خودکار طور پر تیار کردہ متن ہے، اس میں غلطیاں ہو سکتی ہیں۔ درست الفاظ کے لیے ریکارڈنگ سنیں۔
0:00 Al-Fatiha. 0:37 My name is Walid Lang and I have been elected by acclamation, I might say, to introduce our guest speaker for this evening. His name is Muhammad Abdul Hakeem Thomas. 1:12 He was born in Belgium, but he was reared in New York, where he purchased the Quran at the age of 11 and accepted Islam seven years later in 1985. He has an M.A. in Applied Linguistics and a B.A. in Music. He has participated in translations of Islamic publications from English to Mali and has conducted several Islamic lectures both in the Kingdom and in the U.S. He is currently working as a lecturer at King Saud University. 1:44 in the English department, in the Institute of Languages and Translation. Today's topic is thoughts on music and Islam. Thank you. And there are among men those who purchase idle talk in order to mislead others from Allah's path without knowledge and who throw ridicule upon it. For such, there will be a humiliating punishment. Do you marvel at this statement and laugh and do not weep? 2:37 While you amuse yourselves proudly in vanities, rather prostrate before Allah and worship Him. The topic tonight are some thoughts on music in Islam. As my introducer mentioned, I have a lot of experience in that area, and I've spent most of my life studying music very seriously. I want to begin by saying that music is, of course, everywhere. It's something that's part of being human. You find music in... 3:10 Every society, all over the world. Just like you find marriage, or you find language, or you find folklore, or dancing. This is something that you find in all cultures. From Mecca to Mississippi, you'll find this. Music surrounds us everywhere, wherever we go. If we're on a bus, if we're on a train, walking around, television, of course, film. We find music is just everywhere. Now, Islam, of course, as we know, is a comprehensive, 3:44 religion, dealing with all aspects of life. And music is no exception. Islam does talk about music and teaches us about music, just as it teaches us about marriage and folklore and the other things that I mentioned earlier, things that are part of being human. Islam is not silent about music, although some people say so. We find that there is some controversy, actually, among Muslims concerning music. 4:16 I can say from the outset that I'm not here to settle every controversy, simply because I'm not qualified to do so. However, I hope, inshallah, that I am qualified to give you nasiha as a Muslim and as someone who has a little bit of experience in these matters. So, inshallah, tonight I hope we can take a look at music in light of our religion, in light of Islam, and in light of some experience. 4:48 both personal experience and experience of those in our society. As I mentioned before, I spent most of my life studying music. I started when I was about maybe this big, with the Suzuki method of violin, which is a method by which you give the person the instrument and just tell them to go and play. And then later on they'll develop into great musicians. Later on I studied piano and guitar and baritone and several instruments, and also music theory. 5:19 Later on, I went to the university. I attended Indiana University School of Music, which is the largest music school in the United States, where I studied classical and jazz piano. Before that, though, I had a lot of experience playing music professionally and also teaching music. I taught piano for a long time to adults and to children, and also taught music theory. And I've had some very interesting experiences working. 5:50 as a musician. Now we find in the West, as well as in the East, that many times the people who are involved in music tend to have a certain character. We find, for example, that people who are very, very serious about music sometimes tend to get a little bit arrogant about it. We find, for example, classical musicians will practice eight hours a day and they're very, very serious about it. So serious that they feel that people who don't do that are not real musicians and they should not waste their time. 6:22 being around such people we find also a lot of the time among musicians we find things like drug abuse and other corruption we find this also among people who are involved in other arts a lot of the time artists feel that they are a segment of society that do not need to follow the same rules as the rest of the society that they are somehow special and that they are on the cutting edge of the way the world should be 6:52 And they will reject the norms of the society, such as religion, for example, and such as other conventions. I found in my experience that drugs particularly was a very, very, very large part of the music scene, not only with rock music and jazz music, but even with classical music. People become involved in drug abuse. We know, of course, that music is so powerful, and it affects emotions to such an extent that it can be... 7:22 In fact, it's a substitution for spirituality. People become so involved in music, it becomes like a religion almost. And they have a spiritual experience brought about by both listening to music and or playing the music. One of my experiences I had when I was a teenager, I was playing in a rock band. And we were hired to play at one particular club for a child's confirmation. 7:51 A confirmation is something that's done in the Catholic Church, in which a young man, a young woman, a young man in this case, is confirmed as a Catholic. From this point on, he is considered an adult Catholic. And so we went to play the music at this confirmation, and the father of the child came to us, and he came to me in particular and said, Listen, if you guys want to do anything, just go ahead and do it. If you want to do anything beforehand, go ahead. 8:20 So we said, well, we thought it sounded kind of strange, but we said, yeah, okay, okay. And then later he came back again because he thought that maybe we didn't understand him. And he said, remember, I'm saying you can do anything you want beforehand so that you'll play the music very well. And he said, okay, okay. Finally he said, look, if you want to go and smoke some marijuana or take some other drugs, just go ahead and do it. Because his feeling was that if we were high and if we were under the influence of these drugs, that we would play very, very well. 8:51 So we happened to have some drugs with us at the time, and he invited us to his van. He had a van there. And he said, just stay in here for a little while and do whatever you want. So naturally, we did what he asked, and we came back with our minds not really with us. And when we got back, we started playing the music, and we thought it was good. And we found that we had a tremendous effect on the people that were there, that they were ready to do anything that we told them to do. 9:24 The lead singer, for example, told all these people there was a large display at the area. He says, you know, just take part of it and break it. Take one balloon and pop it. And the whole place was destroyed in a matter of seconds. It was incredible. So not only were we not quite with our senses, but the rest of the people there were not with their senses at all. Now, of course, there are two things operating here, both the drugs and the music, but they came together. And we find that oftentimes they come together. 9:54 Later on, of course, we found out that the club was very angry at us for causing all this damage, and the boy's mother was very angry at us, even though the father was the one who wanted us to get so high in the first place. That's just one of many, many experiences. Oftentimes we found that when we were using drugs and playing the music, we thought we were just playing the best music that ever happened, ever, in the whole world. We'd be playing and say, wow, this is great. And then the next day, when we were no longer under the influence of the drugs, we would look into the tapes and say, wow. 10:25 That's terrible. How did that happen? But of course, that was the effect of the drug. Now, I'd like to take a look now at some of the major music personalities in the world, particularly in the West. Of course, if I talk about rock and roll, everybody knows that these people are often involved in such activities. You find some music singers, for example, use so much drugs that they die of it. 10:57 I can think of another one in particular who would have so much sex when he was out doing his concerts that he actually took out paternity insurance so that in case a woman were to sue him and say, hey, I'm carrying your child today, no problem. I have insurance. So there's nothing to worry about. This is true. For example, we find in America the personality of Elvis. Elvis is a singer who became so popular that he was almost worshipped. And I've heard one woman in particular. 11:29 Talk about believing in Elvis after he had died. Some people, of course, claim that he never died. People collect relics of Elvis, just like they might try to collect a relic of Jesus Christ. This is a piece of the cross on which Jesus was crucified. They'll say, this is a piece of tile from the floor of Elvis' bathroom. This is true. This is a piece of Elvis' head. And they will have auctions in which they sell these things. 11:59 for hundreds and hundreds of dollars, even thousands of dollars. A photograph I once saw of Elvis with his signature on got $500 easily from someone who wanted a piece of that. We find the much celebrated Beatles, for example, were drug addicts. John Lennon was a heroin addict. And although he's often remembered for talking about giving peace a chance, he was really into giving peace a chance, P-I-E-C-E. 12:28 and a piece of some sort of drug. And there are many, many others who found a similar fate. In the field of jazz, jazz music is an Afro-American art that came about in the 20th century. We find that just about all of the major figures were deeply involved in drugs and other corruptions. Jelly Roll Morton, he was the first great composer. 12:58 of jazz music. And he was a pimp. A pimp is somebody who sells a woman as a prostitute. This is his profession. He did music on the side. He was a hustler. He cheated people out of their money. And he was extraordinarily arrogant about his music. He claimed to have invented jazz on such and such a date and thought that nobody else was any good. And he is the father of jazz competition. Duke Ellington and Dizzy Gillespie, they were involved 13:30 in the big band era, in which they would play music and people would dance, men and women dancing together, just going crazy. Charlie Parker is another one who was celebrated as probably one of the greatest musical geniuses of jazz ever. And he died a heroin addict. Although he was considered a genius, he spent a lot of his time lying down in the gutter in the street and died like that. Coleman Hawkins was an alcoholic, another great... 14:01 jazz musician John Coltrane also died a heroin addict and of course Miles Davis who died recently he survived his drug addiction days but died recently after many years now maybe you haven't heard these names before but maybe some of you have and you realize that these are the giant figures in jazz music and they all ended up with that sort of end 14:32 In classical music, a lot of the time in the West we think of the classical composers as being such lofty figures, very disciplined, very intelligent, geniuses. But we find that Mozart, for example, was an alcoholic. He had all his girlfriends. He was sort of a party animal. He was also a mason. He belonged to the Masonic cult and was deeply involved in that. He even wrote one opera. 15:03 involving the Muslim world, in Turkey in particular. We find that Beethoven, who again is celebrated as probably one of the greatest composers ever, was really sort of a crazy man. He used to urinate out of his window anytime he felt like it. His house was a complete mess. He would yell and he was very grouchy all the time. And people couldn't get along with him. Interestingly, he became deaf towards the end of his life, couldn't hear anything, and at that time composed. 15:33 what's considered a very great piece of music. Mendelssohn, for example, was a Jewish composer, and he was hated by another composer of his time named Wagner. Wagner was sort of a pre-Nazi. He hated Jews, and therefore he hated Mendelssohn. And he was so arrogant, he felt that he was just God's gift to the world because he knew how to write opera. His operas would go on for hours and hours and hours. Schumann, also another great composer. 16:03 he lost his mind completely and ended up in an insane asylum. And of course, there was Schoenberg, who was a 20th century composer. He was so arrogant that he told the world that he had just created a new system of musical notation and composition to ensure German superiority in music for the next century. Ironically, he was thrown out of Germany because he was a Jew, and he was thrown out by the Nazis. 16:34 So we find that all these great people in music actually have very strange lifestyles, often involving self-destructive behavior. I want to emphasize also that in the East, perhaps you have... Music may be looked upon as something that maybe a silly person does. But in the West, it is taken with extreme seriousness. When I was in music school, we found people that practiced all the time. All the time. Just constantly practicing. 17:05 trying to make their art perfect. And the music just simply becomes an end unto itself. So if we look at the profession of music, we find that it's usually associated with things like, as I mentioned, alcohol and drugs. It's often associated with mixed dancing, meaning dancing between men and women. It's often associated with religion. And of course, there's not music in the Islamic tradition, as far as worship goes, if we ignore some Sufi things. 17:36 Therefore, it's usually Christian. And also parlor music. People like to sit around and have a little drink and pretend that they're very sophisticated while they listen to a musician. So we find that this sort of profession in itself is very, very, very questionable for someone who is a Muslim. A Muslim is someone who is supposed to stay away from drugs, stay away from alcohol, stay away from self-destructive behavior in general. 18:08 So we find that before we've even looked at any Hadith or anything from the Sunnah, we find that the lifestyle of the musician is very, very, very questionable indeed. Oftentimes in song, when people sing, we find that some of the biggest topics for song are often un-anthropic things as well. When people sing, they often sing about romantic love or premarital sex. 18:47 or dancing, or rebellion against society, youth culture, and even suicide, and even worship of other gods and this sort of thing. An extreme example in the West might be this heavy metal music, which often includes satanic songs and groups. One in particular is called Merciful Fate. This is the name of a band from Scandinavia. And they were Satanists. 19:16 they just came out and said, yes, we worship Satan. Satan is the one that we love. And one song is quoted, it ends with a statement, My sweet Satan, named Shaitan. My sweet Satan, you are the one. And they openly worship Satan. In my area, in New York, there was one young man, about 13, who was murdered in a satanic ritual involving this kind of music. His eyes were gouged out of his head. 19:48 before he was murdered. There have also been several suicides associated with this kind of music. Two suicides in particular also happened in the Midwest, in the United States. Two young men were listening to a Judas Priest album. That's the name of one of these groups. And they just became so high with the music that they just decided that they should kill themselves. And they took their shotguns. People in the country often have shotguns. And they went out of the house and the first one took it. 20:20 shot himself in the head and killed himself on the spot now the second young man he felt maybe he shouldn't do it but now he felt committed because his son and his friend had just killed himself so he thought that he better do it too and he started reciting what he had heard or what he thought he heard in the music do it do it do it and he shot himself we know the story because he survived for a short time and his family came and he told them that they had listened to the music and 20:50 And they felt inspired to kill themselves for that. In the same area, there was another young man listening to heavy metal music who decided to kill himself. He shot himself in the head with a shotgun, but was unsuccessful with his suicide. And now he's very deformed and disfigured. The first case that I mentioned was so shocking to people that they decided to try to legislate heavy metal music and music in general. To try to get people to say, well, look, maybe we shouldn't listen to this music. Something's wrong here. 21:22 and they petitioned the government. They went to the Capitol and they said, look, we've got to regulate music. We've got to put warning labels on these records, on these CDs, to warn people about the music. This music might cause something bad to happen. Of course, in the United States, we have these different freedoms, so none of these laws have ever gone through. But there was a very strong and active movement to try to get not only some music banned, but also to try to warn people about this music. Another example is... 21:52 There's one group, it was a rap group, and they used to sing about sex all the time, even rape and abuse of women. And people tried to get them arrested also. In fact, they were arrested, and they tried to ban the music. But again, because of certain freedoms mentioned in the laws of the United States, everything was thrown out, and they were allowed to continue their music. Of course, this controversy always generates much more interest than should actually be there. 22:21 about this music. As soon as something becomes controversial, everybody says, hey, we want to buy the record that caused somebody to shoot themselves. We want to buy the record that caused somebody to rape somebody. And they immediately try to listen to it more and more. And so the problem grows. So, of course, we can easily agree that as Muslims, any music that calls someone to something that is un-Islamic must be completely and totally avoided. So any song having to do with doing something with Torah, a drinking song, for example, 22:56 Absolutely must be completely avoided. Something asking you to dance with this beautiful girl. Not permissible in Islam. Now one could also easily argue that, well, if we have some music that doesn't have any words in it, maybe that would be allowed. Because there's nobody singing or telling you to do anything. You just listen to music and I could sit down and relax and listen to music. So at this point, we should turn to the Islamic literature and try to see what is actually said. 23:28 about music. Again, I want to mention that I'm not a scholar, but I can convey some things that are in our literature, inshallah. There are some Quranic verses dealing with what some say is music, which we recited at the very beginning. Some people say that this vain talk applies to music. Others disagree, but there is that opinion. We also find in the Hadith literature, though, 24:02 authentic hadith dealing with music. This one hadith is from Bukhari, and it goes as follows. The Prophet ﷺ said, There will be, there will be, meaning at some future time, there will be people from my ummah, from the community of Muslims, who will seek to make lawful fornication, wearing of silk, wine drinking, and the use of musical instruments. 24:39 Some people will stay at the side of a mountain, and when their shepherd comes in the evening to ask them for his needs, they will say, return to us tomorrow. Then Allah will destroy them during the night by causing the mountain to fall upon them, while he changes others into apes and swine. They will remain in such a state until the day of judgment. Now the part that interests us here is there will be a people of my ummah who will make lawful 25:09 fornication, the wearing of silk, wine drinking, and the use of musical instruments. Now, we all know very clearly that fornication, meaning sex between people who are not married, is absolutely forbidden. It's absolutely forbidden and not permissible in Islam. We know that the wearing of silk, for men anyway, for women it's permissible, but for men, is prohibited for Muslim men, just as gold is. Wine drinking, 25:40 We know it's forbidden for Muslims. And the use of musical instruments is included in these things. Furthermore, the Prophet ﷺ is saying here that the nation will seek to make lawful these things. And musical instruments is included among those things that we all know are haram. There is another hadith narrated by Ibn Majah from the Kitab al-Fitan, which goes as follows. 26:16 The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said, A people of my ummah will drink wine, calling it by other than its real name. Merriment, which means joy, having a good time. Merriment will be made for them through the playing of musical instruments and the singing of lady singers, or women singers. Allah will cleave the earth under them and turn others into apes and swans. This is an authentic hadith. 26:53 In authentic hadith. In another one, the Prophet said, Verily Allah prohibited wine, gambling, and al-qubah. And every intoxicant is prohibited. Sufyan said, I asked the narrator, Ali bin Bazima, What is al-qubah? He answered, it is the drum. And in another text, Allah's Messenger said, Verily Allah has prohibited for my ummah, wine, gambling, a drink distilled from corn, 27:31 The drum and the lute, while he supplemented me with another prayer, the wicca. Now here the lute means a type of guitar that was used at that time. It's not exactly the European lute, but a sort of stringed instrument played like this. So we find several narrations in which the Prophet, peace be upon him, is mentioning that people in the future time will try to make this permissible. 28:05 Many people have said that this obviously means that musical instruments, when mentioned like this by the Prophet, must also be haram. Now, for some reason, there's been some controversy about this matter. For example, the scholar from Muslim Spain, Ibn Hazm, and also Abu Bakr ibn Arabi, have permitted music. Ibn Hazm, for example, he wrote that every hadith related, meaning prohibiting music and singing, is false and forged. 28:36 Meaning that these are not true. And Ibn Arabi said that there is no authentic hadith prohibiting singing. Furthermore, recently, more recently, Yusuf Qardawi wrote a book that is popularly read called The Halal and the Haram in Islam, in which he takes exactly this point of view. That, well, there's nothing authentic about music, therefore we can't say that music is really haram. However, we can say that if music is about something bad, or if a song is about something bad, that we can reject that. But we can't say that music is actually haram. 29:07 I myself personally after Jamal Bedouin. 31:45 and worship your Lord until he gives you the certainty, until he gives you the certainty, until he gives you the certainty, until he gives you the certainty, until he gives you the certainty, 32:34 This is the meaning of this verse. 33:02 We did not write it for them except to seek the pleasure of Allah, so they did not see it as their right to take care of it. This is how it is. 33:30 I myself personally asked Jamal Bedouin, who is not really a scholar, but he's a very famous guy who lives in Canada, and he had the same opinion. Well, we can't really say that music is haram. However, if it accompanies something bad, then it would be haram. But in and of itself, it's not really haram. Now, it's interesting to note that these scholars, for some reason, don't mention the hadith that I just mentioned. Yusuf Qardawi, for example, 34:03 He doesn't mention this hadith in his book. Oftentimes these people mention the hadith with Aisha, in which the Prophet was with Aisha, and they were watching this training going on, and they pointed that as showing that the Prophet approved of music. However, if you look at the hadith, you don't find anything about music in that hadith. If we look at the opinions of the four imams, meaning the founders of the modern schools of fiqh, Hanafi, Malik, Shafi'i, and Handali, 34:35 we find that Hanafi considered all music haram. He just rejected all of it completely. And he was probably the most severe against any kind of music. Malik, of course, who was born about 100 years after the Prophet, said, in fact, that singing is done by the sinful ones. 35:06 Someone had asked him about, well, what do the people in Medina say about this singing? And he said, well, in Medina, it's the sinful people who do this. And this is problematic. Shafi'i said that the song is makrur. He said that it resembles the false and vain thing, al-batha. It resembles that, that falsehood. The one who partakes of it frequently is an incompetent fool whose testimony is to be rejected. So, for example, if you have a person who... 35:37 who partakes in this sort of thing all the time, you cannot take his testimony in a court, because he's involved in all this foolishness. This is Shafi'i. Hanbo, he felt that, he called it a bid'ah. During his time, it became popular for people to sing songs about religion and about piety and this sort of thing. But he called it a bid'ah and a curse in ovation, although he didn't disapprove of some religious songs. But generally in singing, he... 36:09 He didn't really like it at all. So we find that all four of the imams were against this sort of thing. Although, of course, we see that there are some exceptions, which I'll go into later, that they did permit. There's one hadith that talks about the Eid festivals. Aisha said, Allah's Messenger, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, entered into my presence while two young girls were singing the song of Ra. Whereupon he laid down and turned his face away. 36:48 Abu Bakr entered and scolded me, saying, The flute of Satan in front of the Prophet? Allah's Messenger, peace be upon him, said, I turned to Abu Bakr, saying, Leave them be. Aisha continued, When the Prophet dozed off, I signaled to them, and they left. In another narration of Abu Bakr, Aisha mentioned that her father, Abu Bakr, came to her during the days of Minna. There were two young girls with her beating upon the dust, while the Prophet was covered with his cloth. 37:20 Then Abu Bakr began scolding the girl who, upon the Prophet, disclosed his faith from under the covenant and said, Leave them, Abu Bakr. These are days of the Eid festival. So some scholars have concluded that on days of Eid, this sort of thing is permissible. Likewise, for the wedding feast, the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, said, The demarcation between the unlawful and the lawful in marriage is the daf and the voice. Also, Aisha, related that the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, said, 37:51 proclaim this marriage, solemnize it in the mosque, and beat the deaf upon its occasion. So there are some exceptions that some of the scholars have permitted about music and about singing. But again, of course, the principles are always there that it should never be something un-Islamic. There is also the opinion, however, that even drum playing and singing is not something that should be done commonly, but only done in these certain situations. 38:20 Some even say that it's not something that should be done by men and should be done by women, only among other women. Another exception that some scholars also permit are songs dealing with jihad or songs dealing with welcoming a pious person to a particular place, for example, or work chants in which people are working. 38:51 songs to make the work go a little bit easier or to keep some workers in rhythm. Also to encourage a riding animal. If you have an animal that is not riding properly, they're allowed some of these chants. And also for a parent to a child to, for example, comfort a baby. They have no problem with a mother singing to a child in that circumstance. But again, there's the agreement about the musical instruments based on the sunnah. 39:23 Some of which I mentioned earlier. Now, as we know, music is such a part of our lives, whether we like it or not, some more than others. And so I'd like to mention some alternatives to music. The first of which, obviously, is the Quran. Learning the Quran is one of the best things that we can do, and even better than learning it, is to learn it and put it into practice. Abu Hurairah reported that Allah's Messenger, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, said, Whoever does not chant the Quran is not one of us. 39:58 Aziz related, that Allah's Messenger ﷺ said, Adorn the Qur'an with your voices. Meaning when you make recitation of the Qur'an to make it sound nice, then to do so with the utmost respect and to do it with the proper pronunciation. So this is something that we're all enjoying to do. And the Qur'an is something much better than any sort of song about somebody's girlfriend or about anything else for that matter. Also there are some Islamic songs that encourage people, unaccompanied by music, to encourage people to do righteous deeds. 40:32 to encourage us to remember Allah and to remember the Muslims who are in trouble. This is something else that we can avail ourselves. Zikr is something else, the remembrance of Allah, the reciting of certain prayers is something else. And of course there are the physical activities and sports and recreation to get ourselves away from this questionable matter. So in Islam we know that our lives... 41:03 are very, very short and our lives are very, very precious because this is the preparation to go into the hereafter. And frankly speaking, we don't have a lot of time for a lot of fooling around and a pursuit in something that's not going to benefit us. In my life, our expense for any amount of time is music. Only for the sake of music to improve it, play better, try to compose better and make better sounds. But this is not something that really benefits me other than being able to do it. 41:35 We know for certain that our deeds will take with us into the grave and into the hereafter. So a good deed, our charity, our recitation of Quran, our prayers, our kindness to each other, to our families, and our learning Islamic knowledge is something that we will bring into the hereafter with us that we know will benefit us. And this is something that we should spend more time with. Instead of spending more time with something that would just be a complete waste, 42:07 or more seriously, will also come with us into the hereafter and might bring punishment onto us. May Allah protect us from that. So, with that nasiha, again I'm saying that I'm not making any fatwa here, as I'm not qualified to do so, but there are many people who are qualified, and I suggest anyone who has any questions in this matter to seek out the religious scholars who know about this matter and can talk much more about what is said in the Quran, what is said about the sahaba and the tabareen. 42:40 I pious predecessors about this matter. And to do serious research with sincerity. With sincerity. If I approach this issue trying to find permissibility for me to go ahead and continue with my lifestyle with music, maybe I could probably push to make it mean exactly that. But if we approach this issue and other issues with complete sincerity, inshallah Allah will guide us to the correct choice and will make us successful, inshallah. 43:13 So, I want to thank you all for coming and listening to my short talk. I'd be happy to take any questions. Although, as I mentioned before, I'm not really qualified to talk about the Islamic literature. But I'd be happy to talk about music. Okay? Yes. The question is, what can we say about the Muslims of Muslim Spain and their contributions to music? Well, as I understand, the Muslims of Spain... 43:44 They were very good musicians. In fact, they were in the process of really refining the art at the time that they were thrown out of Spain, and perhaps the events eliminated. There were some developments of the written manuscript of music that was taking place at that time. Later on, after the Muslims were expelled, the Europeans took that, and of course their own innovations, and developed... 44:13 the very, very sophisticated system of musical notation. It's said that Spanish Muslims invented the guitar. However, if we say that they invented the guitar, we can't say all guitars, because I just mentioned Mr. Prophet also talked about a lute, which is a type of guitar-like instrument. So exactly how that instrument differs from other similar instruments, I'm not really sure of. But the Muslims of Spain were very involved in music. 44:40 And, incidentally, they were also involved in many other corruptions, which, as we know, led to their downfall. Similarly, if we look at Turkey and the Ottomans, we find similar cases. Great musicians, great dancers, great wealth and spending of wealth, and perhaps this also led to their downfall. Okay, the brother mentioned, to summarize, that music... 45:10 has taken Muslims away from the seriousness of our religion and has distracted Muslims. And he repeated the ayat that we mentioned earlier. And he stated that Ibn Mas'ud said that this idle talk referred to in the Quran is sinning. And also he mentioned the hadith that we mentioned earlier. I just want to mention that as far as taking Muslims away from the seriousness, it's interesting to note that in times past when... 45:39 when Israel was at war with the Arab countries, that the Israelis used to play the music and broadcast it to the Arab areas. Interesting. There's another question here. Is it haram to sing in your own home without instruments, especially children's songs? To my understanding, no, it is not haram to do so. That's one of the exceptions that I mentioned earlier, that if a parent, for example, is singing a song with a child, 46:11 Provided, of course, the song is not inviting evil or dealing with the worship of something other than Allah or some sort of al-Gharati. So long as it's something that's necessarily acceptable that this is okay. There is no context of, so to say, on whether music is haram, you know, and plainly haram or otherwise. 46:42 I think that, like some people are trying to suggest, that music is like other aspects of human culture which can accommodate, I mean, which can be corrupted and which is also capable of being defiant. I think that, like some people are trying to suggest, that we can reform music. I mean, reforming it will be... 47:14 less demanding than prohibiting it entirely. It has been in human nature, and so it seems so expected to remain. Especially in Muslim societies, if you can suggest ways that which music can be refined, even though we cannot say that we are Islamizing it like days before, I don't know what's your view about that. 47:44 that we allow the music to escape and suggest ways of refining it. So let's keep it a little bit objective. The benefits of several different points. Of course, as I mentioned in the very beginning, music is a part of all cultures, even Muslim cultures. It's here. And it's deeply ingrained in the soul of human beings. And it's probably not going to go anywhere. 48:16 if we judge history as any indication of what may happen in the future, that music will probably always be in our society, in some segments of our societies always. And also the better mention that music is a part of human achievement. I might mention some other things also that of course are also part of being human. The example may seem a little bit extreme, but think about it. Killing, for example, is something that is part of human society since the very, very beginning. War. 48:46 Cheetos, Zinnia. People have been smoking marijuana for thousands of years. And people have gone to tremendous lengths. And one of the greatest technical achievements that we have are in weaponry, figuring out ways to kill each other. And I hope that this will not be some sort of way to say that these things are necessarily good. Now, I don't mean to equate music necessarily with... 49:18 killing, but I'm saying that things that are part of being human are not always necessarily good. And this is why we have religion. This is why Allah gives us a guide to live our lives, to stay away from the bad things that are part of our world, and to go into the good things, to make choices between what's right and what's wrong. This is what our religion is all about. Then also I mentioned reforming music instead of not allowing it completely, to make it 49:48 to give it maybe more of an Islamic flavor, possibly, instead of just prohibiting it, necessarily. But the question comes down to, well, what did the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, say about music? Okay? I mentioned a little bit, some of what he said, in authentic narration, during my talk just now, in which the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, mentioned musical instruments along with these other things. The other source, 50:17 to look at, of course, the Quran. Now someone could easily say, well, music is not really mentioned in the Quran. Okay. But let's look at the opinions of the earliest Muslims. The earliest Muslims. See, the opinions are better than ours could ever be because they knew the Prophet personally. And they could ask him questions. They lived with him. And the Prophet said that the best generation was his generation. They were with him. They saw the Prophet. They lived with him. They knew him in a way that we could never know. And the next generation after him will be the next generation. 50:48 And the next after that, the next. So if we want to learn something about our religion, it naturally behooves us to look at what the Prophet said, and what his companions said. The people who were with him and knew him best, and knew the religion best. And after that, the next generation. Okay? The Qadayim. The people who came after that. And then the people who came after that. To see what they said. Not only about music, but about any issue. Let's see what their opinion is. Because their opinions are stronger. I've mentioned some of the opinions of the early imams. 51:18 But there are other opinions. The guy mentioned Ibn Mas'ud saying that this is singing. Ibn Abbas made a similar analysis of the same thing. So that's my suggestion, is to go back and see what these say. Saying that it's part of being human or part of being culture, part of human culture, is not an argument in support of doing something necessarily. So we have to go back to the basics. 51:48 the very basics of our religion. Because that's our foundation of our religion. That's the foundation that can never be changed. When we need to know something about the religion, we can talk about the Quran, the Sunnah, the opinions of the earliest Muslims, and those who came afterwards. So that's my best suggestion. Again, I'm not a scholar making a patch for you, but I'm saying look into the issue so that there won't be any doubt. As I mentioned before, I was a musician deeply involved in this. 52:19 deeply involved in music. And I don't want you to think that I'm coming out with some sort of reaction having become a Muslim. It was several years in which I looked into the issue and kept trying to justify it and continue it in different ways. So my best advice to anyone is to just look into the issue from the Islamic literature and make your own judgment. Consult the people who are knowledgeable today and see what they have to say. Someone mentioned Justin Buzz. 52:50 There have been many, many, many others. Okay? Yes, please. I clearly remember when reading the Hadith by Avocati that one of the sayings by the Prophet was that we shall not listen to music which comes from instruments played by air or by strings. I remember that very clearly. I can't cite the exact reference. My question is, more on the present day, I've noticed many groups coming up now using Islamic names. 53:21 And specifically, Paula Abdul. Are these people Muslims or are they just mimicking Islamic names? And if they are, this seems to place a very bad effect on Islamic society. And it seems to degrade all the work that we're trying to do to put Islam in a favorable, acceptable light. They seem to be tearing it down quickly. Paula Abdul. I hear that she's half Syrian, but I don't know if that's true. 53:51 I hear that she's half Syrian, but she really does have a Muslim name. But do that as it may. It's true that many groups now use Muslim names. I can think of several off the top of my head. Queen Latifah and many others. But this actually is representing something that's going on in America, an American phenomenon, which is actually the Islamic influence that's happening in America. You find many African Americans taking Muslim names even when they're not even Muslim. And this is because of the... 54:20 Islam has influenced the African-American community tremendously in America, and it's gone to such an extent that names are very common. When I was teaching in elementary school in New York City, I ran into one child who was named Allah. The boy's name was Allah. His parents named him Allah. Many, many other names like that. In fact, many names are invented because they sound sort of like Muslim names. So this is a phenomenon. This shows Islamic influence. Now, of course... 54:46 As Muslims, we have to try to correct this sort of thing. I mean, you can't say, hey, God's in here, you know. It's not acceptable. But, you know, at least that does show some sort of Islamic influence, and we hope that in the future that the Islamic influence will grow to the extent that they'll become Muslims and their Muslim names will be genuine. Inshallah. Yes. Do I have any advice for people who are maintaining their livelihood through music? Well, my advice to anyone, 55:22 Muslim or not is to come to Islam for the Muslim to come back to Islam and to try to make it something that comes into the totality of their life not just in one aspect of prayer or something else but to make Islam something living in all of their life so of course if somebody is living their life and making their money doing something that's forbidden another example might be working in a bank 55:52 or something worse than that, you know, working as a prostitute or something like this. The best thing to do is to try to leave that, which is bad, and replace it with something that's good. We, of course, should try to know our religion very well, so that there's no question about what's wrong and what's right, and to put into practice, like I mentioned earlier, reading the Quran. But better than reading the Quran is understanding the Quran and putting it into practice. That's my advice to myself and to anyone. Yes, brother? Yeah, the gentleman mentioned the Hadith. 56:26 I don't have the ideas in front of me. I can't speak on its authenticity or anything. But he mentions that the Prophet said that if someone leaves something for the sake of Allah, which is the meaning more or less, if someone leaves something for the sake of Allah, Allah will replace it. And sure, if somebody leaves something bad, of course Allah will replace it. Allah is just and Allah will give us what we deserve. Hopefully He will give us mercy and Allah will be just with us. 56:58 So if we need something that's bad, we can be sure that Allah will reward us for it, if we're sincere. Okay, I hope that our discussion was helpful. I know it was helpful for me. I just want to remind us that all of us are in this life together, and we're in this dream together. And we must work together and help each other. Okay? Nobody is perfect. So when we stumble, when we fall, or when we have problems, 57:34 The brother should not be there to condemn, but to help, mixed up. So, inshallah, we could be successful. World Assembly of Muslim Youth, WANI. The World Assembly of Muslim Youth was founded in 1392 of the Hijrah. 58:13 That is 1972 of the Christian era. Its headquarters is in Riyadh, the capital of Saudi Arabia. The World Assembly of Muslim Youth is the first international Islamic organization dealing specifically with youth affairs. It embraces over 450 Islamic youth and student organizations in the five continents. Among the owners of WAMI are the following five. 58:49 One, to serve the true Islamic ideology based on Tawheed, the unity of God. Two, to consolidate the factors which are necessary to establish an ideological unity among Muslims and to strengthen the Islamic fraternal relationship among the Muslim youth. To introduce Islam to the world 59:24 by using all available means. Four, to support the constructive role of youth and students in developing an Islamic society. To assist Islamic youth organizations all over the globe by coordinating their activities and helping them to implement their projects. International conferences. Wyoming holds an international conference every three years. 60:02 Several such conferences have already taken place. Five of them in Riyadh in the years 1972, 1973, 1976, 1979 and 1986. One in Nairobi, Kenya in 1982 and another one in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia in the year 1993. They were attended by representatives of Islamic youth, 60:32 and student organizations from all over the world. The participants were selected members of WAMI's General Secretariat and they discussed issues concerning Muslim youth. WAMI also holds and assists in holding local and regional youth camps in different parts of the world throughout the year in order to train Muslim youth in leadership and organization. The World Assembly of Muslim Youth. 61:10 P.O. Box 1084-5. Riyadh 11443. Saudi Arabia. Telephone 01-464-1663. 464-1669. 462-8984. 462-8984. 61:43 and also fax 014641710 62:21 or 464-1669, or 462-8984, or 462-8975. You may also reach Wani by sending a fax to 01-464-1710.