Transkrip otomatis. Mungkin ada kesalahan, jadi periksa rekamannya untuk kata-kata yang tepat.
0:03 And he's also a lecturer at the American University of Dubai. Quite a remarkable personality given this history, and we're very fortunate and pleased to have in our midst today this very man sitting on my left, our Sheikh Abu Aminah Bilal Phillips. He's the author of many books on Islam. In fact, today he's one of the most prolific writers of the English language on Islamic books. 0:30 Many of his books are available outside in the hall for sale. During the break, when the books are available for sale, I would encourage you to go around and look at some of these books, and perhaps some of these will catch your interest. He has authored, for example, The Evolution of Six, which previously was published under a different title, The Evolution of the Mouthpads, a book explaining what are the four schools of thought, do we have to follow them, should we, should we not, to what degree, and so on. 0:58 He has authored a number of other interesting books, a lot of books dealing with my own subject area, dealing with the Da'wah to non-Muslims, for example, a book which I've benefited from tremendously, a book entitled Salvation Through Repentance. Another little book like What is the True Religion of God? And so on and so forth. He's done a chapter of Surah Al-Hujurat, which many of you will find to be a very interesting study on that Surah. So without further delay, I'd like to now call upon our Sheikh to speak to us. 1:26 on the obligation of da'wah. Where does it say that we have to do da'wah? Who told us to do da'wah? Should we not do da'wah? Do we have to do it or is it just optional if we want to do it? What exactly is this da'wah and what is the obligation? Where does that obligation come from? Where is it stated? Our Shaykh is going to tell us that. 1:57 Verily all praise is due to Allah, and as such we should praise Him and seek His help, and seek His forgiveness, and seek refuge in Him from the evil which is within ourselves and the evil which results from our deeds. 2:25 For whomsoever Allah has guided, none can misguide, and whomsoever Allah has allowed to go astray, none can guide. And I bear witness that there is no God worthy of worship but Allah, and that Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam is the last messenger of Allah. As brother introduced, the topic is fundamentally the obligation of da'wah. And we'll be looking at it from two aspects. First and foremost, the general obligation. 2:55 derived from the Quran and the Sunnah the principle that da'wah is obligatory on each and every Muslim. It is a part and parcel of the commanding the good and amr bil ma'ruf wa nahi an al munkar and prohibiting the evil about which Allah has described the ummah, described it as being of its distinguishing characteristics. 3:28 We have from the Quran a direct command in which Allah says, That is, call to the way of your Lord with wisdom as understood from the Quran and with good speech. This is found in Surah An-Nahan verse 125. And though this is a general command and some may conclude from it that 3:58 This is for the specialists, the people who are specially trained. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ also made a statement which is authentically reported, بَلِّغُوا عَنِّي إِلَىٰ آيَةٍ Convey from me whatever you have learned, even though it be only a verse from the Quran. This is what brings it right down to the individual level. That whatever knowledge we have, we have an obligation to share it. 4:29 We have also other descriptions wherein Prophet Muhammad, for example, said, خَيْرُكُمْ مَنْ تَعَلَّمَ الْقُرْآنِ وَعَلَّمَهُ The best of you is he who learns the Quran and teaches it to others. He didn't stop at saying the best of you is he who learns the Quran. But teaching it to others is an integral part of that learning. For it to be blessed by Allah, the obligation of sharing that knowledge, passing on that knowledge. 4:59 has to also be there. And this is absolutely necessary because of the fact that Allah through His Prophet has made the seeking of knowledge compulsory. As you all know, Prophet Muhammad has said, Seeking knowledge is compulsory for every Muslim. Were it not also compulsory for those who had knowledge to pass that knowledge on, then that command would not have made sense because it would have been putting a burden on Muslims. 5:28 which they could not fulfill. So the two have to work together. And this is why when Prophet Muhammad described this world as being cursed, he said, الدُّنْيَا مَلْعُونَ The whole of this world is cursed. مَلْعُونٌ مَا فِيهَا Everything inside of it is cursed. إِلَّا ذِكْرُ اللَّهِ Except the remembrance of Allah وَمَا وَلَا And what encourages you and helps you to remember Allah. وَعَالِمًا وَمُتَعَلِّمًا 5:58 And the scholar, the one who is knowledgeable, and the student. That relationship, the scholar and the student, the teacher and the student. Passing on the knowledge, gaining the knowledge. This is showing the significance of seeking knowledge and passing it on in Islam. And this is, of course, directly related to the da'wah. Because what are the knowledge? When Allah SWT, through His Prophet, 6:27 had made seeking knowledge compulsive for us, what other knowledge than the knowledge of Allah and what Allah requires of us in our daily life is more important. This knowledge should be given priority over all other knowledge. So, it is compulsive for us to gain this knowledge and it is compulsive for us also to pass on this knowledge for those who don't know. But in order to further stress the critical nature of passing on the knowledge, 6:55 Because though we may be encouraged and told that people may still have reluctance, etc. Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala on the other side has put a curse on those people who don't pass on the knowledge. I mean to show, to stress to us how serious this obligation of passing on knowledge is. He cursed those who do not pass on the knowledge. Those who hide the knowledge. 7:22 In Surah Al-Baqarah, verse 140, we find Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala saying, or sorry, in verse 159, it's also in verse 40, I should say that first. وَمَنْ أَظْلَمُ مِمَّنْ كَتَمَ شَهَابَةٍ عِنْدَهُ مِنَ اللَّهِ Who is worse, who is worse in the sense of being more oppressive than the one who hides a witness which is with him from Allah. The witness is Islam, recognizing that commitment to Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala. 7:53 you know, and the knowledge that comes along with it. Allah says, there is none worse, none more oppressive than such an individual. Furthermore, the actual curse is mentioned in verse 159 of the same Quran, Surah Al-Baqarah, in which Allah says there, إِنَّ الَّذِينَ يَكْسُمُونَ مَا أَنزَلْنَا مِنَ الْبَيِّنَاتِ وَالْهُدَىٰ مِنْ بَعْدِ مَا بَيَّنَّاهُ لِلنَّاسِ فِي الْكِتَابِ أُولَٰئِكَ يَلْعَنُهُمُ اللَّهُ وَيَلْعَنُهُمُ الْمَاعِنُونَ Verily those who hide what we have revealed, 8:21 of the clear messages and the guidance, after it has been made clear to the people in the scripture, such are cursed by Allah and cursed by all who are cursed. For Allah to put the curse on someone for not passing on that knowledge is indicating that it must be obligatory. Furthermore, we have Prophet Muhammad saying in a narration found in the authentic Jamiat Saghir, 8:53 Reported by Abu Dawood and Nasai Ibn Majah. Whoever hides knowledge will be branded by Allah with a branding iron from the hellfire. We know, as a general principle in Islam, if the hellfire is associated with any action, it means this action must be haram. So, we have both sides of the picture. One, it is haram for us to hide the knowledge. 9:26 And the other, that it is obligatory for us to pass on that knowledge. Now the hiding may be, of course some people may say, I'm not preventing people from getting the knowledge. Because of course if somebody came to you and said to you, what is Islam? If you refuse to tell them for one reason or another, then this is obviously and directly hiding that knowledge. But the other way is for you to passively hide that knowledge. Where you go to work, you know, five days a week, 9:55 Here's the 65 days of the year. You have a person sitting next to you in your work. You have to deal with this person every day, and you never say a word about this person. Your neighbor, who has lived beside you for 10, 15, 20, 25 years, you say hi to him when you're going out, you know, when you come in contact with him, but you don't give him anything beyond that. This is passively hiding their knowledge. And on the day of judgment, 10:30 Such individuals, those who worked with you, those who studied with you in school, those who are your neighbors, etc., if they end up going to hell, they will be blaming us. They will be pointing the finger at us, saying that such and such lived next to us all those years, never said a word to us. Went to school with us all those years, never said a word to us. Worked with us all those years and never said a word to us. So, that obligation is something that we should not take lightly. 11:01 We should feel bad whenever we are with non-Muslims and we don't share that knowledge, of course. The reality is that certain circumstances may not be conducive. It is for us to try to find those circumstances. We should feel an urgency, a need within ourselves to share it. Try to find some route to get that information across to them. And in terms of the dawah, of course, 11:32 Some of us may say, well, you know, they are Christians or they're atheists or whatever, you know, and maybe my language, I can't really explain too well to them, you know, I'm a new person in this country, whatever, you know, I don't speak English too well, I'm not that educated. So the point is that we have to give them whatever we have. Whatever little you can say, you say. You find pamphlets which are being printed at the different Taoist centers, to get that passage on, you know, tape, booklet. 12:04 Whatever means that you have at your disposal, we should try to convey it. But of course, the most effective, one of the most effective means is by living Islam yourself. By being an example. By being distinguishable in the society. Meaning that if one lives here, and one has accepted all of the outer trappings of the society, 12:35 where one becomes indistinguishable from the non-Muslims, then it's very difficult to give da'wah. If you're doing the same as they're doing, you're living just like one of them. Really, what's the difference? You know, as Prophet Muhammad said, whoever imitates the way of a people, becomes like them, he's of them. So, Prophet Muhammad, in so many different circumstances, stressed that we should, in our outward dress, 13:04 For example, distinguish ourselves from the disbelievers. It was the custom of Arabians, people of Arabia, to wear a turban. Everybody wore it. The Kafirs, the disbelievers, and the believers. So Prophet Muhammad said, wear a turban to distinguish yourself from the pagans. Similarly, we have principles of Islamic dress which we should conform to in order that we become distinguishable in the society. 13:36 And this distinction oftentimes serves as a means of introducing Islam to the non-Muslims. They will ask, why are you wearing this? Why do you look like this? And it becomes a means to introduce the subject to them. But of course, the outer aspect, as it is important, the inner aspect is even more important. That we, as individuals, exemplify Islamic 14:08 character. Because Prophet Muhammad ﷺ summarized the essence of the Deen in terms of Islamic character. When he said, إِنَّمَا بُعِثْتُ لِي وَتَنِّمَ مَكَارِمَ الْأَخْلَاقِ He has summarized the essence of the Deen in good character. Verily I was only sent to complete for you the highest of character traits. Morality. Morality as described and identified by 14:40 Allah in the Quran and by Prophet . So, the character of the believer becomes a means of dawah in and of itself. And we know much of Islam was spread to the greater parts of the world through the character of Muslims who went to these different countries as traders, etc. etc. In the initial stages, as Islam left Arabia, 15:10 There was direct military struggle, confrontation with the leading empires of the day, Byzantium, Persia, India. So there was direct struggle because the doors for conveying Islam into these areas were closed. The people were oppressed and the rulers did not want the message to get to these people because Islam represented freedom and the toppling of these empires. So direct struggle was the only means by which to open the door. 15:39 for dawah to continue. Where that becomes necessary, then jihad is applied. But where the doors are open, people were able to go and just trade as traders, then it was necessary. So Muslims went out into Asia and to many parts of Africa just as traders, carrying their goods, selling their goods, etc. But the impression which they left on the people to whom they sold their goods was such that it caused those people to want to know what it is. 16:08 that made these people this way. Because you know Prophet Muhammad had addressed the traders there and said that traders are criminals. Traders are criminals. Why? Because this is the nature. The nature of people when you're selling products to want to deceive people. You make your product out to be what it isn't. You blow it up. 16:41 Because you're trying to sell, you want to get this across. If there are defects in it, you try to hide it. And this is the nature of trade, right? Whereas Islam is opposed to this. All of the principles of trade forbid deception. So if you have goods and they're damaged, it's your duty to tell your customer, there is damage in it. You know, it's not so good. Perhaps you can get a better product, a healthier product. I'm selling it cheap. Why? Because it's damaging. 17:08 Not because I, you know, I got this special deal. No. It's damage. That's why I'm selling it cheap. Okay? So, by having this kind of approach where the traders dealt with these people in a way they had not come in contact with traders dealing that way. This left an impression on them. Left an impression on them. So, it's very important for us, as I said, we utilize all of the different channels of da'wah. Whether it be the media. Media means through literature. 17:40 taste, etc. But most important, that our character reflects that message. Now, in the approach to dawah, of course, people may come with many different questions from many different directions. They may want to know why Muslim women are covered. Why is there polygamy? Usually these are the type of topics that they want to talk about. Why do you guys have to have four wives? So, 18:12 Oftentimes this is the starting point that you have to go from. But you should not forget that the goal is to bring them to Tawheed. So the essence of the message is Tawheed. As we know, Prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam, when he sent Mu'adh ibn Jabal to Yemen, he told him that you're coming to a people from the people of the book. So let the first thing that you tell them is to make Allah one. Faith. 18:44 in practice. And you watch it as well. So this is what we have to bring them to. Whether we explain about, because they want to know about polygamy, then we have to give them some. We can't just say, well, no, no, we don't want to talk about this. We only want to talk about this. No. We have to address the topic which they bring. But we try to turn that topic and use it as a means of getting them to Tawheed. Because this is the essence of the message. When dealing with Christians, of course, many of us may not be 19:14 verse in the text in the bible etc to be able to show them in their own text that look you know even jesus according to your own gospels or points he was pointing towards you know one god he was worshiping god and so on so we may not have the knowledge to get that across to them to be able to quote for them these verses etc but we can still appeal to their basic sense 19:46 the basic sense of who is God and who is man. That we can approach them from the point of view that would they accept somebody that's going to become God? And they will say no. There's no way that I can become God. Most. If somebody says yes, one day I'm going to become God, you tell them, nice meeting you. You know, keep on going. This is a person who has reached a sense of self-delusion that you really can't communicate with this person anymore. Because dawah 20:19 You're dealing with people who have some sense, you know. That's what Allah tells us in the Quran. They are ignorant people. People are so mind-blown, often their own delusions, self-delusions, try to talk to you. But you just tell them, salam, you know. It's nice meeting you. See you later. But for those who have some level of intelligence ready to reason, then you can show them that they recognize that they cannot become God. You ask them, why? I tell you, because our man, 20:49 You know, human being, man, cannot become God. So then you say, well, was Jesus a man? Well, you say, yes, he was a man, but then what do you think? If you said you cannot become God because you are a man, and you just said Jesus is a man, and you're saying this can't become God, he couldn't be God. You know, for the general person, oftentimes they never even think this, right? It's there in their mind, but they never put the pieces together. The Trinity thing is always confusing them anyway, right? 21:18 So just break it down to a very simple level. Try to put it to them. You know what? So you try to, you can give some simple reasoning without necessarily having to have memorized huge portions of the Bible and courses and that to them, right? Because sometimes, actually, this approach sometimes has its own dangers because it ends up being your interpretation and their interpretation. You know, they start to argue, you bring this verse, they bring another verse. You know, sometimes it can get very, very complicated depending on who you run into. 21:44 He's just an average Joe Christian who's just hardly read the Bible. You know, the only thing he knows is, you know, I'm the way, the truth, and the life. That's the only verse he knows from the whole Bible. Okay, you can shake him up with some of the other things. But some of these people who have read, you know, and they know their Bible well, you start bringing these verses, they start bringing counter-verses, you know. And, you know, as well, in the end, it ends up being your interpretation and my interpretation. So, one of the, what I found from my own experience, one of the easier ways to try to go to them is to say, let's reason. Let's use our reason. 22:14 You know, God gave us a reason for a purpose. I mean, this is part of what distinguishes us from the rest of the animals. The ability to reason, to understand things, to come to conclusions. So, I mean, part of that reasoning is like what I mentioned here. Of course, they may come back to you with the point, well, don't you believe that God can do anything? And this is the common response, right? Don't you believe that? And of course, it does say in the Quran, in Allah, where Allah is able to do all things. True. 22:45 However, you clarify to them that when you say, when God states that he can do all things, you're talking about all things that are consistent with him being God. Not including in it the absurdities, the impossibilities, the things which will make God no longer God. Because if you can just reason back with them, you believe that one of the characteristics of God is that he doesn't die. He isn't born. 23:18 This is part of the characteristics of God. So if somebody was to say to you, can God be born? But he just said, one of the characteristics of God is that he is not born. So, though you are saying, yeah, he can do all things, you cannot include him being born in it. Because it means there was a time when he didn't exist. And if there was a time when he didn't exist, for him to come into existence, it means somebody has to make him exist. So there is somebody else who is really the God, not him. This is where you end up. So, 23:51 The point is that you can show them from what they themselves believe. Take them from what is known to them to what is confused in their minds. That in the same way you are saying that God cannot be born, we are also saying that the Creator cannot become His creation. Because creation means what is in need of a Creator. To be a creature of God, to be a creature means 24:23 That there has to be someone to create you. So if God became his creation, then it means that he is now in need of a creator. So this is an impossibility, an absurdity. And this falls in line with the general philosophical argument that the atheist philosophers used to like to throw on Christian philosophers. They would say to them, okay, you believe God is able to do all things? Do you believe God can make a stone which is too heavy for him to lift? This is what they would throw on them. 24:56 And of course it creates problems for them. Because they said he can do anything. Including this, having a son. Being a man. So they are going to also have to accept that he can make a stone which is too heavy for him to lift. Meaning that there is something greater than God. Because they have accepted absurdity. Because they have accepted the absurdity that God could become his creation. God could have a son. And they are now obliged to accept the other absurdity that God 25:29 can make a stone which is too heavy for him today. That God could become a mosquito and you could catch him like that. Ridiculousness. You can just show them how ridiculous that type of thinking is. Just reasoning. Put down your book, put down my book, and let's just sit and reason a little bit. You know, God gave us that intelligence. And, you see, you'll be calling on the natural understanding that they have. You know, as Allah said, 25:59 When he created Adam, he took from Adam all of his descendants. And he asked them in that state, before they ever came on the earth, Am I not your Lord? And they said, We are with you. Without a doubt. So they have an instinctual understanding of God. Which if you can put aside the confusions that are there and just bring them back to that. 26:28 that natural understanding, then these things will make sense to them. And they will end up telling you, well, you know, I always thought it was strange anyway, you know, how Jesus could have been God, son of God. It did seem, you know, I never really understood it, I will tell you, really. I had doubts about it, really. But, of course, in the church, you don't express these doubts. You express these doubts when you are an apostate. So, the dawah, obligatory, 26:59 At the same time, we try to focus on the core issue, which is the oneness of Allah. The oneness and uniqueness in His oneness. Because it's very important for us not to stop at oneness, because sometimes we say, well, we focus on the oneness of Allah. Of course, in the end the Christians will say, we believe in one God too. He's only three in one, but He's still one. And if you go to the Hindus, they also believe that there is one Rahmah over all. 27:30 from which everything was created and He pervades everything. And you go to all of the various religions, they do ultimately have a belief in one God. So when we are talking about one, from the Islamic perspective, we have to stress to them the uniqueness of this one. So when they come back to us with the egg theory to explain how it is that God is three in one, you know, like an egg having a shell, the yolk, and the white, like one egg, we say, no, no, no, no. 27:59 You see, you're talking about an egg. We're talking about God here, right? You know, you're making God like an egg. Right? It's not unique anymore. Or they have the tree theory. Right? Where a tree has branches, it has a trunk, and it has roots. Again, R makes up the tree. You see, you're talking about a tree here. You're not talking about God. You know? Or they have the steam theory. You know, water exists as ice. It exists as a liquid. It exists as steam. Again, you're talking about water. 28:29 He's not talking about God. Now, God is unique in His oneness. This is the point that we stress to them. Unique. His attributes are not shared in their infiniteness. They are not shared by human beings. This is what we try to bring them to. Now, the other aspect of the obligation of doubt that I'd like to present, and I think this side of it is very, very important for us in North American context because 29:00 What we're addressing here is the situation that most people find themselves in in this country. In that they have migrated here from other parts of the world. The vast majority or a large portion of the Muslim community represents those who have migrated here. And the other portion, those who have accepted Islam here. Now, we have a particular verse in Surah An-Nisa, verse 97. 29:30 This is one that we should also reflect on when we're looking at the issues and the responsibilities of da'wah. Wherein Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala says, إِنَّ الَّذِينَ تَوَطَّاهُمُ الْمَلَائِكَةُ ظَالِمِي أَنفُسِهِمْ قَالُوا فِي مَا كُنْتُمْ قَالُوا كُنَّا مُصْطَدَحَةِينَ فِي الْأَرْضِ قَالُوا أَلَمْ تَكُنْ أَرْضُ اللَّهِ وَاتِعْتَ وَتُهَاجِرُ فِيهَا فَأُولَٰئِكَ مَأْوَاهُمْ جَهَنَّمُ وَ 29:59 They say, in what flight were you? They reply, we were weak and oppressed in the earth. They say, was the lost earth not spacious enough for you to emigrate to Meqhidra? Those will find their abode in hell. What an evil person. This verse is again another Sehir warning to Muslims. Muslims living in a minority situation where the majority population 30:32 is a non-Muslim population. The laws of that society oblige Muslims to give up certain aspects of Islam, not to implement Islam completely. So when a person gives up an aspect of Islam, he abandons some aspect of Islam. This Allah refers to as self-oppression. Golly me and sooty. Oppressing themselves. Why? Because when we disobey Allah, 31:10 We are not hurting Allah. We are not harming Allah. We are harming ourselves. We are harming ultimately ourselves. We are the ones who will suffer the consequences. So Allah refers to it as being in a state of self-oppression. Such people, when the angels take their souls at death, the angels will ask them, what was your situation? Why you were like this? And they will say that we were weak and helpless. And the angels will reply to them, 31:42 wasn't Allah's earth spacious that you could make hijrah. And Allah goes on to say that those people who die in that state, meaning that they were able to make hijrah, but died in that state of self-oppression, that their abode will be hell. And it's on the basis of this verse and other verses and hadiths of the Prophet ﷺ that the scholars of the past unanimously held that hijrah was 32:16 wajid, compulsory. From the land of disbelief to the land of belief. And that to make hijrah, to leave the land of Muslims and to go to the land of the disbelievers was also haram for the disbelievers. It was their ruling in the time. Of course, there is hadith wherein Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alayhi wa sallam has said, as narrated by Ibn Abbas, found in Abu Daud, Sunnah Abu Daud, which is authentic. 32:52 يَوْمُ الْفَتْحِ سَطْحُ مَكَةٌ لَا هِجْرَةَ وَلَكِنْ جِهَادٌ وَنِيَّةٌ That the day of conquest, of the conquest about which Allah speaks in the Quran, was the conquest of Mecca. And there is no hijrah after that. The only thing remaining was jihad and niyyah. Having the intention to make jihad or actually being involved in jihad. 33:31 However, as scholars explained, this negation of hijrah was the negation of the obligation of hijrah to Medina. Not the negation of hijrah totally, but the negation of hijrah to Medina. Medina was a point of hijrah which was compulsory for Muslims. And when Prophet Muhammad s.a.w. established himself there, it became compulsory for Muslims to make hijrah to Medina. Until... 33:59 the conquest of Mecca. Once Mecca was conquered, then it wasn't necessary anymore for Muslims to leave those areas that were controlled by the disbelievers and go to Medina. To establish it, to get the message out. Because we have other statements, for example, that one group narrated by Muawiyah, in which he said, authentically narrated, لَا تَنْقَطَعُ الْحِجْرَ حَتَّى تَنْقَطَعُ الْتَوْبَةِ That Hijrah will not cease until Tawbah, or repentance, ceases. 34:32 And tawbah will not cease until the sun rises in the west. So it means that hijrah remains enough until the sun rises in the west. So in understanding that, with relationship to the situation of Muslims for example here in North America, we have to point out that for a Muslim, 35:06 to be satisfied with this life, living an American Canadian life, nice house, nice car, money in your pocket, you know, just comfortable. To live that life wherein at the same time your children are going outside of Islam, the influence of the society is throughout your home, throughout 35:41 your workplace, etc. You have abandoned so many aspects of Islam. That state of affairs is a cursed state of affairs, a forbidden state of affairs by Muslims. And one who dies in that state, Allah has promised him or her hell. This is Allah's promise. And this is what we need to convey to the mass of the Muslims here, to wake them up to this reality that they are on the edge of the hellfire. Except, 36:17 if one is involved in establishing Islam and conveying Islam. So this is where the dawah comes in again as another critical point. That if we are involved in establishing Islam here, in other words, we are serving as a means of conveying Islam, we are involved in dawah. If we are involved in dawah here, then that justifies our being here. Because, 36:46 Somebody has to take the message to these people. Muslims have this responsibility to carry the message of Islam to the people. So if everybody made hijra out of the country and left no one behind, then of course the message would be lost. So it is necessary for people to be here to carry on that message. So the dawah becomes again an obligation on Muslims to justify their presence here. To justify 37:19 their presence here in this land. Establishment of Islam and conveyance of Islam to those around us. Establishment of Islam, of course, involves establishment of schools and the different institutions that are necessary for the Muslim community to survive. And ultimately, in my view, it also involves acts of internal hijrah. Acts of internal hijrah. Where Muslims, whether it's in Canada or the United States, 37:53 in one province or one state. Choose a particular area which has the greatest potential for growth and congregate there. Migrate to that area to establish a community. A real community. Not a community which only meets and sees its members on Friday. So after Juma, we run into each other. Assalamu alaikum, wa alaikum salam. And then we leave and go back to individual lives. 38:22 As portrayed by a program which used to be in America in the past called Little House on the Ferry. That was a classical example of the style of life of these people. Every person an island in and unto himself. That lifestyle is hated. Islam teaches that Allah's support is there with the Jama'at, with the community. Islam invites us to congregational prayers 25, 27 times, praying by yourself. 38:54 Salatul janaza cannot be performed by yourself. You need a community. Eid, prayers, zakah, distribution, needs organization, gathering, distributing. All of the Islamic principles have built in them community. The people should be working as a community. The pressures that people are faced with now in terms of dealing with riba, interest for purchasing homes or purchasing cars or whatever. 39:24 This is a product of not being a community. Not having other members of the community combining finance to make possible different social, economic activities which are necessary for Muslims. These are all symptoms of a bigger problem, which is that of lack of community. So, it is very important for us. 39:58 to address these issues with regards to the dawah, the obligation of dawah on each and every individual, the obligation of dawah on the community, to address them from the point of view of justifying our presence here in this land, having a responsibility before Allah on the day of judgment, not to hide whatever knowledge is in the hereafter, that each and every one of us feels an internal drive, an internal force, 40:34 which makes us want, strive to convey the word of Islam, word of Allah to those around us in this society. So Allah basically summarizes the essence of the presentation on the obligation of da'wah. You know, this is really introducing the topic. You have looked at the characteristics of the da'i. This is further introducing the topic. And in the future lectures we'll be going into, you know, more detailed aspects of the da'wah itself. 41:06 At this point, I'd like to invite your questions, brothers and sisters. We're going to take questions both in written form and in oral form. I will give preference to the written questions. In other words, if somebody is taking the pains to write, then I will make sure we can get them read as far as time permits. So we'll read out the questions and I will answer them. Let your questions reflect the fact that you have listened to the lecture. In other words, let your questions be on the topic. 41:34 Let your questions show that you've been thinking about the issues raised and you want more clarification. Let us get your questions now from both the brothers and the sisters. Yes. Who's going to ask the first question here? No, it can be written or it can be oral. Yes. I'll just repeat each question so the sisters know what we're answering. Otherwise it will sound to them like one hand clapping. They don't hear both the question and the answer. All right, so our brother has asked here. 42:32 Some people say that when we go to give Dawah to the Christians, we should not refer at all to their books. We shouldn't quote anything out of the Bible, for example. So, what is the clarification on this point? Should we, should we not, how to get the Dawah to the Christians? The basis of this is the narration in which Prophet Muhammad found Omar ibn al-Khattab reading a portion of the Torah. Or what was it? 43:05 reported to be the Torah. And the Prophet was obsessed with him and told him that if Prophet Musa was here, he would follow me. So on the basis of that, it was some scholars or some individuals concluded that we should not use their books or texts from their books in presenting Islam to them. However, we have to look at the context in which the Prophet said that. He said that 43:35 to Omar ibn al-Khattab, indicating to him that if Musa was here, he would follow me. Meaning what? That whatever is contained in those papers that you are reading, it doesn't contain any guidance beyond what I have already given you. Do not go to these books to seek guidance. There is no knowledge and guidance in there for you. Because if Musa was here, who received the origin, the original scripture, he would follow me. Right? 44:09 I have the final message. So, when we look in, for example, in the Quran, we see Allah referring to the fact that in the books of the people and the Jews, there is, as Prophet Muhammad is mentioned. So Allah is referring to their books, referring to places in their books where it is mentioned. So, it is quite reasonable for us to try to find, since Allah said it is in their books, to try and find those places where 44:37 there is indication of Prophet Muhammad and point it out to these people. Because they are today unaware that there is mention of the Prophet Muhammad in their books. And that doesn't contradict the principle which Prophet Muhammad brought out in chastising Omar for reading the Torah. Because that was in reference to seeking knowledge, trying to gain knowledge and to apply it. 45:09 You had certain groups that have appeared amongst Muslims in North America here, a group like the Ansar, like Ansarullah, who were around for a while, during the 80s and late 90s, you know, where they were taking text out of the Bible and interpreting it and implementing it and applying it. In other words, they were going to the Bible for knowledge. Of course, they were deviant. They deviated and they deviated themselves right out of Islam. But that is the... 45:39 is the bottom line. We cannot go to those books for guidance. Why? Because the books have become corrupted. And whatever is in there which is guidance for us is already established in the Quran and the Sunnah. So we don't need to go to these books for guidance. It would be a mistake. Because we will likely pull out of them misguidance as opposed to guidance. So we may only use it to control them. So we can show them a look. Even Prophet Jesus, Prophet Moses, Prophet Abraham prayed in the same way. 46:13 Here it is mentioned in your book. So, using the book to confirm what is in the Quran, for them, there is no harm. This is not an innovation, in the sense that earlier scholars did it. If you read the book of Ibn Taymiyyah, Al-Jawab Al-Fahih, Fiman Badda Lafidin Al-Masih, Awliman Badda Lafidin Al-Masih, this book, the major work written by Ibn Taymiyyah, he draws. 46:42 sections from the Gospels, etc. And a number of earlier scholars have done the same. So this principle, the principle of utilizing their books as a secondary source to support Quranic teachings, Quranic injunctions or laws, for example. You know, like today in the society, these people are, you know, accepting homosexuality. It has become sort of like a norm now. People are not wanting to question it, you know. 47:08 We have a clear stand. Islam has a clear stance against homosexuality. We can say, look, it's even in your book. It's also in your book that these people are cursed. Adultery. You know, the idea, you know, that you execute the adulterer. I think this is barbaric. You know, these Arabs, you know, crazy, just killing people over adultery. Adultery has become commonplace today. You know, it's no longer considered a crime in most circles. So, 47:37 When we take the stance, we can point to them and say, look, in your own book, here in Deuteronomy or in Leviticus, whatever, there it is, saying that you should stone the adulterer. This is part of your own teaching. This is the teachings that should Jesus follow, the prophet Moses follow, so on, so on. So we're not introducing something new. When we say that the women should cover themselves up, we can, you know, oh, you're covering the women, the profession of the women, so on, so on. You can go back and say, look, you know, there it is mentioned here that the women should cover their heads. If they come out with their heads uncovered, it's this, that, and the other. 48:07 It's only supporting and supportive evidence to the positions that we have taken. And of course, some of them, when you use evidence from their book, they may come back to you and say, well, why do you want to accept this one and not accept the other? You want to take part of the book and not the whole book, you know? Because we have other things in here too which you're saying you don't accept. You point out to them that we recognize that something of divine revelation remains in the scripture. 48:36 Not that these scriptures are themselves divine revelations. No. There is a much that human beings have put in their change, have distorted, according to your own scholars. Allah says in the Quran that they have changed the book with their own hands. يُحَرِّثُونَ الْكَلِمَ مِن مَوَادِعٍ Allah says they will change words from places to change the meanings, etc. They will do it with their own hands. 49:06 Your own scholars, you can bring evidence. Your own scholars say you have done it. So therefore, these scriptures are no longer reliable sources, primary sources. But what is true in them, they have been confirmed by the Quran and the Quran. This is what we can utilize to clarify for them. So, just in summary, we are saying that it is permissible to use evidences from their texts, from their history, to support. 49:37 Islamic principles, but not as a primary source, meaning that your da'wah is coming straight to them from their book. Your da'wah should be coming from the Quran, from the Sunnah, and their book is supportive, using, again, the wisdom, the logic, which were taught in the Quran itself. We have a number of questions on the topic of Shijrah itself. 50:06 And I'd ask you to be brief as I ask you these questions because we do have a number of questions on the same topic and you did cover the topic extensively in the speech itself. And then we have a number of other subject areas touched by various questions. So the first question is concerning hijrah. If a person becomes a Muslim from a non-Muslim country, should that person make hijrah to a Muslim country or can that person stay with the Islamic community? 50:35 in the non-Islamic country. In other words, that simplifies to say somebody in Canada embracing Islam. Does that Canadian new Muslim have to migrate to a Muslim country? Or should that new Canadian Muslim stay among the Muslims in Canada? When we take the issue of Hijrah down to an individual level, people have to look into their own lives and see if they find that they can hardly practice Islam. 51:05 There's so many things preventing them from practicing Islam. The so-called community that they accepted Islam within is not really a community. As I said, it's only a Friday community. The reality is that the rest of the week, it's not a community. People are scattered living their own individual lives. So they find themselves there. There's not this support systems and they're not there for them. And they have the means to leave and go to a land where they are Muslims, where they'll be able to practice Islam better. 51:36 And of course we know there is no Islamic country, meaning that they are applying Islamic laws across the board in the world today. And there are no Islamic countries putting their arms out, opening, open and saying, come Muslims, come and be with us. Okay, so we know this is a reality, right? This is reality. Let's not delude ourselves into thinking there is any Islamic country out there and Khalifa and all these other things. No, this is reality. 52:05 But there are countries where the majority of people are Muslims. To different degrees, they are applying Islamic law in those societies. It may vary from country to country. So for us to choose one which is the best that we can find and to emigrate there and stay as long as the law permits us to stay there, then this is better than remaining in that non-Islamic society where one feels oneself being sucked in. 52:32 in by the society, one feels one's faith being lost, etc., etc. But if that person who accepts Islam in that fragmented community finds himself or herself a part of an effort to establish Islam and to give the dawah, then it's perfectly legitimate for them to stay. If they don't have the means, because how many people have the means to pack up and just say maasalaam to Canada or America and just get off to the Middle East? 53:03 or some other part of the world where Muslims are majority. Many people don't have that means, don't have the ability. So those people, obviously the obligation is not on them until they have the means. And it is for them then to try to find other people who are conscious and try to work with those people to try to establish some form of community, establish Islamic schools, establish the dawah. This is what their responsibility would be. 53:39 Sir Jalal is inviting you. If you have some kind of follow-up question on the one which he is just addressing, we can take that. We can take that. You see, that's just an archipelago. We won't just ask you. And we have a number of questions here. I think some of them will be follow-up. Bear with me. I think it will be good. Now, some of the questions I'm going to leave aside for the moment because many of them will ask the Sheikh to repeat what he's already said in the lecture. I'm going to leave those aside for the moment. I have two here which are very similar. 54:09 As a single woman without a mahram to travel with, how can she make hijrah to a Muslim abode? And similarly, can a single sister make hijrah in order to save her deen without a mahram? If her mahrams do not want her to make hijrah, can her mahrams do not have a valid reason for her to stay here? As I said, the hijrah issue is one of obligation. 54:42 especially where one's being is being threatened. And a Muslim woman, if she's single, for example, she accepts Islam and she's on her own, right? She is in a situation where whether she stays where she is or she goes someplace else, she's still going to end up in the same position of being a single Muslim woman without a mahram. She doesn't have one. Whether she's here or she travels. So the point is that what is best for her? 55:16 To stay in a situation where the danger of the society is so great that it is destroying her, her religion, the religion of her children, for example, she comes in with children. Or for her to go to a society where at least she can practice Islam, there are Muslims there, her children can go to Muslim schools, they interact with other Muslim schools also. Obviously, the second choice is a better choice. It's a better situation for her to be in. Because there is no community here to protect her anyway. 55:44 If there was an established community, a practicing, established, real community, where there is a leader of that community who becomes her wali, who becomes the guardian for her without a guardian, then we'll say, no, don't travel. But if there's no such community, if it's fragmented, there's no leadership, no nothing, and there's nobody to protect her here anyway, whether she stays here or she travels is the same. Legally speaking, it's the same. So, she then has to look. 56:13 If her travel is going to take her into a position where she can better practice Islam, then it's better for her to travel, if she has the means. Though we have the general rule about a woman traveling without a mahram, that stands in the circumstance where community exists, where Muslim communities exist. When you're in a situation which is as this, which is fragmented, where people are on their own, then to talk about the issues of traveling without a mahram is out of context. Similarly, if, for example, 56:44 a young sister, her parents, she has realized what the deen is and the requirements of the deen, etc, etc. And her parents are out of it. They are not practicing Islam, they are happy to live here, and you know, this is what they want. And she fears for her deen here. For her to travel without their permission, without a mahram, to save her deen, becomes discrimination. But if the parents are practicing, etc, and they are providing protection for her, etc, etc, 57:16 then she should not travel without the accompaniment of the mahram. I will try as far as possible to give more preference to the questions which are more directly related to the subject area that we already covered. And I've seen a couple of here on the borderline, because it touches upon, you know, the curse, being a Muslim, living here, a non-Muslim man, and our children going astray, and so on. The first of the two questions is this. If one's children are non-Muslims, and they are doing things that warrant a curse upon them, 57:48 Is the curse also upon the parents or parents? And the second question is, if the children are all married and they live an un-Islamic life, would the parents still be responsible for them on the day of judgment? Would Allah punish the parents for what the children are doing? When Prophet Muhammad was going to make hajj, he came across a woman, this is Saeed Bukhari. 58:21 And she held up a child and said to him, is there hajj for this child, young child? The Prophet said, yes, but the reward is for you. If a Muslim raises a child Islamically, takes the child for hajj, teaches the child how to pray, you know, all the different practices of Islam, the parent gets the reward. 58:52 Because the child hasn't reached puberty, it's not reached the age of maturity, that responsibility for actions are now on them. Similarly, if a child is born in a non-Islamic circumstance, and the child is raised as a non-Muslim, as a disbeliever, the kafir, the child does not carry the sin of having been raised that way. This is Allah's destiny that the family they were raised in. 59:26 as long as they haven't matured. There is no sin on them, but the sin is on the parents. The sin will be on the parents who raised that child as a disbeliever. This is the basic principle here. If those parents raised their children as believers to the best of their ability, they were not able to make hijrah, to find other circumstances to provide for them, they did what they could here. 59:55 and then the children went astray after they became mature, etc., then their deviation will not fall back on the parents. But if the parents had the opportunity to make hijrah, and they didn't, and they chose to stay here, in un-Islamic circumstances, where they could see their children being corrupted, etc., but because of the dunya, because of the money they were making, the comfortable life they were living, they chose to stay, then yes, they will carry a portion of the sins. 60:26 of the deviation of their children. Does that apply also to the married children? Once children are married, does that obligation still continue? Well, in terms of the married children, once the children reach puberty, because in this society here, if a child reaches the age of 16, etc., and he or she says, I want to do my own thing, you know, that's it. You have no control over them anymore. 60:59 So whether they're from that age onward, even if they get married or whatever, you know, you don't have control over them anymore. So that child, if they are deviant, as a result of the foundation of deviation which you gave them, then you carry some of the sin also. Because it follows the principle of Prophet s.a.w. said, whoever starts a good sunnah, whoever sets a good way, he will get the reward of, 61:30 Everyone who follows that way until the last day without decreasing their reward. But if he begins an evil way, he raises his children in an un-Islamic way. He allowed the corruption in his home and etc. etc. Then he will carry the sins of everyone who follows that way. Not only the married, but the children of the married and their children until Yom Kippur. Because he is the one who put them on that path. 62:00 But he will carry the sin of everyone who follows our path until the last day. Contrary to the Christians, we don't bear for who came before us, but we bear for those who come after us and follow us. All right. Should the dawah be confined to non-Muslims? In other words, do we have to give dawah to non-Muslims only? If not, then what form of dawah must be addressed to the Muslims? And then a related question, actually two related questions. 62:34 Is there the same obligation to give tawah to members of the Nation of Islam, of Sufi sects or any other deviant sects or persons whose aqeedah is not straight? What is the best way since they believe that they are Muslims also? So we're looking at the question of whether we have to give tawah to only non-Muslims or also to Muslims. And what about the various groups who name themselves as Muslims, like Nation of Islam? 63:02 various Sufi sects and other persons who may not have the right belief but consider himself or herself a Muslim. What is the best way to give dawah to these people and do we have to give them dawah? Traditionally, the term dawah refers to inviting people to Islam. And this generally is understood as inviting non-Muslims to Islam. When we invite a Muslim to practice Islam correctly, this is called maseeha. This is giving them... 63:38 good advice. We can also call it dawah in a general sense that it involves inviting people, but it's really not inviting them to Islam, but inviting them to practice Islam correctly. So it becomes really more nasiha, advice to them, to correct the misconceptions or the malpractices that they have. And that is also a part of the deen amongst the requirements. You know, when the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said, I deen on nasiha, 64:07 as religion is good advice, and they ask to whom, O Messenger of Allah, he said, to the leaders of the Muslims and to the general Muslims, you know, etc., etc. But he stresses, لِعَيْمَةٍ الْمُجْنِنِينَ or المُسْمِنِينَ وَعَامَتِهِمْ To the leaders as well as to the common people. So this is part of that نصيحة, fulfilling that obligation of advising our Muslim brothers and sisters. Now, in terms of how does one advise? 64:37 Of course, it has to be in a way which people can hear. We cannot approach them attacking their belief directly. This is when you're dealing on a one-on-one basis. On a one-on-one basis. You're dealing with a follower of the nation of Islam. There's no point in calling that person a kafir and so on. So, there they are. They consider themselves to be Muslims. 65:10 But in the general ruling with regards to the Nation of Islam, they are disbelievers. With no ifs, ands, and buts about it. If anybody has any doubts here that the Nation of Islam are disbelievers, then that point can be clarified in more detail for them. But the reality is that they are disbelievers in the fullest sense of the word. They believe that Allah came in the person of a man, they call Farad Muhammad, who taught Elijah Muhammad, 65:42 and appointed him as a prophet of Allah. I mean, all of that is more than enough statements of disbelief. So, dealing with somebody like this, one needs to use language which will not antagonize them or run them away in the first few moments. You know, we have to try to reason with them, so we try to find a common ground with them and discuss and from that try to get to the 66:15 vigorous issues, deeply what Islamic teachings with regards to Allah and to human beings and the Prophethood and the finality, etc. And that obligation to call them, they must be obligated to call Christians and Jews and the others similar. For our Muslim brothers who have not deviated to the point where they have left Islam, but are having some 66:47 concepts or some practices which are incorrect again we have a responsibility to try to reach out to them and to help them to have a proper understanding to cut them off to negate them to brand them and just have nothing to do with them this is error i know it has become very popular in these times you know where the principle of hajj of abandoning or avoiding 67:16 those who innovate, you know, has become a practice amongst Muslims. This is the fifth rank of those people who are themselves, you know, falling to the Quran and Sunnah as it was understood by the early generation of Muslims. We find that breaking their ranks. Yes, there are narrations of scholars like Abdullah ibn Mas'ud and others of that generation who, if they saw an innovator coming on one side of the road, they would go walk on the other side of the road. It would have nothing to do with them. 67:48 If an innovator came to them and started trying to talk to them, they would put their fingers in their ears and walk away. Sahaba, from the early scholars, did this. Now, brothers, we'll hold this up and say, okay, there it is. These people who we know are innovators, they have these innovative ideas, this is how we should deal with them. I'm not saying that don't sit next to them, get out of their sight, no. But we have to look at the context in which the Sahaba applied this. What is the context? This was the time of the Islamic State. Islam was fully established. 68:21 The Muslims were the majority. There were few innovators popping up amongst them. So when these innovators popped up with their ideas, they cut them off. They didn't allow that idea to spread. And they executed them in the end. Those who just persisted, then the state would execute them. In our time, we are living in a minority situation. Where the vast majority of the Muslims are involved in some deviation or innovation. For you now to say, I have nothing to do with this person. 68:53 What effect does this have? Is this going to isolate his or her ideas or something? No. All it is, is going to block an avenue for dawah and natifah. That's all it's doing. So it is not serving the purpose that it served amongst the early generation. Our time is different. The scholars will tell you to apply the sharia in the sense of the hudud. A Muslim amongst us commits adultery to take that person out and to kill them. This is wrong. 69:23 In these times, in our circumstance, it is not applicable. Because we don't have authority. And the repercussions of such actions on the community would be so great that it could create greater harm than the benefit that we're trying to achieve. And basic principle in Islamic law is that if in trying to achieve a benefit you create a greater harm, got it. That benefit is not worth achieving. If in trying to create... 69:55 to attain a benefit, which is an Islamic benefit, you are going to produce a greater harm to scholars' morals that you should leave that benefit. So, similarly, the issue of Hajar is not applicable today. When we are giving da'wah amongst Muslims, etc., we have to keep doors open. How can we reach people if we have closed the doors? We label them as thisy and thaty. You know, you are so-and-so and so-and-so. 70:25 My name has been put on you. It means I don't want to hear anything from you. And of course, they don't want to hear anything from us. And a big divide is there. How to reach these people. How to bring them to a consciousness. How to correct the mistakes of their belief. And if we are to apply this principle that you have a mistake in your belief and we're going to reject what you have to say, then we'll have to do that to much of the great scholars of the past because you're not going to find a scholar of the past who didn't make mistakes. 70:56 So you're not going to find one who didn't make you sick. Abu Hanifa tells the view that it was permissible for you to drink drinks which were intoxicating in large amounts as long as you don't drink it to the point of intoxication. Based on the information that was available to him. His students, Abu Yusuf and Muhammad Sayyidani rejected that view. 71:28 When they came across the hadith that what intoxicates you in large amounts is forbidden in small amounts, then they abandoned that view. But Abu Hanifa had that view. If anybody stood up now amongst us and tried to propagate that, what are we going to say about this guy? He's deviant. He's destroying the Deen. But we accept it from Abu Hanifa because no one is free from error. Even the Sahaba themselves. 72:02 When Imam Malik was asked, if we follow a Sahabi in everything he does, will we be on the correct path? He said, no. He said, no, unless he was correct, because the truth is one. So if we cannot follow blindly a Sahabi, then how are we going to justify cutting off people because of some mistakes they have made, whether in their belief or in their practice? 72:33 This is just from the hikmah and the wisdom of Dawah and Messiah, that we keep doors open for communication. We don't cut people off, avoid labeling, to the point where we can no longer communicate with people. We only have about less than five minutes left for our question period, and we do have a number of questions. If you can be very brief with these ones that we'll follow now, and just relate to now what you just answered. 73:01 Are we allowed to go with Jamaat al-Tabligh for dawah and are they people of Bihar? Jamaat al-Tabligh is a Jamaah which fundamentally was formed in India with the goal of bringing people back to the market. The people who founded it maybe had certain errors in some aspects of their knowledge. So these errors are reflected in their dawah. But the intention 73:40 The general thrust is to promote Islam. To promote Islam among... Our intention should be, if we see errors in their way, and there are some errors, to invite them to what is correct. I don't have a problem, personally. I don't have a problem with going with some of the people of Jamaat Sabli. And in the course of going with them, advising them. Not just going and sitting. 74:16 I'm not saying anything. But going and advising them. If a person came into Islam initially, and this is what was available, for them to go with them and get the basic practices of Islam in terms of how to sleep, how to eat, and how to do the basic things, and treating people in such or such a way. There is no harm in that. As long as they keep an open mind. This is the key, that they keep an open mind. So, there is good in the Jama'at. 74:49 But at the same time, there is harm. If a person is ignorant, then it is necessary for them, if there are other opportunities for knowledge, to continue to seek knowledge and to improve and to grow. If that is all that is available to them, I would never tell them, stay at home. If in your area, the only people who are doing anything Islamically, are the Jamaat Tabligh, I would say, take from them what is good. But remember, you have a foundation of Quran and Sunnah. 75:24 You should try to get evidence for whatever is being given to you. Our duty is to advise them in their error, to work with them, whether it's good. And what you will find is that the jama'ah is going to vary from place to place. In some areas, depending on the background that they come, they may have greater errors than others. If you go, I know, we have a book, Tablighi Musab, you know, Shazaili Amal, these books, right? 75:56 There are many weak hadiths in there. Publications in there. But also in many other books that are available on the market, collections and so on. So there are weak hadiths. There are some publications. You can find this in Sunan Ibn Majah. If we are going to reject a book because there are publications and weak hadiths in it, then we'll have to throw aside Sunan Ibn Majah. Sunan Natai. Because this book has publications and weak hadiths. The point is that we try to get... 76:25 as much clarification as possible, get to what is correct, and take out the good and leave the bad. Similarly, with the Jama'at in their books, etc., there is a lot of good. A lot of good information is there, but of course, there is some deviation. Certain things are questionable, and these things should be questioned. In some areas, for example, in the Middle East, in the Emirates, in Saudi Arabia, they don't read these books. What they read there is Riyadh al-Saleheen. That is the standard book in which they read. 76:54 you know, which still does have some weak hadith in it, but very few fabricated hadith. That is the common book, which is used. And their attitude with regards to certain issues of haqidah, you know, may be much more firm and in keeping with the general way which was understood by the early generation of scholars. So, we can say that they tend to be more correct in that sense, whereas in other 77:24 Areas in other you may find people are more affected by the background that they're coming out of So in summary, I would say that the there is error in the minhaj of the Jumat Tabligh But not such error as takes them out of the deen That it is not possible for us to work with them We should keep the doors open to work with them in what is good. We should give them advice where they are 77:54 We do have a number of very interesting questions here, the answers to which we would have learned tremendously from. 78:20 but we don't have sufficient time. I'd ask you, if you didn't hear your question answered in this session, to repeat your question in another session. I hope that one of the other speakers will be able to address your question for you. JazakAllah khairan wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh.