♪ Playing in the audio bar belowLectures & RemindersAudioSectarianismadmin·6 views·5 months agoA lecture in English delivered by Sh. Bilal Philips on sectarianism and its harms. By: Bilal Philips Source: IslamHouse.com · Bilal Philips#Audio#Bilal Philips#IslamHouseTranscriptionbeta▸Transcription automatique : elle peut contenir des erreurs, vérifiez l'enregistrement pour la formulation exacte.0:05I praise you to Allah and your last peace and blessing will be on the last prophet Muhammad and on all those who follow the path of righteousness until the last day. The topic which was given to me for handling or presentation in this session concerned Islamic history.0:38and the rise of sectarianism. And this topic is of particular relevance to us today, here, in Britain, and in all parts of the Muslim world, because large numbers of individuals claiming, and in doing so, they condemn other individuals, large numbers of people, relegating them to a state of kufr, or kirk. And many of us, who are in Islam,1:38by reversion or conversion, awakening, having been born in a Muslim family. But those of us with consciousness of what Islam is, to some degree, wish to look at Islam and to see Islam living in the communities around us. We are faced with some of the various, or what appears to be various sects that are calling a variety of different paths. There is a way to resolve what we should be following. And we know that Prophet Muhammad had said the nation would divide us.2:4373 different were going to hell except for one. So there is addiction on the part of the Prophet Muhammad to a living. And he did this with a means of determining which was in fact the correct path. Because he was asked, actually he said that, by the companions, what then is the path? And he said, that it is the one that I and my companions are on. He had the right circumstances. He emphasized the Holy One and the Sunnah. And who does so,3:35never go astray. He invited Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam,4:26Umar Ibn Ali was seen to cover that period of time that was predicted by the Prophet Muhammad with the intrusion of Hassan Ibn Ali. A short period of his leadership completed that period of time which the Prophet Muhammad passed on. The Prophet Muhammad while identifying that there would arise a variety of different sects, something which was unavoidable, he did what he means for us, determined that in the right way. If you look to the time of the Prophet Muhammad,5:12found that there existed individuals who began that deviation from his time. Banu, the people from the Kameen tribe in eastern Arabia, in what is now known as Naft, they had come to give bay'ah to the Prophet Muhammad and also to lead them. But Musayla must say that he did not go forward with the rest. And the Prophet Muhammad spoke about that one who did come, that he would later on, and surely.6:04After 8, Musaylamah Fitness not only involved Musaylamah, but it also involved certain individuals coming. A new interpretation for Zakat. I'm sure you all are familiar with the Muslim Mosque in Medina was being threatened. And Abu Bakr was advising them that they had to click upon this to get those individuals who refused to pay Zakat. And all of a sudden, these people, they say, no, no, no.7:08And they're making fun of it. So Allah went away and made them cave. So it's hard to tell if it was cave or the king. You know, the people are forced to pay tribute to the king. So as the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, he made the tribes and gave the cap to the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him. By the way, the theme is taking place. The principles of Islam. He gets arrested. They don't follow him. And Ali, peace and blessings be upon him, handed him the prisoner. And they broke away.13:13according to arbitration which they attempted to put into place. They viewed it, these individuals who broke off, they viewed it giving the judgment of these individuals. He ended up having the arbitration broke down and he ended up trying to fight these individuals as these individuals themselves started to attack the main body of Muslims. They began an inquisition where in whatever area they moved into, they would put people to the test.13:58as to their views concerning Ali those who tell that these individuals were righteous companions of the Prophet Muhammad who had been guaranteed paradise as stated by the Prophet Muhammad such individuals were in the name of preserving the purity of Islam in deviation when in fact they were themselves and it is reported to the attempt to convince them to come over and to give up these views following these attempts a number of them did rejoin the main body14:48of Ali and his companions to see them, they mentioned recorded in what is called Asar of the Sahaba or statements of the Sahaba recorded, authentic that when they came near to the camp, the encampment of the Khawaj they said they heard a sound, sounded like many many bees they were wondering what in the world is this when they came to the camp they realized these people were involved in the recitation of the Quran15:24Late at night, they were there reciting, rapidly reciting the Quran. And when they went in to sit with them, these people all had marks on their foreheads. Most of them, they had these marks on their foreheads from making so much sujood. Took the position, which became a part of the principles of this Maghab, or this commitment to Islam. And they took the position that one who committed a sin was doomed to not. If you take that position, that if you commit a16:15You are doomed to hell. What kind of individual are you going to be? Be an extremely righteous individual. So they took on much of the trappings of what represents righteousness in Islam in terms of Salah and recitation of the Quran and these type of things. Very conscientious about it. Due to their misinterpretation, the Quran clearly committed to Islam and the worship of Allah. But if they have a misinterpretation, that can be enough.17:08to take them out of the bounds of Islam. As time passed, individuals in different places claimed for themselves either prophethood or that they were Mahdis. And a Mahdi is a little lighter than prophethood. I mean, you claim prophethood, then you're gone. You're out. Finished. One can say, well, such a personal claim, he was a Mahdi, not that he was wrong, but that he was wrong. That was a wrongful claim. But the point is that from that period of time down to our time, we find people who have made various clones for themselves.17:59In the last forces of colonialism, utilizing certain individuals amongst the Muslim masses, create fitna by promoting their claims. We have the Qadianis, Ahmed Qadian of India, who claimed himself to be a prophet, and his followers still around today promoting their teachings in Africa, mostly. They have been declared by the Muslim League.18:42Pakistan as being a non-Muslim sect. Some years back, the Baha'is who arose in Iran, they were a branch. Even more recent times, we had in America, early 20s, Abu Dhu Ali, who claimed prophethood for himself. First science temple. He was followed closely by Elijah Muhammad, also claimed for himself prophethood. It went a little further to claim that his teacher was God. Following him, in the 70s,19:39Elijah made his claims in the 30s and that carried on. In the 70s, the beginning of the late 60s, we had another individual, Dwight York, now Isa al-Hadi al-Mahdi, who in his writings claims for himself divinity, claims he's God incarnate, he works miracles, etc. And in the later 70s, we had Rashad Khalifa, an Egyptian, came to America, claimed that20:22mathematical miracle of the quran in the form of the number 19 and on the basis of that he started to make further claims for himself that he was able to determine the day on which Yama Piyama would take place the day of judgment when the world would end he claimed he found out when it was then he later went on to deny the validity of the sunnah went further to claim that certain verses of the quran were false and in 1985 he claimed that he was a prophet his miracle being20:58the discovery of the Night King. Alhamdulillah, a year ago he was executed. There are those who killed him at the entire valley. But this is the process, the process of deviation. It hasn't ended. Imam Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam had told us at the end of our prayers to seek refuge, seek refuge out of hell, trials of living and dying. The evil of Jal is not what is talked about in the book that we have.22:00a tale called tajal that is a book of fiction not fact but tajal being the greatest of those who for himself of divinity he would come as one of the signs of the last day however the first man that before him would come minor tajal and this is what we have experienced there is no end to it only with the ending of the world must we have tajal so what this takes us back to is22:44the message which the Prophet gave us, whereby we may protect ourselves from falling into the clutches of these various dead jails. On one occasion, when he sat with his companions, he drew a line on either side, a number of other lines branching off from it. And he asked them, you know what this is? And they said, Allah and His Messenger knows best. He said, this line down the middle is the straight path. And these others represent the many deviant paths.23:24At the head of each one is a devil. As we seek Islam, we seek to practice Islam, there are many devils out there. People, Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam, had given us a series of principles to help us to protect ourselves from falling into that hell. There's a principle that he said, every innovation in the religion is a cursed innovation. Every cursed innovation...24:28who are at the head of these tabs, the devils who are calling people to his base of deviation. This is how we know who they are. And the message that they are giving will be deviation. However, it will not be all deviation. Because if they come with pure falsehood, open corruption, they will not attract people. People who are seeking the right path, they will not attract them. So they must bring to them something of the truth. Something of the truth, they must bring it.25:19what will attract the people but this is just the bait to pull them in because once they're in then they set them on a path of deviation and the deviation can take many many different forms primarily we know that the message is the quran and the sunnah a deviant wants to be successful ask the people either one or both because cannot be taken without the sunnah26:10Nor can the Sunnah be taken without the Quran. Both on revelation from Allah. I said in the Quran, وَمَا يَنْتِقُ عَنِ الْهَوَىٰ إِنْ هُوَ إِلَّا وَحْيٌّ يُوحَىٰ In reference to Prophet Muhammad , he did not speak of his own desires. It was revelation which was revealed to him. The Sunnah that Prophet Muhammad said and approved things which were done in his presence was based on revelation from Allah.26:52represents the clarification of the message of the Quran. The clarification, the implementation of that message. Allah said, وَأَنزَلْنَا إِلَيْكَ ذِكْرًا لِتُبَيِّنَ لِلنَّاسِ مَنْ نُزِّلَ إِلَيْهِمْ We have revealed to you, O Muhammad, the reminder, the Quran, in order that you may apply for the people what was revealed for them. This is the job of the Prophet Muhammad. When Aisha was asked about the character27:27of the Prophet Muhammad . How was his character? She said his character was the Quran. He represents in his practice, in his sayings, in the things which he approved in his presence, he represents the implementation of the Quran. So we cannot separate the sunnah from the Quran. And the Prophet said that there would come a time when a man would be leaning on a couch and he would hold28:02the Quran and say, whatever I find halal in here, I'll make halal. Whatever I find haram in here, I'll make haram. In other words, he's just going to follow the Quran. Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam went out to say, made certain things I will not mention in the Quran. This was based on revelation from Allah. So these cannot be separated. The Quran and the Sunnah. He said, I left with you two things. You hold on to them firmly, you will never go astray. The Book of Allah and my Jannah. These two cannot be separated. So now, those who seek a path of deviation,28:42They will seek to separate these two, and they will seek to nullify these two. The nullification can come either by openly stating it's not authentic, they say we don't follow Sunnah, it's the Hadith of people, the speech of men, like Dr. York and his compatriots, and Rashad Khalifa and others, or they seek to incorporate the Hadith in fashions which were not understood by the early companions of the Prophet.29:20among the early scholars of Islam. They make their own, come up with their own interpretations. They're all the way to the Quran. And Allah wants us in the Quran. He says, among the verses of the Quran, known as rules which are firm. Here, understanding them requires no special deepened topics. Right here. These, Allah said, were Ummul Kitab. The essence of the book. The foundation of the book. Besides them, there were other verses whose meanings are obscure.30:14obscure, which we do not understand, but which the scholars, those who are firmly grounded in knowledge, say that they're all from Allah. They hold back. They do not seek to go into the interpretation of these verses. However, Allah says that those who have twisted hearts will head straight for these verses. These are the verses that they will pick up and try to bring for you what means and what that means. Furthermore, after they've got you going with that,30:49then they will go right over to even the Muhtamat. The whole Quran becomes, its meanings are not to be understood except by an elite few. So, knowledge is the course of deviation. Islam either misinterpreted the Quran or they misinterpreted the Sunnah. Either separated the Sunnah from the Quran, cancelled the validity of the Sunnah, and changed the meanings of the Quran.31:53How can we protect ourselves from this? The only way in which we are able to ensure that we remain on that path, the one path that the Prophet Muhammad said, leading to paradise, is to not only hold on firmly to the Quran and Sunnah, to understand the Quran and Sunnah, according to how it was understood by the companions of the Prophet Muhammad and by the early scholars of Islam.32:34This is the way that we can be certain.33:21you know the herbs use the valley's translation vegetables translated as pot herbs herbs which are cooked in the pot so he said there it is brother you know h-e-r-b deviation here take the english translation of the quran and then we're making taxier of the english well my brother was explaining to me you know where allah says you should fight the believers just as they fight you so now this became a rationale you know because they say well you know34:08We are living in this country, all these disbelievers around us, they're fighting us in so many different ways. You know? It's no longer a physical fight. This is now a psychological fight. It's an economic fight. You know? So now this became justification for robbing banks and snatching purses and you know. This is where you can go. I met brothers who were involved in... One brother was a Muslim. He was an astrologist. Preparing charts for people and...34:44predicting your future and everything else. He said, it's in the Quran. Please show me where the Quran is. He went to use Zafali's translation again and he opened up a chapter known as Al-Buruj. Zafali has translated Al-Buruj as the zodiacal sign. Bearing by the zodiacal sign. Of course, Buruj does not mean zodiacal sign. Later on, you know, when Arabic took on the Arabic language, you know, there's classical meanings of Arabic.35:19But, you know, as it spread, its meaning, some of the meanings became modified to include certain other concepts which existed in the society. And this was one classical example. Originally, Uruj meant constellations, formations. The superimposed images, you know, of Leo and the others, you know, which came out of Babylon and Greece, you know, based on star worship, etc. It's a separate thing to that.35:55However, later on, the concept of Buruj came to include that. So, the English Quran deviation. God said that he revealed Quran in Arabic and Quran. The Quran is the Arabic. That English that you're reading is not the Quran. It is not. It is explanation of the meanings in English. A tafsir, an interpretation. And that is why, you know, we have the issue of can you touch the Quran with the love, wudu, or if a woman is in a mensage and stuff.36:51this type of thing. In the case of the translations of the Quran, Yusuf Ali is perfectly okay. Because this is not classified as Quran. Once you have the words other than the Quran, more than the Quran itself, then it becomes allowable for you to handle this without being in a state of wudu. Based on the fact that the Prophet sent letters of Rome, Persia, which had Quranic verses in it. It also had statements from the Prophet. And he knew he was sending it to them.37:27and that they were disbelievers, Allah may do it. So it is no longer considered, according to the scholars, they identify that once the words of Allah are greater in a text than the words of Allah, that text is no longer considered to be Quran in and of itself. So the rules no longer apply. So, it is very important, because there is another aspect of it that we should be very clear on. Because Allah says in Surah Baqarah, that if you do not believe that this is revelation from Allah, then produce one chapter like it.37:59If you go to the end of the Quran, pick up, you know, three lines in English, you know, you can get, you know, a modern poet, or if you took it to Shakespeare or Wordsworth or whatever in English, you could write a better book than those which were written by Yusuf Ali or Mamadou Piksal or whoever else. And if it meant that this was what Allah was referring to, then it means that the challenge of Allah has been met. Where in fact, it was not met. It was not met in, because this is where the miracle of the Quran lies. So the Quran38:36I, in essence, is an Arabic Quran. To understand and to interpret and to be able to apply effectively and correctly, we must have a firm grounding in the sciences of the Quran. And similarly with the Sunnah, it is necessary for us to have a good background. Something of the Sunnah which appears to be contrary to is the norm. None of us can pick up the Quran. We can't pick up the Sunnah in English and read it and benefit from it and do it.39:12I'm saying you can't. And we should. That's what you must do. But you should realize that you have in front of you some limitations. Therefore, you don't pick it up and just start making your interpretations. You will find in the Quran much which is very clear, very straightforward. Doesn't require any kind of interpretation or anything. That you read, you go with. When you find something that, you know, its meaning isn't really clear and so and so, don't get into that. Better you go and you ask some brothers, learned brothers who have, you know, studied.39:44science is required, etc. who can bring the clarification for you. This is what you do. Save yourself from deviation. Similarly with the Sunnah. You know, you see people doing many different things. You read the authentic traditions, for example, Bukhari Muslim, Mu'tah, so and so. And you see things in there which people are doing, but it's identified in there. This gives you clarity. This is from the Sunnah. This is from the way of the Prophet, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. But if you come across something which seems to be, you know, with what everybody is practicing,40:14Then don't grab on to that thing and say, well, ah, this is the sunnah, people are not following. No, no. Better you sit with somebody who has learned the classification. Because this may be something which was done in the early period of Islam, which was later abrogated. And you don't have sufficient reading to understand and to know that, for example, this was done in that period and it no longer was done. You have a verse in the Quran where Allah says, for example, don't come to Salah in a state of intoxication. You may pick up that verse and say, huh, I can get intoxicated, but just not at the time when I have to go pray.40:49You don't know that in fact this was one of a series of verses which were revealed. And that it was superseded by later verses which prohibited alcohol absolutely. So similar the case of the Sunnah. We can protect, we can find that path. Lots of those who have attained success in this life. And the name. By holding on firmly to Quran and Sunnah. According to how it was understood and practiced by the companions of the Prophet s.a.w.41:24the early generation of righteous scholars who followed them. So with that, I'll close this brief presentation, allowing you an opportunity to raise any questions on the subject. Those who would like to raise it by actually speaking, we'll take those who would like to write their questions and send them forward. You're welcome to do so. Sisters may do the same. Before we go into the questions, I just add to that, for those who want to make their questions direct, then we have a microphone here. Please come to the microphone.41:58and do it that way, inshallah. Then just to pay attention to one or two things we've had to make to the program. This session will be ending, inshallah, at 4 o'clock, after which we'll have an hour's break from 4 to 5, during which we'll also pray Salatul Asr. After that, then we'll go into the session entitled Towards Understanding the Hadith and the Sunnah, inshallah. So the first question. As-salamu alaykum, Rabbi Bilal. You mentioned the verse, fight them as they fight you. Qatilahum kama qatilakum.42:32Is that the small ayat you mentioned just now? No, not quite as you put out before. Can I ask about it, please? A Muslim country were to be invaded, and they're using musket gas, something like that, which can destroy a palm tree or an olive, can poison wells, and can harm indiscriminately women, old people, and children. Are we allowed to resist them, defend ourselves against them, as they fight us? Can we fight them as...43:04They use such chemicals against them knowing fully well that there are other prohibitions that we ought to take care of when we are fighting war. Second question, if I may just ask you quickly. I will say it in English because I don't seem to be able to pronounce it. There is no compulsion in religion. Is that not sukh? Is it abrogated? These are two questions. First question, we are not allowed to do anything that the disbelievers may do to us in the course of war.43:42There are clear injunctions given by Prophet Muhammad to prohibit us from doing certain actions in the course of our fighting. Destroying trees, vegetation, you know, fruits, trees, etc. Children, destruction of the worshipping places of the Jews and the Christians. Hindus are not included, Buddhists are not included here. A variety of other injunctions have been given for the Muslim Mujahid, the one who is fighting.44:25And this is one of the examples which may be given to help to clarify that the verse does not mean as people have misinterpreted to mean. We are fighting a cause for the sake of Allah.45:08refers directly to collection of opinions of any given scholar whether they be philosophical, legal, spiritual, in any way as a whole. In that, the Prophet Muhammad had said to us by twirling, If you hold on to that firmly, you'll never go here.46:03Kitabullah and Sunnah. The Book of Allah and my Sunnah. The concept of the foundation from which I am not in fact binding on the Muslims. In the sense that if it's something which each and every person must choose, must follow their religion in some way or some shape, you know, incomplete, deficient. I'm just saying that to put the idea from the very beginning, you know, in...46:53context, as I view it. And hopefully, you know, the view that I'm presenting to you, I mean, I make it very clear that this is my view, but that might be alone in the sense that I'm bringing something which is new to you. You know, I have a particular madhhab, and I'm going to now bring this particular madhhab to you. I'm expressing to you a view which is based on the position held by scholars from the past, all the way from the time of the Sahaba till today. This is the position47:24commonly known present day times as the position of the Salaf I mean I do not particularly call myself a Salafi per se but anyone who intends to follow Islam as it was revealed has to be in concept a Salafi Salafi being the righteous early scholars of Islam and represents47:53their understanding of Islam. Because though they say that we follow the Quran and Sunnah, in fact, every deviant group says it follows the Quran and Sunnah. So, though our Prophet said that we hold on to these two, we'll never go astray, at the same time, in another stateness of his, it also made reference to following the Sunnah, and the Sunnah48:24of the righteous guided caliphs after him there is to the way of his companions the living figures amongst them we also had him say on another occasion that the best of generations is my generation then those that come after them then those that come after them these are all sort of pointers to let us know that that really that understanding of the early generation is of importance here because ultimately it is what49:04separate those who are following the Qur'an and Sunnah as it should be followed and those who are not. That is to say, everybody, in order to maintain some form of legitimacy, must claim that they are following the Qur'an and Sunnah. However, it is how do we understand the Qur'an and Sunnah which separates between those who are in fact following it as the Prophet intended, and those49:37who are interpreting it in their own manner to suit their own ideas which are in fact deviant, which are deviated from the main role which the Prophet Muhammad left for us to follow. So, the concept of madhhab itself binding on the Muslim, you know, to say, I follow this madhhab or I follow that madhhab. We are obliged to follow the Quran and the Sunnah in accordance50:20with the understanding that was held by the companions of the Prophet Muhammad , that also of the early scholars of Islam. The Mahab, as it is understood today, meaning that one is either a Shafi'i, Maliki, Hanbali or Hanafi, it is something which we have inherited, which developed at a particular period in time, Muslim history, and which we have51:07inherited, those of us who have converted to Islam, those of us who were born in Islam and have become converted to the need to practice it, find ourselves in a situation where we have a body of practices which have been handed down over the generations, and which Muslim agambos, in most of the Muslim world, have taken particular portions of and held on as51:40the correct way or their correct way. When we look historically, we see that these particular schools of thought, legal schools of thought, evolved out of particular circumstances, particular needs. I won't go into the details of it because that will be an extra in itself. There's a book which I have written, which is available, which is above the mention, Evolution of Sikhs, which is in fact the evolution of the Madhhab, how they evolved, etc. You know, those of you who are...52:13like to read more deeply on the subject. Insha Allah the books will be available afterwards and you can, you know, get yourself a copy and read in more depth on it if you haven't already. I would just like to look more from the point of view of our relationship with the madhhab. We have some people who have taken a position that the madhhab, it is haram to follow a madhhab. Period. You have some who have taken a position52:52that they are wajib. You've got to follow a madhhab. We have to decide for ourselves really what position should we be in. Truly, as I said, the concept of the madhhab, as it is known today, was not prescribed by the Prophet Muhammad , nor his companions. So we really cannot say that it is wajib. And some people actually who say it is wajib go overboard to the point where they have even added this53:31as one of the questions of the grave. I read this in a book written by Hosea Heshek, a writer also from Antioch. He's written a number of different books, you know, really promoting very strongly the idea that one must follow a markup. And if you don't follow a markup, then Satan is your Imam. And he added in there that, you know, we all know about when a person dies and he is questioned in the grave. He is asked, you know, who is your Lord? Who?54:03What was your prophet or the person who sent to you? What is your religion? He also added to this, and what was your matter? He added to this. He will be adding to this. This is an extreme view. I'm not saying that people who follow Marja know this, but I'm not saying that this is where it can end up. Those who hold on to it very strongly, they take a position which may be similar to this. On the other hand, those who say it is haram,54:36in my view have also gone to another extreme because when you look at what the Madhhab is in fact in the sense of it being a trend of thought a mode of interpretation and application of the Sunnah we see that it was in existence from the time of the Companions of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ so the fact that some of the Companions took a particular mode or followed a particular approach to the55:09interpretation and implementation of the sunnah, while others took another approach, which was fundamentally saying that there were some variances in how they applied it. This existed from their time, and to say it is haram is really a blanket indictment of even the early generation of Hussain. So then, yeah, that's a lot of lies to follow.55:49But at the same time, it is perfectly reasonable for us to follow the mode of thinking of an individual scholar. Before you have to be very determined. I mean, if you start to study about Islam, your body and knowledge is limited. You have to follow the thoughts of others. Either it is a scholar who has written a book, or it is an imam in a mosque, you know, or the general people of the area.56:36the people who talk to Islam initially, whatever, you will be following a thought or approach to the Quran. It is natural. Your position should be that you are following this thought or a meaning understanding and implementing the Quran and the Sunnah as it was understood by the early scholars. This should be your understanding. In that, what does that mean? It means to us that if57:20At any time we come across anything written, or we hear anything said, which seems to be in contradiction to the Quran and the Surah, then we have to believe what we hear or what we read. But we do not. Elevates it to the point where we will follow it blindly. It's actually prohibited in Islam of the blind following of anyone other than Yusufullah.57:54He is the only one that we are expected to follow blindly. Because this is the meaning of There is no God but Allah. And Muhammad is the last messenger of Allah. This is what it means when we make a declaration. It's not merely just accepting that Muhammad58:29was the last messenger of Allah. It means that that acceptance is a commitment. A commitment to following him because of the fact that what he brought was from Allah. Because we are not following him in fact. We are not following him as an individual. We are following him as the conveyor of the message, the final message of Allah to mankind. He was the means by which Allah conveyed that final message to us.59:03So we're not following him as a man. Now yes, some people go overboard in this area. We're following him as the messenger of Allah. And in following him, we're following Allah. Because Allah said, from the Quran itself, Allah says in the Quran, whoever obeys the messenger obeys Allah. So obedience to the messenger is obedience to Allah.59:38So when we're following them, we're following the commandments of Allah. This means that I said that no one, no opinion, no idea of any group, individual, country, community can take precedence over what the Prophet Muhammad has brought for us. I'm saying that we cannot escape following the madhhab. We should not be60:27rigid in our following of the Madhhab. We should be flexible in the sense that wherever the truth is, we look at the Madhhab as a means of collecting that truth for us. We represent the scholars of that period or individuals who have gathered the information for us. But they are not infallible. They are not infallible. They are not guided by Allah as Muhammad was guided.60:58So it means that they will make mistakes. And surely, if you go through the four different schools of Islamic law, that are commonly known as the Meccans, you will find in each and every one of them mistakes. There are errors. And the so-called founders of these schools themselves were the students of this factor, the human factor. They were not in and of themselves infallible.61:36They gave rulings based on the knowledge that had come to them, but they didn't have all the knowledge. The collections of hadith that we know now as Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Muwattah, you know, Abu Dawood and the others, these took place after the time of the great imams who founded, looked at as being the founders of the schools of Islamic law. So this is telling us that the major draveling of the sunnah took place after their time.62:11So naturally, it was not possible for any one of them to grasp all of the Sunnah. The Sa'aba had spread to different parts of the Muslim Ummah, and they passed on the knowledge they had in their very spirit. So, none of the individuals of the past had all of the knowledge. So naturally, there would be some rulings that they made based on partial knowledge. You know, it's not to say that they were just making, you know, rulings just purely based on opinion. No. They would look back into the Quran, look into the Sunnah,62:41And they would make a ruling based on what they had of the Quran and Sunnah. And in a certain degree, each and every one of us has to do the same. We read the Quran. We read the Sunnah. We learn from people in our midst, you know, who are scholars, who have studied abroad, or who have been exposed to Islamic knowledge, whatever. We get information from them. And circumstances arise where we have to make decisions. How do we make these decisions? We make it based on the knowledge that we have.63:15Is his knowledge perfect? It will never be. Perfect knowledge belongs only to Allah. Therefore, in our judgments, we will make some mistakes. We are human beings. We will make some mistakes in our judgments. But the point is that when we make a mistake, we should not be so rigid. You know, people get into a position where when you make a mistake and, you know, it's started out to you, you feel that it is a personal attack, you know.63:48You feel it's a personal attack on you and your person. So now you must defend it. You start to find arguments to defend what you know inside yourself to be wrong. This is where the problem arises now. It is because one of the students of Imam Malik, for example, explained that on one occasion, he was sitting with Imam Malik as a group, and Imam Malik was asked so many questions, something like 36 different questions. And to use 36 different questions, you know, to...64:17to thirty-one or thirty-two out of the thirty-six he said, I don't know. That would be my malice, isn't it? He was not shy to say, I don't know. He didn't feel that because I am the scholar here, I must have an answer for every question. Because again, this creates a problem amongst us. Where a person who is in a position of educating others feels that if he is not able to answer every single question that is raised, somehow he will be, you know,64:52look at as being inferior, and the people will look at you in a new fashion. He couldn't answer this question, he couldn't answer that question. You see, it's a mistaken view of people who question those who have some body of knowledge, and it's a mistaken view of those who have some body of knowledge to look in this fashion that they must be able to answer each and every question. Because when you take that position, then the chances of you making major mistakes become greater and greater. It is no shame for one to say, I don't know. I'm an original scholar, I know.65:26And I'll tell you what I have, but you know, if you want to be in contact with other people, I will go back and check this in more detail for you and try to bring a more reliable answer for you. Recognize the fallibility of people. We follow based on whatever information has been given to us. So that information is only as good as it is in keeping with the teachings of the Quran and the Sunnah. You know, as Imam Abu Hanifa and Imam Ashraf, they were both quoted to have said,66:02If the hadith is authentic, then it is in fact my madhhab. They cover themselves. They're telling you, I'm giving you what I have. But if you find an authentic hadith from Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, then that is what I really wanted to follow. And you follow that and leave what I said. And in fact they made statements similar to this. That, you know, if you find any contradiction between what I'm saying and what you find in the Quran or from the Sunnah, then...66:34Throw your mind aside and you follow that. This is their position. And this is the approach, this is the way, that flexible, open-minded way in which we should go about seeking knowledge. Recognizing the contribution of the early scholars, but not becoming so attached to any one individual or any one pattern, so much so that we become blinded to all others. We want to raise its superiority above all others, you know.67:07I remember as I was told when I first accepted Islam, when I travelled with the Jama'at Tabligh, and this is not to say anything specific against the Jama'at Tabligh, but just to relay something that's incident which occurred to me at that time, that I was informed, you know, at that time, being a new member of Islam, that everybody has to follow a Masha'ib. There are people who follow a Masha'ib, but they are the same. However, he added, most people on the earth follow67:46Imam Abu Hanifa. So when they were telling me they were giving me now reasons why in fact, without saying it directly, I should really be following Imam Abu Hanifa. And, you know, this is sort of a representation of, you know, you could say, mazhab rivalry, or oppressed and seers, or I'm from this mazhab, it's my tradition, it's my culture, it's my way, it's my people, my community, whatever, you know, I must defend it against the others. But no.68:21This was not the way of the companions at all. This was not the way of the early scholars of Islam. Imam al-Shashari, he studied under Imam Malik for some 20 odd years. He was one of the narrators of the Mota, the collection of hadiths Imam Malik taught. After that, he went to the region of Iraq to study under the students of Imam Abu Hanifa. Imam Abu Hanifa died by that time.68:54He also studied under, you know, Abu Yusuf and Muhammad al-Shaybani. Most of them were Muhammad al-Shaybani. And he gathered that information and he wrote, at that time, a book, you know, of legal interpretation of the Sunnah for its application called Al-Hujjah, the evidence or the proof. Following his period of study there, for some five, four years, he headed to Egypt to go and study under another Imam. Many of you have never even heard of him. His name is Alayth ibn Sa'ad.69:28And he was a major Imam of the same standing of Abu Hanifa and Imam Malik and the others. He went to Egypt to study on them, but by the time he got there, Imam Laith was already dead. So he studied under Imam Laith's students. And after studying under Imam Laith's students and gathering that information which Imam Laith had gathered himself, he said, you know, Imam Laith was a greater religious scholar than...70:00Imam Malik. However, his weak students have caused his approach, his mazhab, to be lost. A man who studied for 20 years under Imam Malik, this is what he is giving, this is the analysis he is giving. Actually, Imam Ulaith, when his mazhab as far as he knows disappeared, people don't follow it. They say, I'm following the lazy mazhab. I don't hear anybody saying that. Imam Shafi, who studied under the ideas of this, in his opinion, he felt that Imam Ulaith was70:37I mean, everybody has different levels, you know, in understanding and interpretation. And this is not to say anything about the individual per se, but Allah has blessed different people with greater understandings than others. He's put people over people. This is the sunnah of Allah. He did not make us all the same in the sense of understanding, beauty, strength, wealth, etc., etc.71:10We are the same in the sense that we all have to stand responsible to Allah based on the knowledge that we have. We are the same in that sense. But in the sense of ability to understand, this is something Allah has given some people more than others. Beauty, handsomeness, you know, makes some people more attractive than others. Allah has given them more than others. So Imam Al-Shaikh, looking at the meanings of both of these scholars,71:46After studying what they taught, gave his opinion that Imam Laith was actually a stronger DJ, legal scholar. However, he was giving us a reality here. The weakness of his students caused his approach to be lost. And in other words, it was not standing there as a major school in that town any longer. It had lost strong and going strong. That of Abu Hanifa was strong and going strong. However, he adored most of what Imam Laith taught.72:30And after having absorbed that, he wrote a new book called Al-Umm. Literally, here it means that the essence. The essence of his ideas. And in it, he reversed no end of rulings that he had made in his earlier book called Al-Hujjah. This is why those people who study Sharia now, from a comparative point, they refer to the old Madhhab.73:07of Ash-Shafi'i and the new mazhab of Ash-Shafi'i. In other words, he changed. They could change. It was no problem for him. Because as he said, you know, he was following the sunnah. Where the evidence came, that's where he went. So it was no problem for him to revert, you know, his pretentiousness with early readings and take this new position. So ultimately, we can say that no individual mazhab encompasses all of Islam. However, when we take them all together,73:43It is in God. It is there. When we take one and we want to push this one alone, then we are denying a portion of Islam. And we are no longer following Muhammad Rasool Allah ﷺ anymore. We are following a madhhab. We are following a madhhab now. We have cut this between ourselves and following Muhammad ﷺ. So, this is how we should look at this madhhab. This is how we should look at the madhhab of the Sahur.74:16Within them, you find Islam. However, no individual encompasses all of Islam. There are the efforts, human efforts of human beings, and as such, in them, there are errors. And when Imam Malik was asked, on one occasion, if we follow a Sahabi, one of the companions of the Prophet Muhammad, if we follow him, if we choose one and we follow him in everything he said and did, all his rulings, etc.,74:47What will be on the life path? Imam Malik said, no. Unless he was correct. Because the truth is one. The truth is one. When you hear a statement of Imam Malik, and when you hear a statement that is commonly quoted, one of the statements I heard when I first came into Islam also, Ashabi can you do? My companions are like stars. The ayah next to daytun is todaytun. Any one of them that you follow will be rightly guided. Sound beautiful.75:25But when you look at that in relation to what Imam Malik said there, you realize there's something wrong here. In fact, this so-called solution is a fabrication. It's not our technique. It's not true. The Sahaba, as much as we hold and in honor companions of the Prophet Muhammad who conveyed Islam to us, they were human beings. And they made mistakes. We're not obliged. And we, in fact, may be incorrect to follow the mistake of a Sahabi knowing that's what75:57The position he had was in fact wrong and a mistake. It would be wrong. Because if we did that, then we are going to be putting an individual between us and following Muhammad Rasool Allah. The second half of our shahada. We will be destroying the second half of the shahada. So now, this is where the issues of aqeedah come. Aqeedah meaning our faith. The fundamentals of our faith. That whenever we put any individual between ourselves,76:29and the following of the prophet Muhammad , then we are in fact destroying an aspect of our aqeedah, our faith. This is critical now. Because this is the Shahada Khan. The two declarations of faith. La ilaha illallah, Muhammadur Rasulullah. There is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is the last messenger of Allah. This is the foundation. If either of these two are destroyed, our Islam is destroyed.77:03We're left in ruins. We're left astray, deviant. So, what happens is that whenever a person decides to follow anyone else blindly, destroys the second half of his faith. You see, this is one of the areas in which what is commonly known today as Sufism, you know, the mystic path, the secret way, this particular path tacks the foundations of faith. Because it is common.77:50amongst those who follow the mystic path, that when the sheikh, the peer, the leader of that particular madhhab amongst the various mystical madhhabs, becomes your leader, becomes his what is called murid, one who has submitted his will. You give up your will. You do not question. You follow this man in any decision he makes.78:30Whatever he tells you to do, it is this approach, you know, you can say a concentrated version of destruction of the foundations of faith. Individual, a view of such a path is a deviant, deviated from the way of Islam. That's a summarizing for you and this presentation is only meant to be brief introduction to the idea, the thought, for some reflection.79:21I wanted to give you most of the time, give me some feedback, some questions in relationship to this topic because I know that it is one which affects the community, Muslim community, no matter where people are. And it's good for you to put these ideas for general discussion, for clarification, for exchange of ideas, understanding. So I'm just going to summarize again briefly. Concept.79:59of the mazhab in relationship to our Buddha and that is that each and every Muslim is obliged to follow the Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam blindly. His way is to be our way without question as long as the information that is coming to us is authentic. We have to have this condition because you may find somebody saying this is the way of Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam. You know you have people80:33known amongst the Sufis as the Whirling Jervishes, coming out of Turkey, where they stand over these big, long kazzes, and they have one hand down, one up, and they spin around in circles, and they say, this is Zikr, and this is the way I started Muhammad . So you'll find people saying, this is his way, you know, all over. We have to discern, we have to look into the traditions, the authentic collections of the traditions, and determine81:04what in fact was the way of the Prophet Muhammad and when we find that way then we have to follow that way blindly have to understand what the Prophet Muhammad has said you know in the complete sense before we can apply it for example he said 1400 years ago that it is better that we do not lie on our stomachs spit on your stomachs81:54The companions at the time, they didn't ask him, why are these people like this? Generations have passed of Muslims who, because of their commitment to the Calumet, to the Declarations of Faith, they chose not to lie on their stomachs. What made, ultimately, the arm that was there, they just knew that if the Prophet told them, it's better not to do this, that it means in some way, shape or form, they had some arm in the cross.82:27Because the commandments of Islam are not arbitrary. It's not a law that's making life difficult here, making life a little easier here. It's like a game of chess or whatever. No. What Islam is, is the best way of life for man. Spiritually and materially. So the things which are prohibited in Islam are the things which are harmful to us. Either as individuals or as a community. Either materially speaking, in a physical sense, or spiritually speaking. There is harm in it.82:58So this is why we have been commanded, don't do this. Better you don't. Do this. Because these things are beneficial to us. And the other things that you have forbidden are harmful to us. And this is a part of our faith. As Allah says in the Quran, Whatever the Prophet has given you, take it. Whatever he has forbidden you, leave it. It's for your benefit. So generations of Muslims, to follow the way of the Prophet Muhammad, lying on their right side,83:34with their knees bent, or at least lying on their back, but not on their top. In recent times, the last 10 years, the medical profession, more people who specialize in problems of the back, that the major problem, what is called sway back, curvature of the spine in old age, you know, collapsing of the vertebrae, the major cause, they give a list of things to avoid damage in your back.84:19Don't do this, don't do that, don't do that. Number one of the list was do not sleep on your stomach. Wait a minute, listen. Your spinal cord is the heaviest daily structure in your body. What is in front of it is just intestines and soft organs. When you lie on your stomach, when it sags downwards, it has no support. Why? People who've got bad backs, they give them a bed which is like a board and tell them to sleep on your back. The support for the spine helps it straighten back out again.85:01They recommended that you sleep on your side with your knees bent. Something, you know, we just found out in the last 10-15 years. But Muslims didn't have to wait for 1400 years to find out before they started doing it. No, they started doing it from the time that Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam turned to it. And in recent times, those medical experts of what they call SDS, sudden death syndrome, or cough death, amongst children, they find that the kids85:46two, four years old, two years old, one years old. Do not put your children to sleep on this. Within the last two years, we started to prove it. It was published today. Let me give you an example of this. There are many other things that Allah has told us to do. You know, we've learned to be able to discover and determine what is the rationale behind it. Where is really that harm that is in there? Where is really the good that is in there? We can't see it. That is the test of the law, alayhi salam, lies. Believing that86:46what we have commanded from Allah and the best way for us. And though it is natural for us to follow a madha, a way of individual or as a group, that seeking knowledge is a perpetual process from the time you are born to the time you die. And the gaining of knowledge has to be seen in one way or another. We are not independent, so independent that we are now receiving revelation and we can make decision. We gather based on what we gathered.87:32We grow based on the knowledge that was gathered by those before. Because to do so is to attack the foundation of our faith. We may follow with an open mind. It seems to be stronger when we leave and we take some day or we may just take some day and carry on in this particular path. But flexible because sin has perfect knowledge.88:53of world who came before understanding and practicing the Quran and Sunnah as it was understood and practiced by the early generation of Muslims like us.Afficher toute la transcriptionCommentairesAucun commentaire pour l'instant. Soyez le premier à partager une réflexion utile.