نص مُفرَّغ آليًا وقد يحتوي على أخطاء، فارجع إلى التسجيل للتحقق من الألفاظ.
0:00 to proceed this is our third session before i forget inshallah inshallah next week and the week after for the next weeks i will be absent inshallah leaving for minnesota and then kuwait for the next two weeks so we will resume inshallah the beginning of april right 0:30 The following two Saturdays, I will be out of the country. The 22nd and 29th, I'll be out of the country. So our next class will be on the 5th of April. Meanwhile, you want to make sure that you leave your emails so that I can send assignments and things like that through Abu Somai. 1:01 And he should, inshallah, send you this, the whole Unit 1, so that you could study it. Whatever we finished, you would study that. And whatever we have not finished, you could read it beforehand so that you would be ready when we come back to it, inshallah. In the first session, we talked about introduction in the first session. 1:29 And in the second session, we talked about the definition of fiqh linguistically and technically according to the earlier scholars, right? So we talked about the definition of fiqh linguistically, and we talked about the definition of fiqh according to the terminology of the earlier scholars. This is what we talked about last time, right? Fiqh from a technical point of view according to the terminology. 1:59 of the early Muslims. And then, so what did we say about fiqh according to the terminology of the early Muslims? What did we say about fiqh in general, in terms of the language? What's fiqh in terms of the language? Knowledge understanding comprehension. So is basic knowledge fiqh? 2:35 Is knowledge fiqh or not? According to Shaykh al-Ashqar , he considered knowledge to be fiqh, even without comprehension of subtleties or anything, to have some knowledge, because knowledge is the basis of understanding. You will have to have information so that you can understand those information. If you don't have the information, the data, you will not be able to 3:05 process the data. So it is part of fiqh to have the foundation of information that is part of fiqh. So fiqh cannot be the mental capacity of deduction without having the data that you deduce from, without the knowledge and having the data that you deduce from. 3:33 so it's the combination of both so you will not you will have the data and then you will process the data that is the knowledge and then you process the data and after you process the data the data you would have added to the body of knowledge right or wrong because you have the data you have like the hadith and then you process the hadith and then you come up with a ruling 4:01 the ruling adds to the body of knowledge so it is knowledge comprehension knowledge there is a basic knowledge followed by comprehension of this knowledge to add to that body of knowledge new knowledge which is the knowledge that has been deduced from the origin of data so that is the linguistically so it is 4:34 It is the knowledge and comprehension, and it is the mental capacity to deduce the rulings or to deduce benefits from the data. Now, fitrah, according to the terminology of the earlier scholars, in summary, what was fitrah according to the terminology of earlier scholars? It's understanding and the knowledge and the comprehension of a subject. 5:12 It was not concentrated only to the Islam of the deen. No. In terminology, in linguistic terminology, it does not pertain to the deen only in language. But for the earlier scholars, it became pertinent to the deen only. 5:42 but not a particular discipline in the deen. And then we said that it included al-aqeedah, fiqh, and akhlaq. Aqeedah, fiqh, and akhlaq were all included under the title of fiqh, which is your understanding of the entirety of the deen. And we give the example of, for instance, Imam Abu Hanifa calling his book on aqeedah al-fiqh al-akbar. In his book on creed, 6:16 He called it al-fiqh al-akbar, the greater fiqh. Okay. Today, inshallah, we will go over al-fiqh according to al-mutaakhireen. Al-fiqh of istilah al-mutaakhireen according to the terminology of the latter generations. So, the latter generations began using the term fiqh particularly for the science of Islamic law. They limited it to imply knowledge of the practical legal rulings. 6:58 practically legal rulings. And then when we go over the definition inshallah of fiqh, the various definitions of fiqh, we will see why they used those definitions. Sadr al-Sharia, which is Abayullah bin As-Saoud said, after the first generation passed, the science of fiqh was used to refer to the practical rulings that are derived from detailed evidences, either by 7:28 generalization or analogy. Thus fiqh became more specific while maintaining its original discipline. So basically what Sadr al-Sharia says is that fiqh became pertinent only to the 7:58 practical legal rulings after the earlier generations so the definition of fiqh according to al-amidi here we'll take this definition and then we will dissect it so al-amidi said define fiqh as knowledge of 8:30 He's talking about the extrapolation being either by generalization, generalization, or by deduction. Generalization is when you have one application and you're generalizing from this application, which is easy. It is basically when they share the same, it is qiyas al-loga. Qiyas al-loga, not qiyas in general. 9:00 Qiyas, in general, is the deduction. So, qiyas, in general, is the deduction. Qiyas al-logha, which is linguistic analogy. Basically, you extrapolate to all that is applicable using linguistic analogy. 9:34 do not hurt them by the linguistic analogy you will use the word hurt in all of the whatever applies whatever applications of the word hurt do not hurt your parents then you will say this is hurt this is hurt this is hurt this is hurt that's that is linguistic analogy but by deduction by deduction 10:02 is when you apply it to something different but it requires some subtlety of understanding which is to apply the ruling of wine to cocaine because you have verified that the cause of the prohibition of wine is intoxication and you will say that cocaine is intoxicant 10:31 Therefore, it takes the same ruling as wine. Now, the process of verifying that the effective cause of the prohibition of wine is intoxication is a form of its death, and not everyone will be capable of doing it. And the process of verifying the presence of that effective cause 11:01 in the new matter that is you know for which you are trying to find the ruling is also a form of istihad and not everyone will be capable of arriving at it through the mere understanding of language the mere understanding of language unlike hurt hurt hurt this is basically this is hurting your parents this is hurting your parents 11:30 So that is the difference between the generalization and the analogy. Generalization is using the PS and the analogy is using the technical PS, which requires some understanding of some of these. Now, that is as far as this is concerned. 12:04 So they manage, they basically manage the terminology of fiqh. They specify it to a particular discipline. They did not transfer the meaning to a different meaning, but they specified it to a particular discipline. So lab al-naqli is referring to? 12:36 the definition itself, so they did not use the linguistic terminology, they did not discipline or change it, but they made it specific. Yes, so meaning that they did not really depart from the linguistic terminology. They narrowed the spectrum that it applies to. They did not move the linguistic terminology to transfer, switch, move, change. 13:08 linguistic terminology and make it a new terminology but they took that very linguistic terminology and they narrowed down the application of it to the discipline of fiqh as practical legal rulings versus other rulings versus creed which is you know your belief 13:36 and rulings of the interior, the heart, akhlaab, and so on and so forth. So he says here, so what Sadr al-Sharia said is that they use the fiqh to refer to the process of deduction of practical rulings from the detailed evidence via generalization 14:07 or the deductive approach, which is analogy, analogical reasoning. So they then narrowed down the definition, narrowed down the definition, narrowed down the definition, they did not alter the definition, they did not alter the definition, the linguistic definition, they only narrowed the 14:38 Then he moves on to Al-Amidi. This fiqh became more specific while maintaining its original meaning. He moved to the definition of fiqh according to Al-Amidi. So Al-Amidi said knowledge of the legislative rulings as derived from their detailed evidences. And this particular definition of Al-Amidi is the one 16:03 that has been generally accepted by the scholars. They tried to refine it, tried to add to it, but this is a knowledge of the legislative rulings as derived from their detailed evidences. Okay. 16:42 so knowledge of the legislative rulings as derived from their detailed evidences so fiqh is knowledge like we said before it is your knowledge of the detailed rulings the legislative rulings so what is the why did he say which is not actually reflected in the translation 17:17 of the practical legislative rulings. The knowledge of the practical legislative rulings has derived from the detailed evidences. Why did he say ? Certainly because we're talking about Islamic law. We're not talking about anything else. So means Islamic law, Islamic legislation, Islamic legislation. 17:53 Now, al-amaliyya, why did he add al-amaliyya? To restrict it to that which is beneficial? No, that which is beneficial. Fruitful? No, yeah. To exclude the inner actions of the heart? Yeah, to exclude the rulings that pertain to the interior. So, fiqh does not address the prohibition of prejudice. 18:26 does not address the virtue of humility this is not because it is not and this is not because it's not important this is because it is separated into a different discipline what would that discipline be called says some people call it some people call it so but it is it has been separated 19:03 from the body of fiqh separated from the body of fiqh why separated from the body of fiqh in the new definition of fiqh according to the latter generations why why they separated those subjects it is evolution of sciences in general in in sciences you know people would talk about microbiology right 19:44 And then you will talk about bacteriology and virology as two different disciplines. And then you will talk about whatever else you narrow it down to. This is how sciences evolve. It is all like together. And then, you know, quantum physics, it becomes a different discipline. So this is how sciences evolve. 20:12 Now, they looked into those rulings and they found obvious differences between the talk about, you know, prejudice, pride, arrogance, self-conceit, etc. And the talk about the conditions of the validity of the prayer. When we talk about the conditions of validity of the prayer, they are well quantifiable. 20:40 measure you know you say one two three four five six and each each one is is quantifiable measurable like standardized this is how you do it and it's up to here up to the elbow including the elbow stuff like that versus to talk about self conceit or it's it's a completely different 21:10 nature of topics therefore they decided to separate between them and have this as a discipline and that as a different discipline now we said that this came at some expense at some price that the fuqaha that were devoted to the study of fiqh became separated from the sciences of the interior 21:40 or many of them became separated, many of them, not certainly half of them. Because the most deserving people of this scale are the scholars who know halal and haram. Because knowing the halal and haram is a prerequisite for avoiding the haram and doing the halal. And that is one of your surest means to escape, to purification. 22:10 But we sent many scholars that were only, that busied themselves only with the study of fiqh as the discipline, the modern discipline of fiqh and did not really study the ahkam of the interior. They became sort of deformed to some extent. Those who did not give attention 22:41 to the Ahkam of the interior, you become a mouthpiece, you become just like an intellectual phenomenon. But you're not the scholar in the true sense of the word that the Sahaba knew, that the Tabi'een knew. When Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal was asked about Ma'ruf al-Karkhi and his knowledge, he said, He had the root of all knowledge. 23:10 the fear of Allah so that is the scholar in their understanding but then later on when the discipline separated so much and some of the scholars who studied the discipline separated themselves from the knowledge of you know the interior and the knowledge of the heart and so on they became 23:40 unaware of the importance of those sciences. That does not apply to the greatest scholars of fiqh, because those greatest scholars that we hear about, it would be quite difficult to believe that those were oblivious to the sciences of the interior. The great grand scholars of fiqh that we hear about, they would have not been oblivious to the sciences of the interior. 24:10 Allah blessed them with all of this knowledge, so it is not expected of them the names that you remember, the scholars that you hear of, the great scholars, and so on. But we're talking about the whole body of scholarship. We're talking about the lesser scholars. 24:43 the ones that are more in numbers. So they have a huge impact on the population. So when they become less interested, less aware of the sciences of the interior, then they dry out the knowledge of FEPP from its sources of nurture. 25:13 certain sources you know because if you have no spirituality infused into the knowledge effect it becomes a very dry knowledge it becomes a very intellectual exercise so so to basically avoid to sort of conform to the necessary evolution of the science 25:44 but avoid the consequences of this evolution. You just need to continuously infuse the knowledge of faq with the speech about the interior, you know, the knowledge of the interior, and the wisdoms behind the legislation. And that is something that should not be missed. It is extremely important that you're talking about the wisdom, particularly here. 26:13 in the United States, particularly Muslims that live as minorities within a non-Muslim majority, oftentimes if you teach fiqh as like a dry subject, right, wrong, wajid, mubah, et cetera, without delving into the wisdoms of the legislation, it becomes really counterproductive. 26:40 And it causes many people to be disinterested. And it causes many people to be suspicious. It causes some discomfort in people's hearts. Because they are isolated from the wisdom of legislation. And they are being introduced to a set of legislations that are completely foreign to them. Without understanding their basic foundation and the wisdom. 27:09 Behind them, they will not be comfortable with what they're learning. Even if they accept it at face value, even if they look to you like they are quite attentive and everything's good, but the shaitan is not going to leave them. Shaitan is going to come back to them and say, what's this ruling? How come? 27:44 it says such and such, or how come there is a consensus on such issue. So as a teacher, you know, as a preacher, as an activist, as whatever you are, you should always reconnect to them, reconnect to them, reconnect to the legislation to its wisdoms, because sometimes the scholars, you know, the classical scholars, 28:14 They omitted that from their books because it was basic knowledge, common knowledge. So you need to reconnect them. And you need also to establish the connection between the fiqh and its roots. The Islamic theory in general is the root of this fiqh. The creed cannot be separated from fiqh. 28:45 The spirituality cannot be separated from fact. So you need to make that connection one more time. Okay, so it is the knowledge of practical legislative rulings derived from the detailed evidences. 29:14 So we said the practical because it is talking about the acts of the exterior. The acts of the exterior. And legislative because it's Islamic law, it's not something else. Rulings, al-ahkar. And what is al-hukm? Al-shara'i. Where does hukm come from? It was hakim. Huh? It was hakim. Hikmah. Hikmah. So, hakimatul. 29:52 is what? Is the... Rain. No, not the rain. What's the part that you put in the mouth of the horse? It goes into the mouth of the horse. The rain is the... Basically, the ropes that are attached to that part that you put in the mouth of the horse. What's the part, the metal part? What is that called in English? 30:25 Huh? Bridal. Bridal? Yeah. Really? You're just so good. Oh, you're good? Yeah. You're not going to medicine, though. So the bridal of the horse. That is the hakama. 30:58 the fools amongst you, I fear, you know, I fear for you from my anger. So al-Hukmah comes from al-Hakamah, the bridle of the horse. So it comes from limiting, binding, you know, controlling, like Hakamah al-Faras. 31:26 So limit to buy and to control, to have a control over someone. That is what hukm means. But that is where it comes from linguistically. But what is the technical definition of hukm? Technical definition of hukm is It is Allah's address to those that are 31:58 subject to takleef subject to rulings in the sense of them being you know subject to those rulings or it's Allah's address to you it's Allah's like commands requirements commands and prohibitions to you as a mukallaf as someone liable for 32:30 the rulings or addressed by the rulings but not any khitab because khitab Allah or the speech of Allah that is directed to you as an addressee is not limited to rulings but it is limited it is khitab Allah could be about aqeedah could be about other matters could be about stories of the ancient nations 33:01 but he said here that pertains to the rulings of the that pertains to the rulings binding to those who are liable for compliance or those who are addressed by the rulings but if you say that the the speech of Allah 33:35 that pertains to the rulings of the Muqallafin, the rulings of the Muqallafin, is not all about the rulings. Sometimes there is a speech of Allah that pertains to the rulings, but it is not in the form of command or prohibition. It is not for them to comply. It is just to inform them of the Khita. 34:05 to inform them of the rulings, to inform them of the salah, for instance. But the hukm al-shar'i is the fitab, or the speech of Allah SWT, addressing al-mukallafin, from which you could actually come up with rulings that are binding on the mukallafin. So that is the definition of al-hukm al-shar'i. 34:35 So knowing those , yes? Regarding the work in , I was attending elections, and I was told that it was something that was introduced due to the influence of Greek philosophy on Islamic law, because the general idea is that none of the rules are actually a burden. 35:03 So to call somebody a mukallif is actually not in the spirit of the law. So was there like a definition before mukallifi? No, it is not against the spirit of the law. Because Allah said, Allah will not burden a soul beyond its capacity. But Allah will burden the soul within its capacity. JazakAllah khair. 35:35 Because there is the burden of taklif in general, and you can't deny that waking up for salat al-fajr is a form of burden. It is not beyond your capacity, it is within your capacity, but it is, you know, making five prayers every day, and fasting in Ramadan, along the days of Ramadan, jihad sometimes, stuff like that. 36:05 These are burdens, but they are within the capacity. So, it is basically knowledge of the practical legislative rulings as derived from the detailed evidence. Okay. So, we're taking each word here and trying to dissect each word. So, the legislative rulings, which is 36:35 And I hope you know that I didn't cause you much confusion with this business. But inshallah I'll come up with like a good translation for But generally speaking you understand. It is Allah's speech or address to you as a in the sense of being a not in the sense of information, in the sense of 37:05 Direct taklif, command and prohibition, requirement, something that is required of you to comply with. So when he says, has derived from the detailed evidences, what does he mean by this? Has derived from the detailed evidences? He means that fiqh is not only to know the legislative rulings, the practical legislative rulings. 37:39 And you would not be faqih, you would not be faqih if you know, you know, if you memorize this is halal, you know, so-and-so said this is halal, and so-and-so said this is haram, and so-and-so said this is maklub. That is not fiqh. But fiqh is when you know, yes, this is halal because of such and such. Is you know how it has been derived from the detailed evidences. 38:09 to know the process. How did we come here? How did we arrive here? It is not just to take the end product as an end consumer. That is the lay person who only needs to take the end product because he is an end consumer. But it is not fiqh and it would not be faqid if you just know what the end product is. 38:37 until you have known the process derived from as derived from their detailed evidences. So what are the detailed evidences? An ayah from the Quran or a hadith from the Prophet . These are the detailed evidences. What about the principles of jurisprudence and the legal maxims and so on and so forth? 39:29 Why are they not included? Although they are used for the derivation of can. So when we say, like we said this morning in the Fickle Transactions class, we said what? We said المعروف كالمشروط. That which is customary is like that which is stipulated in the contract. So this is a legal maxim. We said الخراج بالضمان. 39:59 which is profit follows liability or profit and liability are mutually inclusive, go hand in hand. That is also a legal maxim. Although this particular iftaraj with the one has been reported from the Prophet ﷺ, but not every legal maxim has been reported directly from the Prophet ﷺ. But why does he say here, دلات التفصيلية, detailed evidences? What about the non-detailed evidences? 40:29 the principles of Sharia. The objectives of Sharia sometimes are employed in deriving rulings, right? When the scholars say this is consistent with the objective of preserving one's life. It is called upon in the derivation of rulings from those objectives of Sharia. So why did he only say here the detailed evidences? 41:07 the other foundation in order to get there? Good. You should go into medicine. No, this is because basically anything else that is used in the deduction of rulings will have to be eventually based on the detailed evidences. So even the legal maxims 41:40 have to be, you know, you will have to, basically, you have to prove the legal maxim. You cannot just say, because of such and such legal maxim, without proving the legal maxim. How do you prove the legal maxim? From the detail, from the Quran, from the ayat of the hadith. Now, if, now, why is it that we're not doing this? 42:10 Like, why is it that we say, and we just carry on? Certainty is not negated by doubt, and we carry on. Because supposedly, we should be done with this discussion. Otherwise, if we do everything from scratch, it's going to take too long. But we are done with this discussion. You know, and I know, that this is a legal maxim that is established, agreed upon. 42:37 So I don't need to prove each and every legal maxim for you. However, if I contest the legal maxim, you need to prove it to me. So if someone contests, you probably don't want to be talking to him because he's going to waste your time and give you a headache. Unless it's a student that wants to learn. But if he's actually contesting as a contestant, 43:08 but there are those legal maxims that could be contested by some, particularly when it comes down to the detailed legal maxims within the different branches of fiqh that are called da'ab al-faqih, or legal regulators. Then they could be contested, and sometimes they are madhhab-based and so on, so you can't use your own regulators and your own madhhab in a debate with someone from another madhhab. But once they are contested, 43:39 You know, so you tell me that this is, we're in a debate, and you tell me that this is on the basis of such and such legal maxim or legal regulator. Legal maxim or legal regulator. Then I have the right, if this legal maxim is not agreed on by consensus, you have the right of telling you, but I don't agree with this legal maxim, then what you need to do next is to prove your legal maxim to me through the detailed evidences. 44:08 So everything went back to the detail of the evidences, that is the ayat and the hadith. What about ijmaa? Someone said ijmaa here. What about ijmaa? Ijmaa is regulated by, restricted by the Quran and so on. Or it's conditionally based on that, the detail of everything. An ijmaa is basically like a silent ijmaa, where a sahabi ruled upon an event. 45:00 and nobody spoke against it. That means that everybody was, you know, for that decision. Yeah, but I'm not talking about the nature of ajmaa, but ajmaa in this context is based on the Qur'an and Sunnah because it is impossible. It is either based on direct proof, clear direct proof from the Qur'an and the Sunnah, or it is... 45:28 we would presume that there must be a proof from the Qur'an. It is impossible. People don't agree even when things are clear. So it is impossible for all of the scholars to agree upon a matter when there is not a proof from the Qur'an and the Sunnah. So in this case, Ijma' itself went back to an adillah tafsiriyya. And then you can extrapolate from Ijma' for sure, and you can extend from Ijma'. 45:57 But in and of itself has to be based on the detailed evidences because it is impossible for human beings to agree unless there is some clear proof. So Al-Amidi and Al-Amidi attributed this definition to Shafiri. As for Tajuddin al-Sufqi, he defined it as knowledge of the practical rulings as obtained from their detailed evidences. 46:32 You know the difference in language here. He said Al-Muqtasab is like a beautiful word, or Al-Mustathma. It basically, Muqtasab comes from earning, right? So that are earned from the detailed evidences. It is beautiful because of the connotations of it. 47:00 you feel like you're earning something after you arrive at a ruling you feel that you've earned something through your ijtihad which is excelling you have eventually earned something or mustathmar comes from thamara which is fruit and you feel like you picked the fruit at the end of your ijtihad 47:29 you were able to pick the fruit of the tree. So clearly, these definitions are similar. The definition of fiqh is very precise, and it shows the key perspective which the Muslim scholars have regarding the sciences of fiqh, below is a clarification of the elements of this definition. So fiqh is a science, it covers a specific theme, and has its own exclusive rules and principles. On this basis, the fiqaha treated it 48:10 in their books, researchers and fatawa, it is not merely a technique, as some scholars claim. So that is the first part of the definition, which is, So faqih is a science that has its own basis and foundations and principles, and it is not a technique or basically a mental capacity. 48:42 Because we said FEPP is beyond this, is more than this, it includes all of that. It is the technique, it is the mental capacity, it is the knowledge that you will use to produce more knowledge through a process in which, which is a technique, in which you use your mental capacity, right? So it is the knowledge, the knowledge of the detailed evidences. 49:12 that you will use to produce more knowledge of the end product, final rulings, through a technique, and this technique, through this technique, or this process, you will use that mental quality of the faqir, who is capable of deduction of subtleties from 49:43 the detailed evidences. So fiqh is not only the technique, it's not only the process, it is the combination of all, so it is a science that has a specific theme, rules, and principles. Secondly, fiqh is the science of legal rulings. Legal rulings are those handed down through verbal transmission and taken from the religion itself. They are not based on simple common sense. 50:24 such as knowing that this world was created or that one equals half of two, etc. They are also not rulings that can be merely based upon the human senses, such as the knowledge that fire burns. They are also not derived from linguistic jargon or complex grammatical rules. A legal ruling is a rule given by the legislator on a certain issue. 50:55 When this rule commissions the individual with a certain practice, it is called a حكم تكليفي, binding legal ruling. When this rule does not commission the individual in and of itself, then it is called a حكم وضعي or a declaratory law. Okay, so basically fiqh would be the understanding of those legal rulings. 51:24 as derived from the detailed evidences of the Qur'an and the Sunnah any there is because there is basically different types of ahkam there is al-Hukm al-Shar'i that is what we were talking about versus al-Hukm al-Aqli versus al-Hukm al-Urfi al-Wadhi versus al-Hukm al-Lughawi 51:51 So al-hukm al-shara'i is the legal ruling. Then there is al-hukm al-urfi, which is al-wada'i wal-urfi. So al-hukm al-wada'i is basically the natural rules, like fire burns. That is not a hukm shar'i. 52:24 That is a natural rule. And then there is which is the customary rule. Customary rule. We've come to know that prune juice helps with constipation. That's a customary rule. It is not a legal ruling or a rule. It is customary. 53:01 the customary, you have the natural, you have the aqli, which is the intellectual one, intellectual one, logical ruling. Al-aqli would be what, like what, the whole is bigger than the part, one is half of two. These are ahkam aqliyya. They're deduced. 53:33 through an intellectual inductive process only. Right? So this is a hukm al-aqli, the whole is bigger than the part. This hukm al-aqli is different from al-hukm al-urfi, which is the customary ruling of prune juice, because you would have not known about prune juice unless you tried it. But the whole is bigger than the part, it does not require previous experience. Your intellect, 54:07 is capable of this induction without previous experience. The whole is bigger than the part, or the part is smaller than the whole. And then there is the حكم اللغوي which is the linguistic ruling. That's the rulings that are given by language. So الحكم الشرعي that we're talking about is different from الحكم العقلي, it's different from الحكم العرفي. 54:39 it's different from it is that is deduced not from your not from the near language not from your experience as a human being but from the revelation that is why it's called the now itself is divided into two different types the which is the binding and 55:10 The wada'i which is the declaratory. What is the difference between a taklifi and wada'i? 55:51 Yes, that is right. So is that you have to fast in the month of Ramadan. is that the month of Ramadan starts upon sighting the moon. Is that or not? The month of Ramadan starts upon sighting the moon. Right? But are you required to do something about it? You're not required to start, you know, 56:23 to turn the moon you're required to look for the moon collectively as a woman you're required to look for the moon but the very hukmah that Ramadan starts upon sighting the moon is not something that you need to do something about but sometimes you get a little bit confused because sometimes there are ahkam wa daya that you need to do something about so conditions of validity 56:55 are considered to be conditions of or conditions of obligation conditions of validity you know the difference between condition of obligation and validity is the condition without which the ibadah will not be valid so like you can't have salah without wudu that is a condition of validity 57:31 which is the condition of obligation, is a condition without which the Salat is not obligatory. Like you need to be an adult for Salat to be obligatory. That's a condition of obligation. The time has to have entered. It's a condition of obligation. Right? So, conditions are, in general, 58:04 Are part of al-hukm al-waday or al-hukm al-taklifi? Waday. Conditions. You're not mukallaf to become an adult? No, but to make a plan. Thank you. Okay. So, now, sometimes you're not mukallaf about the conditions at all. 58:36 In most cases, you're not mukallaf about the conditions. You're not mukallaf about being a aqid, sane. You're not mukallaf about being adult. You're not mukallaf about, you know, the starting of the month. You're not mukallaf about most of these declaratory laws. You're not mukallaf about earning the threshold of zakah so that you can give zakah. 59:07 Because zakah is not obligatory until your money reaches the threshold, which is called the nasab, which is the zakatable minimum or the threshold. The threshold for zakah. Right? You have to have a certain amount of money so that zakah becomes binding on you. Are you mukallaf to earn that money? No. You're not mukallaf to earn the money so that you have to give zakah. 59:41 It is just that if you earn that much money, then you will need to give zakat. You're not mukallaf to earn the money. But you are mukallaf to make wudu for the salah. And the wudu is a condition of validity. Right? So sometimes there is this overlap between al-hukm al-wadai, the declaratory law, and the binding or al-hukm al-taklifi. But simply in this case, 60:13 simply in this case, will have been established through the detailed evidences as a there will be another another address concerning the obligation of wudu concerning the obligation of wudu to make wudu obligatory on you there will be another address concerning the obligation of wudu so still declaratory laws 60:47 You don't need to do much about them. They are just there to inform you that the Salah will become binding on you when the sun reaches the zenith. You're not responsible for making the sun reach it. The Salah becomes obligatory when that time comes. Yes, ma'am. Chef, can it be considered circumstantial law? Circumstantial? 61:17 Well, no, that would be the other translation for declaratory laws. They call them circumstantial. But declaratory would be better because it is basically, these are laws that are to inform you of something, to declare something, to declare that the beginning of Ramadan is when the moon is sighted. The Salat al-Zuhr starts from... 61:50 the time the sun reaches its zenith. So examples. Repaying a debt is obligatory and murder is prohibited. Obligation in the first case and prohibition in the second case are binding legal rulings. These are حكم تكلفية. They enjoin either performing an action, such as repaying a debt, and avoiding an action such as murder. As far as the declaratory legal rulings, 62:24 One declaratory ruling is the fact that Sharia invalidates any contract drawn up by an irrational person. Insane, I guess. Does it say irrational or does it say insane? You know, irrational would invalidate a lot of contracts. Wait a second. 62:57 is not irrational. Irrational will invalidate most of the contract. This is a joke. Insane. Invalidity is the declaratory legal ruling which was resultant of the insane. There is nothing called irrational in Sharia because irrational to you is rational to me. 63:44 insane person drawing up a contract where no action was commissioned of anyone in this case basically the fact that legal contracts by insane people are inconsequential this is not a command or a prohibition it is just a statement know that a legal contract now based on this knowledge based on this knowledge the judge but this knowledge in and of itself 64:14 is not legally binding. There is no requirement. It is for your information. But eventually, the declaratory rulings are not just there for your information only. They will be consequential. There will be something to do about it. So here, there will be something for the judge to do. The judge will need to invalidate that contract. If someone bought a house from an insane person, 64:49 The judge will say no, you know that the same is invalid unless You know the contract is made with the custodian Because every insane person like every child needs to have a custodian to look after their interests Thirdly focus the science of practical rulings the word practical here means that thick rulings are related to issues practiced by people Such as acts of worship and daily transactions practical rulings 65:22 deal with the body rather than the heart. We did go over this. Fourthly, fiqh is derived from the detailed evidences. This means that rulings do not belong to the science of fiqh unless they are based on the well-known sources of sharia. A faqih is one who traces back each legal ruling to its evidences. Islamic law or fiqh is not enacted by the state. Rather, it is a religious legislation. 65:51 that depends solely on religious texts. This definition limits fiqh to rulings derived by considering the evidences. As for rulings adopted via taqlid, blind imitation, without thorough consideration of the evidences, they do not belong to fiqh. So mere taqlid does not belong to fiqh. Detailed evidences or mere blind following. Taqlid is blind following or blind imitation. 66:22 Detailed evidences refer to specific proofs from the Qur'an and Sunnah, such as Allah's saying prohibited to you are dead animals, blood, the flesh of swine, etc. Also the Prophet ﷺ said that adorning gold and silk has been made lawful for the females of my ummah and unlawful for its males. It says lawful, so you say unlawful. And unlawful for its males. 67:00 to the detailed evidences or the holistic evidences. These latter evidences are controversial according to the scholars of As-Surah Al-Fat, the fundamentals of Fat, since they are concerned with the fundamental evidences from the Noble Qur'an, the authentic Sunnah consensus analogy and the likes. Also they focus on the implications of the proofs in the Qur'an and Sunnah. So basically those... 67:37 For instance, of these formulated fundamentals are the following. A command that applies obligation unless there is a textual connotation that indicates it being merely desirable. A prohibition implies unlawfulness unless there is a textual connotation that implicates it being merely undesirable. There is a mistaken translation here. In contrast to the detailed evidences or the holistic evidences, 68:40 These latter evidences are the subject of research by the scholars of Rasul. But basically, let's go back to the, you know, inshallah, you will get another document from me, because I did not really get a chance to read the translation, all of it. I went and sort of skimmed over it quickly to get the document ready to send it to you. 69:26 but inshallah i'll go back and look at the translation one more time and read through it one more time it's a very good translation it's a very good translator but there are certain things as far as the source language the understanding of the source language requires like some technical knowledge anyway so the holistic uh evidences 69:59 that we're talking about here the usuli evidences are not mentioned here what is mentioned is the detailed evidences from the Quran and the Sunnah and basically I told you why because the usuli principles will need eventually to be proved by the Quran and the Sunnah right so when you say when you mention this usuli principle a command implies obligation 70:30 unless there is textual connotation. This is an Osori principle that indicates it being merely desirable. There is also the legal maxims, and the difference between Osori and the legal maxims, we can discuss this, inshallah, next time. But these are all holistic evidences. We said that they have to be eventually proven by detailed evidences from the Quran and the Sunnah. 71:00 Because that very statement, what is the proof on this statement? The command implies obligation unless there is textual connotation that indicates it being merely desirable. And the prohibition implies unlawfulness unless there is textual connotation that indicates it being merely undesirable. So in every command from the Prophet, the default is that every command from the Prophet means wajib. It does not mean mustahab. When do you interpret the command to mean mustahab? 71:38 if there is textual connotation if there is something in the text that would point to that direction the proof on this is whenever I command you to do something do of it as much as you could do of it as much as you could within your capacity because beyond your capacity you're not responsible and whenever I forbid you from something abstain from it refrain from this could be invoked here 72:09 to prove this principle all of the ayat that talk about the obedience of the prophet would mean that it is not optional for you to obey him or not when he gives you a command it's not optional for you to obey him or not so this very principle itself is proven 72:37 by therefore it all goes back to or the detailed evidences. Even the holistic evidences, we will have to trace them back to the roots in the detailed evidences. Is it the same concept of saying that unless there's a ruling within the deen, you don't rule it? And in the rulings of the dunya, 73:14 Unless it is restricted, you can do it. For instance, if it is restricted to eat swine, you don't eat swine. But if there is no restriction on eating, let's say, kale, the bird, then we can eat it. So that's like on the rulings of the .. And on the rulings of the ,, it's like if it's said not to, it has nothing to do 73:42 good and, you know, above the sila, then you don't do it. So you're talking about the default concerning worship. It is not rulings of the deen or rulings of the dunya. It is the two spheres in which fiqh operates. Fiqh operates in the sphere of worship, that's your relationship with Allah. And in the sphere of muhammalat, interactions, 74:11 That is your relationship with the creation, not the creator. So in the sphere of worship, fiqh al-ibadat, the fiqh of worship, in that sphere of fiqh of worship, the default is restriction until proven otherwise. So you can't initiate al-ibadat. You can't instigate a new act of worship. But in the sphere of interactions, 74:42 fiqh al-mu'malat, or the sphere of the fiqh of interactions, that's interactions between you and the creation, not the creator, because an interaction between you and the creator is called worship, but in the sphere of the fiqh al-mu'malat, fiqh of interactions, the default is the opposite. No restrictions until proven otherwise. So you could eat anything you want until it is proven haram. 75:10 you could transact in whichever way you like until it is proven haram. Sheikh, is this principle a social principle, or is there something from the Quran that's actually proved that by that it's like this, and from all that it's... No, just two, like an ayat hadith would prove this. هُوَ الَّذِي قَلَقَ لَكُمْ مَنْ فِي الْأَرْضِ جَمِيعًا It is He who created for you all that which is on the earth. 75:43 هُوَ الَّذِي خَلَقَ لَكُمْ مَنْ فِي الْأَوْلِ جَمِيعَهِ هُوَ الَّذِي خَلَقَ لَكُمْ مَنْ فِي الْأَوْلِ جَمِيعَهِ هُوَ الَّذِي خَلَقَ لَكُمْ مَنْ فِي الْأَوْلِ جَمِيعَهِ هُوَ الَّذِي خَلَقَ لَكُمْ مَنْ فِي الْأَوْلِ جَمِيعَهِ هُوَ الَّذِي خَلَقَ لَكُمْ مَنْ فِي الْأَوْلِ جَمِيعَهِ هُوَ 76:17 whoever innovates in this affair of ours starts something new in this affair of ours that does not belong to it shall be rejected shall be rejected so you wait until you're sure that it is prescribed in the area of ibadat you do not have to wait in the area of mu'malat until you know but you will have to learn the fiqh of mu'malat 76:47 if you will be a merchant or someone like this. You have to learn the thick of marriage before you get married, or enough of the thick of marriage to know, you know, what is right and wrong and rights and obligations. Because otherwise, ignorance is not going to exempt you from, you know, the consequences. Ignorance is not going to exempt you from the consequences. 77:16 If knowledge was required in the first place, if knowledge was required, then ignorance does not exempt you from consequences. Otherwise, it would be quite easy for everybody. You're not going to learn anything, so then I wouldn't be liable for anything, and that would be like an easy way out. Let's finish this quickly so that we finish this part. It covers both decisive and speculative rulings. 77:43 This definition shows that fiqh covers the practical rulings, which are qatay, decisive rulings, in the religion, such as the obligation of dhuhr, noon prayer, and the prohibition of wine. Those are the qatay things. And we really need to understand the difference between qatay and dhanni, so that not that the dhanni or the speculative rulings 78:13 you will not talk about them, you will not preach, you will not debate, you will not sometimes commend and condemn, but you will eventually have to understand the difference between and so that you do not become too rigid or too sort of vicious, you know, against your fellow 78:49 brothers and sisters, and too certain of your own positions. So Imam Shafai, with his great knowledge, he said that the qatay, qatay, would be, the matters of certainty, would be like al-dhur arba' wa al-khamru haram. The dhur is for raka'as and the khamru is haram. That is the kind of qatay that Imam Shafai says, these are matters of certainty, 79:21 And people should not be debating about it. But for us, you know, we have like thousands of rulings. You know, whatever it is that you know is a matter of certainty. Which could be somewhat, you know, troublesome. It also covers the thani, speculative rulings. Such as whether or not touching a woman invalidates ablution. Or whether it's obligatory to wipe over the entire head or just the part. 79:54 thereof, when performing ablution, etc. So these are the dhanni rulings. These are controversial issues. Touching a woman in dhala is tabudu or not. It's obligatory to wipe over the entire head or just a part of the head. It'll do. These are dhanni issues. And that is why we said that fiqh includes not only, you know, so fiqh will include zohra arba, 80:26 And there is only one opinion here. So that is recorded, that is fiqh. But fiqh will include, you need to wipe over one hair, shafa. You need to wipe over one quarter of your head, hanafi. You need to wipe over your entire head, hanbali. Fiqh will include all of the above. That is fiqh. 80:55 Until you could say that you could be the arbitrator, sort of the chief arbitrator, we will say that this is fit, fit, fit. Now, you don't need to be the chief arbitrator to say, I believe this is stronger. I believe this is more, you know, like in accordance with the Sunnah. This is more... 81:25 basically evidence-based. You could say that without claiming to be the chief arbitrator, but if you transfer the issue from the area of speculative rulings to the area of certain definitive rulings, now you've made yourself a chief arbitrator over the deen. Some other scholars such as Al-Razi had a different viewpoint. 81:58 they believe that decisive rulings are not covered by fiqh so they said that dhuhr is not fiqh because that does not really require any mental capacity mental quality any process nothing but we said last time this is fiqh right because if we say it is not fiqh then we're building without a foundation because you know dhuhr is for 82:26 And then each one of these units is made up of qiyam and ruku' and sujood. And the qiyam, it consists of, you know, reciting al-fatiha. And then we get into, you know, do you have to recite al-fatiha behind the imam? But all of the rrrr has to be established. It has to be established on what? Zuhr is for rakahs. This has to be established on salah is obligatory. So you build from down up. 82:57 all the way down, and you go up, and the farther up you go, then you start to get into the controversies. So some other scholars, such as al-Razi, have different viewpoints, and they believe that the decisive rulings are not part of, are not covered by fiqh. Ibn al-Humam had a completely different view from that of al-Razi. He limited fiqh to the decisive rulings, by claiming that speculative rulings have no place in fiqh. 83:28 Both views could be refuted by the method which the fuqaha wrote their books since they included both decisive and speculative rulings therein. Furthermore, the decisive and speculative rulings are not agreed upon between all the Muslims. So there are these certain rulings that are certainly certain. And there are those certain rulings that are not certainly certain. That's the area of controversy. 83:58 Does this belong to the decisive or to the speculative? So there are certain areas that are certainly agreed upon to be speculative. And there are certain areas that are agreed upon to be decisive. And there are those things in the middle where they say that this matter has been established by consensus. But then they say, 84:27 No, really, was the consensus reported on this? Is this like the true consensus? But, you know, Ibn Alayya or this or that disagreed, and that would invalidate the consensus. So then there is this discussion over this area in the middle between the clearly decisive Zuhra's four records and the clearly speculative. 84:57 you know, touching a woman does not invalidate your mudu or not. Clearly speculative, clearly decisive, and then there is the area in the middle where they disagree over whether it's decisive or speculative. Furthermore, the decisive, so basically he's saying all of the above will be included in fiqh because that is what the fuqaha did. They included the clearly decisive, the clearly speculative, 85:26 and the controversial, whether it's decisive or speculative, he included all of this in their books. Rather, some scholars may have numerous proofs. So he's saying to both Ibn al-Humam, you know, the author of Shir al-Ashqar, he's saying, he's answering, you know, the claim of al-Razi, rahimahullah, and Ibn al-Humam, rahimahullah. Al-Razi said it's only speculative that's considered fiqh, because it is not fiqh to say al-Tahrir is for raqas. 86:00 Ibn al-Humam says it's only the decisive that is considered fiqh, because we don't know if the other positions are correct or incorrect, so we will not consider them to be fiqh. But we said that this is sharia. Sharia is what is clearly, you know, the intended by Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala, but fiqh includes the correct and incorrect. So he's answering to them and he says, even the distinction between decisive and definitive, 86:30 is not agreed upon. So if you say that it is only the speculative, the decisive and the speculative, distinction is not agreed upon. So if you say that fiqh pertains only to the speculative, people will disagree whether this is speculative or not. If you say that fiqh is only limited to the decisive, people will still disagree whether this is decisive or not. So fiqh includes all of the above. 86:58 Rather, some scholars may have numerous proofs that make them believe that a particular ruling is decisive, while others do not have such proofs. This is the case among the scholars, and hence others will find more controversy on such issues. So basically, faqih includes all of the above. Decisive, speculative, and the area in the middle. Yes? What formula do you use, Calder, for the majority? 87:37 Oh, so how do you choose between the rulings? Now, how do you choose between the rulings? There is a difference between... The scholars have to always base their choice on the detailed evidences of the Quran and the Sunnah. They must base their choices on the detailed evidences of the Quran and the Sunnah. The non-scholars, they have the taqlid. 88:09 but then their taqlid will be to find the person that is most trustworthy and knowledgeable in their assessment and do taqlid. Now is there something between the scholars and the public, something in the middle between the scholars and the public, or those public that do taqlid? 88:37 Will they be ever asked to look into the evidence at any point? Yes, when you go to a physician to tell you you need surgery to get your appendix out, and you go to another physician and he tells you you do not need surgery to get your appendix out, will you just base your decision, 89:14 on the reputation of the two physicians, or will you be talking to those two physicians and asking them questions? And why do you think I don't need to get my appendix out? Why do you think I need to get my appendix out? You will be asking them questions. The same applies here to this case. Yes, you will be a follower at the end of the day. 89:44 Because you may not, you know, that physician will talk to you and the other physician will talk to you. You may not be able to comprehend the evidence completely of both physicians. But you will still ask, because that is part of doing your best to arrive at a conclusion that you feel is in your interest or your welfare. And you should do the same for your religion as well. After choosing the scholars that are trustworthy and knowledgeable, 90:14 you win way the evidence of both sides because that is how you as much as you can unless it is a matter that is completely beyond your comprehension and there are such matters that are completely beyond the comprehension of the lay person and that is relative because you know the scholar and the lay person there it is not like scholar lay person and that's it 90:44 it is a continuum because the lay person learns and becomes a little bit more learned learns more learns more learns more you get to be in a scholar it's not overnight it's not like something would descend on you from the heavens and now you're suddenly a scholar it's a cumulative process cumulative process so you can't say that here you've become a scholar and then it is all different now but 91:14 So it is relative. And that lay person is not one thing. It could be anything from completely ignorant of everything, you know, to someone who is a step away from being a scholar. So in this case, they will exert the utmost effort by choosing these scholars that they listen to. 91:45 but also by weighing the evidences presented to them. Next time, inshallah, we will start with the comparison between Sharia and Al-Faqih.