Transcription automatique : elle peut contenir des erreurs, vérifiez l'enregistrement pour la formulation exacte.
0:00 Our praise is due to Allah and may Allah's peace and blessings be on his last prophet Muhammad and on all those who follow the path of righteousness until the last day. The topic of today's sermon concerns 0:31 what is known in Arabic as hududullah or the six punishments which Allah has set for certain crimes. And these punishments have a particular significance to us and to Islamic society, the individuals as well as the community and the society as a whole which cannot be underestimated. The enemies of Islam or those who are ignorant 1:09 of the purpose or the purposes behind Islamic laws concerning criminal justice have taken this as one of the weak points of Islam that Muslims apply laws which are from medieval times from ancient times when people were barbaric when they treated those who committed crimes very cruelly 1:46 So they chop off heads, they chop off hands, stone people to death. These are all looked at as being barbaric forms of punishment. However, when we look at the effect of these punishments on the society, the peace and the tranquility which comes out of the implementation of these laws, we would then... 2:24 have to question seriously the objections that are raised by those either enemies of Islam or those ignorant of Islamic law and its principles. I would like to just briefly look at the main set punishments and discuss or present briefly the effect on society of the application of these particular punishments. 3:02 The first, the punishment for murder. We have the statement by Allah SWT that those who kill the life, those who take a life, their lives will be taken. The law concerning murder, that a person who kills is killed. This law has its basis in 3:39 what is known as the Mosaic Law, the Ten Commandments, the Law of the Torah. And of course, this is not necessarily where it all began, but this is the codified form which has been retained in Scripture that we know about. But the idea, the eye for the eye, the tooth for the tooth, this is a basic law which has been practiced by the Prophet. 4:12 from the recorded time of Prophet Moses and it is enshrined also in the system of Islamic law. The taking of a life when a life is taken. The importance of it is that if a person does not feel that his life will be taken, if he takes a life, this becomes an open encouragement for that individual to take a life at any instance. 4:44 If he knows that his life may be taken, this will cause him to think. It doesn't mean that no one will commit any murders once they know lives will be taken. However, many of those who may have committed murders if they thought that they could get away with it or their life wouldn't be taken, many of those who would have done that would think about it. There are some crimes which are what you call crimes of passion. 5:14 Where a person just, you know, flies off the handle. You know, just goes, as Western psychologists, you know, call it, temporarily insane. And he takes somebody's life. So, those type of crimes will continue in any society, no matter what laws you set up. However, for a large portion, it would cause them to think. Of course, Western... 5:46 psychologists etc who have studied the issue of of application of the death penalty have recommended that the death penalty not be applied in the West because of the fact that it has not significantly reduced murder the incidence of murder in the society this is the argument that they they hold and in a Western context 6:18 This may be so. This may very well be so. Why? Because people are not executed publicly. Because when they want to execute somebody, they take them into a prison, behind closed doors, only a few people observe, and that person is executed. It's just reported in the newspaper, statistics, something just written there. So it doesn't have very much meaning. You know, just like... 6:48 When you hear of so many people starving in this country and so many people dying in that country, it is just numbers written. It's not the same as if you go and you see these people starving. The effect that it has on you is much greater than just reading it as a statistic. Similarly, when the law is applied publicly, when the masses of people are encouraged to come and see the law in application, this has a much greater effect on the population than when it is done privately. And when you look, 7:18 Back in the past, even in America and Europe, in France and in England, etc., people used to be publicly executed. They used to be. You know, if any of you have seen the Wild West movies, you know, when that individual is finally caught, the bad guy, you know, you see them erecting this gallows in the middle of the town, you know, on the main street, and they hang the person. This was the practice. 7:48 And it has continued up until fairly recently. What we find here, for example, where this law is applied, and you have approximately 8 million people here in Saudi Arabia. 8 million people. And in New York City, you also have 8 million people. However, the murder rate here is equivalent. 8:24 approximately to the number of murders in a year, which take place here in Saudi Arabia, in a year, is equivalent approximately to the number of murders which take place in New York City in one week or one to two weeks. This is the difference. We're having a similar number of people, but with the application of the law directly, the execution, public execution, then you find the incidence of murder is significantly less. 8:56 The application of this law also can discourage people from committing the crime, people who may be doing such crimes out of vindictiveness. For example, last weekend, you know, last Friday, four Filipinos lost their heads in Dira here, right? And in case you're not aware of the reason why their heads were chopped off, it was because... 9:26 They were originally five. One amongst them had accepted Islam. And he had been going to pray in the mosque and so on and so on. The other four were so upset about the fact that he accepted Islam, that one day when he came back from prayer, they held him down and sodomized him. And after sodomizing him, he was so upset he was trying to get back at them, fight them. Then they stabbed him to death. 9:56 So the four of them, this is just out of their hatred and vindictiveness because of the fact that this man accepted Islam. They couldn't let him go. They felt they had to degrade him and punish him for accepting Islam. And they ended up killing him. So all four of them who took part in this crime were executed last weekend. So this, the knowledge of this, would help those people. 10:28 You know, who are upset about the people becoming Muslims, have them think twice before they would try to get any kind of revenge or do anything against Muslims. This is essential. The society, you know, take care of such cases and ensure the safety of those people who are accepting Islam. Also, we have the law concerning fornication and adultery. We know... 11:01 In the case of fornication where a person has extramarital sex, when that person is not in a state of marriage or not having ever been in a state of marriage, the punishment for that act is 100 lashes publicly. If a person has sex outside of marriage, being married or having ever been married, then the punishment is death, stoning to death. 11:34 This is Islamic law. And this is to show how high Islam values chastity in the society. People maintain their chastity. And this is for the protection ultimately of females and children. Because the children that are born out of non-marital circumstances... 12:02 who become stigmatized by the society, people who don't know who their parents are, etc., etc. I mean, this is psychologically devastating for such children. And as I said, the person who suffers the most when such relationships take place tends to be the women. Because the man who is involved in such relationships can carry on and nobody knows that he has done so. But the woman, when she does so, you know... 12:32 She is no longer virgin for one or she may become pregnant. And these expose the reality of her situation. So she is the one who suffers. Herself specifically and the children most. So this law is there. Very stringent. However, though this law is so severe. And I made a distinction between the person who has never been married. 13:03 And the one who has been married or is in a state of marriage, because sometimes people when understanding what adultery and fornication is in Islamic law, they think that adultery is only when a person has extramarital sexual relations, when they are in a state of marriage. However, according to Islamic law, if they have ever been married, it is still considered adultery. Because the act of marriage, for them having been into the act of marriage, this provides them with a certain 13:32 consciousness and a certain protection from adultery or fornication or relationships outside of marriage which the person who has never been married doesn't have so this is why the law is much more severe for the one who has ever been married and the one who is married than the one who has never been married now despite the fact that the law is so severe 14:01 In all of the cases of executions in a year, you will be hard pressed to find one or two who are being executed for adultery and those that are last for fornication. There are few. Why? Because there is a condition that four witnesses must observe this act. It means that a person 14:35 has to be so flagrant, so uncaring in terms of anybody finding out that they have done it in such a public place or in such a public circumstance that four witnesses could observe them. So the law is really, in the case of adultery, it is really on the books as, you could say, a scare tactic to cause people to think twice. It is not applied just like that across the board. 15:13 If a woman, of course, the one who tends to be found out is the woman. The woman who does so and gets pregnant, then she is open now to execution because there's evidence. This is practical evidence and she will be executed. But if she points to the man and says, well, he did it. That's not enough evidence to apply the law to that man. Unless he confesses himself. So that's why I said the woman is the one who suffers the most. 15:44 And the law is there primarily, as I said, as a deterrent, a general deterrent. And it is rarely applied, even down to Islamic history. The number of cases of the application of the law for adultery, death by stoning, are very few. Very few. Also, the law concerning homosexuality. It is death for the one who is involved in the act, both sides. 16:21 The one who is doing it as well as the one that it is being done to. Such individuals who are caught in this act, they are also executed according to Islamic law. And this, of course, this sin is a major sin from an Islamic point of view. It has nothing to do with whether you are married or you have not been married or whatever. It is just automatic if you are caught in this act. Or if you are caught in the act of bestiality, having relationships with animals. 16:53 Also, you will be executed. Any of these forms of deviation, the law in Islam is death. You know, you are carrying with you a sickness that you as an individual have to be weeded out from the society. You will not be given a second chance. You know, in America where people commit such crimes, they're given second chances. You go to jail for a year or, you know, you're on probation. 17:23 And then these people end up committing these crimes again and again and again. So many cases of individuals being jailed and coming back out and committing very heinous crimes. So in Islam it is one chance, that's it. You are caught one time, that's it. And one thing to note in the application of the law concerning murder is that there is a concession for a person who is ruled insane. I mean there is compassion there in Islamic law. 17:57 If a person is ruled insane, then the law is not applied. However, the ruling for insanity is not as it is applied, for example, in the West, where you have a battery of psychologists, they will be testing this person back and forth, and then they finally end up with a ruling of temporary insanity. 18:18 And there are conditions for what defines a person as being insane. If you were to apply that to the population, you would have to say that the vast majority of people walking around are insane, in one way or another. They're psychologically imbalanced, etc., etc. No, in the Islamic law, legal system, a person is judged insane if they were known to be insane before the act. If they were known to be a person, I mean, we know who people are truly insane, we know who they are. Such people, you know, who have 18:48 no grasp of reality I mean their minds are gone before such an act if they commit an act of murder then they are not executed they are put away in an institution or whatever and I should also ask that there is also a factor of wherein the family of those if an individual if my father for example were killed I have the right to take 19:19 from the person who committed the murder a fine. It's called a dia. They may pay me a fine instead of that person being executed. However, it is rare that you will find people accepting it. But that option is also there. That a person may take, you know, looking into the circumstance or whatever, you know, that person may judge that the instance, you know, there may have been some 19:53 sort of justifiable or semi-justifiable factors. You know, a person may accept a blood payment or what they call blood money or, you know, dia for a murder. In the case of the person who takes out weapons, who steals, but he does through armed robbery, he's a highway robber or he robs a bank using weapons. Such a person 20:24 then is liable to the punishment of death he is classified under what is called Muharrim one who takes out weapons against the society and he may be executed the legal system has a choice of executing that person or cutting off his right hand and his left leg or crucifying him or 20:56 banishing him from the land. It's an option. Depending on the seriousness of the crime, the judge may choose one of the different options. Normally for stealing, if a person steals above a certain set amount, then the hand is amputated at the wrist. If the person did so in a fashion which indicates that that person is a professional criminal. 21:29 What do I mean by that? I mean that if one, you left your watch, an expensive Rolex watch, you know, on a table and you went someplace and somebody picked it up and went with it, they're not going to cut the person's hand off for that. Because there was temptation. The person may not normally be a professional criminal who's plotting and planning, but due to the instant that he found himself in, there was this temptation and he grabbed the watch. 21:58 his hand will not be cut off in this circumstance. If also a person, you know, say you're working for a company, and I'm not saying this to encourage thievery, but if you're working for a company and your boss is not paying you your salary and you stole from your boss, they would not cut your hand off here either, right? Because there is some justification here. Your rights were not being given, so they would not apply the law in this circumstance. 22:27 or in a time of famine or a time of calamity, you know, where people are in a state of desperation, they may, you know, break into a home here or there to get food or whatever for their own survival, they will not apply the law to such people. The law is then applied to those people like pickpockets. The person, because there is no temptation here, this is a man who has learned a skill, you know, of working his hand into your pocket, you know, bouncing against you without you realizing it, he's pulled your wallet and he's gone. 22:56 This is a professional thief who has planned and practiced. He loses his hand. Or the person who breaks into your home, opens your safe, and takes your money out. Such a person, one who is that planned kind of a robber, that's the one who loses his hand. Also included in the category of what we said was the Muharrif, one who has attacked the society as a whole, is the drug dealer. 23:28 He has been in recent times included because of the harm that comes from drugs. Such individuals who sell drugs, not a person, a drug user, drug user here is not executed, but one who has a quantity of drugs which indicate that he is a dealer. He is one who is spreading, selling these drugs. Such a person will lose their life. And I'm sure almost every other weekend or so we see... 23:57 Certain individuals coming in from certain countries which are well known for the production of opium etc. are being executed for this practice. The end result of this is that a person here in this society is capable of living a life of relative safety and peace of mind. 24:28 A person is not obliged, as he is in other countries, to latch doors, put double latches, put alarms around the windows and all these different kinds of things that we find in other countries where the crime rate is extremely high. A person can live a relatively comfortable and safe life here. And what it does also is it produces in the society, this application, a desire on the part of the people to try to... 24:57 to stop crime where it may occur. If they see people starting to fight in other societies, people may gather around and start to clap and egg this person on, the big one, the little one, let him beat the big one or whatever. Whereas in this society here, when people start to fight, you'll find people come try to pull them apart. People are concerned to stop the fighting. People will get involved. 25:23 Whereas in other societies, you find people don't want to get involved. Either they're cheering or they just ignore. You know, so you can see major crimes occurring in broad daylight, but nobody will get involved. For example, not too long ago, I remember seeing a program on, what was it, either it was Candid Camera or it was That's Incredible. But what they did was they had some people break in. 25:51 to a car, you know, in downtown New York City, in a major cross street, right? The car was parked near the intersection. And here was a man, you know, using crowbar, etc., breaking into this car in broad daylight, middle of the day. People are walking back and forth. They see this man, you know, they give him a glance and they just keep on walking. Nobody. In fact, what they found is, 26:20 After this had gone on for a number of hours, they actually found a couple of people who went and helped the man break in the car. This is the situation there. Whereas here, for example, if somebody observes anybody doing that, likely they will either try to stop the person directly or they will call the police or something. And I remember very vividly, one instance when I was downtown, I had gotten out of my car. 26:51 And the car, actually it was my father's car, I had borrowed it. And it had the, it was the old model of the Mitsubishi, which had the rear view mirrors on the front fenders. My father had had an accident, and they had fixed the side of the car, but they hadn't replaced the rear view. So it was only on one side. You know, and I had always observed that this looked a bit odd. You know, it's either there should be two or there should be none. 27:18 So, this instant when I got out of the car, I was walking by that side where the rear view mirror was. So, I decided to check to see how easily could I break this off, you know, why could I just remove it. So, I started jiggling with it. Whilst I was, you know, shaking it, somebody came and grabbed my arm. So, you know, I turned, I saw the Saudi is holding on to my arm. I said, what do you want? So, he asked me, well, what are you doing? I said, well, 27:46 You know, what business is it of yours? It's my car. He said, well, prove to me that it's your car. So I took him back. You know, my family was still sitting in the car there. Well, because I was going to get something from the souk. So, you know, I said, this is my family here. You know, they waved at the man. So he said, okay, fine, sorry. And he left. But here was a man walking by. He just saw what appeared to be some act of vandalism taking place there. And he got involved. What we can call a citizen's arrest. He was prepared to... 28:17 get involved here you know and this is the way the society should be this is what helps to keep down crime because once you have this attitude where people just don't want to get involved then it's very easy for you know crime to spread in the second part of the khutbah the imam talked about the importance of the application of the law across the board that these laws are particularly effective when they're applied 28:50 in the full sense. That is, they should not be applied only to one segment of the society and not to another. It should be right across the board. Anybody who commits these crimes should be liable to punishment of the crime. There should be no one or no group of people who are exempt. And, of course, we know the very famous hadith or circumstance which happened in the time of the Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. 29:21 where a woman from the tribe of Makhzum had stolen. You know, this is a powerful tribe there in Medina. She had stolen something. And the law was that her hand was to be removed. So the heads of the tribe, they came to Usama ibn Zayd, who was at one point, he was very close to Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. His father had been... 29:48 the adopted son of the Prophet Muhammad in the early period in Mecca until Allah prohibited adoption. He remained very close with the practice of adoption where a person takes on the family name of the person who adopts them. This is prohibited in Islam. You may take a child and raise them like you raise one of your own children, but the child retains its own name. 30:15 the name of his family, etc. You're not allowed to change that child's name. So in any case, Usama was approached by these leaders of the tribe to try to talk to the Prophet Muhammad since he was so close to him, try to talk him out of applying the law to this woman. So when Usama went, he agreed to. He went and he spoke to the Prophet Muhammad. The Prophet Muhammad was very upset. Very, very upset. 30:46 And he asked him, I mean, do you, dear, do you have the nerve to come and seek intercession in the application of the laws of Allah? He is very upset. And he called the people. And he told them that this is one of the reasons for the destruction of the people of earlier times, who came before. 31:16 Because what they used to do was when a powerful person, a rich person stole, they did not apply the law to them. But when a poor person stole, they applied the full weight of the law. This was the cause of their destruction. So from this, we understand that Islamically speaking, it is very important in the Muslim society that the law is applied across the board. Because if it is not, 31:46 then it leads to corruption in the society. It leads to destruction of the people. And furthermore, it breaks down the confidence of the people. To break down the confidence in the law. And lead them to disobey Allah. To go against the law. And there's also, you know, verses from the Quran that the Imam quoted, wherein, 32:20 Allah mentions that those who disbelieved from the children of Israel were cursed by Prophet David because of the fact that they would not prohibit crimes which they themselves did. Very important that people also apply the law to others and apply it to themselves. 32:50 That they should be committing crimes and then punishing others for committing those same crimes. So in summary, the khutbah spoke to us about the importance of the application of the Sharia. And it spoke in particular in concerning the area of criminal justice. That the application of the law is... 33:26 protects the society as a whole, protects the safety and the security of the individuals that make up the society. It also protects the resources of the society. Because when you consider the number of people who are in jail for these types of major crimes who will spend the rest of their life in jail, what you are finding is that the society has been punished for this man's crime. He is a murderer, you put him in jail, 33:56 for the rest of his life you have to you're paying for his lodging his food you know what did you do so the society is forced to pay for these thousands hundreds of thousands of people who are sitting in jails who committed crimes against the society society now must pay for them you know they living in in jail they you know they have television and they have you know 34:23 Some of them have, you know, rights to visit their families. Their families will come. Women will come, visit them, all these kind of things. I mean, they're living, as we say in America, high off the hog. You know, they're living a very comfortable life in that sense. It's not to say that the jails are, in all cases, comfortable. I mean, there's a lot of, you know, viciousness and such that goes in there, right? But a person who, when he goes in, he learns the ins and outs. I mean, he can live. 34:52 a life in which he is being taken care of for the rest of his days. He doesn't have to think about going out to work, etc., etc. You know, you even have people who actually will commit crimes so they will be put in jail so they won't have to, you know, struggle out there in the society. So, the Islamic system, you know, it protects the society from having to pay for the crimes of the criminals. A person commits such a crime swiftly, you know, in a very short space of time that person is executed. 35:22 You don't have a legal system where that person now, if he's able to buy very expensive lawyers, you know, and they're able to find the loopholes in the law that he can get off, you know, because in America, the top lawyers who make the top money are those who are able to get off the biggest criminals, right? I mean, this is like the criterion of being the top lawyer. Whereas in the Islamic legal system, there's no such arrangement. 35:50 What you have instead is a criminal is brought before a judge or a tribunal of judges. The evidence against him is brought. If the evidence is, what we say, foolproof, it's 100%, then the law is applied to that individual. I mean, he'll lose his life if the evidence is 100%. If there is any doubt as to whether he actually committed the crime or not, they will not apply the law. They will only apply it when it is like 100%. 36:19 In many of the cases here, in fact probably in most of the cases, there is confession. Confession is made by those who actually commit the crime. But there are other cases where the evidence is so complete that there leaves no room for doubt. So what happens is that you don't have a lot of money being wasted in the court. 36:46 cases and the defenses and the retrials and all these different kinds of things which the public ends up having to shoulder the burden of and the people who have the least money pay the most in terms of taxes and you know maintaining the society so by the application of Islamic law in its swift and sure fashion it protects the society the wealth of the society ensuring that it can be now 37:14 utilized in more constructive and progressive means. Because when you think of the millions and millions of dollars spent, billions of dollars spent in maintaining these criminals and the court costs and all these things involved, if you took that money out, you could, you know, all those, you have over a million people right now in America, the richest country, you know, most powerful country on earth today, you know, at least materially speaking, where you have one, over a million people who are living in the streets. 37:43 These people could be given homes and fed. America where education is not free. Where, you know, your education is free up to grade 12, but after grade 12 it's not free. You have to pay. So it becomes the rights of the rich. Health care is not free. This money which is spent on maintaining prisoners could be used to make education free, to make health care free in the society, you know. 38:15 and really fulfill the so-called democratic goals. Because America, which is the biggest screamer for democracy, when you really look into the society, you find that democracy is just a word, which is quoted. It's convenient. But when you look in practice, what does democracy mean? Where it means that the majority of the people, the wishes of the majority of the people, are put into effect. 38:46 If you ask, you know, the majority of people in America, you know, would you like to have free education to a PhD? They will all agree, but it's not there. If you ask them, would you like to have free health care? They would all agree, but it's not there. And it's not because America is not economically capable. So this is clear evidence that democracy is a joke. It is a joke. So the application of the law. 39:21 The application of the law which does not allow compromise. It's not according to the convenience. It should not be according to the convenience of the ruler or the powerful elements in society. And it is divine law, not something decided upon by men, you know, from time to time where you can vary it and change it, you know, like the capital punishment in America where it was... 39:50 banned at one point and now they're bringing it back in, you know. Maybe 10 years from now they'll stop it again. So it's, you know, it's in a state of flux. You know, it is not something which is set. Good and bad in that society is relative. You know, what may be good today will be bad tomorrow. What was bad today will be good tomorrow. You know, this type of a situation. No, the Islamic society through divine law establishes a solid foundation for morality. 40:20 Which doesn't change with time. And those laws are applied across the board. Except under extreme circumstances. As I mentioned, cases of hunger and starvation, etc., etc. But under normal circumstances, the law is applied across the board. And with it, it provides for the society a state of peace and security which no man... 40:51 no man does not wish for. This is something very real. And it is something that I observed myself personally in talking with many of the Americans who came here for Desert Storm and who found Islam here. You know, and went back as Muslims to America. Many of them who I talked to, you know, mentioned that one of the most pronounced differences that they found 41:24 in the society was this state of security where they could walk downtown you know after 12 o'clock at night and not feel that they have to be looking over you know their shoulder you know left and right as they walk you know in the back alleys or you know in the main street and they could if they bought a gold chain you know they could wear their gold chain you know or the gold ring you know they don't have to feel afraid you know they have to 41:53 To hide it or whatever you know as they would you know back home This was this had a very pronounced effect on many of them which caused them to question Why why is it that this exists in the society you know? so These laws which allah has set they are set based on allah's knowledge of human nature allah who has complete knowledge of human nature knows 42:27 What is good for man and what is not. He has set these laws for the benefit of the individual, the family and of the society. And it is the duty of Muslims to establish these laws wherever they are able to establish themselves. Wherever they become the majority, the ruling majority or whatever. It is their duty to apply these as well as the other laws which constitute the Sharia. 42:58 The divine revealed law from Allah. So that is the summary of today's khutbah. If there are any comments anybody would like to make or any questions, they may now do so. In terms of the sisters, for those who wanted to ask questions, we said they could write them on some paper. Hopefully some people brought paper. And they could be brought upstairs to the door here in one of the... 43:30 boys will collect it and bring it across to be read so first we will look at questions which relate to the application which relates to the application of the hudud or the divine laws concerning criminal justice 44:06 Do you know the detail of the execution? Okay, the Imam did mention, I forgot to mention, the Imam mentioned also concerning one of the laws in Islam, concerning the law for riddah or apostasy, that yesterday an individual was executed in 44:36 in the eastern province for apostasy. He denied that the Quran was revealed by God. This individual, it was quoted that this is what he stated. That it was made up by the prophet of the Quran and the person of God, the person of the prophet. Okay, so this individual was publicly executed because 45:06 He cursed God and cursed the Prophet ﷺ and denied that the Quran was revelation from God and claimed that it was made up by Prophet Muhammad ﷺ. That individual was publicly executed. And this is one of the laws which for a Westerner, they look at it as being particularly offensive. 45:35 that where is the freedom of speech, they say. You know, you're not free to speak your mind and express your beliefs. If you do so in a Muslim country, you'll lose your life for it. The point here, to be made, to be explained to such people, if they really want to understand, they have to be told that Islam is not a religion like Christianity. What I mean is, 46:12 It is not a religion which has been divorced from the legal system of the society. You know, a Christianity accepted a principle of giving on to Caesar, that is to the temporal power, what Caesar wishes or is due to Caesar. The legal system of the society, you know, a Christianity accepted a principle of 46:47 Giving on to Caesars, that is to the temporal power, what Caesar wishes or is due to Caesar. And giving on to God what is due to God. They made a separation between what they call church and state. Whereas in the Islamic system, there is no such separation. The religion is all encompassing. The state is Islam. It is not separate from the religion. And in the West, if you... 47:19 commit an act which is against the security of the state, you are judged to be a traitor and can also be executed. Okay? So they have this law also. Only they will kill people for material concerns. Because you have threatened the well-being of our material state, we will kill you. 47:51 But if you threaten the well-being of our spiritual state, it doesn't matter. It's alright. So to them, it's not important whether you believe in God or you don't believe in God or you worship Satan or whatever. You do your own thing. But our material society, this is everything. So we'll kill you if you threaten that. Well, in the Islamic system, there is no separation. When you curse God, 48:24 You are threatening the whole society, spiritually and materially. So in that case, you become a traitor and you are executed. So this is the rationale behind it. Because Islam is like a nation. It is not just a religion in the western concept, but it is the way of life of the nation. And whatever threatens that nation, that way of life, 49:00 If it reaches a certain level as being classified as apostasy, which is to be equivalent of a traitor, such a person will lose his life to protect the rest of the society. Protecting the society how? In the sense that if a person is of weak faith, if such a person is allowed, the other one is allowed to openly express his disbelief, 49:33 then those of weak faith are liable to fall in with this person. So when this person is executed, those of weak faith, they will keep their mouth shut. Those who are hypocrites will be quiet. This sounds as though we are forcing people, you know, to practice the faith. No. If you don't want to practice the faith, then leave. You know. If you go to another country, it's not that we will be sending, you know, 50:09 Death squad hunting you down to kill you because you decide you don't want to be one of the members of the society anymore. No. But in the midst of the society, you would be eliminated for the protection of the society as a whole. And we have, Salah is compulsory. People are obliged to make prayer. See, there is no compulsion in the religion in the sense that nobody is compelled to enter. 50:42 This is the point. No one is compelled to enter the religion. However, once you enter, it's serious. You're taking on a commitment. A full-scale commitment. So, once, you know, this is why it's very important for us, when we're explaining Islam to people, that we shouldn't take it lightly, that, you know, just encourage, you all just say your Shahada, come on in, you know, don't worry about it, you learn as you go along. No, no. Let them know. 51:10 what the basic principles are, let them understand it clearly, and be accepting Islam out of full conviction, not out of convenience, you know, or emotionally. It should be intellectually out of full conviction, knowledge. So such a person becomes a true follower, you know. However, once a person has entered, then he is obliged to stay, unless he flees to another country. 51:46 and decides he wants to give up the practice. Or if he internally, for example, in the country decides he doesn't believe anymore, what he does, he keeps it to himself. He may have to go through the motions, but his disbelief which is in his heart, nobody is going to go and check what is in his heart. We don't set up inquisition courts where people are now brought up and your face is tested, finding out the details of your belief, trying to track down those individuals. No. 52:18 That's between you and God. But at least on the outside, in the society, the basic principles have to be applied and abided by. 53:09 Yes, the question, just for those who don't hear it, our brother here is asking, the incident happened to him a couple of years ago, where he left the kingdom, 53:39 went back to the States and left, you know, an individual looking after his home. We give them the key to his home. He was his driver. He had access to your home in other words. He lived in the home. And the brother had left a jewelry box or a box of jewelry without unlock. And some of the jewelry when he came back was lifted. 54:09 you know was stolen and when he confronted the individual with it the individual admitted and got the jewelry back and returned it to him so he was asking whether this would be considered a case of temptation whether he should have locked up that jewelry and we would say yes this would be a case of temptation you know if the jewelry box had been locked and then he broke open the lock then such a person would be liable now to losing his hand over the issue 54:37 But in this case, you know, we are, it is our duty that, you know, we do not tempt people because everybody has their times of weakness. You know, you go through problems, personal crises in your home and back home or whatever, you know, and then you find yourself doing something which you wouldn't normally do. So we should not, you know, put temptation in front of people where we have goods of this nature. We should lock them away, you know. 55:05 Well, that's virtually the same as being unlocked. I mean, because when we say locked... If it were locked and he knew where the key was. He would have the key, right? You know, not locked and you gave him the key or, you know, something to that effect. Sure enough. 55:46 okay I rather raise the question and it should be raised really from both sides if a man or woman saw their husband or wife in an act of intercourse with somebody else I mean what can they do I mean if such a person is a known righteous person either woman or man 56:17 Can they go to the court and would their witness be accepted? No. Their witness in and of itself will not be accepted. However, they have the option, they're told to swear by Allah that this in fact took place and to make three oaths like this. The fourth time they invoke Allah's curse on themselves if they are liars. 56:47 Then the male, their husband or wife, four times, so this is equivalent to the four witnesses, what they're doing, they swear four times, sorry it's not three times, four times that this person has committed this act, and then the fifth time they invoke the curse of Allah on themselves if they are in fact lying. Then their partner is brought before the... 57:18 court or the legal representative and given a choice of admitting or of making a similar oath. And if that person admits, then the person is executed. If the person doesn't admit and makes the oath and calls on Allah's curse for themselves, then the court, they become separated, they become divorced. Their marriage is cancelled. That's as far as the court can go. 57:50 Because without other witnesses, you know, as has been said by Allah, then even the most righteous of people, because we are judging righteous people by their external actions. We don't know what is going on inside of people's hearts. So even the person we thought to be the most righteous, they could be lying. You see, so the court is not going to act without that full set of witnesses. 58:31 well I mean this is the in the case where the individual who witnessed the act killed those who are involved in the act you know this now is something which the court would look into the circumstances 59:03 If the evidence, you know, does support that this actually took place in such an act, right, then, you know, it is possible that some leniency may be given towards that person who committed, who ex-killed them, you know, out of state of, you know, of jealousy, you know, extreme jealousy, whatever, you know, that some leniency, you know, if the evidence does support that in fact this was the case, not that they went and killed two people and... 59:34 set up a circumstance right and that some concession would be given you know because of course one of the people involved may be actually not married or not having been married in which case the punishment for such a person would have only been lashes and not death you can see it most easily for the case of your husband you know the woman killing her husband or the man killing his wife but then the other person involved 60:04 That person may not have been viewed to be executed. However, as I said, the case would be judged in accordance with the rulings given by the judge. The judge would have to look into the circumstances and make a ruling. I mean, it is possible that if there is enough evidence supporting the claim of that person that they actually caught them in the act, etc., that that person may lose their life. 60:34 But if there is sufficient evidence, etc, then the court may be lenient to the person and let them off. You know, as did happen in the time of Omar, where one man had done this, killing his wife and the person involved in the action, that man was let off. That I am not certain. 61:12 I'm not certain whether the four witnesses, I would imagine that is the case, but I'm not certain. If there's anybody here with a background in Sharia, could confirm. If not, then we'll try to find out next week to confirm what is the case in terms of witnesses for homosexuality, whether it is also the four witnesses, or whether less than four would also be accepted. In reference to the Qutbah. 61:48 In an Islamic society, should they be more concerned about fear of punishment from Allah in the afterlife? And, you know, because one of the examples you gave for capital punishment in a Western society was the hangings that took place in London and beheadings to a certain point. And this in no way deterred crime. Crime was still rampant in that society because they didn't have other things in place. 62:15 to prevent crimes of prostitution and theft and things of that nature, even in the high government circles of the society. And the reason I ask is because I've read that the laws governing capital punishment in an Islamic society were actually prescribed to frighten, or not prescribed to frighten people into obeying Allah, but they were actually prescribed to... 62:44 to keep people who were deviants in the society and who had a propensity for preying on people who were peaceful and who were trusting, but getting them out of the society and thereby preserving the Islamic content of the society, keeping it intact. But the basic question is, are these laws prescribed so that we're frightened by the laws or we should be more concerned about Allah? Well, Islam recognizes that people are in different levels of faith. 63:15 Those who fear Allah and would not commit the crime because of their fear of Allah, you don't need the law for them. You know, we don't need that law. Because their fear of Allah would stop them from committing such crimes. Whereas the larger proportion who fear Allah, but the fear is on such a level, such a low level that it is not sufficient to deter them. 63:52 from committing such a crime then they fear the application of the law the law is there to put fear in their heart from the application of that law on themselves it's really the law is there for the weaker members weaker in faith generally speaking all of the laws because if a person is of strong faith and you tell that person drinking alcohol will destroy 64:25 Your spiritual link between yourself and God. And harm your relationships with people etc. This was enough. This would be enough. And you'll find initially when the revelation of the laws concerning the drinking of alcohol. It came in a gradual fashion. In the early recommendations it was enough. For some people they just stopped. But for other people it needed to be more certain and more definite. And the law had to be. 64:57 a put there, 80 lashes. So, what we have to be certain of is that the law, this strong, powerful law is really for the weaker members of the society, weaker in faith, who need to see the big stick, you know, who need to see and to realize that if they do such a thing, they will suffer the consequences. Whereas, 65:36 For those people whose faith is strong, if the law wasn't there, it would be fine. However, what Islam also takes into account is that even those people of strong faith go through periods of time when their faith gets weak. They don't maintain a constant. So if they are in a period of weakness and Satan comes and makes an idea appealing to them, you may find them committing a crime which they would not normally do. 66:09 So the powerful law is also there for those times of weakness of those even of strong faith. Now when their faith in terms of consciousness of God dips, their consciousness of the power of the law and the consequences is enough to keep them in line, keep them in check. So I would beg to differ with what our brother was saying concerning the application of public executions. 66:42 That in the time when there were public executions, it did have an effect on the crimes that were being punished for. However, I would support it in the fact that with people not fearing a consequence from God, then it would not have as great an effect as in the Islamic circumstance where the law is there not only for the... 67:14 fear, put fear in the heart of people who do not have a good consciousness of God but also to confirm in the minds of those who fear God that Allah's laws are being applied that they may be they may put their full trust in Allah and in its application and that this trust would also help them in their faith in deterring them from 67:46 crime. Non-Muslims governed by Sharia in Islamic society? Yes. Question, are non-Muslims governed by Sharia, these laws, in a non-Muslim society? Yes. The non-Muslim who kills somebody or steals, etc., he will also be governed by these laws. Okay, I'm going to read a question from the sisters. Question, if someone, for instance, has been married and was separated at the time, the person 68:16 has not embraced Islam and later became a Muslim. If a chance came when the person decided to settle down and both are Muslims, will that person be punished under the Sharia law? Will the marriage under the Islamic law be valid? What will happen to the previous marriage? Is there any punishment for it? Okay, what I think the person is saying... 68:50 If a person were to live in a circumstance, what we call in the Philippines, they call a living circumstance, where a man has a woman and he's living with her like his wife, but there's no marriage ceremony that's taking place. Or in America we call it shacking up. If a person lives in these kind of circumstances, then they become Muslims. 69:21 According to Islamic law, they should get married again. Because this was not marriage that they were living in. There would be no punishment for them for what came before. Because we know Islam cancelled whatever came before. One of the statements of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. that Islam cancelled the sin. Whatever wrong you did in the past, this has been cancelled by your acceptance of Islam. If you follow through. 69:51 Because if you come into Islam and then you become corrupt, then you will carry the sin of the previous time. You are no longer absolved of it. So that absolution is on condition that you continue in a righteous path. And also it's on condition that the crime that you did did not involve the taking of somebody else's property. You know, if you stole somebody's property, 70:22 then you accept Islam. Though Islam wipes out the acts of stealing, it doesn't make halal the thing you have stolen. So, if you have accepted Islam, you must now take that thing you have stolen and return it to the people that you stole it from. Right? You are absorbed of the sin of the stealing, but you are not absorbed in the sense that you can now keep that. It makes halal for you what you stole. No. So, such a person who lived in such circumstances, they would not be considered sinful. 70:55 after Islam and the law would not be applicable to them. They would remarry. If they accepted Islam and continued in such a relationship, you know, a woman accepted Islam or the man accepted Islam and they continued in a live-in shack-up kind of situation, of course they now become sinful. Once they continue that relationship, they become sinful. It's just like a man, for example, or a woman who accepts Islam. 71:27 If she accepts Islam and her husband, a person who she's been legally married to, does not accept Islam, then she may not have sexual relations with this man. If she does, then she is committing a sin. It doesn't take her out of Islam, but she is in sin. She is committing a sin. So, when she accepts Islam, though she may go back to her husband to try to convince him to come to Islam, etc., 72:00 Hold him off. She should not have sexual relations with him until she has finished trying to bring him to Islam. If he decides he doesn't want to have anything to do with Islam, then she now must make the choice, if her faith is strong, she has now to make the choice of separating herself completely from her husband. Divorce him. Because according to Islamic law, the marriage is cancelled. 72:31 It's nullified. When she became a Muslim, her marriage was nullified. It became null and void at that point in time. So it's not really even divorce. But she may have to go through divorce in the legal system which requires divorce for that separation to take place. I hope that answers the question. I could also just mention that if a person was married in the Christian system before Islam, when they come into Islam, the person and the husband and wife, 73:01 They don't have to remarry. I know some people mistakenly think that it becomes necessary to have an Islamic marriage. But no, if you are married legally in a system before Islam, then you may continue that marriage after Islam without having to remarry. Another question by the sisters. Why is it that only expats who are executed are well publicized? 73:40 executions done to local countrymen? Yes. Most of the executions that are taking place, they are not to expats. Most of them are to local people. And they are publicized. They are explained usually on television. You know, the crime is read out, etc. Maybe in the newspaper. And publicly when it actually takes place, before they do the execution, the crime of the individual is read. It's read out publicly. So everybody knows what 74:10 is the crime being applied for. What you find is that those who are executed locally, mostly it is for murder. Whereas those that are executed for bringing in drugs into the country, naturally it's expats who are normally bringing in drugs. So you find most of those who are executed for drugs are expats. But you do have some local people who have been involved in drug rings, who have been caught and publicly executed also. 74:48 Yes, just to confirm that for the sisters who asked this question, that the person who was an apostate, who was executed for apostasy yesterday in the eastern province, this person was a local citizen of the country, was not an expat. Before we go, let's stick with the... 75:17 Questions concerning the hudud first. If we run out of those, then we'll come back to general questions. Okay? Concerning hudud. Okay, our brother is just asking for a little more clarification on the payment of what is known as ziyah for somebody who commits a murder. Now, 75:48 If a murder takes place, your neighbor kills your father or your brother, the male members of the family have an option of taking a blood money, which may be whatever the person offers. If the family members accept it, then that person is no longer executed for the crime. Okay? 76:19 What may happen is that when that person, if it was a father, he was killed, for example, and he has a child who is one year old or two years old, boy, they will wait until that child, this is one of the few instances where you find a murderer waiting in jail for 10 years or 15 years. They will wait until that child reaches the age of puberty, that is around 15, and the question will be put to the child. 76:47 to the young person, young man at that time, would you accept, you know, this money in the place? If he says no, then the person is executed. This is the only time really when you find that process taking a period of time. That's in the case of what we call manslaughter in America, is that right? Accidental death. Yeah, this is the case of, no, when you say manslaughter, what do you mean? Accidental death? No, no, no. 77:12 I mean, when two people get into a fight, there are different levels of manslaughter. Let's say two men get into a fight and one hits the other one. He hits his head up against the wall and he dies. No. Where it is judged or ruled that accidental death, this is not the case. Accidental death, a person pays a set fine for the life of that person. Where the case is judged as murder, where the person... 77:40 has struck that person with an instrument which could... You mean premeditated murder? A person can plan another person's murder and then proceed to kill him? Whether it is premeditated or a person hits the other person with an object. I mean, if I hit you over the head with an axe, you see, I cannot say I didn't mean to kill you. Right? You know, this is an instrument which normally causes death. You see, so in such cases that it's ruled as murder. 78:10 You know, even though you just happened to grab it because that was what was nearby, but this is an instrument which normally causes death. But if you just punched a person, and the person fell and hit his head on something and died, then this is not considered a case where you have murdered that person. Right? They are making a distinction in this case. Okay? 78:47 A question concerning an individual who victimizes other people through what we call in the West a scam. 79:15 You know, he's got some kind of a letter or some kind of a program that he offers. You give some money in advance, he promises you something in return. Either a job here or whatever. So he tricks a number of people into giving them his money and their monies and then he runs off with this money. What happens to such an individual? This does not constitute the type for which the hand is removed. Now, this is up to the discretion of the judge. 79:45 You know, how this person may be punished. They may be punished by whatever properties they have being sold and the money is gotten back and given back to those people. And he may also spend a time in jail. You know, this is a case of misrepresentation or, you know, deceit, you know, like forgery. You know, we see people, you know, being caught for forgery, etc. What the usual punishment, they're given some lashes, spend a year in jail. 80:14 They are given also a fine. You know, if the money which has been taken illegally, this is returned if it is possible. It's up to really the judge as to exactly what will be the punishment for the person. But it wouldn't include the cutting of the hand. Do you want to add something to that? 80:45 Indeed, you might sometimes forgive the children. Yeah, okay. I mean, this is what I had understood from the beginning, that it is not really set in the sense that it has to be this amount. In the case of accidental, there is again a set amount made, but the person, the family does have the right to forgive the person altogether. And it's even mentioned in the ayah, in the Quran. 81:13 you know, concerning the murder issue, that, you know, that forgiveness is also an option. Yes, you mentioned it. There is. Okay, what you mentioned initially was in the case of accidental 81:55 murder, you know, a person dies from accidental crime, that there is a certain amount of money paid. In the case where a father kills his own child, according to Islamic law, you know, as practiced by a number of the schools of Islamic law, such a person is not executed. A father is not executed for killing his son. He may be punished, jailed, and a variety of other things. 82:25 But he's not executed for killing his son because of the principle that he was the one who brought him into this life in the first place. A certain concession is made based on that fact. Being done without someone, I think we need to emphasize that before an execution takes place, a thorough investigation is being done by the higher court. And in many, many cases, several years before an execution is made. 83:14 Well, no, it's not usually several years. But what happened? No, there is a due process, but it doesn't take years. 83:38 It depends on the case. But normally speaking, you know, the process of justice is fairly swift. It is fairly swift. Once the evidence has been gathered, etc., the ruling is made. But what the point is that it is not just the ruling of that judge which, you know, 84:07 automatically this person is executed. The ruling that the person has made is reviewed by a higher council, which will look into it and look over the evidence again and ascertain, make sure that there are no possibilities. And then this has to be also ratified by the king himself. A decree is made where it is again looked over. So there's like three levels before the actual thing takes place. And this is what would give the time process. 84:33 But the issue of when a person commits a murder, so the evidence is brought fairly rapidly, that person is brought initially to the first court. But then, you know, the case is reviewed, you know, twice after that, before the actual execution takes place. So this is what gives it a certain amount of time. But relatively speaking, in comparison to what happens in other societies, it's relatively swift. 85:11 The question, if a person commits a crime in a Muslim society for which he is executed, or commits a similar crime in a non-Muslim society for which he is not executed, 85:43 How is he judged in the sight of Allah? Well, you know, of course, Allah ultimately judges people according to their intentions. If they have turned back to God sincerely in repentance, the person commits a crime in a non-Muslim society, turns back to God in sincere repentance, that person may be absolved of that crime, you know, in Allah's sight. Though the law has not been applied to them. 86:11 Where somebody else in a Muslim society may commit that crime and the law is applied to them. But they have not repented within themselves. And they are still held to account on the day of judgment. So ultimately it goes back to the person's own intent. Whether they do turn back to Allah ultimately in repentance and whether they will still have to be held to account how Allah judges them. 86:38 And we have the classical case in the time of the Prophet Muhammad where one woman had committed adultery and had turned herself in to be executed. Prophet Muhammad had sort of tried to discourage her from actually turning herself in. But she insisted. He told her to come back after she delivered the baby. She came back, giving her time and also the option not to come back. But she came back. She still wanted the law to be applied to her. He told her to come back after you finish weaning the baby, another two years. 87:08 And after the two years was up, she came back. So there was nothing left now but to apply the law because here she is confessing and wants the application of the law. She was taken and stoned to death. And during the course of the stoning, some of the blood splattered on the garment which Omar was wearing. Omar was there taking part with the Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam. And when the blood splattered on his garment, he cursed it. 87:37 So the Prophet forbade him from cursing the blood of this woman or the woman. Saying that the repentance that this woman made is so great that if it were divided up amongst the inhabitants of Medina, it would have been enough to absolve them of their sins. This repentance, this is Prophet informing something which was revealed to him by Allah. Because he doesn't have the authority to say this. 88:07 This is from Allah, saying that her repentance is so great. And if divided up amongst the inhabitants of Medina, it would have been sufficient to absolve them of their sins. That's what we said. Ultimately, it goes back to what one's intentions are. Okay, inshallah, the pizza inn is waiting for us. We have gone over our time point. It's now after 2 o'clock. So, you know, we'd like, because there's a number of people here who have to get back. 88:39 They've come from far distances. Transportation has brought them here. We have to try to stay within a certain limit. So the point is that other questions can be made, given to me personally or whatever, as we're leaving, if they can be answered or they can be raised next week. But so as to give brothers a chance who have come from long distances and are anxious to have lunch, that we should stop at this point here now. 89:08 We ask Allah to accept our intentions for being here, one in terms of seeking knowledge, understanding Islam, to improve our practice of Islam, to take what the Imam has given us of the khutbah, concerning the importance of the application of Islamic law, that we should strive in whatever area we go back to or whatever we live in, to try to apply these laws to the degree that we can. 89:37 And we ask Allah that He accepts all of our deeds, righteous deeds as being done sincerely for His benefit. And that He give us the reward of paradise in the next life. Subhanaka Allahumma wa bihamdika. Nashadu wa la ilaha illa al-anth. Nastaghfiruka wa natubu ilayk.