نص مُفرَّغ آليًا وقد يحتوي على أخطاء، فارجع إلى التسجيل للتحقق من الألفاظ.
0:00 Alhamdulillahi Rabbil Alameen, wa salatu wa salamu ala rasulil kareem, wa ala ali wa sahabi, wa man istannat bi sunnithi ilayhum ad-deen. All praises due to Allah and may Allah's peace and blessings be on the last prophet Muhammad, sallallahu alayhi wa sallam, and on all those who follow the path of righteousness until the last day. We finished off in the previous session the practical for... 0:32 general issues. Now we'll be looking at certain specific targets of dawah and what is necessary for us to know about their belief systems, their arguments, their lines of reasoning, etc. So we'll now begin to look at atheists, deists, 1:04 and agnostics as one group. Then we will look at Christians and then we will look at Hindus in terms of Dawa and how Dawa should be directed towards them. The first group that we are going to look at are the atheists. An atheist technically is one who disbelieves in God. 1:39 no God, no God in existence. A deist is one who believes that God exists, created the world, but thereafter assumed no control over the lives of the people. He created the world and let it run by itself. It didn't communicate to human beings. And the third group, the agnostics, are those 2:15 really who don't know, or one who thinks it is impossible to know whether there is a God, a future life, or anything beyond the material phenomena. He says, I don't have enough evidence to say there is no God, nor do I have enough evidence to say there is a God. And Sir Aldous Huxley... 2:45 is the first one in 1869 to coin this term agnostic so if we start with the worst case scenario that is the individual who does not believe there is a God his approach basically is to address believers as fanatics people who believe in God 3:24 Based on blind faith. Blind faith. Not logic and reason, but blind faith. Whereas his or her disbelief, atheism, is based on reason, logic. That's how they usually present it. However, in dealing with atheists, we need to establish the point to them. 3:57 that belief in God is in fact logical and reasonable and that it is the disbelief in God which is illogical and unreasonable and based on blind faith. We turn the tables around. How? First and foremost, we can point out to them that if belief in God 4:29 was illogical. Then the founders of logic. Who are the people who are referred to as the founders of logic? In ancient times, the Greeks. The laws of logic were written down by the Greeks. Not to say that they really invented logic. Maybe there were people before who knew it, who used it, etc. But they wrote it down. They wrote it down as a system, like a mathematical system. Logic. 5:07 a equals b if a equals b and b equals c therefore a must equal c and so on and so forth right this is they had a whole system that they worked out the greeks they were known for their logic inventors of logic so how is it then that plato and aristotle the leading thinkers amongst the greeks concluded 5:40 using logic and reason that there must be a God. Plato and Aristotle both held the position that there must be a God. So if it was so logical and reasonable not to believe in God, then how did they get there? So we're saying then that, in fact, logic and reason should take you to the belief in God. And let me stress, 6:20 That wherever people go in the world, whatever generation we look at, civilization, backwards or modern, all of the vast majority of people believe in God. The vast majority of people believe in God. So we could say in our terminology by Ijma. 6:53 by Ijma, the consensus of human beings in this world, they believe in God. Those who don't believe in God have always been a very small minority. Always been a very small minority. And in fact, the believers, the people who hold that there is a God, being the majority, 7:32 indicate by their majority that the belief in God is something natural it is something natural because the natural things that we do are things that you find people doing everywhere the learned things things that we learn by nurture we will find them in some places and not in others 8:06 This is an argument that anthropologists, sociologists have. The argument between nature and nurture. They say, what is natural? What are you born with? And what are the things that you learn? You're born with a desire to eat. But you learn the types of food to eat, how to eat, the knife and fork or whatever, a spoon or... 8:37 These are the things you learn, but you don't have to learn to eat. You don't have to learn to want to eat. This is something we are naturally born with, nature. So they have classified many of the things that we do in these two categories, nature and nurture. Belief in God, traditionally anthropologists classify that as nurture. 9:08 We believe in God because the society we're born in believes in God and it's something inherited. We're taught this. It's not something natural. However, some British scientists looking at the Ijma of human society, studying societies of the past and the present, ancient, modern, primitive, all over the world, they found people having this belief. 9:38 God they posited some years back that perhaps belief in God was natural of course when they made this suggestion they were laughed out of the scientific conferences that they made the proposal in scientists scoffed at it you know this is nonsense you know who would dare to say this after so many years of believing that it was by 10:08 Freud and Durkheim and other psychiatrists and sociologists had already explained where the belief in God came from, from certain human complexes and all this kind of stuff. How could somebody come around now and say it's natural? Well, they argued, but it's everywhere. And this is the sign of it being natural. Anyway, what happened following that was 10:37 In 1997, scientists at the University of California, neuroscientists, studying the brains of people who had abnormalities in their brain activity, people who had seizures and strokes and these kind of things. They were studying the brains of different people, living people. 11:10 probing, testing, recording data, etc., at University of California at San Diego, they discovered that there was a portion in the brain, in the frontal lobe, which, whenever this was stimulated, or whenever people had religious experiences, it was stimulated, it seemed that 11:38 It was the focal point of religious belief. Meaning that if they had a seizure and the seizure affected this part of their brain, they would feel this overwhelming consciousness of God and feeling about God and things like this. And when they asked people in experiments to... 12:05 you know pray and to go into religious fervor and that they found that that is the part of the brain that was became active so from that they concluded that there was a god spot in the brain that the human brain was hot wired that's how they put it hot wired for the belief in god this article is in your notes this is scientific fact this is not uh 12:34 hearsay stories which is passed around the internet huh it's a scientific fact so what you find there is that this supports the Islamic contention that human beings are born with a natural belief in God and this is found in surah an hour off verses 172 and 173 13:05 where Allah said there, وَإِذْ أَخَذَ رَبُّكَ مِنْ بَنِي آدَمَ مِنْ ذُهُورِهِمْ ذُرِّيَتَهُمْ وَأَشْهَدَهُمْ عَلَىٰ أَنفُسِهِمْ أَلَسْتُ بِرَبِّكُمْ قَالُوا بَلَا شَهِدْنَا When your Lord drew forth from the loins of the children of Adam, their descendants, and made them testify concerning themselves, saying, Am I not your Lord? They all said, 13:34 Yes, we testify to it. And every human being who would come on the face of this earth, already in the spiritual form, testified to God's existence. And that is why Prophet Muhammad said, كل مولود يولد على الفطرة Every child is born with a natural belief in Allah. Right? So, the argument that belief in 14:07 God is natural, is supported by scientific evidence, and we have it supported also from our perspective by revelation. But coming back to the logical arguments for the belief in God. Plato, in arguing for the belief in God, used the basic argument of the Quran. That is, 14:36 Design indicates the designer. That is the basic argument, most common argument used in the Quran. Design indicates the designer. That wherever you find design, there has to be a designer behind it. That is the norm. That is where our minds go. When we're walking on the beach and we see a footprint in the sand, 15:08 we do not stop to reflect on how amazing it is that the tide came in and the water sunk into the stand and made a footprint. We automatically assume that somebody walked there before us. That is natural. Design indicates a designer. The ancient Arabs used to refer to it saying that Al-Ba'lah 15:40 That the dung of the camel indicates the camel. When the Bedouin was riding on the desert and he came across some camel dung, he didn't stop to think about how amazing it was that the wind blew the sand into these forms and rain fell on it. 16:08 mixed up with some straw or some leaves, whatever, and you ended up with something looking like camel's dung, no? He automatically assumed that somebody rode by there on a camel, and the camel dropped its dung there. That is the obvious, the obvious, right? Design indicates the designer. So, that led Plato to conclude that since there is design in everything we see in this world, and truly, 16:40 No matter where we look, out in space, inside the atom, in nature around us, water, snow, sand, wherever we look, we just find designs everywhere. Design. So this implies that there must be a master designer who designed everything. And that's what led Plato to conclude that there has to be. 17:10 Allah said in the Quran, أَفَلَا يَنذُرُونَ إِلَى الْإِبْلِ كَيْفَ خُلِقَتْ Will you not look at the camel and how it is created? The camel is specially created in such a way that it will survive on the desert. It saves water in its hump. It has organs in its nostrils. The way its feet are designed. 17:41 to minimize the loss of moisture from its body so it can last for days on the desert. This is special creation, special creation. So this is, Allah calls us to reflect on the design of the camel, that there must be a designer for it, you know, and so on and so forth. So the arguments from design, as we said, is the most common argument used in the Quran. 18:12 What is the response of the atheist to the argument from design? What does he say? What does the atheist say? The design came by itself. They usually say it came by accident. The design came by accident. It was accidental. That if you have enough accidents, that design will happen. Meaning? 18:49 You know, we take a pail of paint and you throw it against the wall. Sometimes when the paint hits the wall, you might find it looks something like a hand. Or it might look something like a head. Or a foot. Or something. It may have something looking something like something else. By accident. If you mix that pail of paint, red, blue, yellow, green, and all the different colors. 19:22 And you threw it against the wall. Do you think that you would ever, by accident or by chance, create the Mona Lisa? You know the Mona Lisa? Very famous painting. The Mona Lisa, smiling woman. If you mix the paint and you threw it one time or two times or three times or a hundred times, do you think you would ever... 19:57 come up with the Mona Lisa? Do you think so? No. Never. It would never happen. The first time you try to do it, the chances of it happening are zero. The same as the last time you tried. It's the same. It's not going to happen. The way they like to put it, the atheists, they say if you put a hundred monkeys in a cage, I don't know if you heard the monkey example before. 20:32 You put a hundred monkeys in a cage and you give them a hundred typewriters and sheets of paper. Let them bang away at the keys with their heads, their noses, sitting on the keys, beating them to their feet and everything. Eventually, if you give them Arabic typewriters, one of them is going to type out the whole Quran for you. If you give them an unlimited amount of time, eventually, one of them is going to type out the whole Quran. Just banging away at those keys. 21:07 What are the chances of that? You say zero. Each time the monkey tries, the chances are zero. No way. What happens when you present this to the atheist, the atheist will say, but mathematicians and scientists, they say that the chance of this happening is one to the minus zero, zero, zero, zero, or maybe they put a million zeros after it. 21:39 But they say, there still is a chance. But they say, there still is a chance. It's very small, virtually zero, but it's still one to the minus zero, zero, zero, zero, zero, zero. So it could still happen, is what they like to say. How do we respond to that? Then we say, no, it could never happen. The mathematicians say... 22:10 It virtually could never happen because there's so many zeros after the minus. No way. But the atheist still says it's still one to the minus zero, zero, zero, zero, zero. So yes, it may be one in ten billion chances or a billion, billion, billion chances. But it's still one. How do you respond to that? How do you respond to that? Well. 22:50 What we say to him is, listen, mathematics is not true science. Mathematics is an approximation that we have placed on objects, etc., to count them, and they serve a purpose to a degree, but they are not absolute truth. Mathematics actually is a theory. 23:26 which applied in many circumstance works because if we take mathematics as the whole truth and nothing but the truth then there is a group of Greek philosophers who held the position that no two objects collide no two objects collide no two things can come in contact with each other 24:01 So, if there was a door here, and you wanted to leave this hall, according to them, you could never walk out this door. Mathematically, how is that? If the distance between here and the door is 100 feet, okay? For you to get through the door, you have to pass through the 50 foot door. 24:35 point, right? The halfway point. Then you have to pass through the 25 foot point, right? Right? Then you have to pass through the 12.5 foot point, right? And then you have to pass through half of 12.5, whatever that is. Huh? I can't hear what you're saying, but anyway, you know what I'm getting at. So after you divide that, 25:06 You have to pass through the halfway point after that and the halfway point after that. And if you put that into a computer, you will never reach zero. What does that mean? If you never reach zero, it means you can never reach the door. Zero is the door. Mathematically, you can never reach the door. But is that real? It's not real. We go through doors all the time. Right? 25:41 We say that because they said one to the minus so and so, this is just numbers. These numbers, this is not real. What's real is that it will never happen. What's real is that we go through the door. But mathematically, yes, you can say there's a possibility. You will never go through the door. Not only possibility, according to mathematics, you will never go through the door. You cannot go through the door. So, we come back to reality. 26:14 Reality is that the chances of design coming from accident systematically throughout the universe, there is no way. Even if you said it happened once by accident, everywhere, everywhere, no, not possible. Absolutely impossible. So this points us back to the designer. 26:48 What you find, of course, what's related to this is the argument, which was mentioned in, I think it was last night's lecture, you know, the argument about the Big Bang, right? Which is the explanation for why we are here now. The Big Bang being an explosion, an accidental... 27:18 explosion no reason for it to explode it just exploded and from that accident from that accident that explosion we have everything that is again we say this is nonsense right this is nonsense because of the fact that explosions don't produce design and order they produce chaos 27:49 a mess. And that was explained, I think, quite graphically for you by Brother Eusebius. I think we've grasped that point. So, the argument of accident and chance is a very weak argument. It is in fact an illogical argument. We say it's illogical. Why? Because if everything around us that has a design is produced 28:22 by a designer, then does it make sense to say that the whole of this system was by accident? No. If everything in the system was chaotic without design, and there was only a few points of design, then yes, you could conclude that the whole system was a product of accident, which accidentally produced a few designs here and there. That's logic. 28:52 What logic tells us is that there had to be a designer for there to be design everywhere. Now Allah SWT in only a couple of verses in the Quran tackles the argument of the atheist from the logical point of creation and created. And this is the line which Aristotle used. 29:27 The Quran in Surah At-Tur, verses 35 and 36 says, أَمْ خُلِقُوا مِنْ غَيْرِ شَيْءٍ أَمْ هُمُ الْخَالِقُونَ أَمْ خَلَقُوا السَّمَوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضِ بَلْ لَا يُوقِنُونَ Were they created from nothing? Or did they create themselves? Or did they create the heavens and the earth? Indeed, they are uncertain. 29:57 Allah gives two possibilities. The third, which is the reality he doesn't mention. He leaves it for us to come to the obvious conclusion. Were they created from nothing? This is the first point to look at. To be created from nothing or by nothing. Logic tells us, no way. We cannot be created from nothing. 30:31 Nothing cannot produce something. Is that reasonable or not? Nothing cannot produce something. Right? Anybody have a doubt about that one? Is that too philosophical? Nothing, if you have nothing, you cannot produce something from that nothing. You must have something to produce something. Right? So, were they created from nothing? No way. 31:06 Were they created by nothing? Because from nothing implies also by nothing. Can nothing create something? No. So that one is ruled out. Go to the other extreme. Or did they create themselves? Is it possible to create yourself? Again, logic tells us, no way. Why? Because to create yourself, you first have to not exist. Isn't it? 31:40 You have to not exist first to create yourself. But if you didn't exist, how could you create yourself? Isn't it? Because then you're gone into the same situation of nothing producing something. Doesn't happen. Right? Is that logical? Is that clear? And these are the two options that Allah gives. Either you were created from nothing, by nothing, or you created yourself. 32:16 So if you were not created by nothing, and you didn't create yourself, then what does that mean? Something created you. That's what's not mentioned in the verse. Something created you. Something created you who was himself not created. That is understood from it. Because if that something was already created, then it would be in the same category as us. 32:49 Created from nothing? Created itself? No. So, that third conclusion is that something uncreated created us. Something uncreated created us. This answers also the question of people who ask, okay, if God created everything, who created God? You have this question coming up, right? Kids sometimes ask it. That question is, 33:26 what we call a nonsensical question. To ask who created God when God is described as being uncreated is a nonsensical question. You understand that? It's nonsensical. If you say God, who is God? God is the one who is uncreated. For you to then ask who created God 34:01 He already said he was uncreated. So how can you ask who created him? It's a nonsensical question. Is that clear? I know this gets a little philosophical here. But is that clear? Have you understood the point here? So, from that verse of the Quran, we have established here that God, who was himself uncreated, created everything. Had to be. 34:34 If a person, an atheist might say to you, okay, God created everything, but that God was himself created, and the God who created him was also created by another God, and that God was created by another God, and so on and so on and so forth, back to when? Is there a point where we start with the first God started the creating of the other God? No, no. It goes on to infinity. No beginning. 35:05 It's the argument, okay? We say to him, okay, if the origins of this world and everything in it is in infinity, right? You can go back in a straight line, this one creator created by another creator by another creator, straight back to infinity. This means that it would take an infinite amount of time to get to this point. You understand that? 35:40 If we can go back to infinity, it would mean that an infinite amount of time would have to pass before we got here. And what does that mean? It means we would never get here. That's the reality. We would never get here. The very fact that we are here now is proof that there had to be a beginning point in time for creation. Had to be. Understand? This is the argument, that issue of... 36:16 creators back to infinity this is how Aristotle rejected it logically that there would be an infinite amount of time to get here therefore we would not get here therefore there has to be in fact a beginning this is some logic right anyway the point is the belief in God as we said is logical and reasonable the atheist after 36:51 being confronted with this logic and reason, then turns to other arguments. What does he say? He says, well, as Brother Yusuf Estes mentioned yesterday, but he didn't give you the answer for it. If your God is so good, you got a good God, right? Your God is good and He's all-powerful, then where did evil come from? Where did evil come from? Did the God create evil? 37:31 Did God create evil? No. Then who created evil? If you say God didn't create evil, then you're saying there's some other creator besides God. That's serious. God created what? God's creation became evil. Did he allow his creation to become evil? Did he allow it? 38:12 But He's a good God. You still got the problem. That's not the answer. That's not the answer. Did God create evil? Huh? Disobedience created evil? Did Allah allow that disobedience? Huh? Free will. But does free will act without Allah's permission? Pardon? We're not talking about why. We're talking about did He? Yes. God created. 38:57 evil. وَهُوَ خَالِقُ كُلِّ شَيْءٍ He created everything. However, what you find in the Quran is that when Allah talks about evil, and also in the Sunnah, Prophet s.a.w. talks about evil relative to Allah, he doesn't attribute it directly to Allah. He says, قُلْ أَعُوذُ بِرَبِّ الْفَلَقِ Say, I seek refuge in the Lord of the dawn. مِنْ شَرِّ مَا خَلَقْ Allah says, 39:31 قُلْ أَعُوذُ بِرَبِّ الْفَلَقِ Say, I seek refuge in the Lord of the dawn. من شَرِّ مَا خَلَقْ From the evil of what He created. He doesn't say من شَرِّ خَلَقْ From the evil He created. But from the evil of what He created. He created this thing and evil came from it. But it is His creation. 40:00 But he doesn't attribute it directly to himself. And this is a part of etiquette in how we deal with Allah. But we're looking here now practically speaking. Yes, evil is a part of Allah's creation. However, how to understand evil? What we explain is that Allah has not created anything which is purely evil. 40:31 Nothing which is purely evil. Everything will have an element of good to it. Everything will have an element of good to it. And it is for that element of good that Allah created it. Do you understand? For that element of good, Allah created that thing. So even Satan. So I say, what about Satan? 41:06 Satan, before he disbelieved in Allah, was he evil? No. Before he disobeyed Allah and disbelieved in Him, he was good. Furthermore, consider, Allah knew before He created Adam and Eve and put them in the garden and forbade them from one tree, He knew that Satan was going to come and trick Him. 41:43 And Adam would eat and Eve would eat from the tree. So, why did Allah create Satan? If Satan hadn't come in the picture, Adam and Eve would have remained in paradise. We all would be in paradise. Finished. No problem. So the question is, why did Allah then create Satan knowing what he was going to do? See, actually for some people, they have a problem with this. I know I spoke with the Jehovah's Witnesses. 42:20 And they claim that Allah didn't know what Satan was going to do. And you have actually some Muslim thinkers like Allama Muhammad Iqbal in his book, The Reconstruction of Islamic Thoughts, written in English. He states in there that Allah does not know the details of the future. He doesn't know the details of the future. He knows the future in general. 42:54 But the details, he doesn't know it until it occurs. That's serious. It's serious. The point is, what we say, is that when Satan tricked Adam, and Adam ate from the tree, what happened? Adam, here, fell into sin. Remember, Adam was a prophet of God. Here, he fell into sin. 43:40 So when we talk about prophets being infallible, it's not infallible in all aspects. Infallible relative to revelation. Not that they were incapable of error. Because that was a big error right there. Wasn't it? Was it or not? When he ate from the tree, was that a sin? It was a sin. Now, when Satan disobeyed God, refused to bow to Adam, did he commit a sin? 44:19 Yes, he committed a sin. Why is Satan considered to be a disbeliever? Why does Allah call him a disbeliever? Huh? Because? Because of his arrogance. Okay, his arrogance, feeling that he was superior to Adam. If you feel arrogant, right? Feeling you're superior to somebody else. Does that make you a disbeliever? Okay, we deal with this one point at a time. 45:03 Because first we said it's because of his arrogance. Feeling he was superior to Adam. Okay, we can say that's error. That's a mistake. That is not kufr. This is not disbelief. So how did he fall into disbelief? He didn't repent. So, if you commit a sin and don't repent, does that make you a disbeliever? From the women? 45:46 Pride? Better take the microphone. I can't hear you, please. He refused to acknowledge his sin. He didn't acknowledge his sin. That's what we said already. He didn't acknowledge his sin. He disobeyed Allah's command. Okay. That's what we're saying here. He disobeyed Allah's command. Adam disobeyed Allah's command. So, Adam is not considered the disbeliever. This is a point of aqeedah. 46:19 Does disobedience make a person a disbeliever? If that is the case, where are all disbelievers in this room? Have none of us disobeyed Allah SWT? Stop and think here. Think. This is an important point of Aqidah. We need to grasp this carefully. Don't rush and say this and say that. Stop and think. 46:50 Don't make a person a disbeliever. Even if you don't repent from the sin, it doesn't make you a disbeliever. This is the belief of the main body of Muslims. You had a group, you know, in the time of Ali, the Khawarij, they took the position that if you commit a major sin, you become a disbeliever. That was their belief. This is not the belief of Ahl al-Sunnah wal-Jamaah. 47:22 The belief of Ahlus Sunnah wa Jama'ah is that sins do not make a person a disbeliever in and of themselves. So Adam committed a sin. Satan, Iblis, committed a sin. We can say, okay, Satan did not repent. Adam repented. But when we say that sins don't make you a disbeliever, it means that if you don't repent from that sin, that is not enough to make you a disbeliever. 47:56 Adam accepted it as a sin? No, again, your explanation is that Adam accepted his sin where Satan didn't accept his sin. That, if you commit a sin and don't accept that it is a sin, does that mean you're going to hell? Forever? As a disbeliever? No. Go ahead, sister. He said that he rejected what Allah said. He said... 48:27 He claimed that he knew better by saying that he was better than Adam. He knew better than? Than Allah. Okay. This is the point of disbelief. When he said, I am better than him, right? That's his pride. That's one issue. But when he said, I am better than him, and Allah instructed him to bow, he refuses to bow saying, I am better than Adam, right? 48:58 What is he saying here? You made a mistake. No, the challenge is after. That's another issue. This is the point here. He is attributing to Allah a mistake. That you shouldn't have asked me to bow to Adam because I'm better than him. This is where the disbelief comes. Because can we attribute mistakes to Allah? No. No. This is where the disbelief comes. 49:32 He attributes to Allah error in his judgment. And now we say he didn't repent from it. That in and of itself was a statement of Kufr. But if he repented from it, it could have removed it from him. Because repentance purifies us from sin. But here is now when the lack of repentance now comes into play. So here is where this belief now is affirmed. And it goes on into more arrogance. 50:01 You know that if you let me until the last day, I will misguide everybody. He just went on with arrogance from one step to another. But his disbelief lay in attributing to Allah error and refusing to repent from it. This is where the disbelief. That's important because we don't want to understand that he became a disbeliever because he disobeyed Allah. Because we all disobey Allah. And it would mean we're all disbelievers. 50:34 Okay? So, come back to our point. The point is that when Iblis tricked Adam, Adam committed the sin, ate from the tree. He then turned back to Allah in repentance. Right? He turned back to Allah in repentance. Now, the act of repentance, is that a great act of worship or not? 51:10 It is among the greatest acts of worship. Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa sallam said, The one who repents from sin is like one without sin. So that is a great act of worship, of ibadah. So Satan's tricking Adam caused Adam to disobey, turn back in repentance and came back with this. 51:41 great act of ibadah the repentance so his purpose satan was to have adam repent repentance was a great good produced by evil the evil of iblis and adam's sin follow that not only that when he when adam and eve 52:14 Repented to Allah, Allah forgave them. See if Allah forgave them, isn't it? And Allah's forgiving is the manifestation of His attributes of being the forgiver, the oft-forgiver. And that is a great, you know, enormous act of Allah SWT. So great the Prophet SAW said, if you didn't commit sins and turn back to Allah in repentance, 52:47 Allah would have erased you from the earth and produced another set of people who would commit sins, turn back in repentance to Allah, and Allah would forgive them. That's in Sahih Muslim. So Allah's act of forgiveness for Adam and Eve's repentance is a great good. And Adam and Eve's turning to Allah in repentance is a great good. And what was it produced by? 53:20 evil of Satan. Can we understand that? Can we understand the principle here? So, for us, when the person asks, well, evil, where did it come from? Yes, Allah. It's a part of what Allah has permitted in this world. It's created. It's part of His creation. But, He did not create that evil for what appears to you as evil, but for a good purpose which you can't see. 53:58 For a good purpose which you can't see. And I gave the example before about good which comes from evil which we can see. It can happen. We can see it. And sometimes you can't see it. And that's life. Isn't it? Somebody comes up to you and says, I have this needle. I would like to stick it in your arm. Can I get your arm here please and stab this needle in your arm? What are you going to say? Of course not. 54:31 Why? I'm not a masochist. You know, a masochist is one person who likes pain, likes people inflicting pain on them, right? Sick. No, I'm not a masochist. I don't want that pain. Typhoid comes here. You run to the doctor. Doctor, please stick that needle in my arm. Now, the sticking of the needle in your arm, in and of itself, is an evil. Isn't it? When one asked if I can stab the needle in your arm, it was the same evil. 55:03 Stabbing the needle here, the doctor stabbing the needle, it's evil. But in the second case, you're accepting that harm not because you like the feel of a needle sticking into your skin, but because you believe there's a great good which will come from it. You follow that? So you accept evil for a greater good. We do that all the time in our lives. We're functioning like that all the time. Isn't it? Okay? 55:38 So, we say in the same way, you can recognize that. It happens in everybody's life. We're all doing it. In the same way, in Allah's creation, what you perceive as evil is in fact for a greater good. Now, the person may ask, well, okay, I can understand in the case of the needle, that's where you can see the good. But what about these other cases? The tsunami? 56:11 Where is the good in that? How many hundreds of thousand people lost their lives? Where is the good? How do you answer that? Where is the good? Well, the point is, the fact that you can't see the good, does that mean there's no good? This is the point. As they say in Islamic thought, the lack of knowledge of a thing is not knowledge. The fact that you have no knowledge about something, 56:49 It's not knowledge about that thing. That's just a lack of knowledge. That's all it is. A lack of knowledge. So the fact that you don't know the good which came from the tsunami doesn't mean there isn't good. It just means you don't know. That's all. All you can say is I don't know the good. But the fact that you don't know it doesn't mean that it isn't there. Maybe you'll see it after 10 years. Maybe 100 years from now we'll see it. That the shifting of the plate there 57:20 Had it shifted somewhere else, a million people would have lost their lives. So it shifted in a place where only 100,000 lost their lives instead of a million. It was better to shift there than the other place. I'm just positing, right? You could, if you want to sit down and figure out scenarios, you know, where it really was for the good, you can imagine them. You can. So, this is our response to their argument that simply because... 57:50 We can't see the good that is behind something. It doesn't mean that there is no good. Now, in dealing with the atheist, it is also good to point out to him or her that although they like to claim that they don't believe in God, in fact, they do. In fact, they actually do believe in God. 58:25 Because you sit that atheist down and you ask him or her, you in your life, you know, you are successful. You're a successful businessman or businesswoman, whatever. You had a classmate who did the same thing as you, graduated the same time as you, maybe even got better marks than you. But that classmate of yours is now a beggar, walking in the streets, begging people. 58:57 But you are successful. Why are you successful and he or she is a failure? What is your answer? Huh? Luck. That's the answer. My good luck. Her bad luck. That's what they say. My good luck, her bad luck. Well, guess what? If we go from the beginning of that person's day, when they get up in the morning, till the time they go to sleep at night, and you keep asking them, why this, why not that? 59:35 Why this? Why not that? You find that throughout their day they're just saying good luck, bad luck, good luck, bad luck, good luck, bad luck. So what? You mean your whole day is covered. Your week, your month, your year, your whole life is governed by good luck and bad luck. Well, in English we have another word for luck. It is fortune. They say good fortune and bad fortune. Now the term fortune comes from... 60:07 A Greek Roman word, Fortuna, which is the name of the goddess of good luck and bad luck. So here is your God. It's just you're not, you know, recognizing it and putting a statue and actually going through the motions. But you have your God. You have the goddess of good luck and bad luck, Fortuna. There's your God. 60:38 And how do you worship that God? Besides believing in the God, you have your rituals. There are different rituals that they have for good luck and bad luck, right? The rituals are the charms that you wear on your bracelets, you know, different things that you do. Some people feel, for example, if you just graduated from college or whatever, you go out for a job, you go one month, two months, you don't find a job, then eventually you find a job, right? What do you do when you get home? 61:07 the suit that you wore you put in a special place your tie you put in a special place your shoes everything and this becomes your good luck suit so whenever you have to go out and you need some good luck you make sure you put on that suit or that belt or those shoes or whatever these are your rituals these are your rights of worship okay and everybody has them people who deny god they are involved you'll see them involved in so much whether it is this was too 61:39 You have this wasto business, right? The Chinese call it Feng Shui. Shift around things in your house, open windows, and this is going to bring good luck for you. This is all, these are rites of worship. These are rites of worship. So even the person who claims he doesn't believe in God, they have a God, and they worship that God. Now, if we leave the atheist, and we go over to the deist, the deist, 62:18 as we said, was one who believes God created the world and left it to run on its own. And this is quite common among many people who follow religion today. Many Christians, a number of Hindus, you'll find that they're deists. If you ask what's your religion, they say Hinduism, it's Christianity. But when you actually sit and talk to them, they really don't believe. God, yes, there is a God. But all these religions really are man-made. It's another way. 62:51 Some people say, I don't like, I believe in God, but I don't like or I don't believe in organized religion. I'm sure you've heard that one, right? So we say to them, you prefer a disorganized religion, do you? Because if you don't like an organized religion, then you must prefer a disorganized religion. One chaotic religion that you made up from bits and pieces here, there and everywhere. So the point is, for the deists, 63:22 He or she believes basically that Allah, God, did not communicate His will to humankind. That's the bottom line. God created us, left us on our own. We find our own purposes, etc., etc. But we say to them, what you are doing when you say this is to attribute to God the worst of characteristics. You are attributing to God 63:57 the worst of characteristics why because if somebody factory owner he builds this wonderful factory he puts an ad for factory workers hires the people tells them where the factory is but doesn't tell them what to do in the factory what's going to happen they're going to march into the factory and everybody just goes sitting in this position and start doing what he's supposed to do no 64:30 They will go to the canteen, the cafeteria, the restaurant, drink tea, you know, coffee, chat, until somebody comes and tell them, hey, you know, you've got a job to do here. This is your job and so on and so on. So the idea, some, you know, an industrialist who did that, what would you think of that industrialist? He's a fool. He's an idiot. You're going to hire people, you don't tell them what they need to do? Children at school. If you send children to school, 65:01 You don't tell them what they're supposed to do. You think they're just going to march into school, march into their classroom, sit down and wait for the teacher to teach them? No. As soon as they hit the doors of the school, they're going straight to the playground. Swinging on the swing, sliding on the slides, you know. They'll do that until somebody says, come, get in the class. Again, a school which doesn't inform the students what to do is foolish, idiotic. So now when you say Allah created this world, 65:31 And didn't tell us what to do in this world. What is that saying? What is that saying? We don't know what the purpose is. God just created us. No purpose identified. Somebody comes knocking on your door. You open the door. You say, who do you want? He says, I don't know. Why are you standing here knocking on my door? I don't know. What are you going to do with that person? You run back, get your telephone, call the insane asylum, tell them, listen, I have a case here on my door. Come get it, please. 66:12 Somebody who does things without reason, this is somebody who has lost his mind. Right? So when we attribute God to creating us without reason, that's what we're doing. This is a very evil thing to say. So we say no. Logic and reason, common sense tells us that God conveyed his will to human beings. He told them what to do. 66:47 He provided them with the manual. You make a machine, you give it to somebody without any manual. What do you think they're going to do with that machine? Break it up. Isn't it? They're going to smash it up. They're going to misuse it. Of course, Allah gave the manual. He conveyed the message. So the argument of the deist is a weak argument. In the case of the agnostic, in the case of the agnostic, we can really... 67:20 Just say, this person is a lazy disbeliever. He's just a lazy atheist. He's not committing fully. He says, I don't know that there is a God, but I don't know that there is not a God. What is this? Hey, you're a disbeliever. Really. You're just, you don't believe there is a God. Because you cannot not be sure. You know, and unfortunately, we have a lot of Muslims. 67:51 today who worship allah in this way they worship allah not being certain that allah exists they don't pray all year but when ramadan comes you see their brain fasting and praying and you ask them why they'll tell you if they're honest just in case what do you mean just in case just in case if i have to come before allah i can say well you know i was doing some fasting i did some prayers etc etc 68:32 Just in case. That is not acceptable belief. The only acceptable belief is belief with certainty. Some atheists or deists will say, Islam, if it's good for you, it's fine. No problem. But the most important thing is just to be good. If it's good for you, no problem. It's great. But what's most important is just being good. How do we respond to this? 69:13 kind of statement. It's most important just to be good. We say to them, how do you define good? What may be good for you may not be good for me. What may be good for me may not be good for you. So how do we define good? It's not enough just to be good. We need to know what is really good. What is ultimately good. 69:41 And you and I, if it's just up to us, we will always define good as what is good for us. So that is not a criterion. It's not enough to say, as long as you do good. And that's why we have the issue of Mother Teresa or Gandhi or these other issues that came up before. You know, they did good, so why should this happen to them since they were so good? No, because what has happened in their case, people have considered the evil of not believing in God. 70:13 People have considered the evil of not believing in God as He's supposed to be believed in and worshipping Him as being something very small. It's just a small bad. In comparison to the great good that people may do in terms of serving, helping, and all this kind of thing, isn't it? That's what they've done. They've tried to weigh things. Now this small act of disbelief in your... 70:43 view cannot surely outweigh all of the good that the person has done in their life. But the bottom line is what? Do we know what their intention was behind the good they did? Do we know what their intention was? Because if I do good for you because I want something from you or I do it because I want to make a show to become famous, etc. Is that real good? You may not know that. All you can see is the good act. 71:15 But the intention behind that act can change the quality of the act altogether. And turn it from a good into an evil. People may use what appears to be good to exploit others. There is a book which is currently on the best sellers list in the US. Available on Amazon.com. It's called Confessions of an Economic Hitman. Confessions of an Economic Hitman. 71:49 hitman. You know what a hitman is? A man who's given the job of taking out other people, killing them, whatever, right? But he called himself an economic hitman. Basically what he explains is that he, for the last 30 odd years, worked for the U.S. government as an economic hitman. What he used to do was he was sent into countries, third world countries. 72:18 He would offer them huge loans, good, money, lots of money, taken from the World Bank as a loan to them, which is so great that it is impossible for the country to pay off the loan. When they can't pay off the loan, they have a debt. Then they have interest on the debt. They spend their time just trying to pay off the interest. And they're struggling just with the interest, which is increasing and increasing and increasing. 72:53 So they have been caught. Their economies have been subverted. So when the World Bank tells them, do this, they do it. Tell them, do that, they do it. And it is at the command of the U.S. As he explains, the American empire, an economic empire. So that great good of the loan, normally a loan, if somebody says, I need some money, you know, I need some help, I provide you with a loan, that's a good thing. 73:24 It's a nice thing. But they are using the loan to entrap people and to turn them into slaves. Their society now is enslaved to the American economy. This is just an example. You know, it can come in many other ways. That good is relative depending on the intention behind it. In terms of general dawah, for atheists, 73:55 I would advise that you find out why that person became an atheist. Because we have to keep in mind that atheism is an abnormality. It is an abnormality. So for a person to become an atheist, something must have happened in his or her life. 74:26 They were raised by atheists who something happened in their lives. The norm is for people to grow up believing in God. This is the norm. We talked about that earlier. That's the norm for humankind. So when you find somebody who doesn't believe in God, then we have to treat this person as an abnormal person. In which case, we need to find out what made him or her that way. 74:56 So you ask them, you know, why don't you believe in God? If they say, well, you know, all this tragedy in the world, this is general information. There's something more specific. Okay, leave that aside. But why don't you believe in God personally? So when you find out what was actually behind their disbelief, what led them into disbelief, then you can try to deal with that. 75:28 Then you can deal with that actual problem. And in most cases, it is some tragedy that I've mentioned before. Some tragedy they had in life, which they could not find an explanation for. That is the most common occurrence. Somebody like Stephen Hawkins, this British mathematician, genius. 75:56 sitting in the seat for mathematics at Oxford, an ancient seat, you know. This individual, in his early years, he was raised as a Christian, believing in God, etc. And then his genius came out, he, you know, became a big figure in his teens, his late teens. Then he started to suffer from this spinal disease, 76:26 he started to lose control over his limbs his body was crumbling within itself then it led him to that position where he is moved around on a electric wheelchair he can't even speak you know somebody has to punch out sounds for him to be able to speak and after this happened to him and he came to India 76:57 You know, they took him around India. He looked at different parts of India. And he saw a billion people living here. People who were living lives which were, in his view, of no consequence. They were born, they grew up, they procreated, and they died. Finished. They added nothing to human civilization and knowledge exception. They were just like ants. 77:29 But they were healthy. So this was something which struck him. Why? I who have so much to add to civilization, to benefit humankind, I'm in this state. And these people who have nothing, but they're in good health. There can't be a God. There's no reason for this. I'm the one who should be healthy and good. 78:01 They who have nothing to offer, okay, let them be crippled like me. So, not being able to explain and to understand why he is in this state. Tragedy. Led him to atheism. He wrote his book on the history of time, you know, and so on and so forth. Complete atheism. Later on, his nurse fell in love with him. 78:33 And he fell in love with his nurse. He divorced his wife, married his nurse. Love came into his life. Then he started to believe in God again. You see his writings change. Is this how people are? This is how people are. When there's tragedy, you can't explain it. You resort to atheism. When life goes well, things are good, okay, there's a God. I found love. 79:04 So, like Hawkins, if you go into different people's lives, you will find that the reason for their atheism is tragedy. This is the most common one. Or, as I said, it could be that they were raised by parents who were themselves atheists, who became atheists as a result of some tragedy in their lives. Or their parents, you know, maybe a couple of generations of atheists. That could be too. But usually, usually... 79:35 This disease, then really it is a very grave disease for a person to deny God's existence. That is a very grave disease. For a person, for that to happen, there is usually a cause. There is usually a cause. And even the person who was raised as an atheist by his parents or her parents, many times they find Islam. Many times, or they find belief in God. 80:08 you know if they end up in science etc you'll find actually surveys done amongst the scientists the vast majority of them believe in God in the West which we think of as the secular atheistic type society the majority of scientists biologists you know astronomers chemists geologists they believe in God where you find the disbelievers are in psychology 80:36 sociology this is where the big disbelievers dominates you find most of them are atheists and this but those who are in science because science shows them really what is man in relationship to this creation they know when they get up behind that telescope and they look out into to the universe it humbles them there's got to be a god when there's actually an issue 81:06 of Time Magazine. For those of you that are involved in Dawa and dealing with science, it's good to get that issue of Time Magazine, which focuses on, you know, believers among the scientists. You know, that science leads to God. Something I forgot the exact title. If you email me, you need the exact title because, of course, it will be in the archives. You can always look it up. But it's very good articles. And they have different scientists. 81:34 explaining why they believe in God nuclear scientists others you know are talking about different issues and different aspects of science which indicate no doubt there has to be a God you know so it's very good article if you need the title of the set of the issue email me and I'll get it to you I have saved it you know it is it's very very interesting huh email address Bilal 17 82:03 at BilalPhillips.com. Bilal1717, B-I-L-A-L, at BilalPhillips.com. Phillips is one L, P-H-I-L-I-P-S.