Otomatik metin. Hatalar içerebilir; kelimelerin doğrusu için kayda başvurun.
0:00 We're still studying the times of Salat, times of prayer. Last time, we did not have time. So, for another time, Brother Fadi will read us Hadith number 136. 0:32 All right. Narrated by Abu Sayyid al-Khudri, may Allah be pleased with him, I heard Allah's Messenger, peace be upon him, saying, no salat, meaning prayer, is to be offered after the morning prayer until the sun rises, or after the afternoon prayer until the sun sets. And in the narration of Muslim, there is no salat prayer after the Fajr morning prayer. Abu Ibn Namr narrated, there is no, narrated, there are three times at which Allah's Messenger, 1:05 Okay. If you recall last time we talked about this hadith, we said that Saeed al-Khudri's hadith talks about two general times with a long time span between them. 1:38 And Uqba ibn Amir talks about three specific times that are very short and not that long. And to sum things up, it's very easy to make them into three times. And that is, after Asr prayer, until the sun sets completely. We have here two times. After Asr prayer, until the sun begins to set. 2:06 from the moment it begins to sit until it disappears completely so these are two times the last time that the latter one is the latter period is extremely forbidden to be prayed in because this is the time where the non-muslims prostrate to it those who associate others with allah whether they're devil worshippers or whatever so this is one time the second time is when after a person prays fajr 2:36 until the sun rises. And just before it rises, this is one time. When it begins to rise, until it's completely risen, this is the second time, and it's about five to ten minutes. So these are two times. Actually, there are four in two. And the last one, as in Uqba ibn Amr's hadith, when the sun is exactly in the middle of the sky. 3:07 which is about 5 to 10 minutes before the Adhan. And when is the Adhan called for Dhuhr, Rushdie? It's not written. Pardon me? When does the Adhan for Dhuhr is called? When is it called? When the sun... Zaki. When the sun... Sun rise... When the shadow is... Yes. 3:47 Same with the... No. Nor? When a shadow is a little to the meridian. Yes and no. Abu Malik? When the sun is beginning to turn to west, leaving the middle point. Okay. When the sun starts to head towards the west and the object begins to have a shadow. 4:19 This is called Zawal. Dhuhr prayer is indicated by this short shadow. As you remember, when Fajr is called and sun rises, the shadow comes from the west towards the east. And it decreases as the sun rises. And the minute the sun is in the middle of the sky, when the object has no shadow, it's forbidden for us to pray. Until... 4:48 The Dhuhr is called. Dhuhr prayer is called. And when does Dhuhr prayer, the time of Dhuhr prayer begins? It's when the sun sets to the west a bit and the object begins to have a shadow pointing eastwards. This is the time for Dhuhr prayer. So, we have three times, if you look at it in a general way, or we have five times. 5:17 These times it's forbidden for us to pray. The question is, Brother Mustafa, it's forbidden for us to pray all kinds of prayer? Voluntary prayers only. Voluntary prayers only. Because obligatory prayer, you can pray them any time of the day or night. There are no restrictions, none whatsoever, for you to refrain from praying. Now, we come to these hadiths. Scholars have different opinions. 5:48 as usual because some of them say well when it tells us not to pray this is not because it's forbidden no because it's not recommended but if you pray then it's okay some scholars say this other scholars say well it's forbidden because the prophet tells us not to do it so some scholars say you do not pray any type of prayers at all and this is 6:16 One of the schools that does this are the Hanafi school, also the Maliki school. And that is why if you see a person that follows the school of Malik ibn Anas, may Allah have mercy on him, you would find him coming before Maghrib prayer and sitting down immediately without praying anything, without offering anything. And also the followers of Abu Hanifa, they would do the same thing. So others say, no, you may pray. 6:45 And if you look at it, you would find that you are stuck between a rock and a hard place. Because on one hand, you have the Prophet saying, do not pray during these five times. And on the other hand, I come into the mosque after Asr prayer, I'd like to sit down until it's Maghrib, I'd like to read Quran. I want to sit down, but I remember that the Prophet said that whoever enters a mosque, 7:16 must not sit down until he prays two rak'ah. So what do I do? Again, we have a conflict that appears to be conflict in here between two hadiths. And if you recall, we have set four stages, four steps for us to follow whenever there is a dispute or a conflict between two hadiths. One, we join. If we cannot, we look for a hadith or 7:46 the one that obligated the other. If we cannot, we try to determine which one is stronger or more authentic. If we cannot, we just wait until another scholar comes in and Allah gave him knowledge. Zaki, you have a question? Yes, I have some story that I got in my home. Someone pray, ask for prayer, and after praying, 8:15 He prayed again two raka'at and then after praying I asked him, what kind of prayer you do after that? After a moment he said to me, I pray two raka'at to my brother who has died. It is included to the sunnah prayer or maybe... Well, what this gentleman did... 8:46 was wrong in two ways. One, he offered voluntary prayer after Asr, and this is not permissible. The Prophet said, it's forbidden. Two, he offered a prayer to a dead person. And scholars say that no one can offer prayer on behalf of a dead person. Of course, not even on behalf of a living person. Because prayer is an individual form of worship. It's different than 9:16 paying charity, sadaqah. And it's different than performing umrah or hajj. Because you can do this. You can give your hajj to someone else. So if I have a grandfather that is dead, I would say, okay, this year's hajj for my grandfather. And before I set off for hajj, I say, labbayka Allahumma hajjan an my grandfather. This hajj is for my grandfather. But prayer cannot be 9:43 There is no transaction in prayer. You cannot draft a prayer and give it to someone else. This is not acceptable. So he did two mistakes. One and two. Coming back to our hadith, coming back to our dilemma, this guy who came into the mosque and does not know what to do. What do you guys think? Should he sit down without praying? And then he would have not followed the second hadith of the Prophet? 10:14 Or should he pray and then he would have prayed in the time of Nahi? The time where he was not supposed to pray as mentioned in the five times. What do you think? Mustafa? I think he should not pray. He should not pray because the Prophet says that these are times of Nahi. Should he sit down? Yes. Okay. Rushdie? I think I have the same opinion with Brother Mustafa. 10:46 it's better left the salah because it's the time is for a bit i mean okay abu malik well i assume he should pray because this yeah the other hadith you know these are talking about certain prayers this takes this prayer out of these ones you know i say so you're trying to join both hadiths instead of neglecting one exactly of them brother zaki yes i think he could pray 11:14 He could or he should? He should pray. Pray. So we have two knees and two knees. Okay, we're looking for elbows now. Fadi? I think this is an exception. When he entered the mosque, he's not allowed to sit. Therefore, he should pray. And this is like a type of obligation to not pray. Not obligation. Just like an exception. Specializing a general thing. Noam? I think he should pray. 11:44 You think you should pray. What school are you following? Shafi? Yes. Like all Indonesians, you are all Shafi school. And this is an issue of dispute among scholars. And each one has his own chunk of evidence, which is considered to be authentic and correct. It depends how you look at it. And the first thing that we should put in mind is that... 12:16 always allow those who differ with you in opinion to have room of thinking. So it's not always that what I think is the ultimate and it's the best and what you think is wrong. There has to be common ground. I see it this way and I have the evidence that backs it up. You see it differently and you have the evidence that backs it up. We're all doing the right thing, so there's no need for us to fight over it, especially in... 12:45 Lots of things that differences among us is possible and probable. Before going to details, I think we have a short break, so stay tuned. As-salamu alaykum wa rahmatullah and welcome back. Just before the break, we had an interesting survey regarding that if a person enters the masjid, the mosque, just after asr prayer, and he has prayed asr. 13:14 And he would like to sit down and recite the Quran. So what would he do? Would he pray two rak'ah, the salute of the masjid, as it's called among scholars, tahiyyat al-masjid, so that he can sit? Or would he sit without praying? And in both cases, he would have done something that seems to be conflicting with the hadith or the other of the Prophet, alayhi salatu wasalam. We have split decision here. And thank God we don't have to... 13:44 refer to the Golden Goal, and we will just move on and mention what the scholars said about this issue. One, Al-Imam Al-Shafi'i, may Allah be pleased with him and have mercy on his soul, said that if you look at all the hadiths, see, this is the job of a faqih. This is the job of a scholar that works and deals with jurisprudence. 14:13 he should look into all evidence, not only to one. Because if you limit yourself to one, there are many others that have exceptions and exemptions and so on, and you would lose a lot. So Ashafei says that after looking at all the evidence, we can say that it is prohibited for a Muslim to pray during these five times that we've mentioned before. 14:42 After Asr, until the sun sets. After Fajr, until the sun rises. And during midday, when the sun is exactly in the middle of the sky. He says, but there are exceptions, with the exception of things that have a reason. So it is prohibited for us to pray if it's voluntarily general forms of prayer. What are you doing? 15:13 I don't have anything to do, so I'm just going to pray. No, sit down. It's forbidden. It's the time now. It's forbidden for you to pray. And there's another different form of prayers, and that is prayers that have a reason behind them. And he called it the prayers with a reason. For example, we prayed Asr. And just as we prayed Asr and we finished praying, 15:44 They brought a funeral, and we have to pray the prayer of the funeral, of the dead. So one says, hmm, that's a prayer. We can't pray until the sun sets. We cannot pray until the sun sets. So what do you think? Leave the guy lying there for three, four hours and not pray? Or shall we pray? The answer is, we should pray. Then... 16:13 How would we say that do not pray after Asr? This is exempted because this has a reason. This has a cause. Another example. You enter the mosque, you pray Asr prayer. And just as you finish Asr, there's an eclipse of the sun. I don't know if it's possible to have the sun eclipse after Asr, but you have to ask those that deal with the stars. Let's assume. So what do we do? We pray. 16:43 the prayer of eclipse. Why? Because it is time for it. It's being called for. And likewise, if I am going to engage, I'm going to propose to a woman after Asr prayer, the Sunnah is to make Istikhara. Istikhara is a prayer with supplication requesting Allah Azza wa Jal to choose for you and to 17:12 support you if it's good for you and to distract you away from it if it's bad for you. So I have to propose. I hope my wife is not watching again. I'm going to propose after Asr prayer. But I did not perform Istikhara. And my meeting with them is at 5 o'clock. So should I go without making Istikhara and then find myself in real bad trouble because I didn't seek Allah's support? Or should I pray? Scholars say, 17:41 Go ahead and pray. Because this has a legitimate reason. It's not voluntary prayer. It's not something, a preferred prayer you're doing, you're just offering without any reason. And this is the choice of Sheikh al-Islam ibn Taymiyyah, the choice of Sheikh Abdulaziz bin Baz, Sheikh Muhammad ibn Saleh al-Thaymeen, and all the authentic and strong scholars, knowledgeable scholars of Islam. 18:10 They say that this way we combine all evidence together without neglecting this one or that one. It's all combined and it's all joined in one category. Brother Mustafa, you have a question. So that will exclude, for example, if I missed the sunnah of Fajr, can I pray it after Fajr directly? This is different because there's a hadith that states it's okay. So we don't have to imagine things. 18:41 There's a hadith, the Prophet ﷺ finished one day, he finished Fajr prayer, and then saw one of his companions praying next to a pillar, praying two rak'ah. So he came and stood beside him and said angrily, while the guy was praying, is Fajr four rak'ah? Is Fajr four rak'ah? And he kept on repeating it. The guy finished the prayer quickly and said, oh Prophet of Allah, I ask Allah for forgiveness. I left my house. 19:10 without praying the sunnah and i came into the masjid while you were praying in the congregation so i joined you and immediately after you finished i came to pray the two rak'ah of sunnah that i was supposed to pray before but i couldn't i was late so the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam did not say a word and this is one type of sunnah there are four types of sunnah let's try and brainstorm it the first type of sunnah who knows it 19:44 Saying by words. Words. If the Prophet says something, this is sunnah. The second type of sunnah. Action. By action. By action. So if the Prophet does something, this is sunnah. Because he did it, so we do it afterwards. Third form of sunnah. Statement. Statement was already mentioned. First type, which is words. Sunnah is silence. If he refuses to answer. Approvals. Approvals. 20:13 So in this case here, the companion said something and the prophet did not say anything, which meant that he approved it. Otherwise the prophet would have said, no, don't do it again. So by not saying anything, this becomes a sunnah approval. And the fourth and last sunnah is the sunnah. Well, this is again either considered by deeds or approvals. Because, for example, hadith. 20:42 We used to, well I don't want to translate this, they used to do something at the time of the Prophet while the Quran was revealed. And the Prophet did not deny them from doing it, so this is an approval. No, the fourth type of sunnah is the description of the Prophet . So when one of the companions say that the Prophet was this high, he was this big, his eyes were this form, 21:12 His fingers were this or that. He used to wear this and that. This is called Sunnah Wasfiya, describing the Prophet . Coming back again, you have to catch up with me because so many times I talk and I forget what brought me to this issue. So remind me, what brought me to this issue? Nevertheless, yes? We're talking about the times we were allowed to pray during Awqad al-Nahy. 21:41 Okay, so this is the verdict of the scholars that you are allowed to pray in the times that you're not allowed to pray, depending that the prayer has a legitimate reason, a legitimate cause of it. One thing I'd like to point out for you is that the time may span and may be short. Now, it's forbidden for us to pray after Asr till the sun sets. 22:12 Now, does this mean it's forbidden for me to pray from 5 o'clock until 8 o'clock, which is from Asr to Maghrib? No, it can be shortened. In the case, if a person did not pray Asr yet, so if a person prays Asr at 6 o'clock, though people have prayed and gone home, he can pray as long as he has not prayed Asr. I believe that this is understood. 22:42 Again, if you reverse this, if a person is traveling and he preceded Asr prayer and prayed it Jam'a Taqdeem with Dhuhr. So Dhuhr is called at 1 o'clock. He prayed 4 Raka'a of Dhuhr and he prayed 4 Raka'a of Asr. Or, because he's traveling, he prayed 2 and 2. So he prayed 2 Raka'a of Dhuhr, then he prayed 2 Raka'a of Asr. And the time is still 1 o'clock. 23:11 The call for Asr has not been called yet. So if the guy came to the mosque at 2 o'clock and said, well, let me pray Nafl. I just want to pray voluntary prayer. Is this allowed? It's 2 o'clock. The call for Asr has not been called yet. Is this allowed for him? No, no, he went into the mosque now. Now he prayed Dhuhr and Asr. And at 2 o'clock, he went to a mosque while he was traveling. 23:42 And he thought that I might as well sit and rest for about half an hour and pray sunnah, voluntary prayer for about half an hour, then continue to travel. Is it permissible for him to pray? Yes. Yes. Rushdie? Me? Rushdie? I think... Yes or no? Yes. Zaki? Yes. Noor? Yes. Fadi? No. Mustafa? Well, we got four... 24:12 Opposing two, and unfortunately two leads the way. He is not allowed to pray. Now if you look again at the Hadith we've studied, the Prophet says that it's forbidden for you to pray after Asr until the sun sets. You as a traveler, did you pray Asr? You prayed Asr, but you prayed it at one o'clock because you have the option to proceed the prayer. So now it is for you forbidden to pray. 24:43 voluntary prayer though the call for us has not been called because for you individually the prophet tells you that it is not permissible for you to pray until the sun sets so as i said it is individual basis it's quite can be quite uh long on and also on individual basis can be quite short depending if you did not pray asr you can do this we have like uh 55 seconds okay 25:11 What if someone, for any reason, forgot the Fajr prayer? In the same case, forgot the Sunnah of the Fajr prayer. And the Prophet, he never left the Sunnah of the Fajr when he was traveling. And he came in this time between Dhuhr and Asr. Can he enter the mosque and pray the Sunnah of the Fajr that he had left earlier before he left the country or his town? In this case, there is a hadith narrated by Umm Salama where the Prophet, peace be upon him, used to pray two rak'ahs of... 25:40 So she asked him, now you said that we should not pray. How come you're praying? He said, well, I was engaged with some delegation that came to visit me and I could not make it. I could not pray the sunnah. So he prayed it. So she asked, can we pray it? The prophet said, no, you cannot. So this answers your question. You have to delay it afterwards. I'm afraid that this is all the time we have for today's program. 26:09 I think there are a few issues here and there. We shall be able to continue it when we meet next time. Until then, fi amanillah. Wassalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh.