Transcription automatique : elle peut contenir des erreurs, vérifiez l'enregistrement pour la formulation exacte.
0:00 Salaam alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh. Thanks for staying with us. Welcome back. Time now to introduce you to our distinguished guest panel. We have with us Sheikh Hatim al-Hajj, Dean of the Sharia Academy of America, and he's also a pediatrician. Salaam alaikum, Sheikh, and thank you for being with us. We also have with us Mr. Hisham Hassan, and he's a self-development coach. 0:25 As-salamu alaykum, Mr. Hisham. Thank you for being here. Thank you. And Sheikh, allow me to start with you. When we talk about how to parent our children, from the viewpoint of Islam, 0:42 When should we be friends with our children, play with them, and when should we impose our authority, and what should we do with our kids? I mean, the kids we want to be, but maybe by instinct, we want to see them better than us in the future. 1:06 You know, the answer to this question depends on multiple variables. One of the variables is the age of the child. One of the variables is the particular circumstance that we're addressing. And one of the variables also is the psychological makeup of the child himself. And customization is important because no matter how much we talk about child development, 1:35 The parent will benefit from learning, yet customization will have to take its role as well because there is no one size fits all. There is no one prescription for all kids. Exactly. So the variable of age, for instance, it is important that you recognize the different stages of development, whether it's psychological development, psychosocial, mental. 2:04 etc. Because that would affect how you would address the various stages. We can talk about this in detail later, but generally speaking, you have to divide the age groups, I think, before seven and after seven, taking the hadith in consideration. The hadith of أَمُرُوا أَوْلَدَكُمْ بِالصَّلَاةِ? 2:32 Yeah, so the hadith of the Prophet, peace be upon him, in which he said, ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 2:58 in terms of mental development, the classification of gene PHA, the mental stages or the stages of mental development, consider seven to be a milestone and consider 11 to be a milestone. 11 is a milestone of the development of abstract operational thinking and seven or about six to seven is the milestone for the development of 3:24 non-abstract operation of thinking, operation of thinking in the physical world versus the abstract one by age 11 or so. So before seven is one story, after seven is a different story. Certainly a child early on in the first two years of life, that is a child that is sort of testing the world, trying to figure out if he can trust it or not. 3:53 It's called trust versus mistrust, the stage of trust versus mistrust, according to Eric Erickson, from a psychosocial perspective. This child will have needs different from the child that is past 14, for instance, that is going through the development of identity stage through the early teenage and beyond. 4:21 I would say that early on, you infuse trust. You certainly have to give them a large dose of love and a large dose of friendship early on. That is not friendship as the... 4:50 a teenager that you will take as a friend, that you'll talk to as a friend, but rather more love, yeah. And building that trust early on. The age of between sort of seven to... 5:10 10 to 11. it's a long time to stop here and stay in the in the important uh um age category from until seven and and you mentioned the variables so let's stay here and let's move to uh mr uh hisham sheikh hatem mentioned the trust and um 5:29 This is one of the prime states the scholars say children need to develop and maybe it's the very first one. Could you tell us more in depth about that and the important prime states that need to be developed in children and the role of parents here, especially in the early childhood? Well, actually, for further development to happen at an older age, there are certain, as you said, 5:59 the the the sheikh said prime states that that that need to be there uh first of them beginning is is basically trust and this is this is a stage where where they learn to trust their caretakers uh the world and actually have a willingness and an openness 6:16 to depend on different resources, whether these resources are external or internal. And so when trust is fractured at a very early age, then they stop at this stage of development. Although the child grows into an adult one day, but they are stuck at this stage of development and they can't go over it unless there is some kind of corrective action. 6:43 So some of the other very important prime states is confirmation and disconfirmation, as an example. The ability to say no to things and say yes and welcome other things. What some parents do is they take away this ability from a child at a very early age. So when the child refuses something like... 7:11 like a relative trying to kiss them, to hug them or whatever, and the parent says, well, it's not good to say no. You can't say no. And so the child grows with this sense on an unconscious level. They think, okay, so I can't say no. So then as they grow, they'll find that they are very important. 7:34 things that they need to say no to like injustice for example like uh lack of competence like many other things and they won't be able to access this this no they'll always be at the you know okay okay stage no yes no and or no um one of the other uh prime states and and and basically this is what um signifies uh humanness uh is curiosity and 8:05 This is displayed in small children. As they crawl, they always put everything in their mouth. And basically it's not because they're hungry as much as this is the way that they explore the world. And so if a parent starts scolding a child because he's fidgeting with something or because he's trying to climb over a chair or trying to figure out how a toy works and breaks down the whole toy and makes a big mess, 8:35 When they stop this sense of curiosity, we end up with societies basically full of zombies. People just get up in the morning and go to work, do whatever they have to do and come back. So what's being killed here is curiosity and the ability to imagine and be creative and innovate with very, very small behaviors that the parents can do consciously. 9:05 i mean intentionally or unintentionally you know they can they can spoil the future of a child right uh but allow me to stay with you uh mr isham and these are very important points you are mentioning but sometimes there is a thin line between you know letting your child discover and allow him to build his imagination and be curious and danger and many times you you find parents cannot control themselves if if they see 9:31 the kid doing something that they perceive as dangerous maybe it's maybe it is maybe it isn't but this is how they perceived it so so this thin line and and it it also must be um related to the issue about confirmation and dis disconfirmation maybe some parents would like to see their two or three year old child learn from the very 9:56 early ages that if their grandfather for instance comes then he has a certain respect of course and if um this uh friend or ex or that relative comes then so so how do we do we allow the children to be free to to be able to say yes and no and to to explore but at the same time not put them in you know in in danger while watching or not 10:26 Or make them, teach them how to respect the elders, how to, and so on. It's a thin line. Sometimes you feel it's a thin line. And it causes a lot of, probably, a lot of confusion and also fights between parents. Yes. Well, let me say first that parents always have the best of intentions. 10:52 This is a very important thing because we always come down on parents really hard when it comes to child development, but they always have the best of intentions. As far as what's dangerous and what is not, we as parents, we sometimes tend to overdo it as far as what is supposed to be and what is not supposed to be, what's dangerous and what's not. 11:18 According, like the Sheikh said, it's all according to variables and context and the time and the age. So if what the child is doing will cause him immediate danger, like sticking his finger in the, okay, so you can't. 11:31 don't feel free to let him stick his finger into a socket. We shouldn't ignore everything, right? Yeah, exactly. But then there are certain things that could be manageable, things that may cause minor injuries, for example, like climbing on something and falling, or like trying to taste something and so on. So this very thin line has to be according to... 11:57 to the context and not to be overdone as to limit the child from moving freely or exploring the world around him or her. Sheikh Hatim, you mentioned the variables and a very important word you mentioned, the customization. So that gives the parents the room to maneuver and to deal. And that means, for example, 12:25 and correct me if I'm wrong, if I'm playing with my child all the time and I'm bringing him all he wants, and then I started to discover that I am giving him the love and passion, but he's becoming sort of thinking very highly of himself, who's going to be arrogant from a very young age, then I would have to interfere and start balancing this out. 12:54 and vice versa if i'm trying to teach the the the child that not not everything you want i i will get to you because this is life i mean adults know very well that it's not everything that you can't get everything you want and in fact our religion also uh tells us you can't do just whatever you want and there are rules so um is this what you meant by the customization and and could you 13:23 you know, tell us how to deal in different cases if the child is, we find him overconfident or if we find him less confident? Yeah, well, I think that in order for you to be able to move from point A to point B, you need to be aware of where point A is and where point B is. 13:52 So you have to really have a good understanding of the reality of the nature of your child and to correct that nature or the negative inclinations. Because we are born with positive and negative inclinations as human beings. And that's the test in this life. Blessed is he in whose hands is the dominion. 14:21 He is capable over all things. He who created life and death to test you, who's better in action. So the negative and positive inclinations are basically tests for us. So you need to understand your child's negative and positive inclination. You need to sort out the map of your child, his personal map. And then you need to say to yourself, I need to move to point A. 14:49 Point A is your target, and sometimes your target may be exaggerated. If you truly understand the strengths and weaknesses of your child, if the child is not really good at math, just forget about him being an engineer. He doesn't have to be an engineer. He could be like too many other things. So work with the strengths and try to 15:17 work on the weaknesses to some extent, but understand that we as human beings have weaknesses and strengths. Don't pressure yourself and your child. And if you look at how the Prophet used to address those mistakes done by children, look at the hadith of Omar ibn Salama, for instance, in which he says that I grew up in the household of the Prophet, and I used to eat with him. So I was eating, 15:45 I used to eat from all sides of the dish or the pan. So the Prophet said to me, O young boy, say Bismillah and eat with your right hand and eat from the side that's next to you. 16:07 And that is basically starting with positive reinforcement because negative reinforcement. It's actually starting by telling him what is right before reprimanding him or rebuking him for doing what is wrong. That was Abdullah ibn Abbas? No, that's Omar ibn Salman. Okay. So he said to him, say, Bismillah, eat with your right hand and eat from the side that is next to you. And it is very brief and concise. 16:35 he can remember it and he didn't remember it and he reported it thereafter so he was able to give him very short concise advice it's not like a long lecture but it is very you know expressive of what he needed to tell him and it he did not mention anything negative he didn't tell him what mess are you doing 16:59 But he said to him, the right way to go about this is to say bismillah and to eat with your right hand and from the side that is next to you. Now, does that mean that you're going to always be doing this? You're going to never have negative reinforcement? That's also unrealistic. And the problem is, sometimes... 17:23 And as Brother Hisham also mentioned, you know, sometimes we get a little bit hard on the parents. Sometimes intellectuals, they live in a bubble isolated from reality. So they keep on telling you about theories and about this and that. And the reality is that some children will need to be disciplined, you know, positive reinforcement. What if I say this 200 times and nothing happens? 17:48 Am I just going to keep repeating it? The definition of insanity is to repeat the same thing over and over and expect a different result. Yes, I'll repeat it a few times because for a child it may not sink in for the first time. But eventually there will need to be some negative reinforcement. There will need to be some limit setting. And the limit setting has to be also proportionate with the danger, the age of the child. 18:15 Because you have to leave some room for the child to make a mess. You know, after the trust and mistrust stage, you go through the initiative versus guilt. Basically, will you take the initiative or will you have shame and guilt? And if the child is trying to eat with a spoon, and every time they're trying to eat with a spoon and they make a mess and you prevent them and you feed them yourself, well... 18:43 They will be late to eating with a spoon. They will be late to depending on themselves and eating with a spoon. They will develop a little bit of shame from their actions because they think that they are not up to it. And the same applies to multitudes of other applications. So in this case, limit setting will be don't sit him in the living room if it is carpeted. Why don't you just keep him in the kitchen? So if he made a mess, he can basically easily 19:12 mop the floor, and it's over. Right. The negative reinforcements, Sheikh, you talked about, are they limited to a certain age category, or can they be in the early ages as well? They can be in the early ages, but also the tone, the facial expressions, the whole context has to be sort of sensitive to the age. 19:40 So when Al-Husayn picked a date from the dates of charity, the Prophet said to him, We say this, Have you not known that we don't eat from charity? That we don't eat... 20:01 from the food of charity. So this is a negative reinforcement, but it is quite mild, quite appropriate for the age. It's just kikh-kikh. Have you not known that we don't eat from charity? The Prophet, salallahu alayhi wa sallam, when he used to pray, he had al-Hassan and al-Husayn jumping on his back? Yes, and he used to carry a mama. 20:28 the daughter of Zaynab during the prayer, put her down, and when he stood up, he would carry her. And he would walk out of his home, for instance, with Umama straddling his neck. He would put her on top of his shoulder. And certainly, something in an environment like the Prophet was in, this was extremely progressive. Extremely progressive. Even nowadays, if you do this, people will... 20:57 right so if somebody's praying now and and then a child comes we shouldn't you know a two or three or five year old child comes we shouldn't brush him aside and say hey boy go go to the last to the last row because the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam himself yes his his grandchildren um 21:19 Mr. Hisham, you started talking about the prime states. You mentioned the trust, the confirmation, disconfirmation, and you also mentioned curiosity. Any other key prime states? Yes, but I would like to take one of the points that the Sheikh mentioned, and it was how Sayyidina Muhammad corrected the action of Amr ibn Salama and how he did it with Al-Hussein. 21:46 Now, one of the biggest mistakes that parents do is when they correct action, they target the child himself. 21:58 If it wasn't the Rasul sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, then the parents would have went, okay, how can you do that? Don't you know it's bad to eat from the plate the way you are doing? Regular people or good people don't do that and so on and so on. They keep on scolding the child. And so what this does is a thought, a simple thought like you are bad or so and so turns into a belief. 22:24 uh a belief about himself the the self of the child so once this belief is into the neurology of the child it starts uh manifesting into behavior as he uh grows up that's exactly how he's going to uh to act in life yeah because we remember and each one of us of course has his his or her own experiences that when i was personally i was used to be 22:52 My parents used to tell me when I was a boy, Muhammad never lies. He never lies. This is what they used to say. Of course, I used to lie sometimes. But when you grow up, it's just they made you love this character, this character. And they told you you are that. 23:23 you are that although you were not always that but when you grow up because you you are always told that it becomes part of you at least of course I hope that we everybody still lies we hope we all stop lying even there's nothing called the white lie 23:46 I don't want to go and leave the issue, but at least it builds something, is that overall you're not a liar, at least, because you were told this when you were young. Allow us to take a short break and come back with Sheikh Hatem and Mr. Hisham and continue our discussion. Stay with us. Assalamu alaikum. 24:09 Welcome back. Don't forget to call us here live in the program on 0020238555. 24:21 248 or 249, the numbers will be appearing shortly on the screen. And also to email us on familyissues at hoda.tv. We're still in the company of Sheikh Hatem Al-Hajj, Dean of the Sharia Academy of America. He's also a pediatrician. And Mr. Hisham Hassan, who is a self-development coach. Sheikh, you mentioned something before the break. 24:50 about if your kid is not good in math, then he could be good in two million other things. But sometimes, because the child knows that this is very important to his father or to his mother, being good in math or being good in sports or in anything else, he stresses himself because he wants to impress them. 25:18 But as you said, maybe he just doesn't have it here, but he has a lot of other good potential in other things. How do we convince him or her, the boy or the girl, that no, we are happy with you, we love you, you don't have to be good here, but sometimes maybe he or her won't believe because he kept hearing us throughout the years talking about 25:47 how math for instance equals intelligence or how being good in sports equals being a real man or equal or courage how do we take the step back i mean how do how do we change gear reverse gear yeah in fact one word that you said is important to comment on because some people equate math with intelligence and that is true 26:16 in one out of eight types of intelligence, because intelligence comes in eight different types. One of them is the logical and mathematical intelligence. Logical and mathematical intelligence is one type of intelligence, but there is also linguistic intelligence. You can get the best mathematician in the world, but they may not be able to hold a conversation with you. 26:43 Linguistically, they are not intelligent. There is social intelligence, interpersonal relations. People who work in businesses like customer service and so on, they have to have that type of intelligence. It is more important to them than mathematical intelligence, spatial intelligence, navigators and pilots and so on. There is also bodily intelligence, your ability to have good control over your body, great sports. 27:10 people and surgeons and so on they need to have bodily intelligence there is a spiritual intelligence i usually they say musical i say instead the spiritual intelligence because you could be if have a phd in physics but spiritually you're quite behind 27:33 So there is not one type of intelligence. There is even intrapersonal intelligence, your ability to handle yourself, to have a holistic approach to bring together your mind, heart, and body in harmony so that you don't have inner conflict inside of yourself. 27:54 It's called inner intelligence? That is intrapersonal. Intrapersonal. Versus the interpersonal amongst people. I have a sense that this is the most important one. I don't know. Yes, I think it is extremely important, your ability to deal with yourself, to handle yourself. 28:16 comment on whatever it is that you mentioned about how your parents used to tell you something that you grew to believe thereafter. That is something that even Allah does in the Quran. Allah says, وَلَا تَهْنُوا وَلَا تَحْزَنُوا وَأَنْتُمُ الْأَعْلَىٰ وَنَا إِن كُنْتُمُ مُؤْمِنِينَ And do not grieve and do not be powerless when you are the supreme. 28:40 if you're true believers. So during times of persecution, during times of defeat and so on, Allah is telling them, you are superior if you're a true believer. Because superiority here is not by how much wealth you have, how much power you have. It is by moral superiority, your moral advantage, and so on. So you are, and you are the supreme if you are. 29:05 true believers and the Sahaba grew up to that statement and grew into it. They were always committed to being the best nation that brought forth the humanity. As Allah said to them, You are the best nation that brought forth the humanity. I have just corrected Omar ibn Salama. It is Omar ibn Abi Salama. Omar ibn Salama is... Omar was the... 29:34 son of Om Salama, the wife of the Prophet, salallahu alayhi wa sallam, from a previous marriage. Jazakallah. You're welcome. Mr. Hisham, the other prime states, please. So it's very good you mentioned the part of how the kid tries to excel in math and stress himself because he wants to please others. Because one of the prime states is responsiveness. It's the ownership of our two inner powers, thinking and emoting. 30:04 feeling and our two other powers which which is speaking and behaving so if if these powers are somehow taken away from the child at a very early age by being told not to speak all the time or not to act a certain way or it's not good to feel this or to think this what happens is they they they move from their ability to be response able 30:31 or have the ability to respond to the world to being moved around by external events. So when they start pursuing their passion, depending on whatever type of intelligence that they have, they don't actually go for what they can deal with, but with whatever is going to make other people happy. 30:54 And so they end up getting to this mess of doing for others, or speaking for others, or feeling and thinking for others. I can tell you from personal experience, I had to go into medical school because everybody expected that I go into medical school. My passion was for studying Islamic studies. 31:13 uh that was my passion from very early on when i even was nine years of age and i went back to it after i finished medical school even though i continued to work as a physician but you're happy you went to medical school you make the best out of your situation i guess you'll sort of accept your situation and yet but that was not really my interest but it definitely added to you 31:42 It could have added some, yeah. You're taking the plants part. No, because I have a similar story. Because I had some very good grades in high school, so I studied engineering. But then just two years after that, I went to media, and this is where I love. But I do say that studying engineering, although I really didn't work, 32:11 has really benefited me. I do admit that. I think college education is just to give you a key. Maybe it's the interpersonal skill here. Mr. Hisham, Sheikh Hatem, when he talked about the eight types of intelligences, I feel that this is a... 32:35 a topic, a very important one, and it could be a topic for an episode, how we work on developing, on discovering, first of all, our children, which type of intelligence do they really possess, if we are intelligent enough to discover it, and how to develop it, how to work on it. Could you expand on this? 33:04 As far as the theory of multiple intelligences, it will need a program on its own. And it's not really my area of expertise. I just know enough about it to do what I have to do with the self-development. So I couldn't tell you much about that. But I can tell you what... 33:29 they shouldn't do so that the children can find their true passion in life or the things that they can do best. 33:41 stopping the kid's development at any of their prime psychological developmental states is what would stop the child from finding his true passion or excelling in the area that he excels in. So if he has more direction towards art, for example, 34:05 but then his ownership is taken away, his responses are taken away, and he's pushed to do something else, then this child will grow up not to be a very happy person. We believe that Allah has, every newborn gets born on fitrah. 34:29 So there are two parts of that. There's the part of Aqidah, of course, and Tawheed. And then there's the part that has to do with the Khilafah on earth. And it's having the skills, abilities, and potential to make real this Khilafah. 34:53 And this is basically what happens or why they develop on a very early stage as far as the prime states. We have a saying in neurosemantics that a self-actualizing person is not a human with something added, but it's a human with nothing taken away. Beautiful saying. Yes. And it's very true, and I believe it goes with accordance with Islam. 35:21 that Allah has given us all the abilities and potential to actualize in the future. But then when the parents somehow start interfering, or society or culture start interfering with this development, whether it's trust, whether it's the ownership of the responses, whether it's self-esteem and valuing themselves for who they are, not what is around them, when the parents interfere with that, that's when they... 35:48 can't really pursue their passions or can't excel at a certain area. All right. Unfortunately, we're out of time. Final comment, Sheikh, and Mr. Hisham told me a few moments ago, you're taking the parents' side now. And we've been so harsh on the parents. So can we tell the parents something that will make them feel better as we close out here, Sheikh? 36:14 Well, I think that there are two answers to really simplify this. There are two answers to any problem. The first one is to have the right objective, and the second one is to have the right approach. So you set your target, and you know how to go to it and at it. 36:43 I think that the ultimate objective for all of us Muslims should be the pleasure of Allah SWT. We really need to make sure that we are doing justice by our kids for the sake of Allah and really ask Allah to make us just towards them and ourselves and the community. And the second thing is to have the right approach, and that is dependent on more acquisition of knowledge, to acquire more knowledge. 37:13 about the procedures, the approach. 37:17 to get to your target. Sorry to interrupt, Sheikh, but Alhamdulillah, the point was made to you, dear viewers. That's all the time we have, dear brothers and sisters. On behalf of you, we thank Sheikh Hatem Al-Hajj, Dean of the Sharia Academy of America, also a pediatrician. Jazakumullah khayran, Sheikh. And we thank very much Mr. Hisham Hassan, a self-development coach. Jazakumullah khayran, Mr. Hisham. It's been a pleasure. 37:46 Thank you for watching Family Issues. Don't forget to email us if you have any comment or suggestion on familyissues at huda.tv. Until we meet again, same week, same time, inshallah. Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh.