Transcription automatique : elle peut contenir des erreurs, vérifiez l'enregistrement pour la formulation exacte.
0:00 to proceed. Inshallah, we continue with our study of our history of legislation, a book that is authored by Shaykh Omar Shaliman al-Ashqar, may Allah bestow mercy on him. And last time we talked about the Sharia including 0:27 or the fiqh, including both decisive and speculative rulings. Decisive rulings are the likes of zuhr is for rak'ahs, wine is forbidden. These are decisive rulings, meaning qatayya, certain. 0:54 Some of those decisive rulings are معلوم من الدين بالضرورة معلوم من الدين بالضرورة means what? Must be known Necessarily known Essentially known Or must be known When we say معلوم من الدين بالضرورة معلوم means known من الدين as part of the deen بالضرورة by necessity It is known by necessity to be part of the deen Known by whom? By Muslims 1:24 so a muslim should never a muslim grown up in a muslim land or a muslim grown up within inside a muslim community or a muslim that has been a muslim for quite some time should never say well i did not know that eating pork is haram and it would never be you know it would never be conceivable that he actually doesn't know so that is by the necessity of being muslim you should know that it's a must to be known 1:55 So some of the decisive rulings are Those are the decisive rulings that are known. Some of the decisive rulings are not necessarily Because there are many decisive rulings that some of them are known by the scholars only. And it is not You know, the decisive ruling like, you know, 2:28 basically that heirs will not have part of the bequest, or heirs are not entitled to bequests. That's a decisive ruling. Heirs are not entitled to bequests. So there is no disagreement. So not every consensus of the scholars, which would make the matter a decisive matter, must be known by the public, by the Muslim public. 2:56 But al-Ma'loom min al-Din bi al-Darura is the highest ranking within the ahkam in this regard. You know, you would not find a Muslim in his right mind who will tell you khamr is halal. You will not find a Muslim in his right mind who will tell you zina or stealing or sariqah is halal. No, you can't. You don't find someone like this. 3:24 The only exception is the new Muslim or the Muslim that grew up in remote lands where there is, you know, like remote lands that, you know, in our times, whatever, the virtual world, where there's a small village and all of that stuff. 3:49 But even in our times, they still find places where people are really disconnected completely from the outside world. But that used to be like a lot more in the past. So if you grow up as a Muslim in an area where there is not much knowledge and you're disconnected, you're cut off from civilization, from the rest of the Muslims. 4:18 And then you say, well, I did not know that eating, you know, mayta is haram. Maybe. He did not know that eating, you know, dead animals or carcasses is haram. So we said that fiqh does not only pertain to, you know, some of the scholars said fiqh does not include those because those are known by everyone. And a fiqh, you know, you're not going to call someone a fiqh because they know that dhuhr is for rakahs. 4:49 But this is part of fiqh. Even though you're not entitled to the title faqih, if you know that dhuhr is for raqas. Although it is part of fiqh. And if you apply linguistic technicality, the faqih is the one who knows fiqh. So if you know that dhuhr is for raqas, you know a little bit of fiqh. 5:17 But as much as a person is not entitled to the title physician, if he knows that honey is good for wounds, for instance, or if he knows that this medicine works for that, then you're not entitled to the title faqih because you know the sum of fiqh. But those decisive rulings are the basis and foundation of fiqh, so they are part of fiqh. So we talked about this last time. 5:50 And this time we will talk about a comparison between sharia and fiqh, or مقارنة بين الشريعة والفقه. So, Sheikh Omar, رحمه الله, said, the technical definition of sharia, according to the early predecessors, is identical to that of fiqh. التعريف الاصطلاحي للتشريع, and أهل الصدر الأول يطابق التعريف الاصطلاحي للفقه عنده. So, as far as the... 6:19 you know, the earlier generation is concerned, fiqh and sharia are the same thing. He will tell you also that this is true for the latter generations. Because to the earlier generations, fiqh and sharia included all of their rulings, all of the aspects of their religion. Both fiqh and sharia cover all aspects. For them, both fiqh and sharia cover all aspects of their religion, including creed, rulings, and manners. 6:47 They did not limit fiqh to the practical rulings only. But the fiqh to them included everything. So birr al-walidayn is part of fiqh. You know, being kind to the parents is part of fiqh. To ahl as-sadr al-awwal or the earlier generations. Furthermore, this definition of fiqh and sharia, according to the latter generations, match. 7:16 Or, you know, these definitions of fiqh and sharia according to the latter generations match. Both of them cover the practical rulings. However, the underlying difference between them, which should not be ignored, is that sharia is the religion sent down by Allah. So according to the latter generations, they limited sharia and fiqh both to the practical rulings in terminology. But he is saying here, 7:50 that there is a difference between fiqh and sharia that should not be overlooked or ignored. Sharia is the religion that was sent down by Allah. Allah said, He prescribed for you a religion that which He prescribed or that which He recommended to Nuh and that which we revealed to you. 8:19 Shari'ah alakum means he prescribed. So the Shari'ah is from Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala. Whereas fiqh, he says here, is our understanding of this Shari'ah. Fiqh is our understanding of the Shari'ah. If our understanding is correct, fiqh is then in agreement with Shari'ah. On the other hand, if we misinterpret the truth sent down by Allah, 8:48 This misunderstanding is not to be considered the representation of Sharia, but it still remains within the realm of fiqh. And we said the reason why it remains within the realm of fiqh is what? Because you cannot, you know, take it out. You know, these are fiqhah that produced fiqh. They were mujtahideen, entitled, had the capacity, had the tools. And this is their understanding. 9:17 So it is not in your authority to remove this from fiqh. But is it the sharia? Not always. If it is correct, it is the sharia. If it is not, then it is not. But since we cannot, except in a few matters, we cannot determine by certainty that someone actually made a mistake. So he says here we can pinpoint the difference. 9:54 We can pinpoint the difference between the technical definition of fiqh, according to the latter generations of scholars, and the general definition of sharia in the following points. Here are the differences between fiqh and sharia. The first one, which is the sharia, is from Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala. This is the general difference. This is the precept of the rest of the differences. Sharia is what Allah sent. Fiqh is what we understand of what Allah sent. 10:24 But practically speaking, in bullet points, here are the differences. One, fiqh and sharia converge and diverge on a number of points. Both fiqh and sharia apply the rulings in which a mujtahid reaches a judgment wherein he has agreed with the ruling and joined by Allah. Fiqh differs from sharia when it refers to a ruling wherein the mujtahid 11:01 In fact, in order for me to stop this from popping up here, I should disconnect myself. Okay, now it's not going to show. So, basically, the conversion diverge. We say, بينهما عموم وخصوص. The word بينهما عموم وخصوص, عموم is from عام. عام is general. عموم is generality. خصوص is from... 11:39 khas khas is specific which means what when we say between them there is umum and khusus it means that sometimes one of them is more general than the other and sometimes the other is more general than the other that is what it means when we say so sometimes fiqh is more general than sharia sometimes sharia is more general than fiqh in which way how could this be true that 12:09 Sometimes fiqh is more general, and sometimes sharia is general. It depends on the angle that you're looking from. So basically, fiqh is our understanding of sharia. So fiqh includes all of the positions of the scholars, whether they were correct or incorrect. So in one particular matter, you could find nine opinions. In one particular matter, you could find 20 opinions. So Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani mentions, rahimahullah, 12:42 20 different opinions concerning salat al-asr, concerning as-salat al-wusta, the middle prayer. حافظوا على صلاة والصلاة الوسطى Preserve the salah, your prayers, and the middle prayer. What is the middle prayer that's mentioned in this ayah? So Ibn Hajar al-Astari, may Allah have mercy on him, mentioned 20 different opinions of the scholars concerning the middle prayer. Now at the end of the day, we believe the most authentic position is 13:12 that it is Asf because there is a Hadith from the Prophet but there are other justifications for the 20 other opinions so those 20 opinions that is all Fiqh but it cannot be all Sharia because Allah meant one thing with this and when the scholars disagree and one says Halal and one says Haram to Allah it is either Halal or Haram 13:44 But the 20 opinions will be considered fiqh, and the sharia here is one opinion, is one of these 20. So which one is more general here, fiqh or sharia? Fiqh is more general because fiqh has the 20 opinions. It's more general. It includes all the correct and incorrect. Everything is included under fiqh. So when does sharia become more general than fiqh? It has more umum, a'am. 14:16 More general than fiqh. Sharia becomes more general than fiqh in the sense of, yeah, no, it, yeah, because sharia is, let me tell you this, the names and attributes of Allah, part of the sharia or not, part of fiqh or not. Part of fiqh in the general understanding of fiqh according to the earlier generations which included the understanding. 15:04 of the whole deed. But fiqh, as we know it, in the technical definition, does not include that. It does not include the types of hearts. It does not include the prohibition of arrogance. It doesn't include any of that. So sharia is three different components. Fiqh is one of them. Sharia is three different components. What are the three components of sharia? Maqeedah, creed, akhlaq. 15:36 character, and ahkam, rulings. Aqidah, creed, akhlaq, character, ahkam, rulings. Ahkam is the plural of hukm, ruling. Okay, so in this way we know that there is this umum and khusus, or sometimes one is more general, and at other times it's more specific. 16:11 Now, number two, unlike fiqh, sharia is complete and all-inclusive. Sharia covers the broad spectrum of fundamentals and principles that are mentioned. We're not talking here about akhlaq. Even in fiqh, sharia is broader in spectrum, and I will tell you how. Even when it comes to fiqh. We said when it comes to fiqh, fiqh is more general because it includes all of the opinions. But that is not... 16:42 You know, that is from that angle. But there is another angle to look at sharia and fiqh and say that actually sharia is more inclusive, covers a broad spectrum of fundamentals and principles that are mentioned in the Noble Quran and the Prophetic Sunnah. Based on these principles, we derive rulings which cover every aspect of our lives. 17:07 As for fiqh, it is the opinions of the Mujtahid scholars derived from the Holy Quran and the Prophetic Sunnah. It is limited. Can you extrapolate from the statements of, you know, Imam al-Nawiyah or Imam al-Taymiyyah? No. You don't extrapolate from their statements. Their fatwa is limited to what they talked about. But the statements of the Quran and the Sunnah, they give guidelines from which you branch off 17:37 extrapolate so they cover all aspects of life whether directly or indirectly whether explicitly or implicitly but they cover all aspects of life but the fiqh produced by the scholars is limited to what the scholars talk about so the fiqh of the second century after hijrah included 18:09 included, you know, the rulings of surrogate mothers, the fiqh of the 22nd century after Hijr. Did it include the rulings of surrogate mothers, IVF, short sales, you know, and like 200,000 other transactions they make up every day. Okay. 18:48 Did the Sharia include those rulings? Yes. Otherwise we would be lost now. The Sharia included them, whether explicitly or implicitly, directly or indirectly. But how do we drive those rulings now? From the Sharia. From the principles of the Sharia. So the Sharia has this sort of like plasticity, like flexibility that make you extrapolate 19:21 from sharia in this case sharia is broader in spectrum than fiqh or not yes it is because the fatawa of the fuqaha or the the the input of the fuqaha pertains to to only what the things they talked about whereas the statements of the quran and the sunnah can provide you know can cover a much broader spectrum in fact by necessity 19:53 The Quran and the Sunnah, the revelation covers all aspects of life until the day of judgment. So you will always find, Imam Al-Shafi'i said, وَلَمْ تَنزِلْ بِأَحَدٍ مِنَ الْمُسْلِمِ مِنْ أَهْلِ دِينِ اللَّهِ نَازِلَةٌ إِلَّا وَوَجَدَ فِي الْقُرْآنِ وَالسُّنَّةِ دَلِيلًا عَلَيْهَا Or, وَوَجَدَ فِي الْقُرْآنِ وَالسُّنَّةِ In the meaning anyway, وَجَدَ فِي الْقُرْآنِ وَالسُّنَّةِ جَوَابًا etc. 20:26 So that no one, that nothing befalls a Muslim in this life at any time except that he will find in the Quran and the Sunnah, in the revelation, that he will find the answer to it. The answer to it. Okay, so number three. So we said number one, sometimes one is general, one is more general, one is more specific. Number two, you know, the broader spectrum of Sharia because you can extrapolate from it. 20:57 versus fiqh which is limited to what they addressed yes not really because there could be some wisdoms that we have not been able to 21:39 point out. There could be wisdoms of legislation. There could be, you know, things that we as human beings were not able, like the Quran, you know, the final ta'weel of the Quran, the final interpretation of the Quran. Well, we have under, you know, comprehended as humanity everything. 22:10 In the Quran at any time? No. Is there still knowledge that Allah kept for Himself? Yes. So you will be able at different times and different places to glean some benefits from the sun. But you will not be able to encompass all of the rays of the sun. It is not possible. There will be always knowledge. 22:41 that Allah had kept for himself. Third, unlike fiqh, sharia is more general in applicability. Allah says in the Holy Quran, and we have not sent you, O Muhammad, except as a mercy to the worlds. Such generality is vivid from the purport of sharia, its ultimate objectives and its texts, which address all of humanity. 23:15 at all times and all places. Fiqh is the working of the mujtahid. It may solve the problems of a society in the context of a specific time and place. However, that very same solution may not be applicable to the problems of another era or region. On the other hand, Sharia is constant and applicable to all eras and regions. Now, you could use this particular statement in so many different ways. 23:45 some of them to completely destroy the deen. You know, you could take this statement and run away with it and say every generation, you know, has its own understanding of the deen. So we do away with the fiqh of the scholars of the past and we start our own. But this is not, this is by necessity not what the Sheikh meant. I know the Sheikh personally. And I, you know, 24:17 This is not, you know, what you gather from all of his books. But to some extent it is true in certain cases and certain scenarios, in certain cases and certain scenarios, that the customs of people, time and place, are not consequential to the ahkam or the rulings of the Sharia by themselves. 24:49 So the change of time and place is not consequential. However, time and place are vehicles, containers, receptacles of different conditions, situations, circumstances, extraneous factors that will affect the ruling. So if you were able to identify 25:19 that the ruling based on the Sharia changed over time, then in this case, you may say that time and place are consequential, but not by themselves, because of the circumstances within that will make the ruling change. Examples, because usually examples are more helpful than theories. 25:56 Whether or not it is, I'm giving you the example whether or not the ultimate conclusion is right. So Osman ibn Affan radiallahu anhu, when he found that the people have become corrupted, felt that, you know, that when you find a camel, you should not leave it alone until its owner finds it. You should actually take it and announce it. 26:25 Because the people have become corrupted the Medina expanded a lot And he felt that during the time of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam Look at the table or you know lost and found camels or lost camels It's the Medina of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam during the time of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam is Very minimal corruption and so on there was corruption there were munafiqeen in the Medina of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam but 26:55 But the level of corruption would not warrant that you take the camel, because likely no one will take it until the owner comes and takes it. But Osman felt that things have become much different, that he instructed the people to take those and announce them for the benefit of the rightful owner. So that is where, is it just time? 27:29 Or it is because time as a vehicle here contained different circumstances that warrant revisiting the ruling. So it is not just the time. It is not just the time. So when the Hanafi scholars, the earlier Hanafi scholars said that it is not permissible to take money for tahfiz al-Quran or ta'lim al-Quran, teaching Quran. 28:01 Ta'alim al-Qur'an. And then the latter Hanafi scholars said it is okay. It's the same madhhab. It's not a cross-madhhab thing. It's intra-madhhab difference between the earlier and the latter generations. Is this just because of the change of times or because of the change of circumstances within the time? Circumstances. The change of time is never consequential by itself. But the change of the circumstances. 28:36 And the circumstances that varied compelled them to revisit their ruling. Compelled them to revisit their earlier ruling. And, yes, the circumstances earlier on, the original ruling was basically to honor the teaching of the Quran above. 29:13 being something with which material worldly gain would be sought. So the Quran and the teaching of the Quran should be higher than this. And you should not, you know, intend by teaching Quran any worldly gain. But there is another factor also, that Bayt al-Man used to give people what is sufficient to be devoted for this work. 29:42 Like Abu Abdurrahman al-Sulami, one of the Tabi'een, he sat in the Masjid of Kufa for 40 years teaching people Quran. That's it. That's his business. He sat in the Masjid of Kufa. After he learned Quran from Uthman ibn Abi Talib al-Alayhi and Abdullah ibn As-Suhud and all of those Sahaba, he felt that he should dedicate the rest of his life for teaching people. So 40 years, certainly someone was taking care of him. 30:13 You know, someone was taking care of it. So since the Bayt al-Mal did not become as supportive in the latter generations of those functions as it was, then they were compelled to revisit the ruling. So here the Sharia did not change. The Sharia is applicable all the time, but the rulings of fiqh changed because the applicability could be limited by 30:47 the constraints of time and place. So the second position of the Hanafi scholars is it did not depart from Sharia, but it departed from the fiqh of the earlier Hanafi scholars. Yes? Abdullah, did you have it? Can what? Yes. We said time and place are the same. These two factors are the same. They are not consequential by themselves. 31:35 So you can't say that because we are in America, because we're Americans, so this is okay for us, everything is permissible. Like people say, you know, wake up, you're in America. So you want to tell them, you wake up, this is Islam, it doesn't change. But now if you find circumstances that would warrant a departure, 32:04 from the ruling in Morocco, for instance, then he would employ those circumstances. And we know that customs of the people are consequential. Customs of the people are consequential. So this is a very stark example on when the circumstances would warrant a departure from the rulings. What's an example? 32:41 If a woman wears like bright orange in Riyadh, it is not like wearing bright orange in Somalia. Because bright orange in Somalia is the norm, the default. Or Africa, you know. Somalia nowadays may not necessarily be the same. But in most of Africa, Muslim women wear bright colors. It is the norm. 33:12 In fact, if you wear dull colors, you'll be looked at. Weird. So that would be consequential. Because there is no specific ruling about colors. It is a concept that you should not attract attention to yourself. But there is no specific rulings in Islam concerning colors of attire. Anyway. 33:43 So you understand the difference. The fourth difference between Sharia and Fiqh. The rulings of Sharia are unquestionably true, whereas the understanding of the Fiqh may be erroneous. The fifth difference, the rulings of Sharia are fixed and eternal. It is also understood. So these are basically the... So how could we say that the rulings of Sharia are fixed and eternal? 34:19 And we say that the rulings of Sharia are flexible in broader spectrum and they can have this flexibility, change of time and place. Because the principles are fixed. The principles are fixed. It is the idea that this particular action is closer to this principle that would make it halal or to that principle that would make it haram. The principles are fixed. They are staying there. 34:50 in their place, they don't change. My action during this time, within this circumstance, in that particular location, my action is closer to this or closer to that. That is where the fuqaha, that's the work of the fuqaha. So basically, sharia has this principle, it has that principle. Sharia has the principle of honoring the Quran, for instance. 35:21 But the Sharia has the principle also of giving priority to the preservation of the Quran. And if you fear that people will not be teaching because they will not be compensated and they will not have an income, then it is another Sharia principle that you should actually preserve the Quran. And compensation would be warranted in this case. 35:50 Even though the issue of compensation was controversial from the beginning because the Shafi'is and other scholars, they allowed compensation, even the earlier scholars within the other mazai. But this is how the Hanafis perceived the issue and how it changed between their generations. So the principles are fixed, but our actions themselves are not fixed. Like I said, the same behavior in Riyadh, 36:21 And, you know, Chad may have different implications. You know, the principle for women is to not attract attention. So bright colors would attract attention in one area, would not attract attention in one area. So the ruling of wearing bright colors may vary, even though the Sharia has not varied. 36:51 Because the principles of Sharia are stable, fixed, and eternal. Could you also say, and this may be like treading in the dangerous territory here, could you also say that Jihad would be different today? Or basically it depends on your understanding of the issue of Jihad and the purpose of the issue of Jihad and so on. 37:34 But if you believe that jihad is not the first resort, if you believe that jihad should not be sought for killing and being killed, per se, and people have very different understandings of this issue. But although we believe that jihad is not limited to defensive struggle, 38:09 When you take the initiative, are you compelled to be fighting your next-door neighbor all the time? We don't believe that because the Prophet said, 38:37 Allah said, and if they are inclined to peace, then you should also be inclined to peace. The Prophet said, do not wish to confront your enemy, but if you do confront them, then be patient. He said, leave alone the Turks as long as they leave you alone, and leave alone the Abyssinians as long as they leave you alone. He signed treaties of peace with people. 39:03 And when we sign a treaty, we don't violate it. Allah said in Surah Al-Ma'idah, O you who believe, fulfill your covenants to the end of the ayat. But would the fact that war nowadays is different from war during the time of the Prophet ﷺ would make us even more inclined to looking for alternatives? 39:32 and to trying to avoid war nowadays means what? Means, you know, massive deaths of civilians and non-civilians and is very indiscriminate, you know, using like bombs and rockets and artillery and so on is completely different from, you know, two different, you know, 40:03 armies going out, you know, because they did not fight in town. They fought, you know, outside in the battlefield. So two different armies of capable men going out with swords and spears and arrows and so on to settle a dispute. And so when you do this and you sort of break the army, 40:33 The casualties within the life of the Prophet from both sides were about a little more than 1,000. That is from both sides, the 27 expeditions. The two sides, Muslims and non-Muslims. Casualties were limited to a little bit more than 1,000. In return for this, in return for some casualties amongst capable men that are fighters. 41:02 You liberate the people from the oppression of their rulers. In return for this, fighting the Romans who suffered, the subjects of the Roman Empire were liberated. They said it. They attested to it. They swore by it that the Ishmaelites came from the regions of the south to deliver us from the oppression of the Romans. So the price that is paid 41:33 is this confrontation. And this confrontation takes courage on the part of the Muslims, takes dedication, takes sacrifice on the part of the Muslims that would make someone like Abu Ayyub al-Ansari, you know, continue to fight through his mid-80s where he died at the borders of Constantinople. So that determination, courage, sacrifice. And so you break that army. 42:00 and you deliver the people from the oppression, and that is the price you pay, and that is the reward you get. So the balance here of the benefit-harm on the benefit-harm scale is quite obvious. It's quite obvious. You know, those tyrannical armies that subjugated, humiliated, oppressed nations throughout the world, the inhabited world, 42:30 in the past you break those armies and you liberate the people and you spread justice and you allow them freedom to choose their lord and to worship their lord and so on so forth but nowadays that there are multitudes of factors multitudes of factors that will would have to be considered this is not basically liberal modernist 43:00 you know, cowardly talk. This is just, you know, consider it. The difference between the price that is paid is humongous, is huge. And the Prophet said that it is of the signs of the day of judgment or the approaching of the hour. The death will be prevalent. You know, killing will be widespread. 43:30 throughout the world. So this is not something that is intended for itself. So the price is humongous. World War II, the casualty, the deaths in World War II, what about 60 million people? Compared to throughout the life of the Prophet ﷺ, about 1,000. Just compare this to that. And nowadays with nuclear weapons and so on and so forth, war could be extremely pricey. 44:03 On the opposite side, if you have access to give da'wah to the people, and if they are not prevented from accepting their religion, keep in mind the Romans and Persians would not have allowed, you know, the Romans were torturing the Christians in Egypt because they chose to be a different denomination within Christianity. 44:34 So people were, you know, monks were being burned alive because they chose to be Orthodox versus Roman Catholic. So the Romans and Persians would have not freely allowed their subjects to just convert to Islam and then, you know, exercise religious tolerance and so on, particularly of Islam, even though there was some degree of diversity of religions, more so. 45:07 like within the Persian Empire, then the Roman Empire, or the latter Roman Empire, they tried to cut down on this diversity. Constantine wanted to really unify the empire and give the empire one version of Christianity, not just one religion, but one version of Christianity. But at any rate, they would have not been quite, you know, 45:37 open, tolerant of the spread of Islam within their territories, let alone the fact that they threatened the Muslims before the Muslims threatened them, and they violated the covenants with the Muslims before the Muslims attacked them. But in general, the price is different, and the access to da'wah is present. So would you hasten to war in a case like this? No. 46:12 So is this an example on where rulings may change, but the principles of Sharia are still the same. You still want to liberate the people from the oppression of the tyrants. That is clearly stated in Surah An-Nisa' to be the purpose of your offensive war. 46:44 Why don't you fight for the cause of the oppressed men, women, and children who cry out to their Lord, O our Lord, deliver us from this village whose people are oppressors and send to us from you someone who will give us victory and send to us from you someone who will give us support. Clearly stated in the Quran, part of this is the right to worship your true Lord. 47:14 your one true lord this is a right that we do not we this is a right that is considered a basic human right and any authority that will prevent you from worshiping allah will be considered an oppressor authority so it is not just limited to oppression you know in the classical sense but any authority that will prevent you from the worship of your one true lord 47:44 is an oppressing authority and will be treated as an oppressing authority. But like I said, you know, if the access is now open and the price of war is a lot more costly, we would still be within the principles of the Sharia if we said, exhaust all of your means, avoid war. 48:12 You know, it has been always the last resort, but the earlier generations of Muslims needed to jump to that last resort quicker than we need to, for obvious reasons, not just limited to the Muslims. Watch the change of the geopolitical map of Europe over the Middle Ages. 48:45 Borders have never been stable. This state identity, you know, I am German, was never there until the time of the Renaissance and after the time of the Renaissance, then the establishment of the concept of statehood itself. These were empires. 49:11 and those empires expanded and shrunk and expanded and shrunk and the subjects of those empires did not really worry much except about what how much taxes will they levy from them you know if that empire takes over this empire takes over this ruling family or that ruling family how much taxes will they collect will they be you know fair or not will they collect too much taxes or not 49:42 and things of that nature. That's what the subjects worried about, because there was no statehood. But honestly speaking, if you look at the Middle Ages, it is amazing, you know, how empires shrunk and expanded. So it's something like this, but there are many of those videos. 50:46 And some of them have the Middle Ages, and in the Middle Ages you'll see it's just completely amazing. Okay, so we finished those differences between sharia and fiqh. Now, the branches of Islamic fiqh topics. When the jurists compiled the Islamic law into fiqh books, they divided the topics of this law into two major sections, ibadat, acts of worship, and mu'amalat, transactions. 51:23 Did everybody divide them into ibadat and muhammadat? Yeah, but the idea here is sometimes you have other different divisions. Sometimes there are things... Let's come to it, inshallah. So topics included in the acts of worship section, the most important topics covered in this section are tahara, 51:59 And they usually start by Tahara. Why do they start by Tahara? Because how they arrange the fiqh books, they start by the ibadat, acts of worship, first, because those are the rights of Allah on you, and they should be more important. Then, out of the rights of Allah, they start by the pillars of Islam, right? Because those are the most important ibadat. Salah, siyam, zikah, hajj. Salah, zikah, siyam, hajj. 52:29 then they don't start by Salah because Tahara is big enough to not be a chapter within the book of Salah. They used to call them Kitab such and such or Bab such and such. Why would they call them Kitab? It's a collection of many topics because Kataba means what? Gather it. 52:59 And why is Kitabah called Kitabah? Because you gather letters and words and words and sentences and sentences, paragraphs and paragraphs and chapters and chapters. So that's Kitabah. It's a gathering, a depressive gathering. That's why a legion in the army is called Katiba from this gathering. So Kitabah is a big collection. So when they say Kitabus Salah, the book of Salah, even though it is within the book of Taq, 53:30 They write, but they call it Kitab al-Salah because it is worth being called the Kitab by itself, Salah. And then when they say Bab, they mean that it is less than that. So the word Bab means gate. And they called it gate because it opens a gate for you to exit from ignorance into knowledge. So they did not start by the book of Salah because they felt that Tahara, 54:03 is too big to be called a chapter within the book of Salat. So they made Tahara a book by itself. Kitab al-Tahara, the book of Tahara, or purification. And here they did not talk about purification of the heart. Because now we're talking about fiqh in the technical sense of fiqh. And fiqh in the technical sense of fiqh does not address the non-practical rulings. That is creed and character. So they are not talking about 54:34 You know, the heart. So they singled out Tahara as a separate book, and they had to put it before Salah because it's a prerequisite for the validity of Salah. So you put the prerequisite before, you know, what is required for it. And then Salah, Zakah, fasting, Atikaf, funerals, Hajj and Umrah, mosques, their merits and related rulings, oaths and vows. 55:05 Jihad, food and beverages, hunting, and slaughter the animals. Okay. Now, hunting and slaughter the animals, food and beverages, some of the scholars said that this is not ibadat. Yes, you will observe Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala in your hunting when you say this may and you observe Allah in your slaughtering of the animal, you observe Allah in everything. But these are not of the same nature of ibadat. 55:43 If you must make the classification, a dual classification, عبادات المعاملات and that's it, عبادات المعاملات and that's it, then you may want to say that hunting and slaughter of animals and food and beverages are part of the عبادات. Because here you're not interacting with a different creation in the caliber of being your equal or your partner or your counterpart. 56:16 Which is Muhammad at the essence of Muhammad at is that you are interacting with your counterparts? Your counterparts, you know family laws financial laws you're interacting with your counterparts, but here Although you're interacting with creation food is creation brings hunting But they are not as your counterparts. So what you're observing here is Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala 56:44 is what you are primarily observing here. And the rulings that pertain to this have some devotional aspect to them. So when you say Bismillah before you slaughter, it's a devotional aspect. It may not be, it is not like a mu'amalat where it is not, where, you know, mu'amalat are all comprehensible. You would be able to understand the wisdom behind. 57:14 Whether you individually could or not, but the wisdoms are comprehensible. The effective cause behind every legislation is comprehensible, whether or not you understand it. So here they put food and beverages, the rulings that pertain to eating and drinking, the slaughtering the animals and so on, in Ibadat because they found that they are more devotional, those rulings. 57:44 than usually the rulings in Mu'ammalat, and they found that you are not transacting with your counterparts in these rulings. But some of the scholars, if you don't have to follow the dual classification in fiqh, that things are either Ibadat or Mu'ammalat, some of the scholars have a third category. They call that religious etiquettes and customs. 58:17 religious etiquettes and customs. This is basically not an act of worship and not a transaction. It's in the middle. When you walk into the bathroom, say such and such. Walk with your left foot. When you walk out of the bathroom, say such and such. How you dress and things like that. 58:45 These are not ibadat per se. They are not muhammadat per se. They are customs, religious etiquettes, personal conduct, customs, and so on. Tadawi, you know, seeking medicine, is part of this category. It's part of this category. What about jihad? Jihad was placed under ibadat here, although some of the scholars place it under muhammadat. 59:17 Because it depends. If they are looking at the devotional aspect of it, and they see that the devotional aspect is higher than the transaction itself. Some scholars said it's an interaction between you and other creatures. It's fighting. Rules of fighting. So this should belong to muhammalat. But the scholars who put jihad under the chapters of ibadat, they felt that the devotional aspect 59:47 Part of it overshadows that interaction. Because jihad is basically you're sacrificing yourself and your money. And the primary intent is the pleasure of Allah. You're primarily observing Allah. It's not like family laws where there are rights and obligations and a balance between rights and obligation and you're pursuing your interest. 60:15 in marriage, you're pursuing your interest in business partnership, you're pursuing your business in whatever financial interactions there is, you're pursuing, part of it is pursuing your interest. So it's a muhammala in this sense. But, muhammala between you and the creatures in this sense. But when it comes to jihad, they felt, the scholars who put it under the chapters of abadat, they felt that it is more of a muhammala between you and Allah than it is a muhammala between you 60:45 and the creation. It goes like this, more than it goes like this. So, that's why they put it here. And then, in the chapters of topics included in the transactions section, the most important topics they are, you know, they're included in this section, where marriage and divorce, which are called sometimes 61:18 anyway, family laws, and penalties, penalties, prescribed punishments, retribution, and discretionary punishments. Penalties, which include in Islam prescribed punishments, that's al-hudud, retribution is al-kasas, you know, and discretionary punishment is al-ta'zeer. And we know that most of the 61:48 Islamic penal law, most of the penalties in Islam are of which section? You know, the qisas is clear. Qisas is a retribution. Like an eye for an eye, you kill, you be killed, etc. This is qisas, retribution, equal for equal, an eye for an eye. That is qisas. But then the other violations, 62:20 We have the hudud and the discretionary punishments. They make so much of a big deal about hudud, even though 95% of the penalties in Islam are left for the discretionary punishment, ta'zeer, left for the community to decide what the punishment should be for this offense, left for the society to decide this. There is no prescribed punishment for each and every offense. 62:51 There are six prescribed punishments. And why did Allah designate those punishments? Because Allah knows that those offenses have enormous consequences and deterrence is important. Therefore, the punishment should be deterring enough and it should be fixated so that the people do not underestimate the danger. 63:19 of such offenses. And it is not about the punishment as much as it is about deterrence. And how do you prove this? That it is not about punishment as much as it is about deterrence? Yes. No, this is, you know, you could certainly say, you could certainly say that it is effective deterrence. But I'm saying it is legislated for deterrence more than for punishment. And, huh? 64:08 Crime statistics, you use this. This is the same thing that Abdullah pointed out. But there is no punishment for eating pork. There is no had for eating pork. Right? So it tells you what? Because eating pork was mentioned more times than the other crimes that were mentioned in the Quran that have prescribed punishments. 64:44 It is about the urgency, the urge to do the act. When the urge is huge, the deterrence must be bigger so that it prevents you from. So things like stealing and zina and, you know, these things, there is like a huge urge to perform the act. So the fence that should be built between you and this act should be higher based on the attraction. 65:15 the pulling force to do this act. And since the pulling force is huge, Allah erected a fence between you and this act so that you contemplate the consequences in this dunya before the year after so that you don't commit this act which has enormous consequences on the well-being of the individual, the family, the society, the ummah at large. 65:43 So al-uqubat would be al-muhamalat, sales, loans, mortgages, watering and sharecropping, leasing and hiring, transfer of payments, which is hawala, preemption, shufa, procuratorship, which is al-wakala, borrowing, that is, you know, qard, deposits for safekeeping, that is al-wadi'a. 66:12 misappropriation waves and foundlings guarantorship bounty wages partnerships judiciary endowments gifts interdiction 66:41 when you prevent someone from disposing of their money. Testaments or wills, that is al-wasiyyah, rulings of inheritance, all of these are under al-mu'amalat. And if you don't want to adhere to the dual division, the dual classification, which ones you will take out of here? This you will take out, and this. Yes, al-qadah, you will take out. 67:24 And where do you place them? They are not like that for sure. Prescribed punishments and judiciary proceedings. A fourth category, which is called al-qada' and al-hudud al-jana'at. Qada' and prescribed punishments and penal laws. Basically, the scholars who wanted to put this in a fourth category observed what? Observed the difference in nature between these things. 67:58 and the rest of the transactions. Because here your interaction is not with your counterparts, your equal partners in this world, the creation. You are having an encounter with the law. And the judge here is sort of the representative of the law. So this is an encounter that is a little bit different. 68:27 This is not a matter of devotional ibadah, a devotional matter of worship between you and Allah only. This is not a transaction between you and the people only. This is of a little different nature. Just like, you know, food and drinks and dress code and these things are of different nature, so they figured that we put it in a third category, call it religious etiquettes and customs and so on. 68:57 they found that these things have a different nature so they put it in a different category and they called it and the difference is that it's not a pure worship and it is not an interaction with equals it's interaction with the law and the representatives of this law the difference between acts of worship and transactions 69:28 As mentioned previously, the majority of the fuqaha divided legal rulings into acts of worship and transactions. They noticed tangible differences that caused them to differentiate between them. Firstly, there is a difference in terms of the original purpose of both. If the first and foremost aim of legal judgments is to seek nearness to Allah, give thanks to Him, and seek good reward in the hereafter, then this type falls under the acts of 69:57 worship, such as praying, fasting, charity, and pilgrimage. However, if the aim is to achieve a worldly benefit or to organize a relationship between two individuals, groups, and the likes, then this type is categorized under the section of transactions. The second difference between the acts of worship and transactions. The jurists notice that in essence, the acts of worship are not logic-based. 70:25 The text simply came regarding them, either commanding or prohibiting, and non-grasps their ultimate reality, but Allah. Why do you pray dhuhr four rakahs, maghrib three rakahs, asr four, fajr four? You know, someone would say, well, you know, I would say, you know, had I done it, I would have made dhuhr two rakahs, because you're busy working. 70:54 Or Fajr 4, because that's the beginning of the start. But this is not. But anyway, the idea here is it is not comprehensible. It's a devotional matter that we just do it as commanded. Can you say the same thing about the prohibition of wine or the prohibition of usury? No. Quite comprehensible. Quite, quite comprehensible. 71:27 So basically, you're not going to be able to understand all of their wisdoms and objectives, which the text stated or alluded to, except what the text stated or alluded to. And whenever the text alludes to some wisdom, you're not going to use this for qiyas. Because the acts of worship are very fixed, you know. And there is very limited room for qiyas. Nothing more effectively proves there being strictly devotional matters. 71:58 and the fact that many of its elements are not understood by the mind. Even if one could grasp the wisdom behind them, this only occurs in a general sense. As for customs, they usually carry some clear significance which the human mind can perceive many of its secrets. For this reason, when the wise people legislated during the absence of the divine messages, their discretion 72:26 led them to correctly legislate, and many of their legislations were later confirmed by Islam. You know, you find a lot of laws in previous nations that are quite acceptable, Islamically. Why? Because by default, Allah had given you, you know, the capacity to sort out between right and wrong, and to realize your benefits in this life. 72:58 without the Deen. By default you should be able. But not absolutely, not generally, not all the time, and not to ultimate perfection. Why not absolutely and generally? Because you have, although Allah gave you that discretion, mental discretion, Allah gave human beings the mental discretion to distinguish between right and wrong. 73:30 which is the mental considering of something good, beautiful, or ugly, bad, evil. So the considering of something bad is a capacity that human beings were given, but limited, somewhat limited, and clouded by human aggression, human transgression, you know, human vanity. 74:01 So, many laws that were made in the past showed human aggression. Humans being aggressive towards other humans. You know, humans not holding the rest of the humans equal. You know, colonialists and their subjects. You know, masters and slaves and so on and so forth. These laws that were made that, you know, were departures. 74:33 departures from that quality that Allah has given us, which is the ability to sort out right from wrong. When did we depart? When we failed to see the whole picture because of our limited vision, narrow or short, sometimes it's narrowness, sometimes it's shortness. Limited vision, that is one factor that affects the default. 75:05 which is human capacity of distinction between good and bad, a gift that Allah has given us, has two defects. One, our limited vision, understanding, shortness or narrowness. Two, our vanity, aggression, trans-aggression, etc., that clouds it. So sometimes we're really unable, that is, 75:38 we get lost, and sometimes our vanity and aggression clouds our decision, even though without this vanity or aggression, if we think about it, we'll be able to figure it out. It is not because of our short or limited vision or narrow vision or so on, which is true sometimes. Sometimes you excel in making a decision or a law, and you really want the best interest of your society. 76:08 And you get it wrong because of your limited ability. And sometimes you're not excelling to reach the right law for the society, for the well-being of the society, because you are, your decision is clouded by your own personal interests, your own vanity, your own, you know, inequity, and so on and so forth. But in general, 76:41 Those rulings, the human intellect would lead the people to making the right rulings. And if the human intellect did not suffer from those two issues, it would always agree with the Sharia. Ignorance and transgression. And these are the two issues mentioned in the Quran. 77:13 إِنَّا عَرَضْنَا الْأَمَانَةَ عَلَى السَّمَوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضِ وَالْجِبَالِ فَأَبَيْنَا أَنْ يَحْمِلْنَهَا وَأَشْفَقْنَا مِنْهَا وَحَمَلَهَا الْإِنسَانَ إِنَّهُ كَانَ ظَلُومًا جَهُورًا We have presented the trust to the heavens and the earth and the mountains and to the creations outside of humanity. The trust of what? The choice. To be endowed with the choice. So they feared from the trust and they wanted to be subdued. 77:44 and not have any choice. وَحَمَلَهَا الْإِنسَانُ But the human took it over, took it on. That trust of having the choice. إِنَّهُ كَانَ ظَلُومًا جَهُولًا He was ظلوم, aggressor. جَهُول, ignorant. If you don't have these two qualities, تَحْسِينُ وَالتَّقْبِيحِ الْعَقْلِ that Allah had given you, will get you always to agree with the position of the Sharia. 78:15 But that is impossible because you will not those two qualities you will never be able to get rid of them completely yet many times rulings of sane people would agree with the Sharia because of the default of That capacity that Nama that Hiba that gifted Allah had given humanity just to be able to sort out right from wrong 78:47 Everybody would agree that cruelty to animals is bad, right? Regardless of their religion. Of course, there were instances when they did arrive at incorrect conclusions, you know, laws in the past, because of these two, ظلوم جهود, you know, aggressor and ignorant. This fact is further supported by the legislative approach in transactions. 79:23 So the fact that transactions are comprehensible can be grasped by the mind. The rulings of the transactions. This fact is further supported by the legislative approach in transactions. It did not tend to delve into specific details, but rather came with holistic principles and general guidelines. Then it frequently expressed the justifications. 79:49 For these guidelines, in order to help the jurists apply these principles in various times and environments, as for the acts of worship, the complete opposite took place. The Quran introduced them in general terms, and the Messenger ﷺ clarified their every detail. So, you find so many hadith about each and every movement in your prayer, because they are fixated. They don't need to be changed. 80:18 They should be detailed. But when it comes to financial transactions, you have the hadiths that you have in all of the financial transactions, all of them are less than the hadiths that you have in one chapter, prayer or hadith or one of the acts of worship. Why? Because they are limited to give you the tracks, but not to give you the small details. 80:48 because they are changeable with time. And you extrapolate from those principles what suits you in different times and places. Thirdly, the third difference between acts of worship and transactions, while performing acts of worship, the worshiper must know beforehand. Here we will talk about the reward. 81:16 and the validity of the act. So basically what he's trying to say here is that in order for this act of worship to count for you, you must know beforehand that it is prescribed and you must intend nearness to Allah so that it is valid and so that it is reward worthy. But for transactions, do you need to do that? No. When you borrow some money from someone and pay him back, 81:48 paying him back is valid, right? You paid him back, even though you did not intend nearness to Allah by it. Now, if you intend to pay him back because you're observing Allah, you get rewarded in the hereafter as well. But the act itself is valid without intention. Your financial transactions are all valid if they are valid without intention. They don't require an intention. Now, if you're smart, 82:22 you could actually capitalize on those and get some reward thereafter by having a good intention when you perform them, when you pay someone back or you fulfill the terms of the contract with someone. But if you did not do this with the right intention and it was an ibadah, you don't get anything, right? 82:52 So you make like an act of worship and you did not have the right intention. Do you get anything? You don't get anything. So it is invalid. Invalid. You need to repeat it. You went to Hajj without the right intention. Without intention. You need to go back to Hajj. You didn't make Hajj. You know, so you like prayed without intention. You need to repeat it. You need to repeat it. 83:29 You borrowed money from someone and then you pay them back without intention. Do you need to pay him back again? No. The act is valid, but you're not going to get rewarded in the hereafter. Had you thought of, had you purified your intention, had you been mindful of Allah, all you need to do is to be mindful of Allah when you do these things. So you're not need... 83:56 It's not like you're not going to work and, you know, work in my intention. No, just being mindful of Allah throughout your life will get all of these things in place. So everything that you'll be doing while you're mindful of Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala, you'll get rewarded for. So that is why the beautiful advice of the Prophet ﷺ to Abdullah ibn Abbas, احفظ الله احفظ Just be mindful of Allah. 84:29 Okay, so that, you know, I explained that whole point. And that will bring us to the end of what we wanted to go over today. And inshallah next time, we will talk about the inclusion of secondary man-made laws under the subjects of Islamic law. So we will talk about, you know, public and private laws, international law, financial, constitutional, penal laws, administrative laws. 84:57 and how all of them are included in the fiqh and where they are included in fiqh because nowadays it is important for us to understand the comprehensiveness of Islamic fiqh which is not to say that there is no room for human thought there is huge room for human thought because as we said fiqh gave us some principles but will there be 85:26 a legislatory branch of the government. Yes, there will be a legislatory branch of the government because they need to figure out the details, you know, while being mindful of the principles that Allah has given us. We need to, you know, craft the details, which are so many to be worked out. Now, when we call this Musharra, 85:59 Because it's a little bit trickery here. Is this a form of Tashreeh? No, because Allah is the only Musharra, the only giver of Sharra. But this one will be... Yeah, yeah, yeah. It is Ahl al-Halwa al-Aqd. It's the people in charge and authority. But is their role considered to be Tashreeh? Or... 86:30 clarification of the Tashria. It's more a clarification of the Tashria. Even if much of the details require human thought and human discretion and so on, but as long as you're bound by the milestones set by the Shara, you are still within the bounds of the Shara, and you're still clarifying, you're not innovating a Sharia of your own, because you're still bound by the Shara. 87:00 So whenever you're talking about financial transactions, you're always mindful of watching for riba, you know, usury, watching for gharar, excessive risk-taking, watching for dhabn, inequity, cheating, inequity, and all of that. So as long as you're mindful of this, your lawmaking will be bound by the sharia and in accordance with... 87:28 So we will see how the Islamic law included all of those branches of laws in contemporary times. Because like I said, times change and you do need to be more specific. Like our scholars in the past, they used fit for a different purpose than the earlier scholars of the righteous predecessors. 87:54 They have different classifications of sciences and so on. We could also do the same thing. We could also say to the world that we have administrative laws, financial laws, constitutional laws, penal laws, public laws, whether they are foreign laws, foreign public laws, let's call them international laws, 88:24 domestic public laws and their divisions are such this would not be innovating this would be just like living your time living your time it would not be innovating because you will take the fiqh and rearrange it so that it is it corresponds to all of this