the private laws. It is therefore concerned with studying public expenditures, public revenues, public loans, and the state's budget. A group of rules that defines crime, specifies the determined penalty for each crime, and implements procedures that should be followed in pursuing, trying, and punishing the... 11:33 Criminal. Criminal law. It's understood. Now, the private law, qanun al-khas, now we're done with the public laws. The private laws are a group of rules that regulate the relations in which the state is not a party in its capacity as the holder of authority and sovereignty. It therefore regulates the relationships between individuals as a whole or the relationships between individuals and the state in which the state is treated as an ordinary individual. 12:03 Because the state has no right, if the state goes into a joint venture with a company, it has no right to act like the sovereign authority holder here. It's another entity. It's equal in this case. It has many branches, which the private law has many branches. The mother of all laws is called the civil law, which is a qanun al-madani. That's the mother of all laws. 12:30 Basically, anything will default to al-Qanun al-Madani if you don't find it elsewhere in the other laws. It has many branches, which are civil law, commercial law, marine law, labor law, civil and commercial procedures law, and international private law. International private law is basically how the relationship between citizens of 12:59 different countries you know so the relationship between citizens of different countries here the relationship is not between a state and another state that's public it's private citizens but citizens of different countries like you know in this country or that country and so on so these are the branches of the private laws anyway if it is not if you don't find that you know any law 13:28 it will default to al-qanun al-madani, the civil law. Civil law. A group of rules that regulate all of the relations between individuals, with the exception of those regulated by another branch of private law. With the exception of those regulated by another branch of private law. Civil law is the basis of private law, from which all other laws branch off. Civil law addresses two types of relationships. Those pertaining to the family, al-ahwal al-shaksiyah, 13:59 For the lack of a better word or a better title, we call them personal relations, personal affairs. But what are marriage, divorce, custody, maintenance, the rulings of breastfeeding, etc. So these are the scholars called them family laws. And then, 14:28 Those pertaining to material interests, including everything that has to do with the individual's financial activities. So this is the fiqh of transactions, one and two, in Mishka. And then the other one, the huwa al-shuqsiyyah, is fiqh of family, one and two in Mishka. And then you have penal law also. That is just one subject. Okay. 14:58 so now we're done with the civil law commercial law a group of rules that regulate relationships resulting from commercial business marine a group of rules that so basically commercial law will have to do with corporations and all of those business ventures marine maritime law a group of rules that regulate private relationships resulting from sea and navigation labor law a group of rules that regulate the relationship between employees and their employers 15:27 law proceedings a group of rules that demonstrate the procedures to be taken in courts to protect the rights of individuals in matters of dispute procedures international private law a group of rules that regulates uh the relationships among private citizens of different countries it specifies the jurisdiction and applicable law okay now so the sheikh continues on 15:56 to addressing where those are placed, where those laws, different laws are placed, and that is to show us that Islamic FIP does include all of the branches of man-made law. That is not to indicate that the Islamic law did come with specific detailed regulations in all spheres of life. Islamic law came whenever needed, such as in Ahkam al-Ibadat, 16:26 with detailed, specific instructions. Things that needed more flexibility because they vary from time to time and place to place, Islamic law came with guidelines, leaving a large room for human beings, human intellect, to branch off from those guidelines and to lay down the rules and regulations in light of those guidelines, in light 16:56 or in conformity, in accordance, in harmony with those guidelines. But oftentimes those things will require intellectual exercise, controversy, debate, and they will not be matters of consensus most of the time. Because whenever the human intellect goes in, 17:24 agreement has to go out because humans rarely agree on anything so that is basically not to say that there are specific detailed instructions because if you say this you look like a foolish zealot and then people will not listen to you you would you know you may like to feel this way 17:50 But it is wrong, and it actually compromises the integrity of the Sharia itself. Because flexibility should be shown where flexibility is warranted. And the Sharia determined that flexibility is warranted in these regards. Okay, so the place of these topics in the books of fiqh. The international law or the public external law, foreign, you know. 18:23 The external is a literal translation. It's the public foreign law. Muslim jurists were deeply concerned with matters of international public law. They were indeed pioneers in this field. The writings of Imam Muhammad ibn al-Hassan al-Shaybani, rahimahullah, who died in the year 189 after Hijrah. So he was one of the younger students of Imam Abu Hanifa. There is, you know, like Abu Yusuf is like a... 18:53 as almost a parental figure to Muhammad ibn Hassan. Whenever we talk about Muhammad ibn Hassan Abu Yusuf as a sahiban and the two companions of Abu Hanifa, people may think that they are equal or that they were, you know, peers. They were not. Abu Yusuf was almost like a, I don't want to say, because Muhammad ibn Hassan did, you know, receive knowledge directly from Abu Hanifa. 19:25 So I wouldn't say that Abu Yusuf was his teacher. They were still seeking, but there is a huge age difference between Abu Yusuf and Muhammad ibn al-Hassan. Muhammad ibn al-Hassan is the younger of the two companions of Imam al-Muhannifa. Imam al-Muhannifa died in the year 150 after Hijra. Imam Muhammad ibn al-Hassan died in the year 189 after Hijra. But Imam Muhammad ibn al-Hassan's books became the... 19:55 basically the staple of Hanafi fiqh because he lived a lot longer and he authored books on the fiqh of Abu Hanifa whereas Abu Yusuf did not. Abu Yusuf basically authored his own books which were not comprehensive of the fiqh of Abu Hanifa. So in terms of authorship, Muhammad ibn al-Hassan is the main source of Hanafi fiqh. 20:24 So the prominence of Muhammad ibn Hassan comes from his authorship of the most important Hanafi books. But Abu Yusuf was senior to Muhammad ibn Hassan. Abu Yusuf is the main student of Imam Hanifa. And Abu Yusuf was the chief justice during the time of Harun al-Rashid. And he is credited with spreading the Hanafi method throughout the eastern lands of 20:54 the Islamic state. Anyway, so Muhammad ibn al-Hassan al-Shaybani, rahimahullah, wrote his book As-Siyar al-Kabir, which included much of those laws, international laws. So his writings in this book prompted many contemporary scholars to credit him as the father of international law, Muhammad ibn al-Hassan al-Shaybani. 21:26 in his book, As-Sayyar al-Kabir. It is worthy to mention that the rules of international public law in Islamic Sharia were drawn originally from the Noble Quran itself, the Hadith of the Messenger of Allah, and the reports of the Companions. The most important rules of this law are, and we will quickly go over them. 21:52 And inshallah, I will send you the PDF, the corrected PDF today. I'll send it today once we finish with this. So you will have the up-to-date PDF that has been revised. And that's what you study from for your exam, inshallah, in two weeks for those who came late. The exam of Unit 1. Okay, so the principles of... 22:18 international public law. One, the unity of mankind, the Islamic Sharia considers all people as one nation under the umbrella of humanity. It further stressed that there are different tribes and communities or different nations and tribes are not meant for them to fight and dispute among each other. Rather, it is meant for them to understand or to recognize one another and cooperate for the spread of mutual compassion and the prevention of corruption. 22:45 superiority in virtue is only obtained through taqwa piety and then you know he mentioned the verse from the Quran which is this verse 23:16 Indeed, the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous. Now, number two is ta'awun. Ta'awun is general ta'awun, general cooperation in goodness and piety. Allah did not specify whom you should cooperate with on goodness and piety. Basically, it is a general statement. Cooperate on goodness and piety with anyone of any religion. 23:47 Like the Prophet said about the legions of virtue, had I gone back, if I were offered an alliance like this in Islam, I would accept it. Which is the alliance of virtue is to give victory to the oppressed and so on. That was done during the time of Jahiliyyah. 24:21 The second point after which is cooperation is tolerance, which is a tolerance. Tolerance, the Islamic Sharia called for displaying tolerance when, you know, you will get the revised copy. It says here, it has not been reflected. There are certain things that have been corrected in the translation. 24:56 So it says here in the Arabic, it has not been reflected in the English, just displaying tolerance. It is basically the dignified tolerance. It would be the dignified tolerance. In dealing with individuals or communities, it also calls for repelling hostile attitudes by good ones. 25:25 And not equal are the good deed and the bad. Repel evil by that which is better. And thereupon the one whom between you and him is enmity will become as though he was a devoted friend. So basically tolerance is one of those principles of international law in Sharia. Because, you know, the Sharia gives principles. 25:54 and then the detailed applications are left for people in different times and places. Sometimes there will be some detailed applications shown by the Sharia or some specifications shown by the Sharia in areas that do not require flexibility or areas that require steadiness, you know, fixation. So whenever there is something that requires steadiness and fixation, 26:23 Allah SWT fixated it in the Sharia. Whatever requires flexibility, Allah gave guidelines to be used. The freedom of creed and self-determination. The Islamic Sharia is established upon the principle of the freedom of creed. It therefore forbade compulsion in religion. There shall be no compulsion in acceptance of religion. The Islamic State shouldn't even offer shelter to whoever wants to seek asylum. 26:54 and protects them from being forced to give up their religion. Okay, so someone may say that the laws of apostasy would contradict this. Well, number one, when we're talking about freedom of religion, we're talking about people of other faith groups. We're not talking about Muslims in particular. 27:30 Number two, the rules of apostasy have not been universally applied to every apostate during the time of the Prophet ﷺ or afterwards. Therefore, there is room for choosing without denying the established rules of apostasy that have been confirmed by the orthodox madhahib. 27:58 But there is room for maneuvering because the Prophet did not implement the habd of apostasy on all of the apostates. In fact, it has not been reported that the Prophet brought someone to death because of apostasy. So the idea here is that these rules are established and there is no denial of them. 28:30 the rules of apostasy because they are established in the authentic Sunnah. But is this the only way the Prophet treated the apostates? No, it is not. There were apostates during the time of the Prophet that were not touched by Muslims. And there are several cases of apostasy that are recorded that have not been prosecuted by Muslims. 29:00 Likewise, when we talk about the three options that the Shaykh will talk about now, which is Islam Jizya Harb, Islam Jizya or war, Islam, you know, poll taxes or war, Islam Jizya Harb. Has this been the only way the Prophet ﷺ treated other states or other nations or other groups of people? No, it has not been the only way. Because there were many treaties of peace that the Prophet ﷺ signed with other nations. 29:31 which means that there are alternatives. How do you decide if you seek the alternatives, if you apply the alternatives, depending on circumstances and conditions and the nature of the struggle between the Muslims and non-Muslims, depending on the balance? 29:59 On the scale of harm and benefit, the balance between the harm and the benefit, war is pricey nowadays. As we said last time, enormous casualties, enormous price. The cost is not limited to people in the battlefield because war does not know secluded battlefields anymore. It's about rockets and bombing. 30:28 and so on. So based on all of these circumstances, there are countries that may bar people from acceptance of Islam and the worship of their one only true Lord, which we consider as Muslims to be a human right that we will defend not only for ourselves, but for others as well, to accept Islam and to worship their one true Lord. 30:58 But some states may allow this and may allow freedom of religious practice. So many factors will go into the determination of which set of rules you will use with those different nations. And as we said before, the Prophet said, 31:28 leave alone the Abyssinians as long as they leave alone leave alone the Turks leave alone the Turks as long as they leave you alone and we said the Sheikh al-Albani considered the class that has Hassan and we said that it is recorded in the authentic collections that the Prophet said do not wish to confront your enemy 31:56 So that it is not, you know, the first choice for us. It is a last resort for us. But if you confront them, be steadfast. So like I said, the determination of how to deal with the apostates would be also left for the Muslim state. And many factors would go into that determination. 32:30 rules that would allow the governor to implement the punishment of apostasy. But the governor or the government, it is not like the other hudud. Apostasy is not like the other hudud, where there is no indication that there are alternatives. You know, sariqah, zina, and so on. There are no indications that there are alternatives. 33:00 in the other hadood but this particular had is a had that is that belongs more to a siyasa sharayya than it belongs to penal laws that are fixed it belongs more to a siyasa sharayya siyasa is policy sharayya is sharayya so sharayya policies so it belongs more to a siyasa sharayya than it belongs to penal laws and there is flexibility here because there are indications from the sunnah 33:31 the Prophet that alternatives have been employed in this case. So that was the issue of apostasy. As I said, if it is determined that it is in the best interest of the cause of Islam and the spread of Islam and the acceptance of Islam, that the apostates would not be punished because of reciprocity. 34:01 fear of reciprocity that Muslim converts will be punished by their own people or will not be allowed to convert to Islam out of fear of this reciprocity the determination could be made to not punish the apostles like some of the scholars said if they leave it up to an intellectual if they let it be only an intellectual struggle 34:30 we would welcome it as an intellectual struggle. So we are not thirsty for a military struggle. In fact, we want to avoid it if they let it be an intellectual struggle. Because in this case, we know that the superiority of Islamic teachings is beyond a doubt. To us, we were quite confident. 34:59 that Islamic teachings are superior to other teachings beyond doubt, and if they were left to be just an intellectual struggle, we know that Islam will prevail and the teachings of Islam will be a lot more persuasive and a lot more acceptable by the human intellect. Yes? In order to require us to prepare for protection, defense? 35:32 No preparation is a given. Being ready is a given. And the fact that there will be inequity and injustice on the part of some of the opponents is also a given. The nature of life is based on struggle and based on competition and based on limited resources or finite resources and infinite greed, which will make other nations 36:03 you know hostile towards you so if you're not prepared and you're not ready to lose your life to defend your rights and the rights of the weak and oppressed elsewhere because jihad in Islam and this is something that we have to understand is not limited to self-defense otherwise we would be extremely selfish and egotistic people 36:30 careless, reckless, careless, you know, have no feelings for humanity. So the cause of justice for the entire humanity, it is to defend the cause of justice, not to defend us alone, otherwise we'll be self-centered. It is to defend the cause of justice for the entire humanity. And that's why Allah says, وَمَا لَكُمْ لَا تُقَاتِلُونَ فِي سَبِيلِ اللَّهِ وَالْمُسْطَعْفِينَ 37:00 And why don't you fight for the cause of Allah and the cause of the weak and oppressed amongst men, women, and children who say, cry out to their Lord, O Allah, deliver us from this village whose people are oppressors and send to us from you someone who will give us victory and send to us from you someone who will give us support. It was basically not... 37:29 conceivable for the righteous to leave the people under the tyranny of the Roman Empire, the subjects of the Roman Empire to leave them under the tyranny of the Roman Empire. It was not conceivable for righteous people to sit down and just let this ongoing oppression carry on. 37:53 the Roman subjects after they were liberated, they appreciated the fact that they were liberated by the Ishmaelites or the Muslims or the Southerners from the tyranny of the Romans. Okay, justice, the Islamic Sharia calls for the institution of justice and to judge according to it in peace as well as in war. It obliges its followers to exercise justice with all people. 38:22 You know, all you who have believed, be persistently standing firm in justice. Witnesses to Allah. Even if it is against yourselves. Allah also said, and do not let the hatred of the people prevent you from being just. Be just. That is closer. 38:52 or that's nearer to righteousness. Now, so justice. Reciprocity is also one principle of Islamic international law. The Islamic Sharia affirms the concept of reciprocity and the principle of identical repayment, which could be applied by confronting those who are likely to break the covenants, but only after informing them of our new stance regarding them. 39:19 So if someone is about to break the covenant, then you disclose your intent to them that you're breaking the covenant, which is basically being preemptive. If you know that armies are mobilizing forces to attack you, and there is a covenant between you and them, you do not attack them before you announce the break of the covenant to them. 39:50 and then you announce the break of the covenant, and then you proceed to attack. The four types of domestic public law, constitutional, administrative, criminal, and financial, have been studied rigorously by the jurists, some in great detail and some in less detail, as we said, wherever flexibility is warranted. As for the constitutional law, which outlines governmental structure in a country, determines the authorities therein, 40:19 allots each specialization its faculties, devises the cooperative and supervising mechanisms between its respective authorities, defines public freedoms, and declares the rights of individuals before those of the state or before the state. This is corrected in the revised version. The rights of individuals before the state. All this was studied under the banner of imamah, leadership, khilafah, 40:48 caliphate, the bay'ah, pledge of allegiance to the rulers, the conditions they should meet, and the rights of the people over them. They also dealt with the concepts of justice, equity, and shura, consultation. We'll call it equity for now. This is better, I guess. Because justice is more equity than equality. As for the administrative law, 41:18 which governs the activity of the executive authorities, its protocol in carrying out its function and its guardianship of public facilities. This has been presented in the books. So basically, the first one is the constitutional law under Khilafah, Imama, Bay'ah, and all of that has been studied. Now, administrative laws determining the executive authority 41:47 within the executive branch, how the different entities within the executive branch deal with each other and others. This has been presented in the books of fiqh under the title as siyasa shar'iyya. Shar'iyya means what? Shar'iyya. Shar'a. From shar'a. Siyasa, politics, or policies. 42:12 Or al-ahkam as-sultaniyya. Al-ahkam is the plural of hukm, ruling, as-sultaniyya, from the sultan. The ahkam that pertain to the executive branch, the sultan, in the sense of being the sovereign. Scholars authored independent works on the topic, such as Al-Siyasat Shar'iyya by Ibn Taymiyyah, Al-Ahkam as-Sultaniyya by Abu Ya'la, and Al-Ahkam as-Sultaniyya by Al-Mawardi, rahimahum Allah ta'ala. 42:44 As for criminal law, there is a sector of law compiled in specific chapters in fiqh, books entitled al-jinayat or criminal acts, hudud, prescribed penalties, and ta'zeer, discretionary penalties. The chapters provide detailed information about the types of criminal acts and their respective penalties. 43:13 which are legislated by Islam. Certain criminal acts for which no specific penalty is determined are left to the discretion of the rulers and judges. When you say certain criminal acts for which no penalty was prescribed, it makes it feel like those are few acts. But are they few acts? In fact, the prescribed penalties are six penalties, so there has got to be a lot more. 43:41 A lot of criminal acts, you know, beyond those six. As for the financial law, this issue was studied by the jurists in various places throughout the fiqh books. When discussing the topics of zakah, al-ushr, which is one-tenth given as zakah. No, this is the unrevised version. In the revised version, al-ushr will be the one-tenth given as taxes. Because usually in the lingo of the fiqh, when they talk about al-ushr, 44:11 They don't talk about the one-tenth that is taken out from the zakat of crops. Because the zakat of crops is either one-tenth or one-twentieth. 5% or 10%, right? Depending on irrigation, how it's irrigated. Irrigated naturally, one-tenth. Irrigated with manpower, one-twentieth or 5%. 44:38 But when the scholars talk about al-ushri, they are not talking about this. They are talking about a concept called al-taashir al-harbiyeen. It's a concept called, you know, taking one-tenth from the dwellers of the abode of war. It's basically customs. You know, Muslims through Muslim-dom used to move freely through Muslim-dom without being taxed or without any customs being imposed on them. 45:06 The dwellers of the abode of war during the time of Omar, you know, they basically imposed customs on Muslim traders, and Omar instated customs on their traders in our land. So when our Muslim traders crossed the borders, they took 10% from them as customs. Omar, radiallahu anhu, imposed 10% on them as customs when they crossed the border. 45:35 to our side. So the concept of customs or whatever they call it in Muslim countries is present, but it is not present as people do it nowadays. Yet, could there be flexibility in this regard? Is it like completely haram or could there be like a point in taking customs from Muslims moving through 46:05 Muslim lands. There may be some point here. Because if you flood the market, if you flood the Muslim market in Muslim countries with imported products, this could hurt the domestic industry sector. So there could be a point here. So we should not be quick to condemnation of everything around us. 46:36 We grew up condemning this, you know, condemning these customs as taxes and mokoos and so on. But there could be a point, because otherwise people will favor many products that come until there would be an agreement between the different countries, reduce customs, remove customs, whatever. Then you work by the agreement. 47:07 But if the Muslim country wants to protect its domestic industry from the markets being flooded by imported products, then there would be some point here in imposing customs. Now, those customs should not be collected on products for personal use. 47:33 they try to do in Muslim countries as well. They try to distinguish between being for personal use or for commercial purposes. But isn't home use personal? Like, what would they impose it on if we want to, like, make the khalij big on cars? No, no, no, no. It's personal use, like, if you come into the airport, you know. 48:11 and you have ten iPads, it's unlikely that you would use ten iPads. If you have like one or two iPads, it may be justifiable, you know, one for me and one for my son or daughters. As for financial law, this issue was studied by the jurists in various places throughout the books when discussing the topics of zakat al-ushr, which is the one-tenth given as taxes or customs. 48:40 Kharaj, which is tax paid on the conquered lands, Jizya, poll taxes, Rikaz, which has extracted treasures from the land, etc. So some books were specifically written about these issues, such as, you know, there is Zakat al-Mahadin also, so Rikaz will extract treasures, but there is Zakat of any metals that are brought out of the land. 49:12 with much disagreement between the scholars. You know, the Shafi'is would consider it only for dhahab and fadlah, and then the Hanbalis would consider it for all metals, including liquid metals, and then the Hanafis would consider it for all impressionable metals. But anyway, so there is this discussion in the fadl books. 49:34 Some books were specifically written about these issues, such as Kitab al-Kharaj by Abu Yusuf. This type, in general, deals with studying the system of Bayt al-Mal, state treasury, its revenues, the deposited amounts, and their channels of expenditure. Now, al-Qanun al-Khas, which is private law and its branches. As for civil law, which regulates the affairs... Okay, we're done with al-Qanun al-Aam. 50:03 International, which is the foreign public law, and domestic, and that domestic is divided into four types, constitutional, administrative, financial, and criminal. And we saw where each belongs and is placed in the fiqh. Qarun al-khas, which is private law, certainly in Qarun al-khas would all be included. 50:35 Because all the relations between individuals have been, you know, outlined in fiqh. You know, whether these relations pertain to the family or pertain to, you know, various transactions between the individuals. Okay, so as for the civil law which regulates the affairs of the individual, this is addressed in the transactions section of Islamic jurisprudence and covers all types of interpersonal affairs, whether those are particular individuals. 51:10 This has been revised in the translation, so it covers all types of interpersonal affairs, whether they pertain to the family or financial transactions. As for commercial law, the jurists studied its topics that were relevant to their times, such as partnerships, mudaraba ventures. Mudaraba is any business venture between capital and labor or skill. Capital on one side, labor or skill on one side. 51:40 So combining capital and labor in a business venture is called mudarabah. Capital does not need to be contributed by one, or labor does not need to be contributed only by one individual. But basically we're talking about bringing capital and labor together in a form of partnership. This would be called mudarabah. So capital from one side and labor from one side. But there are il'inan, for instance, which is full rain partnership. 52:13 which is capital labor from one side and capital labor from one side. There is wujuh, which is credit from one side and credit from one side. There is mufawadah, which is everything from one side and then everything from one side. Credit, you know, capital labor from one side, credit, capital labor from one side. But that is discussed in fiqh of transactions. 52:39 As for commercial law, the jurors studied, we said, mudarab of interest and bankruptcy. Thereafter, they left customs to decide the remainder of its components for commerce then was not as complex as it is today. Rather, it was simple and straightforward. Finally, there is the law of proceedings. This refers to a group of principles explaining the necessary actions and procedures to implement the civil and commercial laws. It covers lawsuits. 53:09 From the time they are filed until the verdict is carried out, the jurors study this law under the rulings in the chapters of lawsuits, da'awa, judiciaries, qadaa, testimonies, shahadaat. Da'awa, qadaa, shahadaat. Da'awa, lawsuits, judiciaries, qadaa, testimonies, shahadaat. 53:30 Therein they explained how a lawsuit is filed, the necessary steps that should be followed until it's judged, and the difference between a legitimate lawsuit that may be heard and an illegitimate lawsuit that does not qualify to be heard in court. Finally, why didn't the jurists categorize Islamic jurisprudence in the same manner that man-made laws are categorized? So why didn't they talk about constitutional? Because, you know, 54:03 Islamic law, like we said before, it doesn't always have to be because they are better and we're worse. That's like too much simplification. Because they are smarter and we're dumb. And we have to classify things for ourselves because we're dumb. It is oversimplification. There are multitudes of factors. Sciences grow over time, right or wrong. 54:32 And the legal sciences also grow. We have the fixed principles of the Sharia, but the legal science itself, don't tell me that the legal sciences did not grow from the time of Tab'een to after the time of Tab'een, that the Mazahib did not contribute to the growth of our Fatih legacy. That Abu Hanifa and Shafi'i and Malik and Ahmed were inconsequential. They helped things grow. 54:58 What did they help grow? The Sharia needed to grow? No, the Sharia did not need to grow. Our heritage of legal sciences grew. So sciences grow. So part of the growth of science is more classification of things, dividing of things. So it is not always because we need it because of our incompetency. It is sometimes also because things have to grow. 55:29 Because things also get more and more complex over time. More and more intricate, sophisticated. So you need specialty. Nowadays, basically they didn't do this because it was just one judge doing everything. They did not have separate courts. They had the court. And they had the judge. Every village had a judge. That judge took care of everything. That judge, whenever needed, 56:00 you know, ruled against the ruler, the sultan. So he's doing constitutional, he's doing this, he's doing that, he's doing everything. But nowadays, with how things have become, it's quite obvious that if you really need to judge in matters that are so complex, such as, you know, business, you know, the relationship between different businesses, are things the same like they were 200 years ago? 56:29 I'm not talking 1,200 years ago or 1,400 years ago. I'm just talking 100 years ago, 50 years ago. The number of different business models they came up with in the last 20 years is huge. Now this adds layers of complexity. And whether or not they're doing the right thing, whether or not much of these models 57:02 permissible to begin with but in order for you know you have been involved in a particular business venture according to a particular business model with your friend or your fellow and the judge will need to figure out how to resolve the problem between you so the judge need to have some understanding of that business model that you have been involved in therefore you do need to break things down 57:32 Not only because we're done, but also because things have become a lot more complex than they were before, and you do need further classification, categorization, and breaking down of things. So that's why they did not divide the laws, because it was one just judge doing everything, and now we may need to divide them, because it's different. The last thing that is mentioned here, 58:00 is that the Islamic Sharia is more comprehensive than man-made laws. And I will let you read this when I send you the PDF, but it is quite obvious. Islamic Sharia is more comprehensive in different ways. One, man-made laws, and this is also pointed out by the Orientalists when some of them said that it is impossible to translate the word FIP. 58:28 The orientalists themselves said that there is no equal to the word faq in the Western languages because faq in the Arabic language is different from faq in terminology but faq in terminology became such a terminology that has no equal in Western languages because they don't have its equal if they have something like it 59:01 then they would be able to translate it. But since they don't have a word for it. Fiqh is larger than the, you know, Sharia is larger than man-made laws because the Sharia also includes the relationship between man and his Lord. Right? Not only this. It addresses the relationship between man and, but the man-made laws address the relationships between man and man. And himself. 59:37 etiquettes, you know, how you eat and how you dress. It is between you and yourself, even how you use the bathroom. So it's much wider in this regard. Also, the Sharia is much wider in another regard. In human laws, although this may be true in, I don't know if it's true, but it may be true in some laws. 60:09 very, very, on a very limited scale. But the man-made laws in general, is there such categories like mustahab al-makroor, recommended and disliked? No. No. They don't have those. It is either permissible or not permissible. That is all what man-made laws care for. Permissible, not permissible. And then there is the obligatorials. Those two different categories, 60:45 or the visions of مَسْتَحَبَّ الْمَكْرُونَ are not present because certainly أَلَا يَعْلَمُ مَنْ خَلَقَهُ وَهُوَ اللَّطِيفُ الْخَبِيرُ does he not know what he created when he is the all subtle all aware Allah knows the intricacy of the human self the human soul and knows the weaknesses and strengths and so on so sometimes Allah knows that this is better for you but because of your weakness Allah does not 61:16 make it obligatory on you. Everything where the benefit outweighs the harm would either be recommended or obligatory, right? Sometimes when the benefit far outweighs the harm and there is a need for it and so on, and Allah knows it is within the capacity of the weak individuals amongst us, within their capacity, Allah makes it obligatory. 61:45 But sometimes when the benefit outweighs the harm to some extent, that Allah knows that some of us may not be able to do it and so on, then Allah makes it recommended only. Likewise, on the opposite side, the haram and disliked. Everything that is disliked, we know that the harm outweighs the benefit. Because to have the harm and benefit tied together, it would have been permissible in the middle, neutral. But anything that is disliked, 62:17 We know that the harm outweighs the benefit. Why has it not been made haram? Because Allah knows our weakness. And if the area of haram was too huge, many of us will not be able to handle it. And then the danger here in making the area of haram too huge, which is also important for the fuqaha and the dua and the preachers and the teachers to realize, is that once you make the haram area too huge, 62:45 And people cannot keep out of it. Once they trespass into that area, that's it. You broke the barrier between them and haram. Because you extended the haram area, people are not able to stay out. So they jump in. Once they have jumped in, that's it. It is an open field. It's all haram now. 63:15 So I broke that barrier, psychological barrier between me and haram. Then I roamed through this whole area of haram. And by this, you know, I'll let you read this because it's all about, you know, this concept. The broadness of the spectrum of sharia versus man-made laws. And examples I give. 63:48 cover this concept and I will let you read this and then you will read it from also the summary of the unit and at the end of the document that I will send you inshallah through Abu Sumayya there will be self-assessment questions read them try to answer them yourself because the exam in two weeks inshallah may contain some of them yes 64:39 It is exactly the yellow traffic light. You know, slow down. Maybe the yellow traffic light is not the best. 65:08 When they classify that area of haram as bid'ah, that's like another field that they throw you. They classify the area of haram as bid'ah? They don't tell you what you're doing is haram. They tell you it's bid'ah? No, but there is a huge difference between bid'ah and haram. Right or wrong? Bid'ah in the deen is haram, but not all haram is bid'ah. Because bid'ah, 65:47 is basically when you try to draw closer to Allah SWT by an act that was not prescribed by the Sharia. And it requires certain criteria for you to be Mubtada. So Al-Bid'ah is an innovative matter in the Deen that looks like the real Deen, Sharia. 66:20 that looks like, you know, shara' but it's not. يُقْصَدُ مِنَ الْمُوَظَبَةِ عَلَيْهَا يُقْصَد one intends مِنَ الْمُوَظَبَةِ by being consistent on it to draw closer to Allah . So يُقْصَد if you do not intend to draw closer to Allah but you just do it for, you know, logistical purposes 66:54 Such as when we have this class at 9 o'clock in the morning every Saturday. That is Dars-e-Ilm, right? It is a Ta'a. It's a good action. And we have it regularly. Are we saying that Saturday is superior or 9 o'clock is superior or anything? No, we're not. So as long as you're not saying this, it's fine. And by Mu'azzaba, which is consistency in doing it, 67:25 to take out any random acts, any random acts that are not regular, routine, periodic, consistent, will not be included under bid'ah. Unless the act itself is innervated in and of itself, then even if it's random, it's a problem. Because there is a difference between al-bid'ah al-asliyah, which is the original bid'ah, and al-bid'ah al-idhafiyyah, which is the additional. 67:56 It's when you add some quality, some number, the form, the amount, the time, the place. Those are the four factors that would make a bida'ah the fair or secondary bida'ah. Primary bida'ah is when the act itself is innovative. You innovate an act of worship. You bring an act of worship from... 68:27 Buddhism and then you start to do it. For instance, you innovate an act of worship. In bid'ah al-idhafiyyah, the secondary bid'ah, you take an act of worship that's prescribed in Islam and you give it a different form, different number or amount, different time, different place. You designate a different place or a different time that has not been prescribed. It has not been prescribed. So that's the bid'ah. 68:57 But in this way, sariqah is not bid'ah, because a person does not aim to draw closer to Allah by stealing. Zainah is not bid'ah, because a person does not aim to draw closer to Allah by fornication. And it is not true that any bid'ah is worse than any sin. These are statements that people just pass out right and left without much contemplation, without ta'mur. 69:35 It is not true that every bid'ah is worse, any bid'ah is worse than any sin. Because there are sins that are mukaffira, that cause one to become kafir. If you basically throw the Qur'an on the ground and step over it, that's not bid'ah. It's a sin that causes one to become kafir. And al-mubiqad, the enormities, we're not going to... 70:11 it is inconceivable that every form of bid'ah is worse than all of the enormities Allah told us in the Quran that He had given the monks the reward for what they have done even though they have invented it invented it the whole monasticism and we have given those who have believed of them the reward 70:50 Even though it was an invention. But they sought the pleasure of Allah by it. Certainly the invention will take away much of the reward. And may subject them to some punishment. But they have been given the reward for this monasticism. Because the difference between the two conditions of the acceptance of deed, which is ikhlas. 71:21 and mutabaa, ikhlas, and adherence to the sunnah is that when it comes to ikhlas, it's all or none. Because Allah does not accept any form of shirk. But Allah SWT forgives people who err. Allah SWT forgives people who have a different understanding out of error, out of this, out of that. And that goes into the second condition, mutabaa. But ikhlas... 71:57 If it is not for him, he does not accept it. So the one who does not have ikhlas is like someone who takes a perfect net to a lake void of fish. The lake has no fish. The net is perfect. So he has mutaba'ah, but he has no ikhlas. Here is the sunnah. That's the net that's perfect. He takes it to a lake, but there is no fish. 72:28 He won't be able to come back with anything. Someone who has the opposite, he has ikhlas, but he does not have mutaba. He has a faulty net. He goes to a lake that's full of fish. Could he come back with anything? Maybe, some, few. But he would never be able to achieve success, true success, unless he goes to the right lake with the right net. And then he will be able to, you know. 73:10 achieve success. In light of that, whenever the issue of Bid'ah has been somewhat underestimated, overlooked by some people, then we should not be of those people. Because Bid'ah imposes a great threat to the deen. And this deen remained the way it is now. We are able to sit down together now because 73:40 Our righteous predecessors, particularly the Companions, fought Bida'a tooth and nail, and they did not allow Bida'a to spread during their times. Otherwise, if at the outset of things Bida'a spread through the Muslim lands, then we would have been practicing completely different religions after 1400 years. But again, at the same time, on the other side, it is overblown by some people. 74:11 who have, you know, excessive focus on this issue. And there is in a deal. There is excessiveness in the deal. Even excessiveness in that which is originally good. You could be excessive. You could be excessive. And some people took it too far, the concept of bid'ah, until to them, everybody accepted their own group or their own little... 74:44 you know, fraternity, and they don't have any room for finding excuse for their brothers because their brothers may be right and they may be wrong. That does not come across their minds. Like they are so certain of each and everything they say 75:18 to the point where everything for them is just as clear as la ilaha illallah. And that's really lopsided, and that's really problematic and dangerous. It could be of catastrophic consequences to the ummah and the unity of the ummah. But at any rate, those people actually distort and ruin the image of 75:58 Salafi or Salafism and we should not allow them to run away with this term so we should adhere to this term not as a title because our title is one we're Muslim but as a concept that we cherish that we love that we adhere to Salafism as a concept you know referring back to the righteous predecessors 76:29 the three generations. Most importantly, the first, which is the generation of the Sahaba. It is our concept. They can't make it dislike it because they would make you dislike yourself. So their excessiveness in this regard should not make us dislike our own concept, our own values. Because if you allow this, 77:01 you will allow so many Muslims to make you dislike Islam because of their misinterpretation of Islam, because of their misapplication of Islam, misrepresentation of Islam. You will allow them to make you dislike Islam itself. So basically, you have to be clear on your values, clear on your priorities. 77:32 your understanding of the deen, and do not allow people to push you left and right.