نص مُفرَّغ آليًا وقد يحتوي على أخطاء، فارجع إلى التسجيل للتحقق من الألفاظ.
0:00 بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful Al-Jum'ah Magazine, Volume 24, Issues 11-12, Dhul-Qi'dah-Dhul-Hijjah 1433 Monotheism in the Hands of Fourth-Century Churchmen by Linda Thayer Innovations of the Church vs. the Teachings of Jesus How did... 0:31 Jesus, peace be upon him, became defined as God. We travel back to the fourth century and observe the proceedings of the Christian authorities with the help of a best-selling author, Richard E. Rubinstein, and his book, When Jesus Became God. These events account for a bellwether stage in the historical legacy left to our Christian colleagues and the predicament 1:00 of their unwieldy convoluted belief system today. There are numerous lessons for us Muslims all along the way in this narrative, both positive and negative. And Allah's refuge is sought from ascribing a son to Him, to God. Revisiting Part 1 1:26 In the first segment of the series, we looked at the reasoning pursued by a prolific modern biblical scholar, James D.G. Dunn, author of Did the First Christians Worship Jesus?, who wanted to make sense of those earliest Christians who practiced their distinctive worship of God in, by, and through Jesus, peace be upon him, not apart from him. 1:53 Yet he wanted to reconcile this kind of worship with the strict monotheism recorded concerning Jesus, peace be upon him, the gospel narrative books of Christian scripture. Following not Jesus, peace be upon him, but the self-proclaimed Apostle Paul and his doctrine of the raised from the dead and exalted to heaven Christ, 2:18 Those so-called Christians of the New Testament in T of the Christian Bible are to be termed Christological monotheists in the words of Dunn. We concluded, however, that Dunn failed to consider that Paul, the outsider spokesman for Christians, or more precisely, as Dunn tells us, for those who call upon Jesus Christ, was the center, if not the cause, of steering 2:48 would be followers of jesus away from jesus on teaching reading along with dunn we noted how the language about jesus peace be upon him and the entity moved from portraying him as monotheistic prophet reformer of bani israel that is jesus peace be upon him according to himself in the first three gospel books to representing jesus as a divine agent 3:14 as a divine agent than divine associates, that is, in parts of the Gospel of John in Acts and the letters of Paul, clear through to language that presents Jesus as co-deity with God, that is, in the revelation to John. All of these being documents comprising the New Testament in T. 3:37 We have looked into the NT writings composed roughly between the years 50 and 100 of the Christian era CE, but not canonized that is officially accepted as scripture by religious authorities until the mid-fourth century of the common era, Christian era CE. We now proceed in this segment to that. 4:01 same fourth Christian century to pick up the ongoing theological power struggles in the wake of what we may regard in effect as the corruption of monotheism set in motion by the Pauline Christological doctrines. Christology is the teaching that the Christ, meaning Jesus, peace be upon him, was the divine Son of God, whose death paid the penalty for mankind's sin, and whose rising from the dead was God's attestation, and whose rising from the dead 4:31 was God's attestation for Paul's teaching. Fourth century Christian controversy and its world. We trace this historical process and its political underpinnings with the aid of Jewish writer Robert E. Rubinstein, a specialist in conflict resolution at George Mason University and his 1999 bestseller, When Jesus Became God, the struggle to define Christianity during the last days of Rome. 4:59 References and quotes cited with page numbers refer to this book. The contest raged over whether the man Jesus, peace be upon him, and his resurrected from the dead and exalted to heaven state, in this sense termed Christ, was God, and if not, was he more than man? It came to a head not in declining Latin-speaking Rome, but in the 5:25 emerging eastern greek-speaking empire in the three cities where prosperity and culture were most celebrated constantinople turkey antioch syria and alexandria egypt page 4 recall that that what is now presented to us as the new testament whatever its original form and language has come down to us in the the in the 5:49 than current international language Greek, not in the very different Aramaic language spoken by Jesus and his Jewish followers. Aramaic, of course, is a Semitic language, a sister language of Arabic. Christianity had grown slowly in the first two centuries, but by 250 CE, this religious group had a rate of expansion whose numbers were soon to surpass that of the Bani Israel, the children of Israel of the time. 6:18 What should have been a Jewish reform movement two centuries previously became a predominantly gentile, non-Jewish religious group with no more than historical roots in Judaism. As a still shadowy minority movement, without the public acceptance enjoyed by the Jewish community, Christians were blamed more than once for the misfortunes of the Roman Empire. 6:43 Because of their distinctive refusal to show homage to the power structure of the Roman state by sacrificing to their gods, Christians had been set up to suffer under the great persecution of the Roman emperor Diocletian in the first decade of 300 CE. The bitter conflicts among Christians did nothing to bring back the glory of declining Rome. 7:13 Rome's power could be rehabilitated through Diocletian, restoring the old gods. But over to the east, in enlightened Alexandria, a quarter of whose residents were Jews, popular participation in another contest for hearts and minds, that of sitting the church's philosophical conundrums, was in high gear. Their collective decision might be an all... 7:42 alternative able to save Roman civilization. The attraction of Pauline Christianity in the pagan world was likely related to its promise of immortality, which was to take effect with the personal resurrection from the dead, which in turn followed the model of Jesus' submission to wrongful suffering and supposed death, his return to life, resurrection, and his 8:09 exaltation to heaven as an intercessory Christ. The Christians suffering in the insecurity of earthly life would be compensated for if only in the next life. While the Roman gods were privileged immortal beings, the Greek philosophers had only imagined the human soul as immortal and Jews then merely hinted at inheriting a world to come. 8:34 Jesus, peace be upon him, however, was an exemplar of human behavior, and the Church promised its adherents eternal life as their reward. While Muslims believe in something roughly equivalent to this immortality of the human soul, such an ongoing existence of individuals beyond their 8:57 Earthly years is not something that has been brought about by the death, resurrection and exaltation of Christ Jesus, Paul's teaching or by any other event in human history. Rather, it is simple or it is simply part of the program for human beings as created by Allah. That is, it's our distant return to human or to him. It is our distant return to him, whereupon each is to give comprehensive account for himself and to be generously compensated for choosing goodness in this life. 9:28 People today often understand the intramural disputes among Christians as happening based on ideological grounds alone, but in fact they were enabling or complicating historical factors just as crucial as the competing belief statements. There was the pagan Roman word with an... 9:51 who naturally wanted stability and peace among his subjects, who thus was eager to take an active part in regularizing church doctrine. There were church power structures developing during those times with competing personalities. In the Eastern Roman Empire, the primacy of the Western Roman Catholic Church was still to emerge, and only in the 11th century would the schism be made permanent, separating Western Roman 10:21 dominance from the Eastern Greek Orthodox Church Jesus peace be upon him a son of God and Allah's refuge is sought Rome and Constantinople were the main cities vying for fading Roman power Rome and Constantinople were the 10:42 or main cities vying for fading roman power yet it was the intellectual melting pot of alexandria egypt that would host the ensuing battle over how to conceive of the relationship of jesus to god page five in order to see how the question could even arise we need first to understand how jesus spoke of himself using terminology meaningful to his jewish constituent constituency in politically volatile times jesus peace be upon as narrated in the gospel 11:10 books of christian scripture the new testament in t had employed coded messianic coded messianic language referring to god as his father and to himself as son a roman ruler who would feel threatened by a claim that jesus was ben israel's messiah or spiritual political king thus challenging 11:35 Roman rule would give hardly a second thought to a Jewish teacher using a family-oriented metaphor, calling God his father and referring to himself as God's son. After all, Roman gods were commonly enough said to have human sons. 11:54 by contrast though in the context of jesus palestine a son of god was a hebrew jewish phrase meaning a godly person righteous in terms of the intent of the law of moses promised in jewish scripture he the hebrew bible or old testament ot of the bible one chosen by god a messiah a messiah would come to restore to ben israel or the jewish people the glory of the previously ruling house of king david 12:23 peace be upon him, to us Muslims, Prophet Dawud, alayhi salam. The new successor of the king figure would be a godly person fit to represent the descendants of Abraham, Ibrahim, and Moses, Musa. This godly personage, the Hebrew Messiah, would be there to the promise made by the Lord God Almighty according to the Hebrew Bible. Bible, 2 Kings, chapter 7, verses... 12:52 4 and 5 chapter 7 second king chapter 7 verses 12 to 17 the prophet nathan with king david but that night the lord said to nathan go and tell my servant david that i say to him when you die and are buried with your ancestors i will make one of your sons a king and will keep his kingdom strong i will be his father and he will 13:20 be my son. I will not withdraw my support from him. Nathan told David everything that God had revealed to him. For a prophet Jesus, peace be upon him, that is Isa, to acknowledge the Hebrew idiom, son of God, meaning a godly person, would have been quite naturally appropriate. Prophets of the one God must be, or must of course by, must be, 13:43 of course be godly obedient to God's revealed guidance but in Jesus context it meant more the title son of God like son of David was an insider code name for the expected messianic prophet as heir of king David Jesus peace be upon him spoke of the kingdom of God or 14:02 euphemistically as the kingdom of heaven since jews did not pronounce the holy name of god and when he did he referred to that society of god fearing individuals who submit to what god requires of them by the way aren't we muslims by definition intended to be a society of god fearing individuals who submit to what god requires of us the kingdom of god was jesus code name used in his reformed message god's kingdom was 14:31 to be that social unit in which people would consciously submit to God's law and live righteous lives of dependence upon God as their king, so to speak. Here are some examples of Jesus' teaching according to the NT. Bible, Matthew 5, verses 1, 6 and 10. Jesus saw the crowds and went up a hill where he sat down. 15:00 His disciples gathered around him and he began to teach them. Happy are those whose greatest desire is to do what God requires. God will satisfy them fully. Happy are those who are persecuted because they do what God requires. The kingdom of heaven belongs to them. The Bible Mark chapter 4 verses 30 to 33. What shall we say the kingdom of God is like? Ask Jesus. 15:30 What parable shall we use to explain it? It is like this. A man takes a mustard seed, the smallest seed in the world, and plants it in the ground. After a while, it grows up and becomes the biggest of all plants. It puts out such large branches that the birds come and make their nest in its shade. 15:57 Jesus preached his message to the people using many other parables like these. He told them as much as they could understand. He would not speak to them without using parables, but when he was alone with his disciples, he would explain everything to them. Such believers would be corrected by God and blessed when they obeyed him. Thus, the father-son metaphor that is God in relationship to his promised messianic prophet Jesus. Peace be upon him. 16:25 in Jesus' word had nothing to do with the firstborn or begotten son of the creator at least not as long as the followers of Jesus were Jews but the later predominantly gentile converts were willing to bring with them into the new Christian faith their pagan sensibilities so in Paul by means of his gentile friendly doctrines had 16:48 discouraged Jewish participation in the Jesus Reform movement. The Greek-speaking church lost the Hebrew meaning of these terms, Father and Son, as the Bible context originally reports through translation Jesus' idiomatic usage of them. With Paul's prolific input into the nascent movement and with the simultaneous loss of the original Jewish followers of Jesus, the pagan Greek meaning of such terms would eventually kick in. 17:18 Jesus would be understood as God's son in the same sense that half human Apollo Hercules was the begotten son of the supreme in the same sense that half human Apollo Hercules was the begotten son of the supreme pagan god Zeus in Greek mythology Paul had written as if Jesus were God's partner 17:45 Paul had written as if Jesus were God's partner in creation in the same sense that the Greek philosophical logos or word was with God at the creation event and was God, whatever that might mean. Part 1 has a discussion on this. Once that Greek sense was securely fixed in place as the correct Christian conception, 18:12 All the other philosophical adjustments would have to be worked in if this new religion were to command the respect of the Greek educated intelligentsia of the Roman Empire of the time. The technical term Christ was another malleable expression that Paul co-opted and filled with his own meaning. The Hebrew term Messiah, one anointed, that is chosen by God for leadership. 18:41 became in Greek the title Christ with the conveniently added implications of the spiritual power of a pagan mystery cult personality like that of Serapis or Mithra Serapis or Mithra such secretive cults were associated with initiation rites into initiation rites into sacred mysteries with benefits in the afterlife 19:08 if jesus peace be upon was a son of god or even son of the one true god of the jews that is an offspring of an immortal deity and do not miss the and do not miss the demotion of the creator to god status the chief among many gods then then was jesus to be understood as a human at all or was he exclusively divine or was he human and divine and by the way 19:37 What would it mean to be divine? In particular, what would it mean for any human being to be divine? Would it mean he embodied the same essence as that of God and Allah's refuge is sought? Even as late as the fourth Christian century, there were still those who insisted that Jesus was a human prophet, like the previous Hebrew prophets. 20:00 Yet, while he was not God or God or divine, for this would violate monotheism, he was clearly more than a normal human being in the Greek mind. Didn't the Greek language in New Testament NT say as much that he was more than a mere human, for he spoke from God and performed miracles? Of course, a Muslim reader of the NT gospel narratives would feel completely comfortable in categorizing Jesus, peace be upon him, as a prophet in the Islamic sense. 20:29 But the Greeks didn't have the Hebrew concept of prophet and that is the departure point from which the corruption of understanding grew into a raging controversy and eventually an established doctrine with a pagan orientation. The 4th century Alexandrians would simply draw on the current trends in Greek philosophy to interpret biblical texts and church doctrine. 20:53 And thus the stage was set for this irreversible foray into theological speculation. Herein is one patent lesson for us as Muslims. We must take to heart the dangers of engaging in theological speculation so as to avoid making the same mistakes as did those who had revelation before us. And in time, Allah will cause them to understand what they have contrived. Indeed, the truth deny they. 21:22 who say, behold, God is the Christ, son of Mary. Chapter 5, verses 14 to 19. To those who are bent on ascribing divinity to oath beside Allah, you follow but other people's conjectures, and you yourself do nothing but guess. Alexandria and Arius. Before beginning the... 21:51 Before beginning, at the beginning, we jump into the middle of our drama, Alexandria, Egypt of 356-361 CE, with the central question at hand was Prophet Jesus, peace be upon him, now known as Paul, Jesus Christ, to be considered a god, or even the god, now that the pagan gods were known by the pagan enlightened to be fictitious carriers of culture, perhaps like the modern Santa Claus or the Easter... 22:20 Bunny or the tooth fairy was the Lord Jesus Christ or Christ Jesus or Christ all terms used by Paul to be considered divine that is somehow God himself and Eastern Presbyterian and Eastern Presbyterian a church officer lower than Bishop and Eastern Presbyterian church officer lower than Bishop 22:48 known to history as Arius had responded to this exploratory hypothesis with nay, while Bishop Athanasius of Alexandria countered with yea in agreement with his Western colleagues. This bishop would more than once lose his bishopric over this question. 23:21 or over this question. He would be sent into exile when the new Aryan friendly emperor Constantius II took the throne in faraway Constantinople. This time Athanasius was replaced with an Aryan bishop from elsewhere in the empire in keeping with the views of the Roman throne. George of Cappadocia in Asia Minor Turkey 23:49 The imported outsider bishop was unwelcome in Alexandria. The local community wanted the return of their beloved hometown, Athanasius. After a year of Aryan, George's persecution of pagan and non-Aryans alike, the Alexandrians took matters into their own hands and attacked George, who escaped assassination with his life. But when a church council ruled in favor of the Aryan position, 24:16 George audaciously took it upon himself and returned to Alexandria, reclaiming his office. Four days later, the Aryan emperor, Constantius, died. The Aryan emperor, Constantius, died inconveniently for George and anti-Aryan supporters of Athanasius co-opted Alexandria's churches, putting George in a prison. With the advent of the new 24:46 Non-Aryan emperor Julian George was brashly dragged out and beaten to death, 361 CE, in retaliation. Within two months, Athanasius returned from a monastery hideout in the Egyptian desert to his ecclesiastical post. 25:08 But let us now backtrack from this particular climax confrontation to fill in its background before moving on to complete the saga. Athanasius' anti-Aryan theology took the position, accepting Pauline writings as incontestable, church truth that Jesus Christ was unbegotten, just as God could be referred to as the 25:37 unbegotten one but what Athanasius meant was that Jesus was not created but what Athanasius meant was that Jesus was not created from nothing but rather that he was created by God from the same substance as that of God himself and that accordingly Christ was not separate from and lesser than God and again we seek refuge in Allah 26:02 In contrast, Arius took the position that Jesus, peace be upon him, was created by God like other humans, and that while Jesus was the holiest person who had ever lived, Jesus was not the eternal God incarnate, i.e. embodied in human form. For Arius, God by nature was perfect and could not be imitated by human beings. However, Jesus' virtue as Christ could be. 26:27 and thus individual believers could possibly become sons or daughters of God by adoption as a result of consciously having developed within themselves a godly manner of life, the same way in which Jesus had become the ultimate son of God by his perfection of life. No one in church circles seemed to notice that both Arius and Athanasius were 26:54 philosophizing and greek concepts not explicating the hebrew or jewish categories used by jesus peace be upon him the personal fortunes of athanasius waxed and waned as church councils periodically condemned him five times he was exiled from his office as bishop of the alexandrian church even pursued by impartial even pursued by imperial troops for arrest in the end 27:25 In the end, bewilderingly, councils ultimately settled on approving the views of Athanasius, not those of Arius. Athanasius' winning argument was that if the Christ were to be less than God, that Christ would not have the standing to save mortal humans from the consequences of their sinful deeds. Christ had to be superior to sinful humans, meaning that he had to be God. 27:55 and Allah's refuge is sought. The Christian concept of salvation means to be exempted from the guilt of the individual's inevitable sin and thus rescued from the punishment of hellfire in the next life. If anyone did not believe that Christ was God, Athanasius said, then that person could not be saved from his deserved punishment. According to Athanasius, the arguments of Arius were so clever and convincing that the struggle against Arianism was a battle against Satan. 28:24 Page 9. Also, thanks to Athanasius, the church councils made Christianity exclusivist. Outside the church, there could be no salvation. After all, they reasoned, had not Jesus said, Bible, John 14, verses 14 to 11, Jesus to his disciples, you know the way that leads to the place where I am going. 28:57 Thomas said to him, Lord, we do not know where you are going, so how can we know the way to get there? Jesus answered him, I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one goes to the Father except by me. Chapter 14, verses 4 to 11. Now that you have known me, he said to them, you will know my Father also, and from now on you do know him. 29:29 and you have seen him. Philip said to him, Lord, show us the Father, that is all we need. Jesus answered, For a long time I have been with you all, yet you do not know me, Philip. Whoever has seen me has seen the Father. Why then do you say, show us the Father? Do you not believe, Philip, that I am in the Father, that I am in the Father, the Father is in me? The words that I have spoken to you, 29:59 jesus to his disciples do not come from me the father who remains in me does his own work believe me when i say that i'm in the father and the father is in me if not believe if not believe because of the things i do this of course comes from the gospel of john the new testament book that implies contradictions to the three other gospel books and serves to introduce jesus as a divine associate 30:28 Still today, Christians tend to quote only part of Jesus' metaphor, taking it literally to mean that Jesus is God in human form and that there would be no further prophet that could ever be rightly followed. For Muslims who believe Jesus to be a God-sent prophet, there is no difficulty in reading the above words of Jesus, peace be upon him, as a way of saying that Jesus, as many Israel Hebrew prophets conveyed the teaching that God was giving. 30:57 was giving him and that for his Jewish audience of his time and place he was the exclusively correct way as the other Jewish teachings had been corrupted. Let us be clear, having a correct concept of prophethood makes the difference between wrongly worshipping Jesus or even worshipping God in by and through Jesus as against the believers of his time rightly following him and his Sunnah as a human exemplar sent by God. 31:27 Unfortunately, our interfaith Christian partners will more likely be those who worship God in, by, and through Jesus. Some will appear to worship Jesus directly without misgiving, calling upon him by name and thanking Jesus for God's blessings. The intolerance of Athanasius was perhaps matched eventually by persecution on the part of Arius against his opponents, both pagans and anti-Aryan. 31:53 Christians. Mass participation of Alexandrians in discussion of the issues was fierce and evilly divided. Each side had their staunch adherents and the church would never be totally rid of this controversy for reasons of intransigence and above all by reason of following Paul. Antioch and Diocletian. At the temple of the pagan god Apollo in Antioch, at the temple 32:24 of the pagan god Apollo in Antioch, Syria, in 299 CE, the pagan Roman emperor Diocletian, returning from his victory for the moment, see Surah Rum, chapter 30, verses 2 and 3, over the Persians, was attending the sacrificial ceremonies in celebration. Was attending the sacrificial ceremonies in celebration. 32:53 Internal organs of bullocks and sheep, one animal after another, were consulted for signs of the emperor's future fortunes. Without exception, the hearts and livers were abnormal. Was disaster imminent for Rome? Or some of the emperor's household servants were said to have been spotted making an occult sign? 33:21 in the air just when each animal had been dispatched the mysterious sign of the cross a sign of good or ill diocletian was not taking any chances there must be no christian sectarians to upset this or to upset his balance of power any members of his household and any members of the army were to be let go if they refused to sacrifice to the immortal gods thereby christians would be weeded out 33:50 if they were not willing to show loyalty to Rome and its civilization. The Great Persecution of Diocletian intended to eliminate any Christian non-compliance with the state that could comprise the emperor's success. Christians were not asked to otherwise compromise their faith. 34:16 Christians were not asked to otherwise compromise their faith and the ritual requirements of compliance were minimized for them. Pages 22 to 28 What was offensive to the Roman ruler was the Christian exclusivity. Their inability to respect other people's gods. Furthermore, Christians had 34:48 deified Jesus whom a previous Roman ruler had considered a seditious Jew long ago properly executed for disloyalty to Rome since he supposedly had claimed to be a Jewish king which didn't help the standing of the Christians either. Many pagans had already come to believe in a supreme God so why must the Christians demonize the pagans lesser gods? 35:16 why insist on a single deity that alone ruled the universe and then inexplicably and most confusing of all say that this single exclusive deity did so with the partnership of his divine son and if that wasn't enough then consider this with their exclusive it aims christians might just aspire to making the religion the one and only in the empire and this at a time when there were live threats of invasion from 35:44 germanic and north african tribes to the live threats of invasion from germanic and north african tribes to the west as well as counter-offensives from persia to the east diocletian's army was riddled with barbarian troops of numerous new religions some 20 or 30 years previously the emperor had already dealt with a mesopotamian dualistic religion 36:13 Manicheism, while the Manicheans worshipped the good God, they believed that an equally powerful evil force, Satan, was at work in the world, countering the good efforts of humans and the good God. Thus, there was a duality of supreme power in the universe affecting human affairs and leading to their sin. 36:44 The Manichaeans' spirit-led prophet Mani had been martyred in the 270s. Not only was the religion seen as pro-Persian since many Manichaean converts had been gained in Persia, Rome's adversary, but their Christ-linked missionaries had reached India and China, thus constituting 37:13 a further threat from within to Diocletian's Roman hegemony. In 302 CE Diocletian had burnt a number of their priests and their books but their martyrs simply became heroes for a continuing faith . In those days there were also the traditional Roman and Greek pagan oracular shrines. 37:43 in mountain groves throughout Roman-controlled territory. These served to answer visitors' personal questions through the medium of a kind of fasting prophet called an oracle who uttered unintelligible words. Those words, also called an oracle, said to originate with the half-human god Apollo. The interpreter of the prophet would put the god's prophetic message into poetic verse. 38:11 often ambiguously worded and left for the inquirer to make sense of. Military people of the time seem often to have consulted an oracle in making strategic decisions. Note, by the way, that several centuries later in Arabia, Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, would be accused of being a soothsayer, that is, an oracle, in keeping with the enchanting verses that came to him. The same year as the mentioned 38:41 As the mention witch hunt was taking place, an oracle near Miletus on the southeast coast of Asia Minor indicated to Diocletian that the god Apollo was being hindered in communicating his foretelling of future events due to those called the righteous of the earth. Accordingly, Diocletian ordered the pulling down of churches, the burning of their books, and the banning of Christian worship. 39:10 access to law courts would be banned for those failing the loyalty test to the roman state that is a simple sacrifice to the god pages thirty two and thirty three the surviving church in time the persecuted christian clergy bishops priests became more street savvy 39:30 In time, the persecuted Christian clergy, bishops, priests became more street savvy in avoiding the loyalty test of pagan sacrifice. Many opted to go into hiding in the desert rather than to be unnecessarily martyred. As for those who got caught, imprisonment became their penalty more commonly than execution, especially if they were able to hand over their religious books. In this way, many irreplaceable Christian documents were lost to history as the 40:00 host for sparing Christian lives. But such traitorous Christian priests in North Africa and Numidia, modern Tunisia, Algeria and Morocco, who avoided standing up for their Christian faith through a glorious martyr's death, were relieved of their sacred priestly powers. Also, lapsed laymen similarly had to do extreme penance in order to be 40:29 readmitted in order sorry in order to be readmitted also a lapsed layman similarly had to do extreme penance in order to be readmitted to the salvic salvic membership salvic membership of the church remember that 40:52 salvation was only for those in the church excursions punished with excommunication were cast outside this safety net while the followers of the zealous priest 41:05 donatus of north africa were not willing to forgive those priests who unlike themselves had recanted under pressure the roman catholic church ruled that it was the office of priesthood that merited the honor of spiritual priestly powers and not the holiness or purity of the individual priest who held that office thus a lapsed christian 41:27 even a priest could return to the Roman Church pages 37 to 41 compare the ruling by Prophet Muhammad living in the tough 7th century tribal pagan Arabian society that the saving of life is to take precedence over submitting to probable martyrdom for one's faith in the one God as long as one has not 41:54 in fact given up his belief in the one God we can infer that a pressing need for political control in church affairs came to take precedence over ideological purity that is truth was or would become as it needed to be the example of Jesus whether in ideological realms i.e. monotheism or in behavioral ones i.e. a non-violent settling of intramural controversy as in the 42:24 Donatus affair took a backseat to the survival of the Christian institution now immersed in power politics. For the sake of its public credibility, the church institution was under pressure to regularize its stated ideology or creedal belief system. By 310 CE, the terror campaign of Diocletian was 42:47 generalized to include christian laymen as well as clergy even in the western empire britain spain france germany where an army officer from the eastern danube dalmatia yugoslavia area had become second in command uh constantius i had no stomach for such persecution constantius the first had no stomach for such persecution it would be his son constantine brought up in 43:17 diocletian's court and a companion on the emperor's military campaigns who would be named at 32 years of age as western emperor when diocletian abdicated for reasons of poor health the emperor of the east soon fell deathly ill and called of the persecution of the christians proclaiming it a failure and asking the christians to pray for his health and that of the state 43:45 pages 37 to 44 passing the scepter passing the scepter the competition between east and west for supreme rome roman power was soon to be settled when the new western emperor constantine marched on rome against his rival maxentium constantine an enlightened pagan believed in a supreme god in particular the unconquered son sol invictus sol invictus 44:16 in the commonly spoken roman language latin the sun god was a popular roman deity the sun god was a popular roman deity whose biography had numerous elements similar to today's familiar christian celebration surrounding jesus supposed birthday on december 25th i.e christmas as well as his resurrection from the dead i.e easter on sun 44:43 day, now the Christian weekly day of worship. Furthermore, Constantine had taken an interest in a second minority religion, having acquired a Christian counselor, Bishop Josius of Cordoba, Spain. Page 44. The key players were now in place and some watershed events. 45:05 were about to happen constantine and his soldiers were en route to rome when they reported witnessing in the sky a cloud pattern or a solar halo in the shape of the christian symbol the two greek letters one imposed on the other with the visual instructions by this sign you will conquer said to have been confirmed shortly thereafter in a night dream which bishop 45:32 Hoseus validated for Constantine as genuine and in which he reported Jesus Christ himself showing him the Christian emblem. Constantine ordered his army to replace their old pagan symbology with a new insignia and interwining of the first two letters of the name Christ. 46:00 and interwining of the first two letters of the name Christ sure enough it seemed to Constantine divine providence had arranged for the failure in strategy divine providence had arranged for the failure in strategy of Constantine's unpopular rival and for the victory of Constantine in the West 313 CE he already had a strong ally in the East 46:31 Licinius, who however subsequently in 316 CE had to be fought in the First Holy War to secure the survival and expansion of Christianity with the final defeat of Constantine's opponent in Asia Minor, 324 CE, pages 44 and 45. Roman paganism was clearly decadent and Christianity now had the potential to be the unifying force and the new face of a revitalized Roman Empire. 47:01 But unification would be hard-won already. The theological descent of Arius in intellectually astute Alexandria had been referred to an Egypt-wide church council where Arius was ruled out of order and expelled from his church. With the support of Arius' allies in Palestine, Syria, and Asia Minor, the Aryan controversy went regional. Local attempts at force backfired and it was clear to... 47:28 constantine that he must take a command in order to bring about the need or the needed conflict resolution predictably he sent his trusted advisor bishop hosius of cordova to investigate pages 46 and 47. constantine's church patronage when in 30 when in 325 ce hosius arrived in alexandria 47:53 with Constantine's letter pleading for accord within the religion that was to be a universally unifying force. Bishop Alexander of Alexandria had already been bombarded with affirmations of support for Arius, a Libyan known for his personal purity, from influential Eastern bishops in Nicomedia, Bithynia, Asia Minor, Tyre, Lebanon, Caesarea, Palestine. 48:23 where regional bishops had met and pronounced aries to be orthodox or at least within the boundaries of orthodoxy bishop alexander ii had been busy collecting signatures to show that his anti-aryan view was no minority opinion more significant than correct teaching was that neither side was willing to accept the implications of defeat pages 51 59 and 61 for the anti-aryans 48:52 For the anti-Aryans, being a Christian meant that God had sent a savior no less in stature than God himself. For the Aryans, the idea that the Eternal could become a man was to demean God Almighty. At the same time, the Aryans did believe that God had taken on the form of a man without ceasing to be God. Athanasius, Alexander's right-hand man, 49:20 took up the anti-Aryan cause. The anti-Aryans were faced with an impossible paradox. Merging the father and the son meant that the son was not really human or that only his body was human. The personage of Christ had to be wholly human in order to suffer for mankind's sins. Not that in Islam, by contrast, God forgives sin. 49:48 as a result of the sinner's repentance, not as a result of a righteous person suffering punishment in place of the guilty person, and much less God suffering for the sins of disobedient humans. And recall that it was Paul, not Jesus, peace be upon him, who propounded the concept of salvation through belief in the sacrificial death of Christ, that in the Trinity 50:16 The trendiness of such mystery cult ideas in the culture of the age tipped the scales toward Paul's version of the Jesus story. As to the question of Christ's deity, well, wasn't that also clear in the writings of Paul? Now that the Western Church clearly required a supernatural savior, the anti-Aryan bishop Hoseas was ready to join forces with the bishop Athanasius for the sake of national unity and security. 50:43 He prepared to convene councils in anti-Aryan strongholds so as to reverse the decision of previous Aryan-friendly councils. A statement of faith, a loyalty pledge was drawn up. The Lord Jesus Christ was the only begotten Son, not created at all, but the Creator Himself. He was to be considered begotten from the Father, from which we seek refuge in Allah, not created from nonexistence. 51:11 The Son had always existed, being as unchangeable as the Father. The Emerging Creed stated, and the Son was the image of the essence of the Father. This formulation was simply a matter of Greek logic applied to unassailable truth as set out by Paul. Recall not set out by Jesus. 51:33 Whether Aryan or anti-Aryan Christology, i.e. the theological doctrine of the nature of Christ, made Jesus deity, whether created, begotten, born, or adopted into that divine essence. Even Arius had said that Jesus was God, but not true God. Pages 78 and 79. A reported 250 bishops, mostly from eastern areas, arrived at a place called Nicaea. 52:01 Arranged by Emperor Constantine near his palace in Nicomedia, Northwestern Asia Minor, Constantine set for his bishops the task of hammering out a creed agreeable to all the clergy of Christendom. With this as their task, they would have to listen to each other and come to an agreeable wording. 52:30 pages 72 and 75. By trying to define Jesus' relationship to God and to humanity crystallized other concerns as well. One underlying question was this, to what extent were the values and customs of the ancient world still valid guides to thinking and action in a Christian empire? Some Christians among them, Arius and Eusebius of Nicomedia of Nicomedia. 53:00 media. Eusebius of Nicomedia had a stronger sense of historical continuity than others. Those whose ideas and social relationships were still shaped to a large extent by the optimistic ideals and tolerant practices of pagan society and for whom Christianity seemed a natural extension of and improvement on Judaism tended to be Aryans of 53:30 one sword on another. By contrast, the strongest anti-Aryan experience there present as a sharp break with the past. It was they who demanded in effect that Christianity be updated by blaring or even obliterating the long-accepted distinction between the Father and the Son. Pages 73 and 74. The Muslim might wonder whether it ever occurred to the bishops to consider what to us 53:59 may seem obvious if jesus peace be upon was no god but merely a man with the god revealed mission then many complications derived from this struggle today for jesus peace be upon would simply evaporate why seemingly did no one question the authority of paul as setting the pace in theological questions for the fourth century for the fourth century church in fact an early sect of jewish followers of jesus called the 54:29 In fact, an early sect of Jewish followers of Jesus, peace be upon them, called Ebionites, did reject Paul and his teachings outright, considering him a corrupter of Jesus' teachings. This group is earliest mentioned in our existing records in the 2nd century CE. It would seem that the acceptance of Paul had been under attack in the 2nd century. 54:54 it would seem that the acceptance of Paul had been under attack in the second century since the Ebionites took such a strong position and since around the same time at the other end of the spectrum from the Ebionites came the followers of Marcion of Sinope Marcion of Sinope 85 to 160 CE whose hero was Paul whose scriptures were restricted to the letters of Paul 55:23 the Acts of the Apostles, where Paul is highlighted, and the Gospel of Luke, whose author was presumed to be the same as that of the Acts, all of these being writings included in the NT. Is it possible that Paul had successfully steered Jews away from the Jesus movement by refitting it with the new doctrines repulsive to Jews but attractive to pagan new Jews? 55:52 to pagan non-Jews. Paul's Christ, the deified Jesus, was a violation of strict Jewish monotheism. A deified Jesus would naturally put off Jews from following the human Jesus, peace be upon him, as their messianic prophet. By the 4th century, Paul's adoption into the corpse of genuine apostles of Jesus was secure. It would appear, except on the part of marginal voices like the 56:21 It would appear except on the part of marginal voices like the Ebionites. Paul's teaching provided real philosophical meat. Moreover, one could get caught up in the spiritual rupture of mystical union with the spiritualized figure called Christ. The Jewish scripture was not needed except as an historical anchor in human affairs. Even if its law, Torah, was obsolete, 56:50 For Christians, this ancient collection of writings, now to be called the Old Testament OT, was claimed as a Christian book, to which the New Testament NT was eventually added to make up the Bible found in its various forms in bookshops today, all reflecting the results of these theological fights. Constantine's Church In fact, 57:19 the roman world was moving on from the historical jesus and his original message to ben israel which must have looked inappropriate to pagan non-jews in this new environment metaphors counted as literal truth mythological figures were strongly enough to win military contests and thanks to precedence set by constantine by his son cons 57:42 constantius the second and by their successors the opportunity to play the leading role in this emerging project of civilizing humankind under the roman banner was not to be missed by the church still practical logic stood in the way from the perspective of our time it may seem strange to think of aryan heretics as conservative but emphasizing jesus humanity and god's transcendent otherness had never seemed heretical in the east 58:11 On the contrary, subordinating the son to the father was a rational way of maintaining one's belief in a largely unknowable, utterly singular first cause while picturing Christ as a usable model of human moral development. For young militants like Athanasius, however, ancient modes of thought and cultural values were increasingly irrelevant. Greek humanism and rationalism were shallow. 58:39 Greek humanism and rationalism were shallow. Judaism was an offensive anti-Christian faith, and while admirable figures like the hermit Antony could try to perfect themselves in the desert, most people's primary need was the need for security. Only a strong God, a strong church, and a strong empire could provide helpless humans with the security they craved. 59:06 Constantine would give his church the structure it needed, the Roman virtues of law, order, and efficient administration. Page 75. Constantine saw himself as a facilitator in the proceedings of the church councils which he convened and attended. He did not hesitate to offer conciliating suggestions. How could Jesus be divine and yet subordinate in some way to the Father? Constantine, or perhaps it was his personal advisor, Bishop. 59:35 Osios of Cordova suggested that the son and the father shared the same essence. In Greek, homo osios, the Muslim can all but hear the verses of the Quran echoing objection to the creedal formulations proposed and countered. Verily in the sight of Allah, the nature of Jesus is as the nature of Adam. Surah Ali Imran, chapter 3, verse 59. 60:04 ought beside him although he forgives any lesser sin unto whomsoever he wills for he who ascribes divinity to ought beside allah has indeed contrived an awesome sin surah nisa chapter 4 verse 48 and lo allah said o jesus son of man did this thou say unto men worship me and my mother as deities besides allah this is answered limitless art thou limitless art thou in thy glory limitless art thou 60:34 In thy glory it would not have been possible for me to say what I had no right to say. Surah Al-Ma'idah, chapter 5, verses 116 and 117. Say he is the one God, God eternal, the uncaused cause of all that exists. He begets not, and neither is he begotten, and there is nothing that could be compared with him. Surah Al-Ikhlas, chapter 112, verses 1 to 4. By this stage, however, no... 61:04 participating party is seen to have adhered to a simple one god creed monotheism or jesus only policy of religious teaching paul was acknowledged interpreter of jesus and even the aryans subscribed to the pagan greek view that jesus was god in some sense or another no one was seen to argue for sticking to the words of jesus alone as arbitrator in this controversy 61:27 Under the influence of Paul, the religion of Jesus became focused on Jesus' death, his resurrection, rising from the dead, and the taking up of Jesus. The message of Jesus became a museum piece, but thank God we still have some account of the story and saying of Jesus in the gospel books of the New Testament by which to measure the gravity of Paul's departure from Jesus' message. 61:55 Recall that Arius had taken the position that Jesus was God, but not true God. For Arius to say that Jesus was the Logos, the Word, who was with God in the beginning and was God, Gospel of John 1.1, was to make a metaphorical statement. The word that God spoke was an aspect or activity of God such that the power given to the Son by the Father was done by a superior to a subordinate. 62:24 Even to say that Jesus had been pre-existent with God simply meant that Jesus' role had been pre-planned by the creator. Jesus was still part of the creator order, not part of the creator. Page 79. Creating a unifying creed. The anti-Aryans wanted to construct a creed that the Aryans could not interpret in their own heretical, i.e. metaphorical manner. A creed that would be a test of their own orthodox, i.e. correct anti-Aryan faith. The Greek term, 62:54 homo ocs in english same essence or uh con or or con substantiality or consubstantiality was a philosophical expression not a biblical one hardline aryans could not sign on but some aryans agreed to accept it after all it could be interpreted to mean not only same homo essence or ocs 63:19 but a whole range of semantic nuances as used by philosophers essence substance reality being or type the concealed argument of the aryan party was that if human beings are made in god's image as the biblical book of genesis chapter 1 verse 27 stated then aren't all human beings including jesus of the same type as is god the emperor constantine had suggested this term homo 63:48 Osseous so for the time being it would stand the son was begotten from the Osseous of the father. The creed propounded and formalized at Nicaea. The Nicaean creed however added in contradictions to the Aryans that the son was through God from through God of the Aryan bishops all but to both Libyans signed under pressure from Constantine. 64:13 hoping to settle once and for all an orthodox doctrine that could be standardized throughout his empire. The two dissenters were immediately relieved of their offices. The Aryans who signed under Durres would later try to justify their compliance with alternative interpretations, pages 79 to 84. After the force agreement in 325 at the Council of Nicaea, mutual consultation to the extent that it had 64:41 ever worked would no longer be possible. A malicious spirit of conflict had been set in motion, Aryans had been demonized, and Constantine's use of pressure had set a permanent precedent. The Quran reinforces the definiteness of this mindset. And so we have cast enmity and hatred among the followers of the Bible. 65:11 i.e. literally their book, to last until Resurrection Day. Surah An-Nisa, chapter 5, verse 64. Constantine celebrated the end of the Council of Nicaea with a spectacular banquet in which he assured the attending churchmen of his commitment to the advancing Christianity in his empire, as he soon thereafter... 65:32 As he soon thereafter wrote to them, their collective decision was from God and free from error. Page 89. This doctrine of the present Roman Catholic Church in regard to its inerrancy. 65:50 apparently has its precedent in Constantine. Constantine's forgiveness and reinstatement of excommunicated Aryans was soon forthcoming, but lack of consensus on basic theological issues, belief about the innovated God nature of Jesus, peace be upon him, would continue. Administrative organization was thus hindered and regional authorities went on functioning independently when Rome claimed the right to control the council of bishops eastern 66:17 Churches became less and less able to come to a consensus with the West. Their separation steadily increased but would not come in its eventual final definitive form, the Great Schism, until the 11th century, pages 84 and 86. Sex and Church Politics Sex and Church Politics Emperor Constantine's quest for peace and harmony was shattered by family intrigues and political challengers, which he handled brutally. Therewith, 66:47 Bishop Hosius returned to Spain, leaving Constantine without a skilled anti-Aryan advisor. Next, Constantine's obsession with sexual purity would give weight to the concepts of celibacy for clergy and the male domination of women found in earlier Christian writings. His was in stark contrast to Jewish tradition where most sexual pleasures were harmless or good, provided they were in moderation under the regime of reason. Page 96. 67:17 and all of this would play into the Aryan controversy . Sex and politics were enlisted in the bid to correct or to win the theological context. Roman subjects were accustomed to hear of sexual hijinks and tragedies among members of the imperial elite at court matters of state where 67:39 Often family matters, but the ruling class now included bishops and other zealous Christians dedicated to or obsessed with ideals of sexual purity. Almost inevitably, disputes over religious issues took on a sexual cast. It was not enough to call one's opponent a bad Christian or a heretic. He must also be a seducer, a rapist, or a frequenter. 68:03 of prostitutes this tendency to sexualize conflicts added an intensity and potential for violence that made them even more difficult to resolve similarly a practice had grown up of dedicating female virgins to the church widows were expected to remain con con continent and lifelong virginity was considered a holy state christian 68:29 Marriage without sexual intercourse was also valued, yet clergymen were not expected to remain celibate. Priests usually married in the 4th century. Celibacy was recommended for bishops, but many bishops were also married. In one celebrated case, a Libyan priest nominated to be bishop of Potol Limes. 68:56 told the bishop of alexandria that he would not accept unless he could continue to have intercourse with his wife i shall not be separated from her he wrote nor shall i associate with her surreptitiously like an adulterer i desired and pray to have virtuous children evidently his request was granted this uncertainty about the sexual code applicable to the clergy reflected more 69:19 general ambiguity that troubled ordinary christians as well what did it mean to live as a righteous christian in a post pagan society the second century bishop clement of alexandria expressed this ideal in extreme terms our christian ideal is not to experience desire at all pages 93 to 95. the recommendation of paul probably weighed heavy in the direction that church that the church took regarding sex bible 69:47 First letter of Paul to the Corinthians, chapter 7, page 38. So the man who marries or lets his daughter get married or get married does well, but the one who does not marry or doesn't let his daughter get married does even better. Sexual abstinence would become a major struggle, reminiscent of Paul's above advice, as admitted by the 4th, 5th century Augustine of Hippo prison day, Anaba, Algeria in North Africa. 70:16 book now commonly available as the confessions of saint augustine 397 to 394 ce rubin stein page 96. by contrast we are reminded of the words of prophet uh uh muhammad which marriage and family are the default and most biased state of affairs the companion annas ibn malik narrates that allah's messenger said when a man marries he has fulfilled half of the 70:46 religion then let him fear Allah regarding the remaining half." Christians, of course, have been the perennial symbols among human kind of personal and religious contradictions, especially as manifested in the incongruity of strict sexual code versus actual behavior and of the paradoxical theology that this has inspired in Christianity. The two sides in the Aryan controversy as 71:14 relevant to the questions of sexual code can be characterized as follows. Thus, the contradiction, men and women had a new sense of the power to perfect themselves, but most were unable to exercise it. The mind, wrote Augustine of Hippo, orders itself to will. It would not give the order unless it willed it, yet it does not obey the order. While Aryans tended to... 71:39 emphasize people's potential to follow the moral example of Jesus. Anti-Aryans like St. Augustine focused on their continued self-enslavement, which implied the need for a Christ who was God. Only God could liberate his people from the crushing forces of habit and concupiscence. Only a Christ who was God. 72:02 could forgive them, even if they remained helpless sinners. For both sides in the controversy, sex had become the dominant symbol of the power and weakness of the human will. The lack of consensus between Aryans and anti-Aryans opened the door for political challenges to finish off the opponent. For the parties in the Aryan controversy, the result was 72:33 to privilege negative statements and punish affirmative ones. While it was safe to criticize an opponent's ideas, presenting one's own theology in any detail was dangerous. Arius had paid the price of speaking too clearly in the banquet in which he seemed to imply that Jesus was essentially a creature like other creatures. You state theus. 73:00 of Antioch exemplified the opposite danger, for he insisted that homo osseous meant Christ and God were one and the same, and one and the same individual reality or person, hypostatus. This made it seem that Jesus was merely an attribute or activity of God. On this point, most of 73:31 the eastern bishops were inclined to accept that while the father and the son were in agreement on everything they were two distinct realities that could not and should not be merged page ninety nine eustatius 73:47 tried to defend himself against the charge of Sabellianism, i.e. that God and Jesus were simple aspects of or names for the same individual reality, by arguing that Christ had a human nature too, but he insisted passionately and confusingly that the two natures were entirely separate and different. God himself, he argued, could not have suffered on the cross. Therefore, when Jesus declared the Father is greater than I, 74:13 When he maintained the Father only and not the Son, knows the date of the last judgment. And when he said, Why do you call me good? No one is good but God alone. All Aryan proof text, it was Jesus the man, talking not Jesus the son of God. This was a brave attempt to formulate a doctrine of Christ's dual nature. But the result was to turn Jesus into a kind of schizoid creature. 74:42 schizoidous creature a fallible vulnerable human personality attached but how to an omniscient omnipotent timeless god personality this doctrine would not provide much protection against a determined aryan assault pages 63 99 and 100 again a proper concept of prophethood would have come in real handy for settling the aryan controversy 75:10 Again, a proper concept of prophethood would have come in real handy for settling the Aryan controversy, but instead these two parties would continue to duel to the death of the other. Cold calculations versus WWJD. While the Aryan charges and counter charges were being readied, there were accusations regarding the corruption of bishops and their immoral behavior. 75:38 suggesting a culture of personal feuds as well as the fluctuation of ethical standards. Next, this would escalate into allegation of treason. The upper hand at church council was always sought where the tide of clerical opinion would swing back and forth between Aryan and anti-Aryan parties. There would never be lasting compromise. Bishops were unseated. 76:02 than reinstated, according to their party affiliation. Brutality was commonly employed on both sides, quite unbecoming for churchmen. Mutual personal attacks intensified, pages 100 and 102. Perhaps such behavior should be seen as common human reaction due to lack of respectful brotherly handling of disagreement, or perhaps as a natural jealousy or envy when one's opponent has the 76:31 heir of the imperial patron who had made known his favor for the Christian faith just then emerging from state persecution but not the precedent for such cold and calculating deportment toward one's brothers in faith as found in the writings of Paul just 76:52 at the time when paul as an outsider was working his way into the true apostolic leadership of the jesus movement which included peter james and john in jerusalem in new testament the letter of paul to the galatians 1 16 to 19 chapter 1 16 to 19 chapter 2 verses 1 to 14 but god 77:16 When he decided to reveal his son to me, I did not go to anyone for advice, nor did I go to Jerusalem to see those who were apostles before me. Instead, I went at once to Arabia, and then I returned to Damascus. It was three years later that I went to Jerusalem to obtain information from Peter, and I stayed with him for two weeks. 77:45 It was three years later that I went to Jerusalem to obtain information of Peter, and I stayed with him for two weeks. I did not see any other apostle except James, the Lord's brother. Fourteen years later, I went back to Jerusalem because God revealed to me that I should go. In a private meeting with the leaders, I explained the gospel message that I preached to the Gentiles. I did not want my work in the past or in the present to be a failure, pretending to be 78:14 fellow believers these men slipped into our group as spies in order to find out about the freedom we have through our union with Christ Jesus but those who seem to be the leaders I say this because it makes no difference to me that they were made no they were that they were made no new suggestions to me James Peter and John who seemed to be the leaders where Peter came to Antioch I opposed him 78:45 in public because he was clearly wrong paul was claiming his own right to leadership even when he who had never met jesus disagreed with the actual apostles that is jesus disciples after they had been mentored for years by jesus peace be upon it would be difficult to argue that paul's attitude jived with jesus fear of god bible matthew chapter 5 verse 8 and 44 happy 79:15 are the pure in heart they will see god but now i tell you love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you bible matthew 4 verses 9 to 11 all this i will give you the devil said if you kneel down and worship me then jesus answered go away satan the scripture says worship the lord your god and serve him serve only him then the devil left 79:44 Jesus and angels came and helped him. The popular modern Christian maxim, What Would Jesus Do?, abbreviated as WWJD, is used by Christians as a reminder to gauge themselves as how to best imitate Jesus. 80:06 Congratulations to them for responding to pattern their behavior after their prophet. Our applause also to the many Christians who have throughout history or through history doubted the divinity of Jesus and his corollary, the doctrine of the Trinity, since these are not teachings of Jesus. Why then is it not also common for Christians to question Paul's credentials? Is it because Paul's writings have been legitimized as part of the New Testament canon since the mid... 80:35 4th century CE and because Christians claim the New Testament as God's word even though there has been an endless number of reformers who have questioned almost everything else in church history. Surely the Quran and Prophet Muhammad are the corrective to endless controversies and to the contradictions created by adding fine print to monotheism. In the coming third installment, inshallah we continue the sequel. 81:05 to the Aryan controversy and the heritage left to the modern-day Christian. The fact that books still come out in fresh attempts to explain the doctrine of the Trinity, not to mention the fact that theologically unsophisticated simple Bible-reading Christians today still have very much an Aryan view of Jesus, both suggest that the Church has not satisfied the simple Christian as to the legitimacy of their theological exploits across the centuries. 81:37 Another footnote Bible references are translations from the American Bible Society American Bible Society's Good News Bible Today's English Version 1979, Nelson, New York And yet they assert Allah has taken 82:07 Unto himself a son, limitless is he in his glory. Self-sufficient is he. Unto him belongs all that is in the heavens and all that is on earth. No evidence whatever have you for this assertion. Would you ascribe unto Allah something which you cannot know? Say, verily they who attribute their own. 82:36 lying in vengeance so allah will never attain to a happy state or we never attain a happy state surah eunus chapter 10 verses 68 and 69 it is inconceivable that the most gracious should take unto himself a son not one of all the beings that are in the heavens or on earth appears before the most gracious other than as a servant 83:05 Surah Maryam chapter 19 verses 92 and 93 The Annunciation in the Quran Indeed Allah has chosen Adam and Noah and the family of Abraham and the family of Imran above the people of all the world. They are descendants one of another and Allah is all-hearing, all-knowing. Behold, the wife of Imran said, My Lord, I have indeed dedicated to you. 83:32 what is in my belly, to be solely devoted to your service. So accept this from me, for it is you who are the all-healing, the all-knowing. So when she delivered her, she said, My lord, I have indeed delivered her a female, and Allah knows best what she had delivered. And my lord, she said, the male is not like the female as to service in the high temple. 84:00 Yet I have named her Mary, and I do indeed seek refuge for her in you and for her children from Satan the accursed. And so it was that her Lord accepted Mary with goodly acceptance and caused her to grow wholesomely in the years of her growing. And he entrusted her in the temple to the foster care of Zechariah. 84:24 Whenever Zechariah entered upon her place in the sanctuary, he found her with provisions. He said, O Mary, from where does this come to you? She said, It is from Allah. Indeed, Allah provides for whomever he so wills without measure. Then and there, Zechariah called upon his Lord. He said, My Lord, grant me from your bounty wholesome children. Indeed, you are the hearer of prayer. 84:49 then the angels called out to him as he stood offering his prayer in the sanctuary allah indeed gives you glad tidings of a son who shall be named john yahya confirming the revelation of word from allah and he shall be an honored leader and abstinent and a prophet from among the 85:11 Righteous, he said, my Lord, how shall I have a boy when old age has already come upon me and my wife is barren? He said, so shall it be. Allah does whatever he so wills. He said, my Lord, appoint for me a sign that this will be. He said, your sign is that you shall not be able to speak to people for three days except by gesture. Yet remember your Lord much with reverence. Yet remember your Lord much with reverence and exalt him in the evenings. 85:40 and the mornings. And behold, the angel said, O Mary, indeed Allah has chosen you and purified you, and He has chosen you above all the women of the world. O Mary, be ever devoutly obedient to your Lord, and bow your face down to the ground before Him, and bow with those who bow in prayer. O Muhammad, this is of the tidings of the unseen past that we reveal to you, for you were not with them when they cast their 86:07 to resolve which of them would have the foster care of Mary. And you were not with them when they were contending for this honor. Behold, the angel said, O Mary, indeed Allah gives you glad tidings of a son brought into being by a word from him. His name is the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, imminent in this world and the hereafter and of those brought near to Allah. And he shall speak to people of heavenly guidance while in the cradle. 86:36 and in the prime of manhood and he shall be of the righteous she said my lord how shall i have a son when no human being has touched me he said so shall it be allah creates whatever he souls when he decrees a matter he but he but says to it be and so it is moreover he shall teach him the skill of writing with regard to the divine law and the wisdom of prophethood and the torah and the 87:06 evangel and appoint him as a messenger to the children of israel to say truly i have come to you with a sign of my commission from your lord that i indeed form for you from the mud of the earth a bird-like figure then i bow then i blow into it and so it becomes a bird by law's permission i heal the born blind i heal the born blind 87:30 and the leper and i give life to the dead by allah's permission and i tell you what no person knows of what you eat and of what you store up in your houses indeed in this 87:41 there is a sure sign for you if indeed you are believers. And I am to confirm what has preceded me of the commandments of the Torah and to make lawful for you some of what has been previously prohibited to you. I have come to you with a sign of my truth from your Lord. So fear Allah and obey me. Indeed, Allah is my Lord and your Lord. So worship him alone. This is a straight way to salvation. 88:07 But when Jesus discerned from them resolute unbelief, he said to his followers, Who will be my supporters on the path of Allah? The disciples said, We are the supporters of the religion of Allah. We have indeed believed in Allah. So bear witness that we are indeed Muslims in willing submission to Allah alone. 88:29 our lord we have believed in the revelation that you have sent down to jesus and we have followed him as the messenger you sent to us so inscribe us among those who bear witness to your oneness now they 88:43 who disbelieved had devised a plan to kill Jesus, but Allah had devised a plan, and Allah is the best of all those who plan. Behold, Allah said, O Jesus, indeed I shall take your soul, and I shall lift you up to me, and I shall cleanse you from the defilement of all those who disbelieve in you. Moreover, I shall place those who follow you and confirm your message above those who disbelieve until the day of resurrection. 89:10 Then to me alone shall be the return of all of you, and I shall judge between you regarding that wherein you have been disputing. Then, as for those who disbelieve, I shall torment them with a severe torment in the life of this world and in the hereafter. And for them there shall not be any helpers against Allah's punishment. But as for those who believe in Allah and do righteous deeds, He shall render them their rewards in full. Yet Allah does not love the wrongdoers. 89:40 This account that we recite to you, O Muhammad, is among the signs of your prophethood and a confirmation of the truth of this Quran, the all-wise reminder for all humanity. Indeed, the likeness of the creation of Jesus with respect to Allah is as the likeness of that of Adam. He created him out of dust. Then he said to him, Be, and he was. This is the truth from your Lord regarding Jesus. 90:09 So do not be of those who have doubt about it. Hence, whoever argues with you concerning him after this knowledge has come to you, say to them, Come, let us call upon our sons and your sons and our women and your women and ourselves and yourselves. Then we shall earnestly pray to lay the curse of Allah upon those of us. 90:35 who are liars. Indeed, this is most surely the true narrative regarding Jesus. Nor is there any God but the one God. Indeed, Allah is most surely the overpowering, the all-wise. Yet, if they turn away from this summons, then Allah is assuredly all-knowing of the sowers of corruption. Surah Al-Imran, Chapter 3, Verses 33-63 The Witness of Jesus 91:06 on the day of judgment on a day hereafter allah shall assemble all the messengers and say to them what has been the response of your peoples to you they shall say we have no knowledge of their hearts indeed it is you who are all-knowing of all the realms of the unseen it is then when allah shall say o 91:34 Jesus, Son of Mary, remember my grace upon you and upon your mother, when I aided you with Angel Gabriel, the Holy Spirit, so that you might speak to the people of heavenly guidance while in the cradle and in the prime of manhood, and when I taught you writing and the wisdom of prophethood and the Torah and the Evangel, and when you formed out of mud a bird-like figure by my permission, then you blew into it, 92:04 and behold it became a bird by my permission and when you healed the born blind and the leper by my permission and when you brought forth the dead by my permission and when i withheld the children of israel from killing you when you came to them with clear and miraculous proofs confirming the truth of your message then those who disbelieved from among them said 92:30 this is nothing but manifest sorcery and remember when i revealed to the disciples believe in me and in my messenger jesus they said we believe and bear witness that we are indeed muslims in willing submission to allah alone behold the disciples said o jesus son of mary 92:48 can your lord send down to us a table spread of food as a sign from heaven he said fear allah if indeed you are believers they said we wish to eat from it and for our hearts thereby to repose in full assurance so that we may know with certainty that you have spoken the truth to us and so that we may ourselves be among the elect witnesses to its miracle jesus son of mary said o allah 93:17 Our Lord sent down to us a table spread from heaven to be a feast for us, for the first of us and the last of us, and to be a sure sign from you of my prophethood, and provide for us always for you are the best of providers. Allah said, Indeed, I shall send it down to you, but whoever of you disbelieves thereafter, I will punish him with a punishment such as I shall not punish anyone else with among 93:46 all the people of the world thus it is then on the day of judgment when allah shall say oh jesus son of mary did you say to the people take me and my mother both as gods apart from allah jesus jesus shall say highly exalted are you far above this it was not for me to say what i had no right to say if i had said it then truly you would have known it you know that you know what is in my soul and i do not know what is in yourself 94:16 Indeed, it is you, you alone, who are all-knowing of all the realms of the unseen. I have not said to them other than what you have commanded me. Worship Allah alone, my Lord and your Lord. Moreover, I was witness over them only while I remained among them. Then when you took my soul, you yourself were ever vigilant over them. 94:37 For you are witness over all things. If you torment them, indeed they are your servants. And if you forgive them, indeed it is you who are the overpowering, the all-wise. Allah shall say, This is the day when the truthful shall benefit from their truthfulness. For them are gardens beneath which rivers flow. Therein they shall abide forever and ever. Allah being well pleased with them, and they well pleased with Him. 95:04 That is the magnificent triumph. To Allah alone belongs all dominion over the heavens and the earth. And all that is in them. And He alone is powerful over all things. Surah Al-Ma'idah, verses 109 to 120. Alhamdulillah. Third in a five-part series. Biblical inaccuracy. 95:34 And John 3.16 Lawrence B. Brown The following is a summary of what we have covered to date in this series of articles. Episode 1 The Gospel known as John almost certainly was not written by the disciple John. Episode 2 Bible translators illegitimately capitalized him in John 3.16 for God so loved the world that he 96:05 that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believes in him should not perish but have everlasting life, to make Jesus look like God. Episode 2 Also, the Bible does not stand up to the basic requirements of reliability and hence does not satisfy the standards of sacred scripture. 96:31 The last item in this list, number three, is critical in order to give credence to the claims of John 3.16. The Bible itself has to stand up to critical analysis. It is that analysis that I continue here. The previous article was more scholastic. What follows is more common sense. Let's start with the obvious. If the Bible is the Word of God, then what should we make of verses that tell us they are not the Word of God? 97:00 Paradoxically, this is precisely what we find in 1 Corinthians 7, verse 12. But to the rest I, not the Lord, say, indicating that what follows was from the author, in this case Paul, and not from God. So if nothing else, this section of the Bible, by Paul's own admission, is not the word of God. 1 Corinthians 7, verse 12. 97:30 1.16 points out that Paul could not remember if he baptized anybody other than Crispus, Gaius, and the household of Stephanas. Besides, I do not know whether I baptized any other. Now, does this sound like God talking? Would God say, Paul baptized Crispus, Gaius? 97:59 and the household of Stephanas and there may have been others but that was a long time ago and well you know so much has happened since then it is all kind of fuzzy to me right now 1 Corinthians 7 verses 25 and 26 records Paul as having written now concerning virgins I have no commandment from the Lord 98:24 Yet I give judgment as one whom the Lord in his mercy has made trustworthy. I suppose, therefore, that this is good because of the present distress. Italics mine. I suppose, therefore, that this is good because of the present distress. Italics is mine. 2 Corinthians 11, verse 17 reads, What I speak, I speak not according to the Lord, but as it. 98:56 Again, does anybody believe that God talks like this? Paul admitted that he answered without guidance from God and without divine authority, and that he personally believed himself to be divinely trustworthy in one case, but speaking foolishly in the other. Paul justified his... 99:20 presumption of authority with the words according to my judgment and I think I also have the Spirit of God first Corinthians chapter 7 verse 40 the problem is that a whole lot of people have claimed the Spirit of God while all the time doing some very strange and ungodly things so should Paul's confidence be admired 99:42 or condemned. However, we answer this question. The point is that whereas human confidence wavers at times, such is not the case with the all-knowing, all-powerful Creator. God would never say, I suppose, as Paul does. In essence, the Bible is its own critic. If we view the Bible as a revelation, including telling the story of Jesus Christ, then we have to wonder why it is so inconsistent. For example, when 100:11 celebrities die their final words are frequently immortalized and yet the bible gives us two different accounts of jesus last words luke 23 verse 46 states and when jesus had cried out with a loud voice he said father into your hands i commit my spirit having said this he breathed his last but john 19 30 says something completely different so when jesus had received the sour 100:40 He said, it is finished, and bowing his head, he gave up his spirit. This is a bold and undeniable contradiction. The Lord's Prayer. Jesus' most famous and respected teaching is probably the Lord's Prayer, which Matthew 6, verses 9 to 13 records, As our Father in heaven, hallowed be your name, your kingdom come, your will be done on earth. 101:09 as it is in heaven give us this day our daily bread and give us our debts as we forgive our debtors and do not lead us into temptation but deliver us from the evil one for yours is the kingdom and the power and the glory for ever i mean but luke eleven verses two to five records the same prayer with some very crucial differences 101:36 Our Father in heaven, hallowed be your name, your kingdom come, your will be done on earth as it is in heaven. Give us day by day our daily bread, and forgive us our sins, for we also forgive everyone who is indebted to us. And do not lead us into temptation, but deliver us from the evil one. Jesus Christ's most famous prayer and the two gospel writings that tell the tale disagree. 102:06 Jesus Seminar, a body of prominent biblical scholars announced the only word of the Lord's Prayer that can be directly attributed to Jesus is Father. Newsweek, October 31, 1988, page 80. This conclusion is startling, for it not only shakes one of the most accepted trees, 102:31 in the forest of christian faith but it questions the very trees legitimacy regarding the law jesus taught all testament law furthermore he taught the law would endure till heaven and earth pass away do not think that i came to destroy the law or the prophets i did not come to destroy but to fulfill for assuredly i say to you till heaven and earth pass away one jot greek iota 103:00 One jot, Greek iota, the ninth letter of the Greek alphabet, or one tittle, stroke, or dot, will by no means pass from the Lord till all is fulfilled. Matthew 5, verses 17 and 18. Add to that, but if you want to enter into life, keep the commandments. Matthew 19, 17. So that is what Jesus taught. Now, what did Paul teach? 103:28 Answer, justification by faith. The vain concept that belief in Jesus Christ cancels a person's sins. Paul didn't change just a jot or a tittle. No, he cancelled the entire law and by him, Jesus Christ, everyone who believes and by him. 103:57 Jesus Christ everyone who believes is justified from all things from which you could not be justified by the law of Moses Acts 13 39 and by him Jesus Christ everyone who believes is justified from all things from which you could not be justified by the law of Moses Acts 13 39 a more permissive blanket statement would be hard 104:22 to conceive we can easily imagine the voice of the collective public screaming please let's have more of that and here it is but now we have been delivered from the law having died but now we have been delivered from the law having died i.e suffered to what we were held by so that we should serve in the newness of the spirit and not in the old and the oldness of the letter romans 7 6 104:50 Or if I may freely paraphrase, but now I tell you to forget this old law, the inconveniences of which we have lived with for too long and lived by the religion of our preferences rather than by the old uncomfortable mandates of revelation. According to Paul, God's law was good enough for Moses and Jesus, but not for the rest of humankind. No trinity for Jesus. Punch the skip button. Punch the skip button. 105:20 Nowhere in the Bible did Jesus teach the Trinity. In fact, he taught Tawheed, divine unity or oneness. Read Mark 12.30, Matthew 22.37, and Luke 10.27. The first of all the commandments is, Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one. But presto change. But presto change. All Pauline theologians adopted the Trinity. 105:46 But presto change, O Pauline theologians, adopted the Trinity. So Jesus' most important teachings, his last words, his prayer, the oneness of God and our Creator's law for mankind are all cancelled elsewhere in the Bible by Paul or by Pauline theologians who followed in his wake, which of Jesus' teachings precisely are not contradicted in the Bible. Unreliability is such a common problem. 106:15 indoctrinated audience doesn't know what to believe 2nd Samuel 24 verse reads again the anger of the Lord was aroused against Israel and he moved David against them to say go number Israel and Judah however in 1st Chronicles 21 chapter 21 verse 1 states now Satan stood up against Israel and moved David to number Israel 106:41 Well, which was it, the Lord or Satan? Both verses describe the same event in history, but one speaks of God and the other of Satan. There is a slight as in total difference. If a book of scripture can't differentiate between God and Satan, the only thing we know for sure is that it's not pure, unadulterated revelation. 107:08 There are so many contradictions in the New Testament that authors have devoted books to this subject. For example, Matthew 2.14 and Luke 2.39 differ over whether Jesus' family fled to Egypt or to Nazareth in Palestine. Matthew 6.9-13 and Luke 11.2-4 differ over the wording of the Lord's Prayer. Matthew 11.13-14 107:36 And chapter 17 verses 11 to 13 and John chapter 1 verse 21 disagree over whether John the Baptist was Elijah. Things get worse when we enter the arena of the alleged crucifixion. Who carried the cross? Simon, Luke 23, 26, Matthew 27, 32, Mark 15, 21 or Jesus. 108:04 Who carried the cross, Simon or Jesus? John 19.17 Was Jesus dressed in a scarlet robe? Matthew 27.28 Or a purple robe? John 19.2 Did the Roman soldiers put gold? Matthew 27.34 Or myrrh? Mark 15.23 In his wine? 108:32 Was Jesus crucified before the third hour? Mark 15.25 Or after the sixth hour? John 19.14-15 Did Jesus ascend the first day? Luke 23.43 Or not? John 20.17 These are only a few of a long list of scriptural inconsistencies but they 108:54 underscore the difficulty in trusting the new testament as scripture and if we can't trust the bible as a whole how can we trust any particular part of it like say john 3 16 upon which christians base their salvation copyright 2002 lawrence b brown lawrence b brown is a muslim uh lawrence b brown is a muslim and of the malik an ophthalmic surgeon a retard 109:24 Air Force officer, an ordained interfaith minister, and the author of a number of books of comparative religion and reality-based fiction. His works can be found on his website, www.leveltruth.com.