Transkrip otomatis. Mungkin ada kesalahan, jadi periksa rekamannya untuk kata-kata yang tepat.
0:57 because to the most primitive of modern society there's always human culture the denial of god's existence is something which has always been a few in the 20th century that idea of god etc is that to this idea proposed the idea that this was in fact of the anthropologist because accepted explanation 3:42 God, they are already accepting the Darwinian explanation of existence, which really is a couple of years ago, people who had problems with their brains, epilepsy, schizophrenia, these kinds of mental problems, which man malfunctions in the brain. In doing experiments with such people, which involve boring holes and sticking probes into their brain, the human brain. 4:35 to find out what would happen if we touch this part, or what would happen if we touch that part, that perhaps they may touch a part that would rectify the problems that these people were facing. And they found, in the course of their experiments, that there was a particular part in the brain that every time they probed it, the person who was being treated, in the presence of God, this kind of thing would come out of these treatments with these feelings. As a result, 5:20 There was, they did an article in Scientific American, and it was published in international newspapers, that the scientists had found what they believed, the God spot in the crossfire, that is something so basic in existence, that belief, especially when we consider that though the majority of people believe in God, one finds a variety of different understandings. 6:27 of God. We have a variety of different religions, these different understandings. The concept of God, the concept of their being, wants to have God as part of the attributes. That was primordial, and that in time degenerated, and we understand that some aspect of God's creation is given the attributes of God, so God may be worshipped as part of nature, which 7:57 defies but yet the cornerstone of the faith of the vast majority it is the belief that god hinduism and christianity and the offshoot of hinduism deserves to be questioned deserves to be reflected upon because what we find is that in islam the concept leaves the idea that he became a man in the time of the past which to one category 9:28 and loves all those that there is of him, as they self refer to us, then that self is at the same time with a thousand heads and a thousand eyes. To Brahman came the segment of the soul, came the righteous, the shouldn't. How society then was organized, coming from the belief that God has then sacrificed himself to himself. 12:44 human beings as a boar as a man he comes back reborn and he dies in the process of being reborn and dying if he started from the shudras then he is good and eventually reaches to the brahmin level where after he goes through the process known as moksha or nirvana in which he now reunites back with brahman this idea that for them in this life 15:03 is to realize that they are, in fact, to the high rate of suicide among children. People sometimes wonder, why can't they kill themselves so regularly? You read so many articles in the newspapers, because whenever people have a problem, you know, so many people are hanging themselves, killing themselves, and swear another way. When India lost a cricket game two years back to Syria like that, people went out and killed themselves. Well... 15:47 the concept of course that you're coming back again it means then if this life is not comfortable you don't like it it's uncomfortable then you can always do away with it and come back again now why hindus hold the idea because if the person is on the ladder 16:44 because maybe you're eating your grandfather or something like this. So this thing of vegetarianism became infused with society. I mean, philosophically, of course, people may be trying to promote it today as being healthy, you know, it's better, human beings really weren't meant to eat animals, et cetera, et cetera. But the essence of what is behind it is their belief that human beings can come back and be the same animals that they used to be. 17:14 This is the essence of it. And for Muslims, of course, it's rejected. The idea of coming back is rejected. And God gave you an ability to utilize flesh to digest it. He gave teeth that could break it down, an enzyme that could break it down in the stomach and the body which could absorb it. So if it wasn't really for us to eat, then why would we eat? As we said, this belief that God 18:15 And other individuals refer to also, you know, God in presence of human beings, the most famous of whom is Sai Baba. Sai Baba in India, who is worshipped by millions, including some of the leading figures in India, who worship this individual, Sai Baba, as God. This is the Hindu world. If we look at it, we find God, at least ten major times, 19:23 one time. Development of Christianity. It is something. He is the main architect. It is put in the gospel. Specifically in the gospel of John. It is stated in the beginning of it. The beginning was the word and the word was God. It was God. From the day of the word became flesh and dwelt among us. Full of grace and truth. These things are not made by Jesus. And this gospel was not written. 20:59 by somebody anonymous. If we go back to the early days of Christianity, it becomes evident that there are many biblical scholars available on the market which are worth looking into for those who come from Christian backgrounds. One is called James, the Death of a Legend by John Peter. Another is called James, the Brother of Jesus. 22:27 The third is called Brother of Jesus by Pierre-Antoine Bernheim. Well over 400 pages of research, academic research into James. They all confirm from the early records that James was the head. In fact, the author says in the book of Genesis, which describes James with regards to early writings, there is far more wisdom. 23:30 about for the first time of Jesus followers referred to commonly as Jewish significantly different from today thought that you wanted to Matthew and rejected Paul as an apostate from the Jewish law that it was not that which was held referred to as promoted by Paul Paul 26:59 absorb an argument to promote the idea that jesus god referred to also found in that gospel of john and it is well known this term is an ancient philosophical concept which evolved in its understanding till the early is the beginnings of time after jesus in which philo the jewish philosopher of alexandria 27:45 church in lovis that it was between god and the cosmos to comprehend god in his writing was the first begotten son when he expressed before it became a part of the later gospels and the writings of that the concept of god being however it became a part as a result of the efforts of paul and others christianity 28:50 went through Greece and into Rome, those teachings became paganized to greater extent. The day of worship was changed. The Sabbath, the Sunday, the day for the worship of the sun god of hollow in Rome, shifted the concept, this pagan concept that God became. Now, Muslims believe in some segments of Muslim society that the human was accepted in certain circles. 29:51 to be known as the mystic circles, the circles of mysticism. This idea that God, that the human was in fact of the divine soul, this idea, when it spread, it became the basis of the concept that human beings, as God has become a part of human beings, came and was developed in Christianity. But it's a counterpart, similar to, it has links with true Islamic concepts with regards to the human soul, is that the human soul is created. 30:57 a part yes blew into in the context where god refers to being his and we find god referred as being to be god so god uses this being his spirit or part of his spirit not meaning literally that it is a piece and a portion of god but that this spirit with the noble spirit is given a special sacrifice god refers to his house or god 32:09 In the case of the camel, which was sent to Prophet Salim as a miracle, is that the human soul is not divine, does not possess a soul. God created it by His command on the soul. The soul to save is from my God, my Lord's command. Allah said that whenever He wishes something to be, He merely commands it be part and parcel of God's command. 33:12 creation now could benefit from that he developed that god created himself that he creates from different parts of god misunderstanding of god received of god's creation human beings when they create they meditate they create from that which already exists we make this it's made from a tree cut down chairs buildings we all make 34:25 they exist. So what they did was, so if God, and there was nothing else beside him, when he created, he created from. If there was nothing else to create from, he must have created from himself. So this is where it ended up with this, of God creating from himself, creation, and God becoming. On the other hand, why they came to the concept that God created, God became man, explanation. 35:34 that when Adam disobeyed God, that the sin which was not forgiven by God, but was inherited generation after generation after generation. Jesus had become so great that there was nothing human beings could do to remove the sin from themselves. It required that God now himself becoming a human being and life sacrificing himself to himself. Sacrificing himself. 36:25 self to himself. Very similar to the Hindu concept. They also add that God became to understand what it is like to be a man. The sufferings of men, the desires of men. They also explain that God became a man to know that God is like human beings. Somebody else unless you are human qualities knows. Doesn't have to be. But they are projecting this concept. 37:38 of God onto God. The situation amongst the major faiths of Christianity is that God becomes man. Muslims hold that this is become a man. He never became a man. Normally he doesn't. One time, twice he's done. Many times so far. When one looks at the... Because God, to then ask, can God die? Because it was already said that God has no end. 40:29 That is one of the attributes of God, not having an end. To ask then, can God die? Because if God dies, we already said, God is what can readily grasp. Christian philosophers. Can God create? Because Christians said, okay, if your God can do anything, can he make his soul merely for him to live? This became a problem. Because if their concept, God can do anything, means there's nothing greater than he, Allah. Then that means, 42:29 That for him to create something. So what we say is that he does not make God no longer God. Because God is God. So not included in God being able to do all. Are the things which would make God no longer God. A God that dies. A God that is born. A God that creates things greater than himself. Of God becoming a man is also an absurdity. Included in that saying. 43:32 catapult. Because is creation. God is the creator. Then he becomes in. So it is a contradiction in terms. The creator cannot become his creation. Just as the creation cannot become, then God became man. It's an absurdity. The concept, the fundamental concept of God being the on, the true by 44:44 Accepting of a slave of Islam. I mean as I say This is it. There may be how many other things around It's not that God is one in this sense, but that God as he said lay second in shape The one thing single unitary things of this world which are divisible into parts Like the Christian how God is three in one it will say well, you know, they all of that 47:23 If you are holding a confused concept yourself that the human soul is divine. 48:31 and that human beings sometimes can become gods, that you would clear up this nonsense for yourself. It has been said, if you believe that your soul is divine, and you go to hell, that a part of God is punished in hell, even logic tells you, hey, this kind of belief is God's prophet. There's something wrong here. Who follow the best will benefit from what they give. But in this, we ask Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala to reward their time. 50:15 We thank the main club management for their assistance. We thank the main sponsor, official and volunteer question and answer session for 30 minutes. We will have a class. Each question will be for two minutes maximum. We will take one written question and one oral question. As they appear, they will be taken. 51:14 I have a question regarding, or a comment. In about four to six weeks from now, the Christian work will celebrate the Christmas time. A lot of Muslims, they share. 52:24 this kind of rituals of the christmas and still they think that we have still the good thought and we don't believe that god is a man it would be very nice if you would make any comment on this kind of point since muslims in a growing number in different parts of the islamic world are celebrating this kind of festivity 53:04 focused on ones which were more directly into a topic, especially if we had, you know, from our non-Muslim guests who are here in the audience, we'd like to hear from them, give them priority, give them the opportunity to raise any questions that they would like to make. There's a tendency in our gathering that Muslims tend to dominate the questions, and our guests hardly get an opportunity to raise any questions at all. 53:38 Muslim, the audience would like to raise a question. Then I'd like to give priority to our guests and the guests. Do we have any who would like to raise a question? Okay. There are questions more directly related to the topic. More directly related to the topic. First question is, because Allah, as we always do, we know that Allah, His name, not one of them is God, and can we translate His name? We know that Christians, they translate it. 54:34 Okay, okay, this is an issue which pops up from time to time, which I find is really a very, you know, semantic, here's the thing, you know, because Allah refers to himself as ila humu. What does ila mean? 55:13 your god what is his name which means capital g which means the god it's not the problem it should in fact some people have even gone to the extreme of claiming that allah's name is the name which was if we consider that the prophets came to you know all nations and tribes 55:56 وَلَقَدْ بَعْدًا لِكُلِّ أُمَّةٍ رَسُولًا And he said to every nation and tribe, a messenger, they're calling the people to worship Allah and avoid Allah. And then Allah said, the only sent messenger is speaking the language of the people, and then they're going to be using languages other than the language that the people know, not tentacles. The point is that, whether we call Allah in the sense of 56:27 The title of God, instead of the name of God, the title of God, you know, in English, God, or in Spanish, or in Korean, or, you know, whatever, this is not an issue. As long as we're the creator of the universe, you know, who is not a part and parcel of His creation, etc., etc., as long as that is our understanding, then to use other terms should not be a problem for us. 56:59 given to God in Arabic, Allah, you need this, but Allah for himself, al-ilah, la-hukum. Do you have dhalil, the touch with the Sufis or people? Well, you have. Other than this? Yes. I mean, this topic, actually, I have explained it at length in a book which I wrote called The Fundamentals of Tawheed, which is available in the Indian Center. And it's a topic of a lecture in itself. 57:54 to try to to deal with it completely but it is enough to say that when allah refers to things he refers to some things as literally from himself his mercy his love but when he was he also his aspect of his creation is also being here so we know that we talk about my hands for example we talk about my book but it's my book the same as my hands so we use the same 58:34 terminology. My hand is a part of me, my body is not. It's something which I possess. So, when we look at that in the context, you know, of the explanation given by Prophet ﷺ about the angel coming and blowing the spirit into the child, you know, when it reaches a certain stage of development, you know, we can understand that though the spirit is using as him doing it, as he refers to him doing things which human 59:09 in other contexts. You know, as he said, وَمَا رَمَيْتَ إِذْ رَمَيْتَ وَلَكِنَّ اللَّهَ رَمَىٰ When Prophet ﷺ threw dust at his enemies and it reached all the way across the valley to reach their faces, you know, many, many hundreds of yards away. That throwing that the Prophet ﷺ did, Allah refers to it as his throwing. So, you know, together, this is where we end up. 59:44 There is often a fluctuation between the first news by the Holy Quran. Sometimes God speaks to mankind as we, but then he turns to the third person as your God. Could you explain this? First let me say, before explaining this, the term the Holy Quran is improper. Improper. Christian culture, Western culture, we have ended up now saying the Holy Quran. 60:33 Do we find this in the statement of the Prophet Muhammad in the Quran, of the Sahaba, etc.? No. It is in concept. There is the Quran al-Azim, the deficient Quran, al-Quran al-Kareem, the noble Quran. We have all of that. But the Holy Quran, so it is something which Muslims have innovated, which we need to correct as soon as possible. I mean, it's not a major. It doesn't mean the person becomes a mushrik, you know. 61:10 worshiping other than god because he doesn't but we should know that it is incorrect terminology you know when we use certain terminology like issues of god and not another area but the area of holy we don't have any precedence for that but the brother asked for the evidence i said okay and he refers to us but for holy quran holy prophet we have no evidence we should refrain from doing that now which we find 61:45 Whereas Allah is a singular term and a plural. This is an aspect of Arabic that the use of the plural is commonly referred to as the majestic, we. It exists even in English. When she announces to her subject that she is going to travel to America, or where she says we, it's known. It's honored, etc. This is common in Arabic. We greet each other, As-salamu alaykum. 62:37 But it's only one. Technically speaking, we say Salaam alaika if you're a masculine. Or Salaam alaiki if you're a feminine. But we say Salaam alaikum. So the plural exists not only in Arabic, it exists in the Semitic languages. This is why you'll also find in the Bible, you know, God referring to himself. What is authentic, they will listen to authentic of it. We don't use plural. Further questions? 63:13 Okay, I brought this question for those of you who couldn't make it out because it's a bit garbled. Is there anything from Jewish beliefs that indicate they hold that God became a man? Well, 64:00 Which has to do with Prophet Jacob. That he wrestles, he describes the process of wrestling, etc. It implies that God, that Jacob is actually wrestling with God. They say the name Israel means the one. So there are implications there. Though the Jews don't make it a belief system, they don't make it a basic part of the belief system, they do. 64:46 that's within the text of their scripture. Furthermore, you can also find many references where God is portrayed in human terms. For example, when Adam ate from the tree, Adam was eating from the tree, they realized they'd done wrong, and they went and they hid. It's described in Genesis that Adam could hear God's footsteps in the garden. And God called on Adam to rise. 65:24 This portraying God is kind of, you know, human kind of term. Unable to know walking in the garden, you can hear footsteps. God is also described as feeling sorry about what he thought to do to the Jews. You know, repenting. Terminologies are used with regard to God in the Old Testament. Specifically the area which is referred to in the Torah. You can find a number of references by God. 65:55 In the Talmud, which is the Tafsir, the Jewish Tafsir of the Torah, they have many references where they speak about God, you know, having conferences with the rabbis. You know, before he does something on the earth, he has a conference with the rabbis, gets their permission, and then he goes ahead and does certain things. Again, the Lord God can almost be the personal servant of the Jewish people. When they need something, he's there. He's their personal God, the Lord God of Israel. 66:27 He became like a personalized God of death. Like somebody has a genie, you know, you rub the lamp and the genie pops up. You have three wishes, you tell him to do this. That's, you know, that's the sort of God to them. You know, and that God is committed to them to do whatever they need, whatever Israel needs, etc., etc. Here is the question. I want to know the answer regarding the question in your lecture. Had God made the stone which he cannot carry? No. He said, 67:01 that contradicts God being God. That is a ludicrous question, which we don't really entertain, because the concept involves canceling or negating the divinity of God, the quality of being God. Could the Muslim women begin Islamic greetings to a man that is not from her maharib? Meaning, can a Muslim woman say salam alaykum to any man? 67:33 Yes, Islam is a possibility. Muslim culture is a possibility. But of course, if it is done, it should be done in a business-like fashion. Because it's something very native, people have to be very conscious of. Because if there's somebody that they like, then they will say, Salaam Alaikum. Let me say this, somebody says, you know, that they don't believe in Salaam Alaikum. Hey, this is the one that you have. 68:04 If you're going to say it's not related, let's continue with the one which isn't God, you know, the softness of the voice, which obviously, the point is that it should be in his life. Okay, we'll take this as the last question. Yeah, okay, I think I'm better. I'll let this soft question, I'm sure people have gone off our topics some more. You got a question which is right on the topic? 68:46 The concept of intercession, it's a big topic. The book which I did, again, The Fundamentals of Tawheed, has a whole section dealing with it. It's worth reading, so if you want to go into more detail. But we have to look at what is the essence, what is the idea behind that he calls on being done. You must... 70:28 kind of intermediary. You want to see the president of the country. You can't just go to his office, knock on his door and say, hey, let's have a conversation. You have to find somebody who knows somebody who knows somebody who knows somebody. And in this way your requests or your desires can be fulfilled. So people will present this as a rationale for saying why you need to go through somebody. Because you 71:05 etc. Now you want to get to God, you need to get this through somebody who's close. Awali, he was close to God. Therefore, if you want to get to God, the best thing is to use his position relative to God to get your prayer in hand. But Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam, he told his own daughter, whatever you can do yourself, because it was not good for you. Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam was not able to help those who raised him. So, it is delusional. 71:57 And our parts think that we can call on others. Utilize Allah. He's not like the kings and the presidents and the directors and the managers of this world. Allah says, call on me. They call on somebody close. He says, call on me. Well, my question is about the creation of Adam. I would kind of like to clarify exactly, you know, what is the understanding for us as human beings, Muslims? 73:19 Because for me, it seems as if it's giving me an idea, you know, a visual idea of how the angels pass by you. You create something. How it coincides with what the Quran is saying. It kind of leaves you with a look like Christians. Is there a touch? Well, it's given to us. There are stories, you know, many of which are not authentic. They're describing the process, but really, we don't have anything authentic clarifying the details. As it's mentioned, 74:22 is that Adam was created from Earth, from all over the planet. And this was informing us that the variety which exists amongst us today existed with Adam at the time of creation. The clarification was, where did all these people come from? It came from Adam. He had these qualities in himself. It was in his genes. All of us, all of us, that's what existed with him. But the concept of 74:56 God's creation of Adam, and in which we think of God actually as a human being with mold and an image of it, clay or whatever. It's not that process that Allah going to describe the making of Adam. Again, you know, with the agency of the angels, etc. He refers to it as being His making. You know, as the blowing of Him blowing, the making is His making. As I said, we don't need to get into it. Allah didn't say, 75:35 the details for us, because it is really not relevant. It really is of no relevance. We know Allah is nothing like him. He said he created Adam this way, that way, whatever. We just go with that. We just, we don't get it to the anthropomorphic types of understandings, you know, when we start to conceive of God, you know, in terms. A different question or? Okay, follow it up. Yeah, this is a part of the story. But this is not the... No, you see, before, the first thing you need to do... 76:30 The point is that whenever we get into these kind of areas, it's very important that we ensure that the information that we have is authentic. That's the beginning point. 77:05 Right? Then after we've confirmed it's authenticity, then we have to look at it in the light of whatever else we know about Islam. Because every time you take a text, either a statement of the Prophet ﷺ or a statement from the Qur'an, and you take it out of the context of the whole Sunnah and of the whole Qur'an, then you can change meaning. You can create understandings which are contrary to the understanding that was intended. 77:43 Holy Quran is incorrect so explain me to me how God can be correct chances of wording God's plural God is female we're allowed to go for chances well again it's not I touched that try to leave it you know the point here as I said has no basis in the Quran or Sunnah of the Prophet or his companions it has no basis whereas 78:25 in the Quran and in the Sunnah. The term God is used. It may not be God, English God, but it is God, Arabic God. Ila. These terms. So it has a name. It has a base. It is legitimate to use. And just as Ila is a feminine version, Ilaha, goddess, God, goddesses, in Arabic also. Yet God uses the term Ila to himself. 79:14 These are our last two questions. And the question of the brother concerning Christmas. We'll try to deal with these in the last chapter. This is the statement of our chairman here. This is the work of Satan. This is the work. Christians, the true followers of Jesus, they did not corrupt Jesus. They continued those teachings, as I mentioned. 79:54 James was referred to as the brother of Jesus. What the brother of Jesus here means, even Christian scholars are not certain. Some say it means cousin. Some say it's in reference to closest to him. There are a variety of definitions they've given for it. And for our purposes, we don't need to get into it. We're not going to argue that he was not actually the brother of Jesus. That term is referred to by that term. 80:24 He was a big figure in early Christianity. A figure who had been deleted from modern Christianity. The vast majority of Christians, if you ask them, do they know about James, the brother of Jesus? What? Jesus had a brother? Yeah. Well, hey, you know, you go to Acts, verse 10, you go to... There are mentions, there are mentions in the Gospels. People read it, they don't even... It doesn't catch their mind. Let us find out. So... 80:54 He has been written out of modern Christianity, but he exists as a prominent figure, the leader of Christianity, the first three decades after the time of Jesus. So the corrupt understanding was not taught by early Christians, but by Paul, a convert, a supposed convert from Judaism, who promoted the paganization. 81:28 of Jesus, the concept of Jesus, the concept of God, having a son, becoming a man, etc. And the Greek and Roman Christians, they put backing behind it, and it eventually became, by the 4th century, the dominant belief amongst Christians. First of all, when did this corruption begin? How did this process of corruption proceed? In my book called True Message of Jesus Christ, 82:03 I do outline in there the stages by which the Trinitarian concept, the concept of Jesus with God, took a hold. I also identified there the monotheists, those who held and stuck firmly to the monotheistic belief, how they continued to hold it for a number of centuries. You know, the fourth century, when the decision was made to come from Nicaea. 82:34 confirmed that Jesus was God, three gods in one, etc. The bishop or the presbyter of Alexandria area, he was the one who, one of the dissenters, who refused to sign the document. And as a result, he was excommunicated, branded as heretic, and his followers were hunted down. And, you know, what happened, etc., after that, I'll explain there. Also, there's a book called Jesus, the Prophet of Islam, in which... 83:03 Ataw Rashman, he traces the evolution of monotheism amongst Christians, you know, from the past until present day. What do you think the roots of the Islamic world as a whole? You can see very obviously in the States, in some countries being oppressed with regards to Islam, and in some countries being silenced. Well, let's not really get into our topic. This concept will be dealt with in the lecture which I... 83:46 to do tomorrow evening on the clash of civilizations. My brother asked the very first question. I know he was tempted to try to catch some of the people before they left. Sorry about that. Some of those who may have this idea that there's nothing wrong in taking part in Christmas celebrations, you know, either directly or indirectly. We don't necessarily believe what they believe. We're being cordial. You know, as they wish us Happy Eid, we say to them, 84:23 Christmas, you know, what's the harm? You don't believe, they don't believe, you're just being cordial. Well, the point is that it is not permitted for a Muslim to greet a Christian happily. The greeting marriage is taking part in the celebration. The idea was to express it even in cordiality, you know, trying to be friendly or whatever. If there are wishes, 85:15 Whatever there is, then it is the duty of wisdom to clarify Jesus, even the date of Jesus' birth. This was something developed many, many years after the time of Jesus. The early 300 years after Jesus' time, they never celebrated anybody's birthday. Because it was known that birthdays were taken. It was not the Jewish tradition to celebrate birthdays at all. So early Christians from the 15th, 18th century really struggled amongst each other. Some were opposed to the celebration of Christmas. 86:14 The early Puritans, you know, went to America. They were opposed to it. They didn't celebrate Christmas in America for hundreds of years. It's not until the Germans became, the Lutheran Germans, the Germans were able to celebrate Christmas. They brought it later, and it became popular, and they started celebrating it. But the early Christians that went to America did not celebrate Christmas. It was considered heretical. So, it's not acceptable. But if we go to explain to a Christian, 86:49 What's the harm? We have to explain to them, either fitr or even adha, not sharing. Prophet Abraham prepared them. When you say happy, the idea that after fasting, giving, sharing food, do you not believe in the concept of fasting? Didn't Moses and Jesus both fast for 40 days at night? So thanks for not believing, you're sharing. Where are you? My friend, do what is said to do. 88:09 How many saints have you dated that God will warn on the 25th of December? It's an idea of misguidedness. It is satanic. This is not God. God never revealed it. It is Satan who taught it. At this point, that's it for you. For more, pray with me. This is the lecture tomorrow. If you can come.